Contract Enforceability of Preliminary Commercial Agreement
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over the enforceability of an agreement related to commercial activity, centering on whether certain executed documents constituted a valid and binding contract, or merely preliminary negotiations or agreements that lacked essential terms or final assent. The court reasoned that for a contract to be enforceable, the parties must have reached a final agreement on all material terms, and the evidence demonstrated that while discussions occurred, the parties did not intend to be bound until a definitive, final written agreement was executed, meaning that the preliminary instruments were incomplete and non-binding.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; PC ; PRESTATION COMPLÉMENTAIRE ; CURATELLE ; CURATEUR ; CAPACITÉ DE DISCERNEMENT ; PREUVE ; FORTUNE PRISE EN CONSIDÉRATION ; DESSAISISSEMENT DE FORTUNE ; ESPÉRANCES SUCCESSORALES | LPC.5.1.let.j
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Testo completo
! !""# $ %&' !""#
$
( $ () )$*) () *
+ !
'# , !""#
-.......... !"! #"$ #" % &'#"()(*+,-
#"
*// )$*) *)) 0-1 2*3 "! #"& %./+ #"012/)()),-0
4(354
) / $
)6 $# 7777777777 84 , #"9 ! ):1( " # " & #&;!-(+##&#& <""!&1*=- (+6&! #! >"!&&#"&&& ""# # !" ? " 66@6 , & >'' @ @ @A @84 , 9&"&0-(+6
(6 B #"!&C" ,&"#&=(+6 @# #" & >;; & / =" (+ #" & # &> " C# "#! & && & ""#6 >D & & ;#"?>!"C6#"!#"-"! #;#(1E- #!""&&"> !"! #<&>!"<<&#" 6 #" & C" & # F #!"! & #" !"! &#" F&! " &! &" & 1 #"#< ((6 #" " &-#! & )1;!-(16&&F&"#&!C"# #"!&! "&# # !"!?#G4! ##" "" &, & &"" %D #"%! " # "# & &- ! - #6""#&&/1B;?- >! #?#6>-& "G"# ; )::: "# # # "C! # #"" & 1B;6C#"#" &"&""#F> H" & >- & "G"# ( ! &" "# # I!3!"G !GJ&>#""&(B;6
16 &G &!# & ): #K" (+ >;; &> " ="! && & ""## !"&#"#&<&&>" " ;! >#"# & ""# &>" #"; F - &! " <,6>;;"""&<&#""&1+2B+)5;*/ "?""& #&"%D #"%!"F&G4#&(B+0*;(*6
+6 @"?># #"#&#"&1 "<(+>;;&&!# # #"# &" & (1 &!< (+6 #; # " &> < & # #&" ? &"# & ;#" " ; ( " ; (1#&!&"#&>!&"#&)*B;6
/6 # # & () &!< (+ " #" ? >"# & &!## #"#"?F&##"-#D!?>;; #& ""## !""#";!&! #&!"#&> #""&<&F>?>#"#&&! 6
#""" #<"!& &#&!"##" "&;#"&#"D"&#">"&6 &"&&> , >;; #!&! !# "#&;"<""# #-!6@>C"&> ! # # # ! # ;"
