Property Settlement Validity Based on Witness Requirements
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe matter concerned a dispute over the validity of a settlement agreement concerning property rights, where one party alleged the agreement was void due to procedural irregularities in its execution, specifically regarding the required number of subscribing witnesses. The court reasoned that the relevant statute, which mandated two subscribing witnesses for the effectiveness of the agreement concerning real property, was not satisfied because only one witness signed the document, thus rendering the document unenforceable against the party who did not execute it before two witnesses, and consequently, the original property rights remained unaffected.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Settlement Validity Based on Witness Requirements: The court reasoned that the relevant statute, which mandated two subscribing witnesses for the effectiveness of the agreement concerning real property, was not satisfied because only one witness signed the document, thus rendering the document unenforceable against the party who did not execute it before two witnesses, and consequently, the original property rights remained unaffected.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
&'()*&+,,- .&*-/&+,,-
.
.0 . 0
12" '
% '' 32" +,,- !!!"#$%&'( ) )* *) ++ , + !) -) !)#& !*!" . */$01#$##'(/
! " ! # $% %
5$2&5
40.
#6 ". "#) "7)$%%&8!!*" -9:.)' ++ , +; ++ ++ + <+ = <!5.)' !=6 >*! !)?)*!@!!>">8(!**)(!")!)!#3! $%%& /% (7) $%%& ) ) * 8 8< =6A !*B*":) .!8 *)* 8. !*. )!)*"#%A(!)$%%&6
$6 )"!! 3"7)$%%&!!@ )"8!*")">88(!*. ) !*C!!*"-9:6
/6 5!@ )" .. !*! ##"7)$%%&)..*>8(!*"*")!" *>8(!* *!"B8)5-9:.* D !6
E6 )"!! #/()!$%%1!)A*" .. !*! 68*@ ") ))!) +)"*)!* 8** B 8" ! <+ = )" C ! -9:#3.*7)$%%3C*)>F. ) .*) .")! *!*! * !! ()!) ) !* B 8!!*" ! @* " *)) 8C!* 8*!(!*"@@*!( !B *!*! F6! ***>8!*")" 8(!*)"!*"*)(!">#3!/% (7)$%%& (* #$!$%%& *)**)(! )8. !*. )!) !* &&%& !*. (!*' )A*!@!).")! D ! 8*!(!*"@@*!(6
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
2#&342$%%1 5/2&5 &6 )))I*!!*#$A!$%%1 )!7" ***> ))I* $1 @"()!) $%%1 ) * 8"** @!* "*!* * . !* 778.'(!*@!*8 7A*8...)' )!7@"") .8!*A>8B) !* 6
16 )))I*#1 J*$%%1 )!7@"")"A:* )!7 "6 @@* !")" > *)* ." .) 8** ( .) -9: .)"*!* . )*")!*!> 8 *)* *)(! (* > 5! !*::".))(!*!!*)6.) "*!*!!* 8 7*!) . ! * )* * )"")*! > 8** ! ()!* C!:) @ )!*) 8 *)(! 8..)*!* 7! . B .)**! 8! !>8B!)()" *).)*!8.)**! *)(!6 .")! 8* . (!* I*) .)! !")*! *!*) 8*!(!*" !B *!*! 6
06 ) ))!) / .*7) $%%1 )!7 " !@ )" .)*! > 8!*"*!*).)!*>"*!*:)"BA:)6
0.
