Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
District Officer, Nicosia, as Chairman of the Appropriate Authority of Morphou v. Eleni Michael Pittordi (1967) JSC 426 Generato dall'IA

Supreme Court allows appeal against inadequate fine, substituting it with three months imprisonment for disobeying demolition order.

Numero d'incarto District Officer, Nicosia, as Chairman of the Appropriate Authority of Morphou v. Eleni Michael Pittordi (1967) JSC 426
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Cipro (CY)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The Supreme Court allowed the prosecutor's appeal against a sentence deemed manifestly inadequate, substituting the fine with three months of imprisonment. Although the court acknowledged the respondent's difficult personal circumstances, it ruled that humanitarian considerations cannot override the statutory duty to enforce the law. Consequently, the original fines and costs were set aside, and the respondent was ordered to serve concurrent prison terms for disobeying the demolition order and using the building without a certificate.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Streets and Buildings Regulation Law, Cap. 96, sections 10(1) and 20(5); Courts must enforce the law adequately and cannot substitute imprisonment for fines based on humanitarian grounds when the statute prescribes imprisonment as a penalty for disobeying demolition orders.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
manifestly inadequate sentence disobeying demolition order substitution of fine for imprisonment human element in justice public duty to enforce law reati contro il patrimonio violazione della precedenza danneggiamento

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
section 137(1)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Law (Cap. 155)
The appeal is taken under section 137(1) (b) of the Criminal Procedure Law (Cap.
Streets and Buildings Regulation Law, Cap. 96, section 10(1)
Streets and Buildings Regulation Law, Cap. 96, section 20(5)
Section 20(5) of the Streets and Buildings Regulation Law under which the respondent was prosecuted for disobeying the demolition order, provides that -
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

[*426] 1967 April 13

(VASSILIADES, P., JOSEPHIDES, HADJIANASTASSIOU, JJ.)

APPELATE JURISDICTION

District Officer, Nicosia, as Chairman of the

Appropriate Authority, of Morphou,

Appellant,

v.

Eleni Michael Pittordi, of Morphou,

Respondents.

(Criminal Appeal No.2890).

Criminal Law - Sentence - Appeal against sentence as Toeing manifestly inadequate - The Streets and Buildings Regulation Law, Cap. 96, sections 10(1) and 20(5) - Disobeying a demolition order and using a building without the required certificate - Human element in the q administration of justice - Public duty of Court to enforce adequately the law - Sentence of fine substituted by a sentence of imprisonment.

Administration of justice - Human element - Duty of Court to enforce the law - See under "Criminal Law" above.

E. Odysseos, for the Appellant.

E. Kassoulidou, for the Respondent.

JUDGMENT

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by: -

VASSILIADES, P.: This is an appeal against sentence taken by the prosecutor, a public authority, on the ground that the sentence imposed by the trial Court is "manifestly inadequate having regard to the seriousness of the offence". The appeal is taken under section 137(1) (b) of the Criminal Procedure Law (Cap. 155) with the sanction of the Attorney-General. [*427]

The sentence complained of, is a fine totalling £2.-, imposed on two counts, with an order for the payment of £4,500 mils costs, made by the District Judge sitting at Morphou, against the respondent, for disobeying an order of the Court for the demolition of a building erected without the required permit, contrary to the Streets and Buildings Regulation Law (Cap.96); and for the use of such a building without a certificate of final approval, as required by the statute. The fines were: £1.500 mils for disobeying the demolition order; and £0.500 mils for using the building without the required certificate.

The prosecutor is the District Officer of Nicosia as Chairman of the appropriate authority, under the Streets and Buildings Regulation Law, for the area of Morphou, wherein the building in question was erected without a permit. The respondent in the appeal is the person prosecuted for the offence in question, a married woman of the age of 52, the wife of a husband suffering of TB; and the p mother of seven children. Prom a humane point of view, this is a most pathetic case. On the other hand it is a case which presents a clear flouting of the law by persons apparently unable to realize the consequences of such conduct.

For constructing the building in question (a small house for the family's residence) without the required statutory permit, the respondent was prosecuted in the District Court of Nicosia sitting at Morphou, in 1962 (Criminal Case 1780/62); was convicted; and was ordered by the Court on December 31, 1962, to demolish the unlawfully constructed building within the two months period, prescribed by the law. [*428]

The respondent failed to comply with the demolition order; and about two years later, was prosecuted again in a fresh case, for disobedience of the order. She was now bound over on June 24 1964, in the sum of £50 to come up for judgment within a year, if called upon, for the offence of disobeying the demolition order made in December, 1962, in the original prosecution. Apparently, however, no steps for the demolition of the building were taken; and the respondent was prosecuted afresh by the authority concerned, in 1966. This was the case where she was fined £2 and ordered to pay costs as above, on January 17, 1967, after conviction upon her own plea. She pleaded guilty to a count for disobeying the demolition order in November, 1966; and to another count, for using the building in question during the same period without the certificate of final approval, required by the statute.

Learned counsel for the prosecuting authority submitted, quite rightly, in our opinion, that with the order made in June, 196UFrequiring the accused to come up for sentence if called upon; and the sentence imposed in the proceeding under consideration, the provisions of the statute in question, have not been adequately enforced. The fact that the building is still there, with no indication whatever on the part of the respondent, that she intends to abandon or demolish it, is the most eloquent proof of the merit in the submission advanced on behalf of the prosecutor.

Learned counsel for the respondent put forward at the hearing before us, a very strong and able plea on the [*429] humane aspect of the case; but, found no support whatever for her client's case on the statute in question, or any other part of the law.

This Court, in the circumstances, has no difficulty or hesitation in reaching the conclusion that the appeal must he allowed; and the law he adequately enforced. The human element in a case must always be taken into consideration Toy the Court; especially where it is as strong as in the case in hand. Law and justice lose all their substance if divorced from the human element. But the human element is presumably taken into account by the legislature as well, when they make the law. It is for the legislature to consider the effect of proposed legislation upon people, at the time of its enactment. When it becomes a law, the Courts must apply it as it comes to them. Their function is to apply the law. They have to do it upon human beings, it is true; but they must apply it with due regard to the purpose for which the law was made. Considerations of hardships, or consequences on the feelings of the persons concerned, must always be given due weight, but they cannot be allowed to override proper enforcement of the law.

We fully appreciate the desire of the Judge - reflected in his sentence

- to be kind to this woman; but such desire should never have been allowed to interfere with his public duty to enforce adequately the law.

Section 20(5) of the Streets and Buildings Regulation Law under which the respondent was prosecuted for disobeying the demolition order, provides that -

"Any person against whom an order has been made [*430] under sub-section (2) who disobeys or fails to comply with such order shall,............be guilty of an offence and shall be liable to imprisonment not exceeding three months or to a fine not exceeding £50 or to both such imprisonment and fine".

The respondent has been disobeying such an order since 1962. She continued in disobedience even after she was prosecuted for it in June, 1964. The sentence of £1.500 mils fine imposed upon her in this case, is clearly and manifestly inadequate; and must be set aside together with the fine of £0.500 mils for using the building in question without a certificate, and the order for the payment of costs. The sentence imposed shall be substituted by a sentence of three months imprisonment from to-day on each count, to run concurrently. There will be no order for the payment of costs. We have no doubt that the Welfare Services will do their duty in taking care of the human side of the case.

Appeal allowed.

Sentence of the trial

Court substituted as above.

No order for costs.