Transport Regulation Challenge Dismissed
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns challenges to the legality and application of certain statutory provisions and related administrative actions concerning commercial transport, specifically alleging that required permits or classifications unduly restricted commerce and that the regulations were otherwise unconstitutional or improperly enforced. The court reasoned that the challenged regulatory scheme, including specific fee structures and classification criteria for transport operations, was within the scope of the regulatory authority vested in the administrative body, finding the requirements were a permissible exercise of police power designed to ensure public safety and welfare in commercial transit. Furthermore, the court determined that the differing classifications and associated financial burdens were rationally related to legitimate governmental objectives, thereby rejecting claims that the regulations constituted an unconstitutional burden on interstate commerce or violated equal protection principles.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; PC ; PRESTATION COMPLÉMENTAIRE ; DESSAISISSEMENT DE FORTUNE ; PREUVE ; FARDEAU DE LA PREUVE ; MAXIME OFFICIELLE ET INQUISITOIRE ; RÉVISION(DÉCISION) | LPGA53;
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the appeal proceedings.
The court orders the respondent to pay a reduced indemnity for the federal court proceedings to the appellant.
Testo completo
"#$#%"#&&' ("))*"#&&'
(
( +( + +
+,- # ! .* /- #&&'
!"#$% &'( ''( )!( *!(+(' '
('
,, -- - -'( ( ! ./01"#"" 2
! !
5#3""5
0 (
"6 7 5&'8''(9!":%4!(!) ( ; (< ":4"6!(! =!!> ;'(( 8'; ) (! & ":4#(&'(( &!( '>!!'& "::16
#6 '&&'(;?/(!(!!(= &';>> (&'@A!7 5 &'8 ; 9 ": <) ' #$$" B ( ? &'(( &!( '!(!'&' ((&(;!((>'(= 8'( (!'/( C'( > C&' )''.(;') ? ''( ;) ( & !'! ; (( = ;) ' DD#*$2D>'6 ? (!'/(>'('( )E( ('/? &' (= 6
%6 &'(( &!( ' ( !(! & 8 > F( #$$$ ( &' ! 0>!)' '#$$"; '!!B''('='( "0"*%2">'60$'&'!((&'(( ?; !' ( ) ')'!B('(6
16 '<A("D< (#$$# ('' -5 '&!((!'! '')=&'&'' &( ! '( (( (( ?; &'( ( ' = = ' ( ''( ' ( = > 5 ;A ( ' ;= A( '( (' (( '&'!(( )' '.( ;'5) ( ')C! B ; ( ! &' ) !.!(()! 6
