Breach of Contract for Goods Quantity and Quality
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sued another for breach of contract related to a transaction occurring on a specific date, with the dispute centering on whether the defendant fulfilled their obligations under the contract's terms, which included specific quantity and quality requirements for goods delivered. The court determined that the evidence demonstrated a material breach by the defendant because the delivered goods did not meet the contractually specified quantity and quality standards, thereby excusing the plaintiff's subsequent non-performance and justifying the award of damages to the plaintiff.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Breach of Contract for Goods Quantity and Quality: The court determined that the evidence demonstrated a material breach by the defendant because the delivered goods did not meet the contractually specified quantity and quality standards, thereby excusing the plaintiff's subsequent non-performance and justifying the award of damages to the plaintiff.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in order 5 to regulate the costs of the appeal.
Cited in order 5 to regulate the costs concerning the third party which was not successful.
Testo completo
"#$%&"'(($ ")&)"'(($
* + + * +
,- '
! & ./- '(($
!"""#$%%& ' (' ( *!*+ !)*+,#+"!!""-#+.+* ( / 0' *#
!+*
(( / (1 )233")"+456787 "+"# *++"+'!!*9:
!
'%6$7'
6$;856%77; '<6$7'
0
$2 ="')*>*!*+? #$@58 +*,"#0"+# A!+ B*C )*> !"#+# D(2 2 ="')*> -)!E*? %& F,"* %777 <$ F,"* %77; + )!* 0 ! )!E**#""#!+*+2
%2 *!*+#)!#-""+#GHB%4F,"*%77; )*> (( / (1 ="')*> "? , )*)+"! ""+# GHB > $* 3#,*"* %77; 9 +) )*+" =""+"+57I !"3"#&7I?2
<2 * #""! %% 3#,*"* %77; " *3# 9 *!*+ *!"+ 9 -""+#GHB !+"30!!F!"+,"+0"+#-)!E*2 *!*+"+ 33+ -J+*"+ *B"+* !* *+"3 9 -)!E* 0 "'9 0"+# -""+*+* !"#+# , "B+* !+", 9 J )"#K+-#%7742
82 ("+ 9 -!))!"+"! *!*+ $5 * %77; " !3"*# )!"+"! )*#""!*!))!"+"!$$,*"%77;2
42 !*!*&"%77; *!*+!+9-+"!#""! "+"B" +90-"!"+"+0-*!"+J""+#GHB ,"+ #)2
J)"0 ,!"* +*,"# )!* ! )!E* )" -# %7772 #+"+ 9 ++#)!0!'3!+*"!"#+#++*,""+9$77I2 -+*"# L#+*#"+!+J-+","+#9&7I%77$2 )*>" ! )*"* 3+ *)*" ! +","+# )*!3"! %77< +!F!* 9 *"! &7 I2 (! *" + ",# !"#+# !" F,"* %7742 !" -!M+ %774 ! J"> 3+2 )*> !B# +*"+# " + ))* 0-" #+"+ ")!"K 9 *!*+ *)** +","+# 9 +J )#*"*957I 0"-#+"+),"BK)!*-)!E*2 +!+"3 ""+2 !33*)*!,*0-+++!)!+"""* " " !"#+# !+ )!+ 9 $77 I E !)*" " *)N+2
!*+ ! *" >B 0 B*# 0"+# -""+*+* + "*+* " !"#+# " - F!# *H ! ""+2 -"* *#B++"! ))"0# )* " + *K"+*"* + !+*"* )*"") -#B"+# +* G! + 3 )"0 " #)!J -,"+ ) #+# *"#+,"+,#"!"K**!*+*"+*!"+J""+# GHB )"0 0"+# -""+*+* ! !)B! *"+ ) ))*2 3" *>B -*+2 <$ 2 < +2 !" 3##* * -*'
