Appeal dismissed; past medical retirement decision unaffected by later health improvement.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe Supreme Court dismissed the appellant's appeal against the Republic of Cyprus's decision not to re-employ him in the Fire Service. The appellant argued that a subsequent medical certificate proved his fitness for work, despite having retired years earlier on medical grounds. The court held that the administrative decision regarding his initial retirement remains valid and cannot be altered by his current health status.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAPublic Service Law; Administrative Law: A decision to retire a public servant on medical grounds remains binding and cannot be challenged or reversed based on the servant's improved health or fitness for work in subsequent years.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IATesto completo
[*561] 1965 June 1
IN THE SUPREME COURT OP CYPRUS
ON APPEAL MD ORIGINAL JURISDICTION
(ZEKIA, P., VASSILIADES, TRIANTAFYLLIDES,
JOSEPHIDES, JJ.)
Melic Parankeva,
Appellant,
v.
Republic of Cyprus, through
Miniotry of interior,
Respondent.
(Revisional Jurindiction Appeal No.2).
Eire Service - Appeal from dismissal of Appellant's recourse against the decision of Recpondent not to re-employ or re-instate him in the Eire Service from where he retired on medical grounds - Appellant's present state of health, several years after his said retirement, cannot affect the administrative decision under which he was retired - Appeal based more on compassionate than on legal grounds.
Ef Ioannidou - Vrahimi (Mrs.), for the Appellant.
Kt C. Talarides, Counsel of the Republic, for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
ZEKIA. P.: The appeal is dismissed and the reasons will be given by my learned brother Mr. Justice Vassiliades.
VASSILIADES. J.: The present appeal * appears to be based more on compassionate than on legal grounds. [*562]
The appellant is a middle aged man with heavy family commitments. He is the supporter of a family with many children depending on the earnings from his work. He is now trying to go back to his employment as a fireman, on the contention that, having been retired on medical grounds, he can now show that the certificate containing the opinion of the Medical Board upon which he was retired, was wrong. He contends that, on the strength of a later medical certificate, he can show that he is healthy and fit for his work.
For the reasons already explained in the course of the argument we do not think that his present state of health, several years after his retirement on medical grounds, can affect the administrative decision under which he was retired.
Learned counsel for the appellant has certainly taken great pains to make out a good case for her client on compassionate grounds. But as soon as the case came to he tested on legal considerations in the course of the argument, it became apparent that there was no legal ground upon which it could be successfully argued.
The question of applicant's present state of health, as well as the other circumstances which would support his request for re-employment now as a fireman, will, we believe, be sympathetically considered by the proper authority on whom the responsibility rests for making the decision for his re-employment or otherwise. This Court is not in a position to express any view on applicant's fitness for re-appointment; and can do no more about it than extend the [*563] sympathy already expressed, in the circumstances, for his numerous family.
As stated by the President, the appeal cannot succeed and must he dismissed. There will he judgment and order accordingly.
MR. TALARIDES: I claim no costs.
COURT: No order as to costs.
Appeal dismissed.
No order as to costs.