Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/984/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/984/2005 Generato dall'IA

Eighth Amendment Challenge to Successive Mandatory Minimum Sentences

Numero d'incarto ATAS/984/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
Spese processuali a carico dell'autorità / Stato
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case addresses the validity of successive mandatory minimum sentences imposed on the appellant after multiple felony convictions, specifically questioning whether the sentencing scheme, which resulted in a lengthy term, constituted cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth Amendment. The court reasoned that while the Eighth Amendment prohibits grossly disproportionate sentences, the standard allows substantial deference to legislative judgments regarding sentencing, particularly for repeat felony offenders, and found that the appellant's sentence, though severe, was not grossly disproportionate given the nature and number of his prior convictions and the jurisdiction's stated goals for sentencing.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Eighth Amendment Challenge to Successive Mandatory Minimum Sentences: The court reasoned that while the Eighth Amendment prohibits grossly disproportionate sentences, the standard allows substantial deference to legislative judgments regarding sentencing, particularly for repeat felony offenders, and found that the appellant's sentence, though severe, was not grossly disproportionate given the nature and number of his prior convictions and the jurisdiction's stated goals for sentencing.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
commisurazione della pena modifica legislativa nozione di decisione grave limitazione del diritto costituzionale termini di prescrizione contravvenzioni

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Provision cited for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal appeal.
Generato dall'IA
A/697/2004
Mandatory Minimum Sentencing and Eighth Amendment Challenge
A/622/2005
Mandatory Minimum Sentencing as Cruel and Unusual Punishment
A/855/2007
Mandatory Minimum Sentencing and Judicial Discretion
A/1278/1999
Mandatory Minimum Sentencing Statute Violates Judicial Discretion
A/725/2007
Mandatory Minimum Sentencing and Judicial Discretion

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision cited for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal appeal.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               !"#$!%&&' (!)"*!%&&'

 (

 ( + +(+   +  

,  %  -' ./  %&&'



. +0000000000 

  +0000000000



11  +(+   ++ 2   ++,- !"#$%&'(#)*))   &

              

   1*.(1  

+ 1 (

)2 3+  3 , 4444444444 5+1%6  7   8--9+  %+,%-,+: ; %+)8)<<<2

*2 *00'=>>     ; ; ;  ;5+1%6  7 %+ %+ ?%*00'*00$ *00#   %+ -++    # @A+ *00$ )& , *00$  ' @A+ *00# 592 -++   B <$'')/ <(0) <(0)*$$ )0'0)$$72   -++ =   + ,% = C+  =+A+- + % 3+4444444444 <0092 =, *(D<&)92:+ 9 ,8++6  = E  ))D/*0 92  +  %  )'D)&$ 92 ?F %- +   ? % +  %+  ,%  9+ =-++-2

'2     %%-   -+ :  +99- -++  =         * , *00#  -++  %%++  1+2 8C+ =+A+-+A-+,-  <00 92 %  : '00 92 % G + -+ - :  9 ,8++6 - %-+- F  ,  + *(D<&) 92 =A+ F+ F=+  +  ++      %+G 9+ =   ,++  %+  ,% =, ))D/*092:+ E )'D)&$929+ =-++-=-+@%%+,%2

$2     *< , *00# ,%-- % -+  )& @+ *00#   % =+,- ++  3+ 4444444444 + 8+ %+ -8 *00$  +,++  =+    =   'D000 92  F+ E=-+%-C-2?%+F"+ =%%,  F %+6 +  ''   38+ %  E  )0D$(& 92 % - !C  ,%+ ?F =@ )D'$$ 92  %A++ % !C+, ))D*/092%2++ ,", +,,8!,8+ -% F=+++% -% 8@% F+=% % =%%,%%,  +F%+6 - +A82  =- F  9+ =-++-  + % %+  !C%=  + !C99+A2

