Supreme Court dismisses appeal reinstatement when respondent filed cross-appeal without procedural fault.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court refused the appellant's application to reinstate a dismissed appeal because the respondent had filed a cross-appeal without procedural fault. The court distinguished this case from a recent decision where the appellant was at fault for non-prosecution. Consequently, the respondent was granted three weeks to decide whether to proceed with the cross-appeal, while the appellant retained the right to raise original arguments during that hearing.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IARule 22 of Order 35s; An application for reinstatement of an appeal fails where the respondent has filed a cross-appeal without procedural fault, allowing the respondent to proceed independently while the appellant may still raise original contentions at the cross-appeal hearing.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*829] 1969 June 6
(VASSILIADES, P., TRIANTAFYLLIDES, JOSEPHIDES, JJ.)
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Jimmy Thomas,
Appellant-Defendant,
v.
Vasilis Gavrielides,
Respondent-Plaintiff
(Application in Civil Appeal No.4779
Civil procedure - Practice - Appeal - Cross-appeal by Respondent - Appeal dismissed for want of prosecution - Application to reinstate refused - Respondent entitled to elect whether to continue or withdraw cross-appeal - Appellant entitled to give cross-notice of his intention to bring forward his original contention on the hearing of the respondent’s appeal.
Appeal - Civil Appeal - Reinstatement - See under "Civil Procedure".
Practice - Appeal - Reinstatement - See under "Civil Procedure".
E. Vrahimi, (Mrs.) for the Appellant,
Chr. Chrysanthou, for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
The following Judgment was delivered by: -
VASSILIADES P.; This application for reinstatement of the appeal presents some difference from a similar application in the case just heard (Civil Appeal No.4774).* This difference lies in the fact that here the respondent has filed a cross-appeal. The failure on the part of the appellant to pursue his appeal should not affect the position. [*830] of the respondent in the letter's cross-appeal where the respondent is at no procedural fault. We have derived assistance in dealing with this matter from a somewhat similar situation dealt with in the Court of Appeal in England in 1885, reported in the Law Reports of the Probate Division (Vol. 10) for the year 1885; the case is reported under the name of Beeswing at p. 18 of the report. Adopting the reasoning and course followed in that case, we decide the matter before us as follows
The application of the appellant for reinstatement of the appeal under rule 22 of Order 35s fails and is refused. The respondent will now have three weeks from today (in view of the fact that he resides abroad) to decide whether he will apply for hearing of the cross-appeal. He must, however, bear' in mind that in such a case, the appellant (as a respondent in the cross-appeal) may give notice as provided in the rules, of his intention to bring forward the subject matter of his original appeal, at the hearing of the respondent’s appeal. No costs in the proceedings for reinstatement taken by the appellant.
Application for reinstatement
refused; directions with regard
to cross-appeal and costs as
above.
* Published in this volume at p. 027 ante.