Supreme Court voids teacher transfer due to improperly constituted committee, allowing recourse on composition ground only.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court declared the transfer of a physics teacher from technical to secondary education null and void. While the court rejected the claim of excess power and abuse of discretion, it found the decision invalid because the Committee of Educational Service was not properly constituted under the 1965 Law. Consequently, the transfer is annulled, and the committee must reconsider the matter with the correct composition.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IALaw 12/65, sections 3, 7(2)(c), 16(1); A decision by a collective administrative organ is voidable if the organ was not lawfully constituted according to statutory requirements.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*1308] 1967 November
(LOIZOU, J.)
REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
In the matter of Article 146 of the Constitution
Andreas Gavriel,
Applicant,
and
The Republic of Cyprus, through
The Minister of Education,
Respondent.
(Case No. 210/65).
Education - Transfer of Teachers - Transfer of a teacher from technical education to secondary education - Power of Committee of Educational Service to effect transfer - Constitution of Committee at the material time - Discretion - The Transfer of the Exercise of Competence of the Greek Communal Chamber and the Ministry of Education Law, 1965 (No. 12 of 1965), sections 3, 7( 2)( c) (3),16(1).
A. Triantafyllides, for the Applicant.
G. Tornaritis, for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
The following Judgment was delivered by:-
LOIZOU, J.: By this recourse the Applicant seeks a declaration that the decision of the Respondent to transfer him from the Technical School Nicosia to the Kykko Gymnasium for Boys is null and void and of no effect whatsoever. [*1309]
The Applicant is a teacher of Physics and Chemistry and at the time of the decision complained of he was posted at the Technical School Nicosia. At a meeting of the committee of Educational Service held on the 9th, 10th and 11th September, 1965 it was decided, inter alia, to post the Applicant to the Kykko Gymnasium for Boys. The minutes of the meeting have been produced and are exhibit "D". This decision was conveyed to the Applicant by a letter dated the 14th September, 1965 (exhibit 1 attached to the Application). The Applicant objected to this transfer and on the 19th October, 1965 his objection was rejected (exhibit 2 attached to the Application). As a result this recourse was filed.
This Application is based on the following grounds of law:
(A) That the committee of Educational Service has no power to transfer a teacher from technical education to secondary education and that therefore, the decision complained of was taken in excess of power.
(B) That at the time the decision was taken the committee was not properly constituted and
(C) That in any case the decision was taken in abuse of power.
A. With regard to this ground it was submitted by learned counsel for the Applicant that Law 12/65 creates separate compartments of education and that there is no legal power to make a transfer from one compartment of education to the other. In support of his submission he cited section 7 of the said law and particularly paragraph (c) of sub-section (2) thereof. [*1310]
This section (7) makes provision for the establishment and organization of the services for the exercise of the administrative powers transferred from the then Greek Communal Chamber to the Ministry of Education by section 3 of the law. By virtue of sub-section (2) of this section the committee of Educational Service is constituted and its composition is defined. The committee consists of five members three of whom are appointed by the President of the Republic, the 4th is the Director of the Personnel Department and the 5th is the officer in charge of the Higher and Secondary education, or the elementary education, or the technical, agricultural and generally the vocational education depending on whether the exercise of power relates to an Inspector of secondary education or a schoolmaster, to an Inspector of elementary education or a schoolteacher, or to an Inspector of technical, agricultural or vocational education or to a master or Inspector of technical, agricultural or vocational schools.
The functions of the Committee are set out in sub-section (3) and they include the appointment, classification, establishment, promotion, transfer, secondment, posting and retirement of Inspectors of Education, schoolmasters and teachers and the exercise of disciplinary control over them including power to dismiss.
The provisions of paragraph (c) of sub-section 2 of section 7, learned counsel argued, afford a clear indication that separate compartments of education are created and that the transfer from one compartment of education to the other is not permitted; if it were otherwise, he said, it would mean, in a case of a transfer for instance, that [*1311] whereas the Head of the Department to which the officer affected belongs would be sitting on the committee, the Head of the recipient department would have no say in the matter and this could never have been contemplated by the legislature. I find no merit in this argument especially in view of the fact that four of the persons who constitute the committee are regular members thereof and one must assume that they are aware of the needs of education generally and of the merits and qualifications of each officer.
