Court reduced excessive sentence for negligent firearm violation, allowing gun return and varying fines.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court varied the appellant's sentence for carrying a shotgun during a close season, finding the original forfeiture and two-year prohibition order excessive. The court determined the appellant's failure to secure a license was mere negligence rather than wilful omission, noting he applied for and obtained the license the day after the offense. Consequently, the court set aside the forfeiture and prohibition while affirming and slightly increasing the fines.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAFirearms Law Cap. 57; Game and Wild Birds Protection Law Cap. 65: Where an accused commits an offense due to mere negligence rather than wilful intent and has no prior convictions, a sentence involving forfeiture of the weapon and a long-term prohibition order may be deemed excessive and varied.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*1316] 1965 December 17
(ZEKIA, P., VASSILIADES, JOSEPHIDES, JJ.)
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Takis Kyprianou,
Appellant,
v.
The Police,
Respondents.
(Criminal Appeal No. 2802).
Criminal Law - Sentence - Appeal against excessive sentence for offences under the Firearms Law, Cap. 57 (as amended) and the Game and Wild Birds Protection Law, Cap.65 (as amended) - Order of forfeiture of gun and prohibition order of carrying it for two years, considered excessive - Sentence varied.
Charge: 1st Count:* Carrying a firearm (shotgun) during a close season without a special permit from the District Officer, contrary to sections 7(1)(ii)(4)(a) and 27 of the Firearms Law, Cap. 57, as amended by section 4(a) of Law 11 of 1959, and section 2 of the Game and Wild Birds Protection Law, Cap.65, as amended by Law
9 of 1964.
4th Count:* Possessing freshly killed wild bird (one dove) during a close season, contrary to sections 2, 13, 26 and 27 of the Game and Wild Birds Protection Law, Cap.65, as amended by Law 9 of 1964
Sentence and Date: £10.- fine on 1st Count and £5.- fine on 4th Count. Firearm (shotgun) to be forfeited. Accused further prohibited from carrying, possessing and using firearms for a period of 2 years from date of sentence, 20.10.65.
Nature of Appeal: Appeal against sentence. Name of trial Court: District Court of Limassol.
A. Triantafyllides, for the Appellant.
S. Georghiades, Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by:- [1317]
ZEKIA. P.: We have heard counsel putting forward the grounds for reducing the sentence. There is no doubt that the Judge was right in saying that one has to be very careful in obtaining his game licence in time and not relying on somebody else doing for him what is strictly required by law to be done. You took the risk and the result was the commission of the present offence.
Here it appears, however, that your negligence to obtain a licence was not due to a wilful omission. The following day after the offence was committed you applied for a licence and you obtained it on the payment of the prescribed fee. We are inclined to accept that it was a mere negligence on your part in failing to obtain the required licence. You did not intend to break the law.
In the circumstances, taking into account also that you have no previous convictions we consider the order of the forfeiture of the gun and the prohibition order of the carrying of it for two years is excessive.
Your sentence, therefore, will be varied as follows: You are ordered to pay £20 on count 1, instead of £10 originally imposed. The fine of £5 on count
4 is affirmed.
The forfeiture order as well as the prohibition of carrying the gun are set aside.
The net result is that you will pay £25 fine, you will get your gun back and you will also have the right to make lawful use of it as from today.
Order accordingly.
* Accused was discharged on 2nd and 3rd Counts by the trial Court.