Appeal dismissed; court finds no legal justification to interfere with sentence for failing to renew annual advocate licence.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellant appealed a fine imposed for practicing without a valid annual licence, arguing the sentence carried undue moral blame. The court noted the appellant had already paid the required fee and attempted to regularize his status before and after prosecution. Consequently, the court dismissed the appeal, ruling there was no sufficient legal basis to interfere with the trial judge's decision.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IASections 11(1)(b)(3)(a) of the Advocates Law; An appeal against a fine for practicing without a licence is dismissed where the appellant has taken reasonable steps to regularize their position and no legal justification exists to interfere with the sentence.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*714] 1967 June 15
(VASSILIADES, P., JOSEPHIDES. HADJIANASTASSIOU, JJ.)
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Osman Mehmed,
Appellant,
v.
The Police,
Respondents.
(Criminal Appeal No.2906).
Advocates - Annual licences - Appeal against sentence - Practising as an advocate without an annual licence, contrary to sections 11(1)(b)(3)(a) of the Advocates Law, Cap. 2 (as amended) - No sufficient legal justification for interfering with sentence.
A. Dana, for the Appellant.
A. Frangos, Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by:-
VASSILIADES, P, : Learned counsel for the appellant made it quite clear to this Court, in presenting his client’s case, that the object of the appeal is to remove any shade of blame which may attach to the appellant from the sentence passed upon him in this case. Mr. Dana explained that his client, a registered advocate, feeling very deeply his duly to the Court, and assessing very highly his standing as an officer of this Court, feels quite uncomfortable that even a sentence of this nature be on record against him.
Learned counsel for the prosecution on the other hand, pointed out that the sentence is measured exactly on [*715] the fee payable for the annual licence; and that this shows clearly that the Judge did not find that there was any cause for punishing the appellant for his failure to renew his annual licence, with a fine in addition to the amount of the prescribed fee. The Judge, as pointed out in the course of the argument, had no power to make an order for the payment of the fee, and he passed a sentence of fine equivalent to the amount of the fee instead.
As already stated, while we appreciate the anxiety of the appellant in the matter, we do not think that there is any real cause for such anxiety. It is abundantly clear from the record, that he has taken every reasonable step to regulate his position, by paying the fee and obtaining the licence which he had failed to obtain in due course, before prosecution. And that after prosecution, the appellant again attempted to regularise his position, but the authority concerned declined, rightly in our opinion, to accept money and issue annual licences to practise for periods which had already expired.
As we have already said, we appreciate the fact that the appellant feels go strongly about his responsibilities as an advocate; and, in the circumstances, we do not think that either the Judge took the view that any moral blame attached to the sentence passed, or that anybody else reading the record can come to that conclusion.
On the other hand before we can interfere with the sentence of the trial Court, we must have sufficient legal justification for doing so. And it is rightly submitted on the part of the respondent that there is none in this case. [*716]
In the circumstances we do think that Mr. Dana was justified in refraining from pressing the matter further, after placing before the Court the position which disturbed his client. The appeal shall, therefore, stand dismissed.
Appeal dismissed.