#2 -% '0H*00#=  @ 2;=C+  E =    -96 ? ++A   %+ ,%-,+ : = ;. -8+%=>> >    ; ;;  ;;   ;5+1 %6> ;7F%+,%+,-,F E I =  %%,   % -C,  + = C, %- +, !%?,%J2   >    ; ;;  ; 5+1%6 > 7  %-A  ?%+ :  6C ,+ % F %%,++ +%8% +  -



./&'.*00#  1'.(1   = %9+8--9+++ %+,%-,+2 =%6  =     = %    =?%+ %-A %+F=+  ++- ,, -%K % 3+ 4444444444  = %  + A  +A+- %9+ = ,++2 ;=C+  9+ + =   %%F%+,%9++9+ !99C =! :=?+ =9+29+ =-++-,%+  , 8+A+?2

&2  +8   -  ,%+ %  %+ F+ =    &%,8*00#2 ++ +F-F+  %  F+   !,8 + -%    9+ =-++-2 1++?%+FF=+=C+ =%+6+-L1 1!-  =+,,8 F=+ % A  -% %+6 %%-,+ F=+  %+  + + E  A+ F  %  + =+A+- %9+  8--A2 = % + A+ A+ &00 + : M  +   +A+- = ,++ = % +  +9  %+ ++  +--:+8--A2 8+ = +NA+N +%  +2   8+ H E- =8+  %%,  +F %+6   ,",+,,8,+=%--%+8,% 9+F=+% , F= E +82  + F=+  A- %     ;  %F+A++@--: ,++2  ?F=+-++- ,++A++ 9O, A+%+6!L+2%-+--C,F-% -+ ,  99   , +  M+ F=  %A+ %  -%  -+ 6 9+C- %  ,- +, F= % 2   % +  +9+,- +2=+,,8%%+--   :C--% A+ +,,8++2   %-  =   +  % +    +=C+ 9+ =-++-299+-++- <92%,+% =%%, '92%,+%!,8+ -% %  9+?9+%=C ,!+:A+%F, ? 28++F9+++  ))* 92 % ,+ % =%%,  %+  + -+2 ;+  !,8 -+%+,%-C, E <)92%,+9+ ++ <92%,+ A+="+2

;F+++-+% +8%6   F+  E  +F %+6   ,", +,,8  --  - ++ F= A,%+% %+9+?-2

(2 %+ (%,8*00#%% &8*00# +8+%-    +  A+ +,,8++   F+  A+ F   , E %%, +F%+6+ ,",+,,8 82



./&'.*00#  1$.(1   /2  +  ( 8 *00#  A+ +,,8++      ,+  +8  E  %%,  +F %+6 +   ,", +,,8 ++F,  %A++%!C  =- +2 +F%%, +F%+6- %+-)<#$:)<&& =E+9-+:(0092!C,%+2  E ,  %%,  +F %+6  %+A,  )D$'0 92 !C  ,%+5-),)<</7)D()#92!C,%+5-) H)<</7)D#0*92!C,%+5-)A,8*00072

<2    ,%+ %  %+  ) A,8 *00# =    + +F- F  ++ = + %   ,+6   C,2 +,+?%++2;F+--C -: @C2

+   (

)2 +CA+=C++@ +++57--, +9+-++- 6 )H*00' +8 +,%- #@C %-+ A+1%-+ #%%-)&@C52)2 #& 72

;+:=+ =-+ )&@C% +89- - *(@A+*00$5 >)'0)0&7  +CA+ %-)'9-A+  +%++++C%, +8  +  +-C   : + @C ++   =  =-+ A?@C2  *2 9,-,:D2#&2)2!2'2*2 +8   + P  + +F  + %-A : =+ #&     + 9- -   %+ C--  +   + 5 7 F+  +A :  + 9- -   %+ ,%-,+:=1A++A+A+A+ +- )<,)<&# 5+1%6  7 ++ F=? %+ ,%-,+  5+1%6  72 ;,%-%@C  =%6++-8+2