B. The second point argued is that at the time of the decision the committee was not properly constituted in view of the fact that the head of technical education to which the applicant belonged was not present. The substantive holder of this post at the time was Mr. Stavros Syrimis. This officer, in January, 1965, went on leave abroad and has since retired but when the decision complained of was taken he was still on leave. In January, 1965 Mr. Origen is Spyridakis Inspector of Physics was appointed by the Committee of Administration of the Greek Communal Chamber, which was the appropriate organ to make such appointment at the time, to act in the place of Mr.Syrimis (exhibit"C"). After the enactment of Law 12/65 the appropriate organ to appoint the Head of Department was the Public Service Commission. The Public Service Commission took no action in the case of Mr. Spyridakis. Learned counsel’s argument was that since no acting appointment was made by the Public Service Commission Mr. Spyridakis was not properly appointed to act and, therefore, he was not properly on the committee. Learned counsel for the respondent argued that no such acting appointment was necessary and this in view of the [*1312] provise to sub-section
(1) of section 16 of the law. I am inclined to agree with the view that by operation of this section the acting appointment of Mr. Spyridakis continued in force after the dissolution of the Greek Communal Chamber and that therefore he was properly on the committee at the meeting when the decision complained of was taken.
But in so far as the composition of the committee is concerned learned counsel for the Applicant made another point after the production of the minutes of the meeting at which the decision complained of was taken (exhibit "D"). He submitted that the composition of the committee was in any case defective in view of the fact that in addition to the Head of the technical education the Head of Higher and Secondary Education and also of Elementary Education were sitting on the committee. That these officers were present clearly appears from the minutes.
Learned counsel for the respondent in the course of his address said this on the question of the composition of the committee; "The persons who sat on the committee when the decision complained of was taken were the three persons appointed under paragraph "a" of sub-section (2) of section 7, the Head of Secondary and Higher Education Mr. Vrahas and Mr. Origenis Spyridakis the Head of Technical Education. Present also was Mr. Kouros who took no part in the decision". It is, therefore, clear that both the Head of the Technical and the Head of the Higher and Secondary Education were present and took part in the decision. The question now arises whether this departure from the provisions of section 7(2)(c) regarding the composition of the committee affects the validity of the decision. [*1313]
In the text-book on Greek Administrative Law by Kyriakopoulos vol. B at p. 20 it is stated:
"Απαραίτητος προϋπόθεσις της εννόμου λειτουργίας
του συλλογικού οργάνου είναι ή νόμιμος αυτού συγκρότησις. Του νόμου ορίζοντος
εκ πόσων και τίνων ατόμων απαρτίζεται το συλλογικόν όργανον, προϋπόθεσιν της
νομίμου υποστάσεως και λειτουργίας, αλλά και του εγκύρου των αποφάσεων,
αποτελεί η συγκρότησις αυτού εκ πάντων των προσώπων, τα οποία νόμω
καθωρίσθησαν, δια ν' αποκτήση τούτο γένεσιν και μορφήν συλλογικού οργάνου. Προς
την έννοιαν δε της νομίμου συγκροτήσεως του συλλογικού οργάνου αντίκειται η εις
αυτό συμμετοχή προσώπου μη περιλαμβανομένου μεταξύ των κατά νόμον μελών αυτού
ή στερηθέντος της ιδιότητος ταύτης λ.χ. δυνάμει δικαστικής αποφάσεως".
To the effect that bad composition of a collective organ leads to its incompetence and renders its decisions voidable are the Decisions of the
Council of State 1273/53 (Συμπλήρωμα Νομολογίας Ζαχαροπούλου 1953-1960 vol. 1 a-k p. 559 para. 59) and 1481/56
(Decisions of the Council of State of 1956 νοl. Γ at p.125).
In the light of the above I am of the view that on this ground the recourse must succeed and the decision complained of, in so far as it affects the Applicant, must be declared null and void.
C. Although this disposes of the case I think I should deal very briefly with Applicant’s ground "C" i.e. the allegation that the Respondents exercised their [*1314] discretion wrongly and abused their powers; it was submitted on the part of the Applicant that even if the respondents had power to make the transfer they exercised their discretion wrongly and abused their powers on the ground that such transfer was undesirable from the educational point of view because a different method of teaching and approach to the subject is used in the technical schools from the one used in secondary education and also because the administrative duties at the two schools are different and for this reason the power to transfer should be used sparingly.
I am clearly of the opinion that the Applicant has failed to substantiate this allegation. The Applicant is a teacher of physics and chemistry which are subjects not peculiar to technical education but on the contrary they are common to both technical and secondary education. On the material before me there is nothing to show that the respondents, in the exercise of their powers, acted in any way improperly or otherwise than in the best interests of education, and for this reason I would not be prepared to interfere with the decision complained of on this ground.
In the result, for the reasons I have stated under ground “B" above, this recourse must succeed and the decision complained of is hereby declared null and void; it is now up to the Committee of Educational Service to consider this matter afresh in its proper composition.
In all the circumstances I have decided to make no order as to costs.
Sub judice decision annulled.
No order as to costs.
Order in terms.