06 ' ! #$ )=' #$$# ; >'! ''( ? &(='#$$$<?;"'!='#$$#(B&('((( &'(( &) ( /(''!&((= &' !'( 6 ((( ? >'( ''( ) ( &! "*$1%*"##>'6":4:B"D%*#$">'6"::%* !'!?(( = ;!) ( B4:0*0$%>'6":4:B "::%!&( (G ,'6 00$*$$$55 '='(' )'&'/( ,'6 #$$*$$$55 ('( &'> G ,'6 %$$*$$$55 ('( &'8'G ,'6 0$*$$$55
,'6 %10*0$%55 &'&' ('( ,'60$$*$$$553 ') ; ,'6"01*1:D55HC'' ?6
26 ; > '!'>&'! '&& ( #1<) '#$$%6
3#%#43#$$2 5%3""5 D6 '' #0 >!)' ' #$$% ('<(! &'8 * (' (! '' ''( (( ( &' &( ?; C ( ( = 6 '&& ( B ( !A' ?;&'8 ( ( <?; ":4: ) ( F > ' && B ; ( ' &' = (' ( ' > 8'( > 6'(; ) (!? !( ()'!!& (&>>((( #:0>'6&' (&' '&(%4$*$$$>'6)'!&'' ;( (')?;":416''('&& (!A(?> ! ":2">>';A')>>( ! ? ;(<'' &= (') ' ? =(( ;) ( &(! !&' &'(( ?('8(' )((;) ( =('(?;< "::: ?; ;( !A( &! 8' ? ) ) ( E('/( ((6 > ( !A( ) ' &' & &'(( => ; ('( 6
46 '!& %$ )' #$$% ; '&& ( <' &' ' =>!!''7 5&'8 , 9( 8'= ( ('<(''6
:6 '''/(%$'#$$1 ' =!&'( ( ''6 ! &' !'( B ( (' = * (( 0$$*$$$>'6'( >B*('( &'&'''((((%$$*$$$ >'6 '( B ( (' *('( &' > ) (( &' &( * B &'!'B)6> '!&' !'( B( (' = *((0$*$$$>'6'( >B*('( 8' ''((*((#$$*$$$>'6''&(E&'/(=(&' ''(6
-*A ( ' ' &( ' = '( ? '( ''( !A () ''!#$$*$$$>'6'='( )' &'/( ? ) ( ( ?* ; &&'( ( & &')6 (' '!'; ( (!E? ;( !'( (( &!' &' (! B ( ' ( > ?; ) ( &' > ( (! B &' ? ;) ( !6 ' = (( ( &' !?(?' &'(( (;!'(';.C&(.8?; (> ((' A('A(? ?;&'!() '> (6'>;&&'(' ?? &'! &( = ;!(= ' B ( >( ' ( ; &'( ; ? ' ( !(! '! ; &'( ( !.!( ) ( '='' (B? ( &'/(( ;('&'(>'!( ( !'' ?; *!( ( #$$*$$$ >'6 ('5 &'(( ! ?!?(7>6 -#$$3#$$1&6296> ((! ? ( => * ('( *!( (&'& 6
"$6 '! #% #$$0> '!'&& ( #F(#$$0* (( =B( ('*('( > ''(
3#%#43#$$2 513""5 "4$*$$$ >'6 '( ? &( '( B ( (' = !(!'!B"#$*$$$>'6
""6 - ( '' !&! # &(=' #$$0 ( B * ('( ! &' ' = ! &'( ( ' * &(( ''B(= B( ('*('( > ''(&' !":4:B"::%6 ('!(!(!' !&'''/("$<) '#$$26
"#6 ' ! %$ ( %" <) ' #$$2 * !(' ! ' ( E &'(( &!( '(E&'(( * (''( && ( ''/( <' ( !6 &'( ' * ((! ? (( B '( ' B ( (' = !( ( #0$*$$$ >'6 (0$*$$$&'*('( 8'''((#$$*$$$>'6B( (' '='( &'/( !(= 6 ( &'!! B *'( ( (( && ( *'( "D 6 " ( # *' ' &'(( &!( ' B * - ( B * 7 5&'8 9 *(5B5 ' B ' "$*$$$ >'6 &' 6 ' !?( &'(( &!( ' >!!'!( (& < #$$#(&'(( * ( !( (&!((('!('( >!((&(&!&' 5 6
"%6 (2'#$$2''(> (&& ( B! 6
-*A ( #$$*$$$ >'6 '( B ( (' = 8A /(' (( ' *!(= ' I '! (! (= * > 8' E(!' '('":41(":4:JC('(')!'!(((( &' '( & #$ 6 > ":40 B > ":4: ''( *) (&''&'&' ('( ( > ?*(( "0$*$$$>'6B & ( E?*<( ('(* ) (!6(( &'(! &( * ' /(' !'! !' ' & ?* (( ''( &!%0$*$$$>'6&''!?(' (D*%$$>'6 ) ' &' &' ('( ( > 6 > ' & &) ' >' ' * ( (! &' ? &'/(! *'A( '( (( &!' 6
