Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
Ioannis Vrahimis v. The Police (1969) JSC 377 Generato dall'IA

Criminal appeal dismissed on conviction but sentence reduced on technical counts due to lack of public notice.

Numero d'incarto Ioannis Vrahimis v. The Police (1969) JSC 377
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Supreme Court dismissed the appellant's challenge to his conviction but varied the sentence on two technical counts. The appellant drove off without producing his driving licence and identity card when stopped by police, leading to a conviction in his absence. The court held that while the offences were proven, the sentences on the second and third counts were unjustified because no public statement had recently drawn attention to the requirement to carry an identity card. Consequently, the conviction stands, the fine on the first count is affirmed, but the fines on the other two counts are set aside or reduced to a recognizance.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Motor Vehicles Regulations 1959-1968, regulations 24(1)(2)(b), 47(1) and 66; Registration of Residents Law, Cap. 85, section 11(2)(5): Sentences for failing to produce driving licence or identity card should not be imposed in absentia without prior public notice of the statutory requirements.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
conviction in absentia technical offences public notice requirement identity card regulation judicial control of police sentence reduction motor vehicles regulations abuso della licenza e delle targhe

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Motor Vehicles Regulations 1959-1968, regulations 24(1)(2)(b), 47(1) and 66
Registration of Residents Law, Cap. 85, section 11(2)(5)
85, section 11(2)(5) - No sentence should have been passed in the absence of public statement drawing attention to the requirements of the law.
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*377] 1969 February

(VASSILIADES, P., TRIANTAFYLLIDES, JOSEPHIDES, JJ.)

APPELIATE JURISDICTION

Ioannis Vrahimis,

Appellant,

v.

The Police,

Respondents.

(Criminal Appeal No. 3064).

Criminal Law - Conviction and sentence in absentia - Failing to display vehicle’s licence and to produce driving licence - The Motor Vehicles Regulations 1959-1968, regulations 24(1) (2) (b), 47(1) and 66 - Sentence on second count reduced.-

Criminal Law - Sentence - Failing to produce identity card for inspection - Registration of Residents’ Law, Cap. 85, section 11(2)(5) - No sentence should have been passed in the absence of public statement drawing attention to the requirements of the law.

Police - Police duties and powers - Subject to judicial control.

Appellant in person.

A. Frangos, Senior Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondents.

JUDGMENT

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by:-

VASSILIADES, P.: The appellant, a medical practitioner in Nicosia, was driving his car when a policeman on traffic duty, at a busy town street, stopped the appellant, apparently having noticed that the vehicle’s circulation licence was not exhibited on the windscreen.

In reply to the policeman’s enquiry, the appellant produced the circulation licence, offering some explanation why the licence was not exhibited as require by the Regulations. [*378] The policeman pointed out that it should be exhibited at the appropriate part of the car as provided in the Regulations.

But, the policeman did not confine himself there. He proceeded to ask not only for the doctor’s driving licence but also for his identity card. The evidence on record does not show the reason for which the policeman considered it necessary to do that kind of checking, in the circumstances; particularly, when that meant interference with the flow of traffic in a busy town street.

Be that as it may, however, appellant’s reaction was to drive off without producing his documents. In fact, the appellant was the holder of a driving licence in force and of an identity card neither of which, he had with him at the time.

Another policeman who was called as a witness for the prosecution, stated that when he informed the appellant of the charges against him some time later, his reply was that the traffic policeman had stopped him at the entrance of Ledra Street to do the checking of his circulation licence and that when the policeman asked for his driving licence and his identity card the appellant drove off as his car was interfering with the traffic coming behind him.

The appellant was prosecuted; and when charged on October 29, 1968, he pleaded guilty to the first count for failing to display his vehicle’s licence; but pleaded not guilty to the second count for failing to produce his driving licence to a police officer, contrary to Regulations 47(1) and 66 of the Motor Vehicles Regulations; and not guilty to the third count for failing to produce his identity card [*379] for inspection contrary to section 11(2)(5) of the Registration of Residents Law, Cap. 85.

On the day fixed for hearing the case was called according to the record - at 10.50 a.m. Accused and his advocate did not appear; and the prosecution called two police witnesses to prove the case in appellant’s absence. These were the traffic policeman on duty and the policeman who took appellant’s statement in answer to the charge. Upon their evidence, the learned trial Judge convicted the appellant on all three counts and proceeded to sentence him with £1 fine on count 1; £2 fine on count

2 and £3 fine on count 3.

According to a note made by the trial Judge on the record, at 11 hours (that is to say, 10 minutes after the case had been called at 10.50)

appellant’s advocate appeared in the Judge’s chambers to enquire about the case; and was informed of the result of

the proceedings. It was then that the Judge made the note. Against that conviction and sentence, the present appeal was filed in due course.

The appellant appeared before us in person today, to complain both against his conviction and the sentence imposed upon him in absentia, by the Judge. Learned counsel for the police very fairly, we think, and with the frankness always expected from counsel appearing in a public prosecution, conceded that the offences in counts 2 and 3 were rather technical matters of very little substance, in this particular case.

We find it unnecessary to go deeper into the question whether prosecution on counts 2 and 3, was really justified in the circumstances. The counts were in fact, there; [*380] and the offences had been proved. We do not think that we should interfere with the conviction as recorded. But as regards sentence, we take the view that after the sentence on count 1, which was apparently a reasonable punishment for appellant’s offence, the sentences on counts 2 and 3 were not justified.

The performance of police duties and the exercise of police power in the application of the law must be guided by the public interest, reasonably viewed in the circumstances of each case; and the officers concerned must always remember that the exercise of their powers is subject to judicial control. This is a necessary safeguard, both for the proper application of the law and for maintaining the respect which the public must have for the law; and for the officers whose duty it is to apply it. Such judicial control is often reflected in the result of actual cases before the Courts.

In the circumstances of this case we take the view that on count 2 the appellant should be required to sign a recognizance in the sum of £10.- to come up for sentence if called upon within the next six months; and that on count 3 there should be no sentence, as there has never been issued recently any public statement drawing the attention of members of the public to the need to carry with them their identity cards, which were introduced as a means of identification for security purposes, in the circumstances then prevailing, over ten years ago.

The appeal against conviction will stand dismissed. The sentence on count 1 will be affirmed; the sentence on [*381] count 2 shall be varied accordingly; and that on count 3 shall be set aside. There shall be no sentence on that count.

Judgment and order accordingly.

Appeal against conviction dismissed; appeal against sentence partly allowed.