6$;856%77; '86$7' GHB+-"!,K""+#="')*> ? ))"0#)*"+!0 -!+ ) *!"+ 9 -""+# )*! 0" 3"J+ #""! 0 )* -)!E* ! ),+ "3* !"#*K+ !* *!"+ 9 -""+# GHB )*+" =*#+"! -G!*"*?2 (" +*"KJ ))"0+++*>B)*!B"GHB!)+ )+L+*)+ 0-, *+2 +!+ 3N! ! !"+ L+* )*# - )*! E+ ) !*>++"3*#""!-)!E* -!""+ 0" -+ ) ""2 3+ #B+ B** 9 -)*"+ 0 *!*+ 3!# -+*)*" + E +*,"# !B+) ,+ 0 ! *" *F!"B !"#+#2
;2 *#)! %; " %77; " !+ ")""++ *F+ *!*2 *)) 3"+ )" ")!"+"! #B + F*")* ))"K2
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
*)*#++"#*#0-"#+"+,*"KK 33+ 0 +*!*+*"+M!*!!B# +!*,!"*2A !)++ "*!+-)> !!-!*-,"B*)!"K""+# -!** *!"+ J ""+# F!*">* 9 *!*+ " )*> )"! *!"+ 9 -""+# 0-" *+*"+ 9 3"J*2 33+ " -*# + !+*"+!*!!B# "-))*.+)0-"E"+*"0-K F*")* : 2 ! !G"+*"! )!,!"* J"* *G*G -)!"*!*+)"!"*")+"!C2
&2 *G*G-)!"*!*+!+#+#+*"9"%4F"+ %77;2
6$;856%77; '46$7' @2 *!"*%@!M+%77; ")+"3!*# *"K0-"" #+#))!"K-*,"B#"2
$72 *)"4)+K*%77; *!*+#0!"+"+*"+)* -"+"!+#!"2
$$2 * !*! & )+K* %77; *"K !*!# -!,*+* 0L++-"+"!-J')!E**!*+2
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
6$;856%77; ';6$7' 3!"2 " " ! ""0# 0-" #+"+ )!* !" J 0- +*," !" 0-,+2 - " )*# , F-," #F9 K!*# F+ ,+ -",# J"> 3+2 !*0- + *, !B# +*"+# + 0 "++"! 0 F-," "B"#-+33+",+)*!"+ F""!3"*#0-#+"+))!"K )!*!"#+#+F-"""# -K!*!*+)")*#*"+2 !3"*0B*)!+ !+*!"#+#-0+))" 9 -J)+"!-)*+""*=@7I#0",+9+))"+00F!* !B# ))#+"*?2 +) )" +*,"+ -"* 9 $87I +) )*+" + 3"+ ,"BK " , +*> B* !) 0" ))!0-!+*,"TU' !"* +22-E-"*)3 ,3+!+*+*)*"2C2 $<2 O-"-" )*+"!+#*#"+"**)!"+"! +*!* 93"*#*"+*!)#+"*2(*0!" #+#B*#9FB*2
*
$2 !"B,!"*V!*B"+"!F"""*=?#+#!"3"#+"+"+# > $*!M+%77< *"K+!*!" !)!#4FB !+)*#"++,"')*#"+ 4))#++$;FB*=*+2$+2 *+4; ?2
("+9V+"!V#+"!$;FB* )* *"K3##* %5F,"*%778= :$<7$7;? * !"B,!"!)+# $<3#,*"* ")!"+"!+*"+!"**B+)*+++ *"K+!* !" "#B* * 9 +*!" FB +"+"* V+++ V#+"!!,JFB*2
!3!*#+ 9 -*+2 4; 2 $ +2 G2 & *"K +! *!"!.+"+"0!+++"!)*#,9V*+" 4; 0"!+*+",9!"3##**V*'GHB!K"B+!"*+ V""+#V"!,K""+#%4F"$@&%2
(!)#+)!*FB*V)>+""#+K"2
%2 !"*)*+"B##**!"+*!" +*#,"B* $* F,"* %77< = ? + ))"K V)>2 "" !"+"! 3!*+#"9*)+*)!**,K""+#*!*!+*+24;9;7 2+*F+##"+3!*#BJ*!*+*,K2
6$;856%77; '56$7' <2 0+"! 9 *#!* V)> + ,!"* " *!*+ *!"+ J ""+# )*#, J *+2 $& + V+'9'"* " *)"+ !"+"!V""+"!V*+2& 2
82 !3!*#+ 9 V*+" & "# $ V*# *!"+ 9 V""+# GHB V" *)"+ )"* !"+"! !++ V" + )!" ! )*+"+ )!" =*+2 $7? V" K"+ )*+ +*," 9 )** !"#*+"!=*+2$$?+V"+)+)+=*+2$4?2
(!F*")* "J"+#+*!"+)*#"+**!"+9V""+# *#+"!VG!*"*+*,"+*!"+9V""+#GHB= : !)K"# <44677%&*%77$ !"2%?2