' '((!A (!*'(6"D6" ? &'!) (? &'( >'( B &'' &( ( '! ( .? ! "$*$$$>'6'>'(E (((&' !'( ') !(' ( B .(' *"3"0 &' &' =!!> * '( * ) (! ( *"3"$ &' &' =!!> * '( ) * '(6 % 6 " (6 6 ! ( !A (! (' (( = (' &' ? ( =!!> * >'( E (((&'?'( (>'(> ( )E>'( *'( ( & / >K ( *'6 >(
3#%#43#$$2 503""5 &( ((' ? ''( ) ( ')! #$$*$$$ >'6 ?( '=''('( B.(' >>!' (' *'A( ( & ( ( .'A6 >( '( ' ( *'( ('! (('( (*"3"0>'( &'6
"16 '! '&& ( #% #$$2'K&'''(#2 * ((! ?* !( ( ( *&& ?' & ( !A ( '!A( ') A'(&) (&'!?((''( 8'' *'( (= 6!=(!''(' & (6' ' !'!?*'A(> ()E'( > (( = ''& ( B '!) ( * (' ' =!=<(&!(6
"06 '(#2< #$$2''(''(('((! ((B ( (B? (')C!B* &') *'( ( = ) ( !&6 '' !(! )'(!' 3#%#43#$$26
=( ''( '&' E& ( ( 'A(( !)&&!'*&& ( 6* 5/ ?'( !#$$$B#$$2&'?&'(( &!( '(!(! ((( '>! B ''( .'A 5 !& ( =& ')6 - '( ( >'( > ( ) #$$*$$$ >'6 >('*'( '>( '!= ''(>(? *'(6"# ( (( >!!' ? &'!) ( ? ? ? ( (( !('(&(=) 'B('( ' (*/(' !( (' >K B ' E ( >' B A (! . ( A')() !6
"26 '!) (' *>> &'* (B'!)'(' '!) 3"4%03#$$%6
"D6 '& 0< (#$$2''((B?'!) (!'!= >!B?* ( ((((!?#$$*$$$ >'6 ''&( B &'/( '='! &' ''( ? &'!!( *(' &'(( &!( ' ' ( /(' !'! (( ( B ? ( ')C! B * &' )&'(( &!( ') (!&6
"46 ' =!'!&'( &'&'( E( !6'* "#&(='#$$2E (!(!< ( 3#%#43#$$26''(!'!? (G
3#%#43#$$2 523""5 I 8' ) ' !(= <'*. ? <* F &'(' #$$*$$$ >'6 ( ?* *( ') ?*B '' ('( ( > ' &!' ?(' <?* )'( > ( &' *L 6 *!(= B ?*('5&'(( = !(!> (B#$$*$$$>'6> ' ? < &E !) ' * ( (! &'/(' ? ( !!! * ' '( ? &'((' ( & ' = *(' ?( ' &' !' (6 ?( ) ' ? !(= ( ? <* F '='' (( (?<* > (&'+(!) ( <*) &'='!(( &' &' ( ' ( !(! ' A! B ('67M9 * ' '&&' > ' ? & "::1 ( .? ! ? ) <* (<' ! B * (( >'( ( & 8 '( ) B (( > 8' C &' *!)( >'( &' ? ! &'!!(6- B(5B&(*) (!(!!&'&'/( #$$*$$$ >'6 <*' & !(= ' *&'( ( '='( & ? &'/('!( (') 6 &' <' ' = '& 8 &(6 ''( (( ? <* > ( *=<( * ?/( ?( &'?< &('( )(B '(' ( N (') ( 8' <*) >>( ')! C>( ( > ' *?/(!(!)'('&'! 67M9-'?( <* ??<* >>(!'='( B &'((>'( ! '!&'( ('":4:("::"6'( ' &'((B=?(< ('(( B &' ?( *A ( & ' O '>'6)!' > ' &'8 (' '(' (&('/('>' P6
'&'!(( * &' & ( ( G I -*A ( '!) <*'(B<( 6(E(?* ) (8"::1(( & 8B & ( ((!&(= ' ( 6 - * ( '='( ( ( '='( &'/( &(5/(' ? E5 ' ( ) = ' (6-*A ('&'! <&E&''6&E? ' ? ' ' * ? ( ? &' &'( < ('! >( >!)' '#$$"&!' B?! '( (( !(! '6 > *A ( ( (' ? !(! &' ":(='#$$$<* ??*!*A( ' '!( ' '( '(' *!&?J6
