Village Authority's boundary loss claim dismissed due to Council of Ministers' failure to consider objections.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court annulled a Council of Ministers proclamation altering village boundaries after the Applicants failed to file a formal recourse under Article 146.2 of the Constitution. Although the Applicants argued they suffered a loss of area, the Council of Ministers proceeded without considering their written objections or the relevant Ministry of Interior file. The court held that the exercise of discretionary powers was defective because the Council acted on inadequate information and ignored material objections, violating principles of natural justice.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAVillage Authorities Law, Cap. 244, section 20; Constitution of Cyprus, Article 146.2: A proclamation altering village boundaries is void if the Council of Ministers fails to consider objections raised by the affected Village Authority, thereby acting on incomplete information and violating natural justice.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*1449] 1967 December 30
(TRIANTAFYLLIDES, J. )
REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
Styllis Xapolytos and Others,
Applicants,
and
The Republic of Cyprus, through
The Council of Ministers,
Respondent.
(Case No. 94/66).
Local Government - Boundary - Alteration - Proclamation of Council of Ministers extending the boundaries of a village to include part of the area of another - Validity - Non-consideration of objections of affected village - Not sufficient enquiry into the matter - Exercise of discretion - The Village Authorities Law, Cap.244, section 20.
Constitutional Law - Constitution of Cyprus - Legitimate interest, Article 146.2 - Proclamation of Council of Ministers extending the boundaries of a village to include part of the area of another - Village Authority of village deprived of part of its area entitled to file recourse under Article 146.2.
Boundary - Of village authority - Alteration - See under "Local Government"
Legitimate interest, Article 146.2 of the Constitution - See under "Constitutional Law".
L. Clerides, for the Applicants.
L. Loucaides, Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
The following Judgment was delivered by:-
TRIANTAFYLLIDES, J. : In this Case the Applicants who are the Chairman and Members of the Village Authority of Galini, complain against the validity of a proclamation made by the Council of Ministers, and published in the [*1450] official Gazette on the 17th February, 1 966 (Not. 75, 3rd Supplement), under section 20 of the Village Authorities Law, Cap. 244, for the purpose of altering the boundaries of the villages of Galini and Karavostasi. By virtue of such proclamation part of the area of Galini, known as the "Potamostou-Kampou” quarter, has been taken away from such village and included in the area of Karavostasi.
In these proceedings no Direction was made to notify the Improvement Board of Karavostasi, as an Interested Party, because from the material before me it did not appear that the sub judice proclamation was the result of a claim to that effect of such Board.
The matter was decided upon by the Council of Ministers (see its
decision No. 5359 exhibit 2) on the 3rd February, 1966. Such decision was taken on the strength of a submission to
the Council made by the Ministry of Interior (see exhibit 1 ); to exhibit 1 there was attached a survey map showing the
area involved (see exhibit 1 (a)).
A much more informative map showing such area as well as the areas of Galini and Karavostasi (exhibit 3) was produced in the present proceedings, but it was not before the Council of Ministers at the material time.
It has been argued by counsel for Respondent that the Applicants are not entitled, in the light of the provisions of Article 146 (2) of the Constitution, to make this recourse, because no legitimate interest of theirs is being adversely affected, as they are not going to suffer any loss due to the said proclamation. [*1451]
I cannot agree with this submission: The Applicants are the Village Authority of the village of Galini, which by means of the proclamation was deprived of part of its area. It is clear that they have filed this recourse in their capacity as the Village Commission of their village, Galini. It is equally clear that their case is that through the deprivation of the area concerned the interests of their village will be adversely affected. In the circumstances I have no difficulty in holding that they were, prima facie, entitled to file this recourse under the provisions of Article l46, and it has not been established, during the proceedings, that in point of actual fact the proclamation in question will not affect, in any way at all, adversely the interests of Galini village.
There have been various arguments put forward against the validity of the sub judice proclamation but I shall limit myself only to that on the basis of which, in my view, it is proper to determine this Case: This is the submission that the Council of Ministers proceeded to decide on such proclamation without having before it - so as to have an opportunity to consider them - the objections raised by the Applicants against the proposed change of boundaries; and that it, thus, was not fully informed about all material factors.
It is apparent on the face of the submission to the Council (exhibit
1 ) that there were stated therein all the reasons in favour of making the proposed proclamation; but, though it was stated in the submission that the Applicants objected to such a course, none of their objections was mentioned therein. [*1452]
On the contrary, an attempt was made in the submission to present the attitude of the Applicants as being completely unjustified, on the ground that the area to be taken away from Galini was only 2/ 23rds of the total area of the village (0.55 of a square mile out of 6.4 square miles). Yet the Council of Ministers was not informed, also, at the same time, of the undisputed fact that, though the area to be taken away from Galini was, indeed, 2/23rds of the total area of the village, in fact it was one out of the only two inhabited localities in the whole of this village. To that extent, therefore, the Council of Ministers has been led to act on the basis of inadequate information and in ignorance of a very material aspect of the matter.
That the objections advanced by the Applicants were within the knowledge of the Ministry of Interior, and that they could not have been completely devoid of substance, is to be derived from paragraph 5 of the facts set out in the Opposition; it is stated therein that the Applicants submitted their views in writing on more than one occasion, and that they were afforded, on more than one occasion, the opportunity to make representations in the matter to the District Officer and his staff, as well as to the Minister of Interior himself.
The objections raised by the Applicants must have been found, thus, recorded in the relevant file of the Ministry of Interior which, according to what has been stated to the Court by counsel for the Respondent, was in the possession of the Secretariat of the Council of Ministers, at the material time, and could be made available to the [*1453] Council if called for by it. But, as further stated by counsel for the Respondent, it is a fact that the Council did not call for such file, nor did it ask fæ any further explanations from the responsible Minister - the Minister of Interior - when deciding on the proclamation in question.
It seems that the presentation, in the submission, of the attitude of the Applicants in the matter, as being totally unjustified, did not enable the Council of Ministers to see the matter in its true light and prevented it from feeling that it should be informed of the objections raised by the Applicants; of course, I must make it clear that I have no doubt that the submission of the Ministry of Interior as presented to the Council, was the product of, only, unfortunate drafting and not of any calculated intention to mislead.
It was a matter of proper administration for the Council of Ministers to have decided, on whether or not the sub judice proclamation were to be made, after weighing duly all the material considerations, including the objections of the Applicants; it was, moreover, a matter of natural justice, in a case of this nature, for the said objections to be considered by the Council of Ministers, In the circumstances already explained in this Judgment, the Council was not enabled to act as required by proper administration and natural justice; and it was, also, led to act on the basis of an incomplete picture of
the matter. As a result the exercise of its discretionary powers under section 20 of Cap. 244 was a defective one and its
product, the subjectmatter of this recourse, has to be declared to be null
and void and of no effect whatsoever, as being contrary to law [*1454] and in excess und abuse of powers. I do think that the Council
of Ministers acted as it did in view of the situation in which it found itself in when dealing with this matter, and I have no doubt that it will now revert to such matter without omitting to consider and examine fully all aspects thereof.
Regarding costs I have decided to award Applicants £20 towards their costs.
Subject-matter of Recourse
annulled.
Order for costs as
aforesaid.