Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/987/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/987/2007 Generato dall'IA

Admissibility of Expert Testimony and Evidentiary Review

Numero d'incarto ATAS/987/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The appellant challenged the admissibility of expert testimony regarding the presence of a substance in the respondent's system, arguing that the expert was unqualified and the scientific methods used were unreliable, which resulted in an erroneous verdict in the underlying matter where the appellant was found liable for damages. The court reasoned that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting the expert testimony because the expert possessed sufficient knowledge and experience, and the methods employed, while perhaps subject to critique, were generally accepted within the relevant scientific community, thereby affirming the judgment based on the totality of the evidence presented at trial.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Admissibility of Expert Testimony and Evidentiary Review: The court reasoned that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting the expert testimony because the expert possessed sufficient knowledge and experience, and the methods employed, while perhaps subject to critique, were generally accepted within the relevant scientific community, thereby affirming the judgment based on the totality of the evidence presented at trial.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
prove inattendibili testimone-perito diritto alla prova censura dell'apprezzamento delle prove procedura probatoria strutturata censura dell'accertamento dei fatti

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs.

Art. 64 LTF

This article is cited in the final order concerning the allocation of legal aid.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

           $%&'($)((* +$&,*$)((*

 +

 +  +       

-  )

" %, .-  )((* 

 !!!"#$$%  & '

 !' !!!"#$(# 



 )'

*++, + -.' )/0$ "9'

1 )2($3#$## 2

.    ++   4!5 #61 )$$7##$##8-$



                 !"   " #

  $:%  

 / +

#< '=>)#7'$((6#28?@' '!@1'!8'!)  1'  "  !- '    "  #;26 )  !' "#;60'!")#6 ) @'$((0<

$< + ?!99'0=>)1'"!)" '!@1'!8'!) ' "  1')> 1'  !)!"  - !'  1'"- A 1' 9!  4! 1' ? "1 /')'!><

0< =>)!- ')-"9!!)!9#'!$((6)")")'!5 99!  '!@"#3!$((61 '/")! 1')><

%<  '!@" !!)"1')! '!)!))! 1'"- A 1!!)'1"!)!))! "9'1'!)! !4'  ))  - !'   1')! 4! ')  '!>  !) )'  #6 ) @'$((0)#'!$((6<

7< +    ''!'   *++ ,  +   ; =!) $((6  1'))!  4! 1)  '!> 1'  ' )  05##2 9'<  5 )'-!"99)9B CD)' !C41! ) @'$((7<$((0 C$((7!")!)")!)C5!-'!)"8-<+  ''!'. )!   !@' 1>           #6  E) $((6 5- !' C 1')>'   ' )  352(0 9'<77  9 ! "!)  1'))! '!>)!)"'D)=45!- '<

2<   ) ) ")" )'! / 1')!   ' 5!)')! < ' 1!  7 1)@'$((6='!!)! '!!4"45C"9)5 @'-)! 5!!#7 1)@'$((6''D)'!)''))@<

6< 5@5 @=)! "!9!/"")">'"C=>'<

  +

#< 5')<$7 !9""''!@'1>1'"- A1' 9!  -!!'-!-))!-!!)"#6"@'#;;0F.G)'"-!>' #'=-!'$((('8>1' "'!- '< '4 = !) ) 1H ''1'))!  ')!C1')>'F')<#$$)#$0  !-!& G =>!!- ' 1"))5')<60<# !9""'' 1'"- A 1' 9!   $7 =! #;3$ FG  !) C 8-  '!@ ) ' !1!#' E)$((0 !)1'84599!'!

    :#;%(:$((6 0:%  

 ")")'!F')<#%$ G/")'5 99!1')>'@ " '"1')!)! ")'!"1'=>!- '<

$< + 5')<$$.F -)'-!>'1!#'=-!'$(((G  !- '  1'))!    ')! 4! ')  '!>  ) 1')>"  9 '") /')<#$$#$0#%#)#%$ I')<0C7 .511!4) 1' >! ))C)'9"''F<#G< '?4 = !)1'))!   ')!C1')>' ''1 C!99"')'1'))!  ')!>)"  - !'  !@' 1> /!)) "-))   )  !- ' )  1'))!  ')!>)"- !'!@'1>/!))"-))  ) ! '!>F9<')<$%.G< ' = ) C  1'))!    ')! ) C 5- !'  !@' 1> /!))   )    !   '!>  !)"'D)    )  !- ' F . #$3  $0(I .#$;%%%G<

 H18  =>  1'!8' !)  ' "  1')> 1'  !)!"  1'))!    ')! 4! ')  '!> 1'  '<  ) 1')!) )H1')'!>#6 ) @'$((0H)'1')#' !$((6)C4=>)!- ')-/") !'<

0< +    ) 1' !)  1'))!  4! 1)  '!> 1'  ' )  05##2 9'< )! 4  4! 1'  ' )  352(09'< 77  !)"'D) A) "=C ")" " 1'  !)!))!   1'"- A "9'< !!' !)C /&"1  ))#57739'<(7 F05##29'<J$G)&! !)C!&C ))%50(#9'<3(F352(09'<77J$G   ') 4 H)  ' 4!  !)  '   ))  $56%09'<6(<

%< 9 '") C  ='!1' 1!  = ' ")'!) 1 '  1')> =45 ))'9')1'))!  ')! ' = !) !- '"@""9!!!'))1'))! ' !)C!)"'D) 1) !''  ))&!< !)"'D) )")/!!"> 5')<#$ 5 ' '1'"- A1' 9! -!!'-!-))!-!!)"  #3 -'! #;3% F $G     )/ '">)!' ! !&! ) 1"'!' F .#$;$77 !<0G<

7<  " )  ' 1'B  1' "' ")) >')!) F')< 60 < $  ) 3;<# !'1' "'!!)')!-#$1)@'#;37G<



KKK



    :#;%(:$((6 %:%  

   + /  +  +       

#< -!)  . )!   !@' 1>   4 )  - ! C )'9"''   1)        $56%0 9'< 6( C  *++, + 9-' !'!!4 !)"'D) 1) !' !"')8#'!$((6=45  ))'9')<

$< HA ))4@ !<

0< !)41' "')>')!)<

%< 9 '  1')!   4H 1-) 9 '' ' '  )'  1'") ''D)   "!  0( = ' 8   )!9!)!  1'8  '!@ 9""' F+?L!M'? 94!22((%  G1'- !' ')!8'' !) 1@! 9 '")/')<3$ !9""'' '!@9""'#6 =! $((7 F .GI  " !'  ' '  !) !!4'   !   )!9 )  A1'-)1 ')'!>)'' ')  )!'I! !) D)' '"  '!@ 9""' 1' - ! 1 )  1' - ! ")' !4 /  !)!   5')< %$  .<  1'") ''D) )  1!8  1 !   ' ')!- 4"  A1'- !-)D)'= !)C5- !<  >'99!8'  '"!)J         ,N O @+ 

 1! 9 '1'")''D)) )!9!"/1')!!!4HCH99!9""' ' !1'>'99

    :#;%(:$((6