3(3(/ 41354 >&""# ; " & F # >C"6 "# & &!"# ; ;;"! # """ & "! D%F>"&# ;;"6@>C"&##F&!(1 >"#&! &&""& &L&&;F#" &>-"&>"!;#"#&"6?# #" & #&!"#&!"#;F"6 "?>&"!&/1B; & >G4! # # 4 !"& >-# -! #- " "#&" && D" ? # #"6 "" F"# " #" #" # ;;"-" M "" # (1 & #=#&>% &#""" "&F>"- &E#" #!&-""!#">G4! #<#";- &# ">#;; ##> !-#"!"6 -#F "& #"""#:2")(";?>"&"#&><" " "? #""#&&C"!%"&#"?>&!;& G"#;#?&C"!%6
06 ! #& ;!-(/>;;#"=" !;,G&!"#;"-&"G"#"#&,F> "" "&&!#"!%!"G""&6@>C"&>-"& #"!;#"##"&F >-# ##6 >#&# & "< ""! "# &> F #" #,& I&<!""C"#J6
26 < #&#! # "# # & " F >" " &"&5(/6N ""## "&F! <F# "C-""""&"! D%F6 ""#" && & # "" " &" " G " D%"F # &C"! >"#"! ""!6 #" !"& # # "C!&F!F"& G>-"!C";#"#? ="6 # " "&>&!F>## "C!>G" "#" @6 @# " "" F" !G6 " ? >#&# & < ""! !"! !&C! ? ! #F #O # #!&"#;#"#&#E4>"!-!!-& &<""!& #6
@ F# "< #&#! >#-" & F." - >&"# & BG4 ! # & #" F #&"# " & >-" "#!6
56 &5(/ " "&-&#" <P #&:(+ <""!"#"F<&>&" !! F> >D & "#Q F # ! ! & &"" #"" " & " #"< & ;"! " E >-" &>"! ;#"# & 1* (+ " "< & &"" & # &
3(3(/ 4+354 & // ; E >#&# & < ""! !-#D" >G " D%"F & )2 (+ E #" & RS T @ @ @84 ,R9&)*=(+E&!"#;(1!&C! "F#"";## "C!# "#Q6
:6 & )0 (/ " & G """ ? >"""# & " F> >" #<&&# ""!!?#<& &#!#""F#& #&!!&!6
)*6 < #!&! ? >&"# & BG4! # & #" &" & / - (/6 4 #;! -# -! #"" & /1B ; F> &-" # " F& ! & # -#"6 > = "& &> # ? F #" " "!!6 C# & F#"# ;>-" &#""- ? ""! #F6@#"#"#;&#FFC" #" # &&F> &""I J6
N > & >& !"! &!&! &>" F"# "- ? >G " D%"F F < ""! &-" &C" &! # &>#K" (+D"!"!;G! 4?6
))6 <>"&!?""; <""! &5-)2= "):#K"(/6"&"&() "<(/G &>G " D%"F&"!&)0 "<(/6
#" & "" G " F & "#< !F G"" & (( #<="-!#-<(( G# D%##CF# "F" !-& & "#< #C"; "" D%##" & "#< G!"; & "#< & " & G #""-6 (1 #- !-"# #" < C;"- & "!6 "#< >CC-" # &!< (+ - %# ""#6 &C#" " &! G" & C-"! #D - # #" - " !"%DF#";#&;<&> "6
)(6 #&>&&# "# #&&"&)5#"#<(/ >;; &!! " #"# & #" F " "! "!C"&##D# >#"#&&! 6@F# !"!C&!?=C6
UUU
3(3(/ 4/354 ) * $
)6 #C-#B#C"#=&89!"!#&;!"""!&, )#K"(1 <"#&## #!&/=C &#" !&""-4 !&"/ !"")0=C8"6)"6 "/0 96
@"?B"#&B!"#&)0=C <;!&! (2=-(+8 ')1*)*09& #C-#&# "!)1;!- & #"#""#C" """ <"#& # & !C ? "# =C "" & B""" & B!"#&#-G=C6
(6 G"&>"/0 <&!#H""F & #"""# "- ? # ;!&! ""# # !" ? >---""-&"!&):):0/84 , 9 F>? # "# ""# "# # !" ? > - " --" " ? > -&"! & (/ #"#< ):05 84 , 96
@# !" #=C&&B ,"!"<6
16 "="!&;#"&! !- # !"#"-< 8"6/0?0* 96