#6 @ )"* B 8)*6 3& 6 # *6 -6 0 )!7 * ) ! K*!*!> ***! .)"(BH)*63& !@"")).)*!:"")) !*) !& * 7) $%%% *)" (!:) #) A(!) $%%/ < = >! * )*!( B ! @"") ) H)5-9: 7!:* !) * H!!*" H! (7!!*" $3A!#40$< =6
+ ."*. )A:)H.'*!!"*7!6
$6 ". " @ ) * "! ":C ) ) * )(7 <)*6 3& * &% =6
/6 !*!: . )* ) ) !* 8!*")" B 8!!*" -9: B .*) #)"7)$%%&6
E6 H)" ) !* B H!!*" -9: ** H! * . ! .)*!*. !<)*606#*6 =6*)".*". !!>! H*..)*!B).. )**)(!*>!-)-BC))*!(!*"B.! *.<)*6#%6# =6
) !*BH!!*"-9:.. > !*! )*!(B.")! *!*! *)"!" >H)"*!7")"<)*606#*6 =6
2#&342$%%1 5E2&5 C*)8)*6#/6# *)(!:)'#)A!*$%%/! >!!!*"!5).)"(B*@@*<)*646/=C)")* D ! ! *!(!*" ! B *!*! ).!* !*! )*!(B.")! *!*! 6
&6 8.'8!*")""*"!7""@!8 *)*8. !*. )!) #)"7)$%%3/% (7)$%%&!8)"!*"*)(!">#3! /% (7)$%%&6
8:!* ' ) "*)!) ! C)" )* D ! ! *!(!*" ! B *!*! ! 8*) *) .")! #) * 7) $%%3#$"7)$%%3)*>7""@!!"8 *)**. )!) I*)@@*"B. ! .* .")! *!*! 6
16 8 ))!8*@ ") ))!)+ )"B* * ! -9: #3 .*7) $%%3 . ) !) ) !* 8!*")" B !!*"6 C*) ))!)L F !* !@!*! 8)*6 E# 8 ) ) 8)5 -9: < = !!** C )" . 3% 8:**! 7)8!!*"* B*C-9:"("'( !@ )" -!* ) *)**)(!*. )!)( .) @!) !*6 (*! .)"( !*()*8!)* .!* *!*! ! . ) ** > 7""@!!!) @ )!* *)5.)**! *)(!*).*)" . !*. )!)7(*! "6
.)'C*!()"-: ))!)(* )!*":( ! ( !(!* B.)) !)!(*6
) .*) .")! *!*! *!! ()!)) !*B8!!*" ! @* " *)) 8C!* 8 *!(!*" @@*!( ! B *!*! 6 .) . ! !. )* . > ! .*! .* 8):!*)) *!*! ()"B*!*))()!"6
))"")*! >'( -!*())B)*!)8. ! C!:) *)5.)**! 8..)*7!.B.)**! 8! !>8B!)()" *).)*!8.)**! *)(!6
' )!..)K*>):( !.)"!*")!*)") () !*B8!!*"@"")@())7""@!!!)6
) ">* .)! * * ! -9: ) * '(8C!)( !8!!*"@ ") *)*8. !*. )!) .)8**'()-)-* .)*!!))"!*".)**! *)(!@ )! *).)*!!)6
2#&342$%%1 532&5 +! * 8* . ! (!* ) !) * * ) !* B 8!!*" -9:C.) )"6
*)!) ())! 8 7!:*! ) :*!)B -):@ *)!F6
06 ))I*#1 J*$%%1*)!**8* . !*77 8.' )!7 @"") !")" > ' ) > )* "!5) )*!@ B .")! *!*! .) -9: 8(!* @@*!(* *)(!". ))(!*!!*)>)*.")! !@")!)B D ! ).!!* . !*! .)"( .) 8)*6 #/ 6 # 6 )!7 @"")C.)"*)("B*":)>.!. )*!*@!*>.) !*)G!)*> *!*! !*"*"":*"!*!) .*.")! *)(!@@*!@6
46 ) ' ) * )"@")) B * ))I* )!7 @"") * ) > 8!*")".*A*!@!).")! D !8*!(!*"@@*!(6 5! 8!!.) !*C!!*"8)5-9:6
!) ) !*5!I*))A*"6
2#&342$%%1 5&2&5
5.04 .0 . 0
%
6 2
#6 ")) ))(76
% 6
$6 )A6
/6 !*>.) ")*:)*!*6
E6 @ ) .)*! >H .(* @ )) ) ) *) .)"* ))I* "! /% A ) ' *!@!*! .)' )!7 @"") <+-M!D)- @>!&&%%E =.)( !) )*!')) !* .7! @ )"*C)*60$ !@"")) )!7@"")#1 A! $%%3 < =N " !) ) ) !* !!>) ! *!@ * ?.)(*. )*)!:*)) )* *!)N! !* I*) )" )!7 @"") .) ( ! . * .) ( ! "*) !> C !*! 8)*6 E$ 6 .)"* ))I* * .!' . ! ) )*!( >" ?.)( !(*I*)A !*B8( !6 :)@@!') )"!* )!5 ! O )!P
.! @ ) .)"* ))I* * *!@!" C .)*! !! >H +)"*)!* 8**B8" !.):)@@
2#&342$%%1