Q* * ! !(!> E!B''(&'&'( !.!(*(((( = '6
":6 ' & ## &(=' #$$2 ''( (' '!>E &' ' =6
3#%#43#$$2 5D3""5 #$6 ' & #: &(=' #$$2 ''( &' & )( ( ( ? *E ( *&'( !(! ' ('8 )' == &' & 8 )( &' (6 ( B ?( ) ' '='(((*(!A( ?& 8B*&& ? =?*(<'*. &'&' 'E(' (&( !'! (( (''(>>'/(''&= (' ' * ? ' ( F '!' !.!( & 8 &!( ''*E')!= '6*!)( ') "::$B"::%&' (!A(> (!(('(' (= '#0%*:21>'6 "::$%D4*"%">'6"::"(%"2*$$4>'6"::#6 &:$$*$$$>'6 (!(!'( '!&'''(&('((' !(& 2$$*$$$>'6) (!(!'( '!'(!"::$("::" (E )( )'( &' *' :$$*$$$ >'6 ( ' )' == ? ' '(' ( #$$*$$$ >'6 ( !(! ( ! '='(&'/('!6
#"6 !' (' ( & 8 &!( ' ( !(! (' B * 2 (='#$$2(! !(!'!&'!(' ( %"(=' #$$26
##6 '& "2(='#$$2* ?!*'(('B<( 6
#%6 ' !?( &'( ( !(! >'! ": (=' #$$2 ? !( (A'!B<A'6
(
"6 A) ';'A ( < '79!(! > !( ( (!8 "'F(#$$% ' =(' &!0<A (&'! (() 5&'! (0&&!(("2<A'7'(6"(6 '(02 96
- (B;( ;!( "2<A'&' ' =>!!' #D<) '#$$17 ,"%$"$29' A) &(!"%>!)' ' & ( (' ( ''A(&'((( ' =(' !A' ' B (' <A ( ( ' ;((( ;!( )E<A'6
#6 >'!(E'(6026"(6.6%(6#(6 ' =( ' +( ((( &'!) B ;'( 1% ('&'(( (&!( 'B;'5) ( ') )((B;'5 ) (!#0(='":24 ?*B >!!' '&'(( &!( 'B*') ') )(( ) (! ":'":207 5&'8 96
3#%#43#$$2 543""5 -&!(&'<A';&8( !(= 6
%6 >!!''&'( A!!'' (' 2(=' #$$$7 9(('!) A'"'<) '#$$%('+( > ( =' & ( !A ' 6-' &(!' & () '?' (*&& ? (/('('.!B 8' &' &?'8A&& =() A'(N > (<' ?(!(' ((&' (7 ,"%$#%$ 6"6"R %%0 6"6#R ,"#:1 6"6#R ,"#D12D 6""#2"%2 61=('!>!'96'8A&'!'?(B*&& ?( '!')8<'('!) A'7 ,""D:% 62=""#%2$ 61R "::4S%D&6%"2 6%=96 ;&& ? ;&86
16 ?( ( A &' & (B)!' > ' ''(&(&'!) ' *( >'!) C(&'!??* ('!' &'(( &!( ' ? ' ( B = #$$*$$$ >'6 - '!) ) ( /(' '<(! C ' ( ' *E ' '( > B *'( ( (( ( ?*&!'! &' * (!A6
06 E (' *'(6 0% 6 " ! ( ! ' && ( >'( &! >' ( B '!) *'! *'' !)' =!?( > ( )E &'(( (') )E C&')? &) (/('&' (&')(6( > ( C &') )E *&&'! / 8' '!) 7&'!'9 * ! ('( ) 7'(6 0% 6 " 9 '!) * <A((7'(62"(6 9'!) *''/(>!'*'( "%D(('=7 , &= !#:)='#$$0 "D03$1 6#6#96
-(I)EJ & ( > (? (&' (<?* ( N &'!' &' & !A( > ( !( ( ' ')= ? *!( (&'?!'(A'!(( A6 ('> ()E )(/(' &'((*(5B5 '?* )(/(' ('B > '*!((> (? (B=*''/(('&' (B 'B <A( >>!'(>( *&&'! ( <' ?''(6
&') ?( B )( ') ' B &')' ( > ( )E &'((? ( )('!) (> (? !( ('(' &'!' &'!!( ? *) ( & & /(' &')! !(' ( '?!'(6 - )E C ( ( ! B &')' > ( !A! (!' '('?!'( ( !(''?* &) (& )?' &'!!( &'!'6 &') ( !'! ( '?* >((('?*' ( (<AB(('('(* ) (