+6 ""# # !" "" ;!&! F "# #" &"! ? #- <# -"G & # <!!; & " & B 66@6 # & B 66&#"&! #" #-" #6 ""# # #&" ? &;;! " - &!"" " - &>"6+ ""61 96@#" # "# -#&#"D"&#">"&8"6/6)"6 ""6 16)"6 96
"" ,C >" #""! " " "C F"# & -#>D&&> ,&<&&#";""# "6
/6 @#= &"&#"B"#"!&""-#=C&#-" #&! ;" # #-! F #FB #" #- & !"! 8V&&W- #L%"+,!&"#):5+ 6)10EDC &-X"C%" ;C (, !&"# 6 (25 %6 /96 &# & #=C;#&&!#;& #"##"&# ;"F;"&B."!"<&,!;"< "# -<< B"4?4& F !"" &C! & -< ! #&!"6 ;;" &# FB ;" ." #&!! " # %D #"%, #<6 "# !!" & ;" !C! #
3(3(/ 40354 -C< =C &#" !%!" " G F " #<< 8 ' )(0 10* #&6 / "6 < )(/ ):/ #&6 %6 ( " !;!96 BG"4"4 &#" & # #FB&""##=C&-"""&&#";-& B!8 ')(01((#&6/"696
B&""# # =C ;#&" !"# # & - ;# -"C"# GF &#-" #!& &B#;; #" #- F " ;" !"" &C! & -< ! #&!""F&B" #<"# #" #&; "" !"# " ; &B&" &B" - 8 !"# " ! & -E V X"C-;% & @#L-%C 6 ()( Y +/*E VZL3R[ X"C-;% & X"C%" ;C&&(!&6 61:Y)))" 6))2Y1(*EDC &-X"C%" ;C ( !&6 6 (2+E ;6 ' )(( +0: #&6 +)((((1#&6196
06 &> , ;" " F " #" #! ? ## >G" &> # # "C! " !!" & ;#" & >#&&+*>'?""&>";#G6
&" >C" & # # "C! ;# " & #"" F> !"! #< " #"" %C! & C! < & # & #; >G" &> " ! #6 " -% !"< F> # # & #" 8#" &# < & ;9>"! ,&"& G6<&;& #"C#""#"&>"#6@>C"&#""&!!?"" &>"; &-" >C & - & >" & #" &#" # " &" F> #" & F&"# (1 !"" !C"-6 -%!"!!"<F#""&K BG4! #&#"<" <!"!-! #"!"&-#>"4?4&&#"(16
@>C" & "! & &" & #" # " - F>=#&>% " G"" # & ;< &> " F " &&> "!&&"&>")0&#& -@6 "";<&> "#;#&>&!G"&C-"!#D" "#" !" & ; & >! (+6 "#< # D%##CFF#"?##C#" !"F"?G& (( "#"6
"&##""&> "F>C"&>## "C!" &>";#G>"G"F"&",-<<6 " -"&/1B;F!"!!"<;#"&#""F#" C# #!& - # !"" #% & , " >"
3(3(/ 42354 &>G F F> " &-6 " &" #&! F> > " & " %"" -<< F> "! " C" # # "" ## #! #C "&&""&#" 6>D &F>";"&#&"C"#>"& &!=& F&"&#".""6
#!F" &!# & >#;; ! " &# -#D! # #-&!#&#&!"6#"F#<""C& &#" ? & &! # "- #"" F "" ;; !"! & # "6 G4#";G!?)/;6
UUUUU
3(3(/ 45354
*$ / $ () )$*) () *
245 6 7 89 ':! *3
5
)6 !#-<6
5
(6 >&"6
16 &!#&>;;&):#K"(+"(1&!<(+6
+6 -# &# ? >;; # #- " #- &!# &#&!"6
/6 #&>;; "&>&"!&)/'?""&&! 6
06 " F # F "" G ""# # !" ;!&! " -" ;# # #" !" ." & &! & 1* =# &, #";"# #&! &! < ;!&! & @%XL%#;F00+ "#G 6 !#&#"P9 &FG""F&!##"&!#<"" & &!# ""F!E <9 G # # F #"; #" " #-# && "" " &!#E 9 #" C" & #" # & # !""6@!##"" "#!!"!!!#"" 9 <9 " 9 4& < ;!&! & # " ", # FB &- &! -<6 !# & # "###D& -F#"=#"!#BBC" & , ## & #"6 @#" !C" =#" !# &!# ""F! " B-# & F !"! G !&! #" 8"6)1()*0")*596 @ <@ ;; C
# #;#& !".""#";!G "FB?B;;;!&! &# C;;
3(3(/