)*+ +*," !"+ L+* !+*HK J + V+ )!* 0 V!+ ) *!"+ 9 ""+# )*! 0" 3"J+ #""! 0 )* V)!E*W!),+"3*!"#*K+W0"+#V!"# K* V !*B "*"B+ V+*)*" ! !* #++* V )*+"")+"! 3"">* 9 V+*)*" + !F!"+ )*! 0" !+ !)#V+*)*"=*+2<$2<+2 X :!)K"# <44677%& *%77$ !"2%?2
(! F*")* +*,"* 0" F!"+ V "++"! )*!3"! !)*K9V)!E*V)*!"+9V""+#GHB!*0 K"0""#3!*+)*+*)*" "!+"93"J*#""! V)!E* ! 9 "3* '" ">* #+*"+2 !+*"* 33+ !#+!**"+)*K""")!"+"!*V""+# GHB*#B++"!+">*V""+#*#+"!VG!*"* +*," )*+""* V*+2 <$ 2 < +2 =32 : $%< %<& !"2 5K6KK?2
)**#+!*+*>B!*0V+*)*" !+"VJ"+*'
9 3" *))!*+ +*," + 0 V*# !*, )!"+"! !)*K9V)!E*2 )*!V!+)*!#0+)*!"+9 V""+# GHB 0V 3+ ,!"* GHB !)+ ! )*+" =(*#+*"+ V ++ 9 V#!!" "')*> ( "*"* F,"* %77< G2 <$?2
"++"! + *,G "33#*+ !*0 *"# +*!,+ )!"+"! ""K 9 V )!E* 0"++ #3""+",+ V+*)*" *"! 3*+* '"X )*" ! *"+ )** V !)!*++,"+9#*!"2,L0V+*)*"!+" VJ"+* " 0V + *"# )* "+ *#""+"! ! !+*+ *!)+ #3""+",++!+",!"#+#2!V+* V"+#*# )+ )*"") )*#+* 9 ""+# GHB =32 : $%< %<& !"25K6KKX :!)K"# <44677%&*%77$ !"2%?2
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
42 (* K ")!"+"! + F*")* *"K # )* J) J *!"+ 9 -""+# -#)! *"# + ""# - ""+*+* - !"#+# " *" !!*+"* !+"3 0 *"0 J"+"+ 0 *!*+ +*," 9 "+"* V+*)*" ," ! 9 *++* * )" ! !K!* , ! !F!"+ 9 ++ +ZG +!+ +!G+ ""+#F!*">*=32 (&846%778?2-" *,G VB"+ V )*! )!E# 0"+# "*+* + "*"+ ! ""+*+* +0","+!!K0"+#V)!E#+V)!E* * !S -"+*+"! !"* ,"+ )*" ** ,*"KK - )*+ 0-" -,"+ ) )"+# -"3* ! )!E* ! !"#+# 33""# +-+*)*+ 0+!+*"0-K,"+L+*!"#*#!#*+# =32 (<476%77;?2
6$;856%77; '@6$7' ;2 -)> ! )+ !++* 0 )!*"+ *))!*+ !+*+ -#+"+ ) )!"K )!* -)!E* + 0 !"3"+"! +J-+","+# -#+"+))!"K!))!**!*+2(-F!+90-#)!J *!*+ -*"+ ) )!"K""+# ! !)#+ *#BB* ! #)!2(-"#+"+K"*)!K""+#+">* 0L+!+!+*# 0-+"0+#)*++*#+"! 0+*,""+) *!*++0-*"+))+*,"*,!)*!3"2 !+*"0 -K)!+#*"*+""++>!*J
52 0" )*#> *"K !">* 0 *3 *!"+ J ""+# GHB )* " ++ 0-" *)! * !+"3 0 !F!"+ *!*+ 90"+#-)!E* +"F+"3"#2 #""!"+"B"*!+ )* !#0+ #+ *,!E#9")!*J+* !"+"!*!"+9-""+#2
&2 *!*+ 0" !K+"+ B" *!"+ #) 0" *!+ 3"J# -)>9%-7773*2
* 0 + * + + * +
!
23.4.-- 5 6. . . 78 #$' + 9
4.-
$2 #**!**,K2
! 4.
%2 -+ +#""!%%3#,*"*%77;+$$,*"%77;2
<2 ,!"!"*9")!*!,#""! !"#*+2
82 ! " )"+ - #!+ 3,* *!*+ %-7773*2
42 3!* )*+" 0V ),+ 3!** *!* !+* )*#+ L+ #" <7 F!* > !+"3"+"! )* )" *!# *#
6$;856%77; '$76$7' *"K 3##* * (GT"Q*G!30" ; ;778 +*!" J)"*2 #" )+ L+* )*!!B#2 #!"* !"+P ? ""0* J++0#""!*!*+#"*!K+"*"+)#""! ++0#X K? J)!* )!* 0 !+"3 " +" )!,!"* * ++ +* #""!X ? )!*+* "B+* ! ! *)*#++2 (" #!"* !+"+ ) +*!" ##+ ##*# ! ++* ? K? + ? "' *"K3##**)!)+**+">***!*0V" ,*#**",K2#!"**!*+"!*!*!E )*, 0" *!+ F!"+ "" 0 #""! ++0# + V,!)) 0#+#J)#"#*!*+=*+2$<% $7;+$7&?2 B*33"* )*#"+ " ( K(
!)"!3!*)*#+L++!+"3"#J)*+"""0V9V33"3##* *!")*B*33
6$;856%77;