Environmental Tort Liability and Contribution Claims Following Hazardous Material Release
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought recovery for damages arising from a release of hazardous materials from a facility, asserting various environmental and common law claims against another party responsible for the facility's operation, and the court considered multiple motions related to the scope of liability, including claims for contribution and indemnity, as well as issues regarding the statute of limitations and the applicability of certain regulatory exemptions. The court reasoned that the statutory liability scheme was broad enough to encompass the claims presented, rejecting attempts to limit responsibility through contractual agreements or by invoking exemptions that did not squarely apply to the facts, while also addressing procedural deficiencies such as standing or timeliness for certain specific claims, ultimately allowing most claims related to the ongoing environmental harm to proceed against the operator.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Environmental Tort Liability and Contribution Claims Following Hazardous Material Release: The court reasoned that the statutory liability scheme was broad enough to encompass the claims presented, rejecting attempts to limit responsibility through contractual agreements or by invoking exemptions that did not squarely apply to the facts, while also addressing procedural deficiencies such as standing or timeliness for certain specific claims, ultimately allowing most claims related to the ongoing environmental harm to proceed against the operator.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAImposes the costs of the federal proceeding on the appellants.
Determines the distribution of costs between the parties in the federal proceeding.
Testo completo
"#$%#"#&&' ("))#"#&&'
(
( *( * *
*+, # ! -. /, #&&'
!"##########$!"%$&'&(
)) $ )) $*++ "% ! &$&,-' )
! !
1'./1
0 (
&+ !2!%!&/ 3',,&$)4!51"!6%!% 7 588 !588 ! ########## ! %6$ !" ########## 916: ;$ % 6 4" &(</ &(<=$ 6:!1"! )) 916:;$488 & 3 ',,&+
'+ !4 ! 6" ! >3 ! ? !> 3 !8"$ 6@ %!6"!6 ! ?7 64!6 +
A+ 'B ',,'$4%66 8"%6%62+ 21 C % 6: ! 3 !" 8$ "6% $ %? @ !D% 5% 6 43$ !: @5 54 6 ?% @5 54 C"E! ?%%$! !34+
<+ C?" !0C4',,<$ 3!" 8C %$C 8"% 6 F ! 3 8%!% ! 916: G ; ! - C ',,<+
-+ 6$ D@ 6" ! 6" 8 >3C !> 6%!$ 6 D ! !2%62+
0+ >H 66H%6"!"!C4 8%4',,0$ !%7D!5266 "!"$&08%4 &/"',,0+
/+ &A 4 ',,0$ !%6% %@ ! 6 7 588 ! 6 $@ 8%'<4',,0""!" !6H$6 ,0/=<-A( $ %" 2 6" ! "" ! &>&(< 8+$ 4 %F 7-I!:&8%4',,0$6<,8+!8!" 8$8 !6 $6! 26""6H%!&C4A&" ',,0+ 8"%66 C"F"+
=+ !%!&0"',,0$8"%66 &0C',,0$ 6%"4%!>66 ""!" !6H" %+
(+ !&'C ',,0$ 75 !6 !5+8 4@5 $5 C"?%! !51"! 4 + %8: 7 > + A+& ! ! ?%%$ @ >66@ 6 7 $ @ 32 8"%+ 6! $ C6! % 6 21 >66@ 6 6+ 6 4 !>88 $ 2$ @> 8 ?%$ :? ! !!3? +
.'-/'.',,0 1A./1 &,+ %6!'-C ',,0$66@5F ! G !<C ',,<8"%588 !588! @!6 !! ! 3? 4 7 !5 6 663 " : !51"! 3? $ 6%+ C ! 7 !6 $6" !'>'//8+6!2%62$8!6 "6$6 %F 7-I !:&B ',,-$ 6C ',,-+
&&+ 6 ! A& C ',,0$ C! !% 6 ! % 2 $ 8"% @ 6: % 7 !6 ?88 6 +
&'+ @ 3!%!%C7 %!"36%!! @ "F" 6 $ 4@ H %" @" "F" ?" +"6 !6 '<C4',,0! "+ 6 6%!% 7 %D? ! 4+ 3 ! 26 + 6! 6 % ! $ ! ?" + >F ! 7 / 8%4 ',,0$ J ) &&<.',,0$ 3 !"% 7 %"" ! -,, 8+ D$ " 8 @ @ ? 4 !%C7 % % !%8 4" % 7 6 6$ @ @ !>F !"% 6" !>%"" 4 % %?%6%%!"" +