'2  -%- 9, -+%-A%+A852#&: &0 72

$2  %+ ,%-,+  9- - F   +- : A+  8+ A+?  % 8--9+++    = ;   =    -%   % A %  2  %+ %  :  +99-   A  -,+   A ,++,, =+ +52$ 2' 72



./&'.*00#  1#.(1   9+ =-F+9%=8@ =-C,+?%%+ + -+ ,:+ A -,+2

E =%%,E,%+9++9+%+  -%   %  %+ ,%-,+ 9- - F %  %+,%-,+A+  - +  52 '8 2 ) 2 8    & 2 ) 2   72 ;=C+  %+  -%,?+,%-%E=-6A:)'D*00 92%%:)#D000%%%F+  9 E   + :   592 2 $ 2 )  6C, 1 72   %+ 9- -   + ,%  + E =, )*D00092%%)'D/0092% %%F+ 9E  +: 5922# 72

#2 =%6++C+F+ A++, E !,8 + -% -%% %%, F%+6 +"%++ -+:+  -%2-%  %=99+,+A +F=  =%%:%+!C2

;  ++A  => ;   % + ,% +,-, F  , =E%+ =%%,%-C,  E = C, F+ + %- %  - +, 9 +    %%,  %  +  -  =  %9+ + +%8  8--9+++   %+ ,%-,+ 592 ++A  => ;1 !2'0*#72

++  ?+6, C, %- % A  % " %+  + -+2

 9  =8   F = = % ++      F+ 8--9+++ = ?+6,%%,%A299 -  !,8 + -%  =1:1 +  %+6 %%-,+   ,",+,,8N+%%%, F%+6A-%2 ?%+F-  9O A+  +8  + % F  !,8 + -%  -+   -+2  %%P +, F   ,F  %   %%,  F %+6 -+  + =8+%%, +F%+62E+--%+ !C % =   @F=:   ,?+,,  ,+2    ?%+F-F=+A+%+ -,!%A%%,%C  ,+F=+=A+%,!C2+=++  +8 %6 8+%,+ =-8+F=99E +F%+66 %-+  %+? F H , =%%,  F %+6 %  !,8 + -% 2  9 %%  99 F  ,   ? 8@



./&'.*00#  1&.(1   8+:E ))D#&/92%-,",FE +F %+6 =+,,8+)(D)&092%-!C,%+ *0D#/092%!C,%+2

&2 -F, !,8+ -% %A++%!C E +A A " %+  ,% ,, -%     %+ ?2

(2 ;=C+ 9+ =-++-,, -8+%=   % + ++=C+= =99+%=+++  ,!+ : A  =+,,82  9+  C8-   , C-- :+ A -,+2

33333



./&'.*00#  1(.(1  

  ( 1  ( + +(+   +  



45.6.   7  8.. .  9: -#% ;

  6. 

)2 -A82

 6.

*2 = , -++%%++ *,*00#2

'2 A+ =   :    A -++  %+    + -2

$2 +F%- C+2

#2 + F %  F+  + ? %+ ,%-,+ 9- -  %+ %A 9,    %- "   -+  '0 @ 6  +9++ % %+ ,, -  -  +8 9- -   ;!Q+L!9F+&&00$    +?,%+2 ,-,+ +R7 + +F?,F -++ -+8++%  -++ F-G 87 ?% % F ,+9   +, %A+ ,    -++G 7 %  +C      %-2;+,-,++%+--,-,-- 7 87  7 +1   +8 9- -    % %   ,+6    F=+ A - +A82  ,-,+   ,+,E %AF+@+,-,+=+=C+  %+6  %+  2 ; -C, @+  ,-,+  -++ F-  =A%%  F   -- ?%- +-   52)'*)0&)0/72  C99+  -+ R   + ; 8;

%+9, %-"+9+-?%+++F=:=99+9- - +%C99



./&'.*00#