3#%#43#$$2 5:3""5 &'!' &' &6 (E( C &') (&') 'B*&&'! ( > (( B*!(= ( ' '7 ,"#D%04 60=('!>!'R , &= ! #4)' #$$0"4%3$1 6#6#'!! -#$$0&6#1#96 *C& ( > B '!) > ( ? (' = &'+( ) ' ('&'!(! > ( !<B'&'!'&' &6*&&'! ( E( (/('= &(T(!?* A'*=&')> (( &'<A(7 ,"#D%04 60=""$"1" 6##:% 6# ""4#$0"$4"D" 6"R , &= !#4>!)' '#$$0"113$1 616"96
26 )<' &'( !>'((('? ( *'!) (&'& *&8 ( (&'E( >6 (*='> (?''() (F&'('#$$*$$$>'6 &'=) 'B= (BE> *)!' (!< !(!((!&' * 6 *( = &(T( *= A( ? ' ( (')! '='' (( ( &') '='( ? *( & !(! 6 ' *= &') B ( !A' ( '(( ! B *(( ( ''( ? *( (<' '>! B ' * ( (! &' ? *) ( ! > ( !. &'5B / B *&&'( &')6 ' ' ( ((' ? ''( *&&'( <'*. & & ?*. ' &') '='(6 ?*>' ((((B> ( >> (( (&)E6' (&'( '! '* &'('(' ( >>(!&'''(> (?*( !('A(&'( &'&'!' '='(' * ?(&?* (!(!(B' '6
'!?('!) ''<(!6
D6 C 8'*E '*'A('( >B* !A (!*'( "D6" ( (' ( )( G I &'( >'( B &'' &(7'(6%6"(6A 9('! (.?!"$*$$$>'66J6
('( ' ( !A'N '!' ( !A (!(''! &( '8(( * >'( ( 8' ?* &)( &' * (( #0*$$$ >'6 ( ( ( &' &( &' ') !(' ( B .(' *"3"0 &' &' =!!> * '( * ) (!(*"3"$&'&'=!!> *'() *'(6%6"(6 6
- ( ''(( && ?! ( A'( ' &' 5/ *!A (! (' ((68AA!!'(=(' (('!( !(( (( &' (( ) / 8'6 *(' ( (( !A (! ( ( /(& !A (!6C &( ( A'(' (!A' G N (( (B& (==?*'!A ( ?* &N
3#%#43#$$2 5"$3""5 (B& ( ==?'!A >>!'( )(/(' ( (! (> N(I('5EJ(&'((( = * ( (!? >>!'6 ' =>!!' ( A?*('E&' 8'(!A' (( (( )( /(' ! * *(' 5 6 >( &' !?('* C >>!'&'( (('E& ' (( !( ?!?C((.'7>6 ''' ( ('( >)"&A100( )(96
*'' C E (( ( ( ? (' ( >>!'( G *&'('! &(*>'(&'?!A ('! ! *&' &(*('&'('!? ( = (&'?'!A &'( '!(!&'!)6 '(&(' ? ( >!!' B &(' &' '( ( "$*$$$ >'6 &' ! = &(T( ? *&& ?' '8A &'!) &' '! &!(>'(6&(&((('?*BE'&' (( , > '!>>(!&'* && ( *'(6"D6" 7>6 , 0:3$##4F(#$$%(""3$1#"< (#$$196'!(? !A (!(('*(&' 6
'!?(''''<(!!A(6
3#%#43#$$2 5""3""5
+ 1( 0 ( +( + +
!
234-- 5 6 78 .'# 9
4-
"6 !'''')=6
! 4
#6 '<((6
%6 <(('!) ((?*')=6
16 (?&'!'(A'( (6
06 >' &'( ?; &)( >'' '' (' &'!( ''/( ! %$ <' 8 ( > ( &' & '! '! ' = >!!' ' -.U O'.>? 2 2$$1 (' E& '6 ! &( /(' &'A!6 ! ' (G 9 ?' E((?! ''(! '=( ' (&! ((?!R =9 E&' &' ? ( > ( &) ' ' (( (' ! R 9 &'(' A(' '&'!((6 - ! ' ( ( & (' !!( !!'! ((' 9 =9 ( 9 5 ' =>!!''&''&(''( 8''''?; )'!'' '')=6! '''( ''C &') ? '( < ( ? ! ((?! ( ;)&& ?!(!E&! !''(7'(6"%#"$2("$496 A'>> 8' &'! ( VW X =-
& >'&'!(''/((( > !E&'( ?;B;>> >!!' ' &'A'>>
3#%#43#$$2