&A+ $C! 3 %!!%62 $ @: ! @> " 6% "%? 4 " 6 ! 6%! !%"" @> !"%74+6% % %6!!> ! !6%! %+!!&= 3 ',,0$ 3 % % @> " C 8 @ %62 !6 ! @! %+ %@ $ % % 6&4"3',,0$ 6 % %8"%@>% ?!%7 C?+
(
&+ ?45? C!9;% %"!8% %$!: &B ',,A$ 3 !$"6%!-C?$ ! 6%! 416%! $-66% &0C?9 +& + -0 ;+
) 75 !5% !&0C?$6 38%!% '/C4',,<9 G&A,&,0;$! ?4!6 %$&A8%4$ !6 ? 6" 3 ! ! %? 7 C? $ $ ! 5 ! 5% !42C?+
.'-/'.',,0 1<./1 '+ 8"%" 7 > + -0 + & + D+ < $ 3 ! K @! 6%475 -0 ! 8%!% 6 ?%% ! ! ! ! = 3',,,9 ;@ 478%!%51"!! &="&((<9 ;+
)"6% 6C?!!56: % 3+
A+ 8%!%6 ?%%!! !!0 3 ',,,9 ; %4?&C4',,A$ K "!8 !"3!6 %?!!"!+) 6" %$6 !4@! >66@! F D%7": !66@:?663 4?"" L 8 C!@" !% " 6! 9 G&A,'A,!+&+&M AA-!+&+'M G&'(<!+&+'M G&'/<0/!+&$&'0&A0 !+<3 %8%;+:?!6%!@ 7>66@ %4!:C! %4?9 G&&/(A!+03$&&'A0, !+<M &((=NA/6+A&0!+A3;+ 566@! !56:+
<+ C %!8" !%6%46$ 439-0 0, ;+
-+ $8!6$F 88%6:!5 "%$!: @5 5 C" E ! ?%%$ ?% ! !5!D%+ @ 8% % D%766$! @ 3 ! % 7 H 4+ @ 88 @ ! ? ! 8!DC?%+
0+ 53? ! 6H 6" !% ! 5 + 0& M 6 ! 53? ! 5 !5" 6 D? ! %4%" %+ %@ C!@ "6% 4 ! 88 6:!51"! 5% !7 !%!19 &(=,6+&0&M&(=&6+0&;+6"!4 F 6H%754 66 "9 +(,+&!5!51"!!'=C&((- O M 8+ D88 &<+& ! ! ?%% !5 6 5 3? !1 !5 )) ;+ @! % 3%%8%!4 !>6! 26"@ %"%+
!4 8 4 6% !% ! 3? 8: ! 5% O 6" ! 6" + 0& ! 6 6 8:5 +0< $!"F"@%@! 12% !3? O64!52% 8% 6 9;6!"6 9 +(,+A ;+
.'-/'.',,0 1-./1 !% !% 66 2% @ 6 !" 7 6H""!5? 78!B % "%2C?" 2% 5 + =, 9 + == + ' $ 4? C@5 A& !%"3 ',,'$ + -< + ' !: & C4 ',,AM G &'0 '0= !+ < %8%;+ $ 8 !" 8 " 7 D?!6%$ !!56:-8+68!66 '-8+65% 3" !"!"9D88&/+& ;+ 88 $ C6!$ H 8 ! 5% @$ 6 "6 " $ 3? 7 ! ! 66 6 52D 7 6H
9 G&'-'/0$ +'//!+'.M ',,&N&-&6+&&/;+
/+ % !6:!!@ 5 66H%6"6 6%! ! & C4 A& " ',,0 9A(= 8+ 6 " 6 D@ %;$ "?%66 "!"!5 "%+
3 ! % @ 6%! ! 4" % % ?" 6 % 6 5 "% @ !4 ""!&>&(<$6<,8+!8!" 8$@8!6 +
54:%@"8!%+
)5? ! %F " $5 +(,+' 6%@55%:4 7 - I 5 6 6" %D 5 + '0 + & + 6" 6H3 !54 2 %D% 4 98+ + &-+& ! ;+ 5$ %D & ! D@ " 6 %F !: ! +H! !%"H6@ ! ! @ %F " !4 F %!:&-8%4',,0+
=+ 6%! ? 66 9 +0& + M +=(P! 6%! !" 4 ! &' 6 "3 &(=- O ;+ 8$ ! %"" !C 8!6%!64 F "7D?! 6 @? !": %"% %"?!%?: %+ 88 $@ 38%!%!5!"$63 %!" ? % ! C %7%?: 66?%%!6%!6%46 3D!9 G&'0&-&!+<3;+
) C6!$ 4% 7 5%D F "% 7 6% : ! %?: % ! %"% % 9 G &'< '=-$ @ ) &((= 6+ &(<;+ 8 @5 %%" O @3 O 5C 3C 4" 6 Q 6 % ! 4 "% 6%! @! 3"F"64 !"6 $ !5 @5 64 3" 2? !5$ @ % !%64 ! D !:+
.'-/'.',,0 10./1 56:$ 6% : ! %"% %$ ! " L ?" 6 @ 566 6" ! 6" !51"! "F" @ 2 4@% 6%%!"" !4 6 32$ ! " 6 8 !4 3 ! %+ $ % % :" !%3 % C!@% %?" 26%+$ 3!%%7!" 6" !5 %"" ! !2 F 6%%! 9 ) (,=.',,- (A/.',,-; ! 3 ',,-$ 8 @5 6 7 54 F !"%$ 8"%" 7 5 + =(P + & $ 7 %"" 2 !%3 5 6 7 !4 3 ! % ! ! 88 "33 6 "F" " 8+ 6 $ % % !"%687!%"" C6%4%+3 $ 74C! 6"F"" 8+
&<+ >%"" !&,>,,,8+"2""$> +'+&!>F %! !> !" :9 -&,+,A;+ %"" 82%>6:7&>-,, 8+$%6 %62+
RRR
* 1( 0 ( *( * *
!
234,, 5 6 78 -'# 9
4,
&+ %43+
! 4
'+ C +
A+ !" ##########6" !>%"" !/-,8+
<+ !"!"##########6" !>%"" !/-,8+
-+ 8" 6 ! @5 64 8" 6% F ! !% ! A, C !: 8 6 6 ""!% !% 3 8%!% ! $ )DS*D8@ 0$ 0,,< $
.'-/'.',,0 1/./1 2"6+ !% 6 F 6?%+ "%" ! Q ; !@ 2 " @!% !%3 6!!% @%M 3; 26 6 @ " 8 " 64 !"! !%M ; 6 ? ! 6% + ) "%" 6 %%" %"%% ; 3; ; 1!$ 38%!%!66 " :@5 !4!%43+"%"!" "H ! 64$ @ C $ @ !% @% 5466 ! @% %26%!% 9 +&A'$&,0 &,=;+ ?88: %! TU V 3)
68"!6% F 8%26 @575888%!% ! %63@6?88
.'-/'.',,0