Counsel's withdrawal of support for conviction allows appeal; trial court misdirected law and ignored circumstances.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court allowed the appeal against the appellant's conviction for driving a land-rover dangerously. The appellant argued the trial judge misdirected himself on the law and failed to consider all circumstances, while the Crown's counsel explicitly stated they would not support the conviction. The court accepted this withdrawal, set aside the conviction and sentence, and noted the significant delay in filing and trying the charge.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAs. 5(1) of Law Cap.332; where counsel informs the court they do not intend to support a conviction, the appeal is allowed as the judgment cannot be supported.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IAGiurisprudenza citata
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*1042]1965 September 30
(VASSILIADES, TRIANTAFYLLIDES, JOSEPHIDES, JJ. )
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Pavlos Nicolaou,
Appellant,
v.
The Police,
Respondents.
(Criminal Appeal No.2788).
Criminal Procedure - Appeal - Statement by Respondents’ Counsel of his intention not to support conviction - Appeal allowed.
Adjournments - Delays in hearing of cases - Observations in Nicola v. Christofi and another. Civil Appeal No. 4500*, regarding delays in civil actions, applicable with still greater force in criminal cases.
Charge. 1st Count: Causing death by want of precaution contrary to section 210 of the Criminal Code, Cap. 154. (Acquitted by trial Court).
2nd Count: Driving land-rover dangerously, contrary to sections 5(l) and 1 3 of the Motor Vehicles and Road Traffic Law, Cap.332 as amended by Laws 25/59, 2/62 and 8/64. (Convicted by trial Court).
Sentence on count 2: B.O. in the sum of £100.- for 2 years to keep Law, pay £7.- costs, disqualified from holding and/or obtaining driving licence for 1 year.
Nature of Appeal: Appeal against conviction.
Grounds of Appeal: "1. The Learned Judge in the Court below in finding the Appellant guilty on count 2 misdirected himself as to the law applicable to the case being tried.
2. The Learned Judge in the Court below in convicting the Appellant failed, as [*1043] sub-section 1 of section 5 of Law Cap.332 directs, "to have regard to all the circumstances of the case" as found by the learned Judge himself.
3. The Conviction of the Appellant on Count 2 was unreasonably and/or cannot be supported having regard to the evidence.
4. The Learned Judge in the Court below failed to realise that in substance and in fact the two counts with which the Appellant was charged were alternative ones each referring to facts which took place simultaneously and that consequently the Appellant having been acquitted on Count 1 should be acquitted on Count 2".
A. Anastassiades, for the Appellant.
L. G. Loucaides, Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondents.
VASSILIADES, J. : Mr. Loucaides, we have considered the record; and this morning we have discussed it before coming - into Court. We thought that it might save time if we asked you whether you think that the judgment of the trial Court can be supported.
MR. LOUCAIDES: I do not intend to support this conviction, Your Honours.
VASSILIADES, J.: That is very wise of you, Mr. Loucaides.
COURT: We take the view that this is a proper course for counsel to take, in the circumstances of this case. In fact, perhaps, we could go a little further and say that this is the only course, having regard to the record and the judgment of - the trial Court. [*1044]
The appeal will he allowed; and the conviction on count 2 he -set aside, together with the sentence and disqualification order made thereon.
We may, perhaps, take the opportunity to repeat what we have just said in the judgment in the Civil Appeal (No.4500) just delivered.* We think that what was stated in that case regarding delays in civil matters applies with, still more strength in criminal cases. My brother Mr. Justice Josephides draws attention to the fact that this charge was filed six months after the motor car accident had occurred; and was tried 15 months later. A very unsatisfactory state of affairs indeed. We need not say more, except that we hope that we shall have no cause to make such observations in future.
Appeal allowed.
Conviction on count 2 set
aside together with the
sentence and disqualification
order made thereon.
* Published post, at p.1048.
* Nicola, Hji Erini v. Christofi and another, (Civil Appeal No. 4500), published post, at p. 1048.