Appeals on Damages and Liability Calculations
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves various appeals challenging findings related to the calculation of damages or liability in different contexts, as evidenced by the numerous cross-references to prior findings and the court's detailed review of specific evidence and legal standards across multiple sections. The court consistently reasoned by applying the relevant statutory or common law rules to the established factual record, often affirming or modifying the lower tribunal's conclusions based on whether the application of the law to the facts supported the original ruling concerning damages, interest, or the underlying liability determination for the various distinct claims presented by the parties.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Appeals on Damages and Liability Calculations: The court consistently reasoned by applying the relevant statutory or common law rules to the established factual record, often affirming or modifying the lower tribunal's conclusions based on whether the application of the law to the facts supported the original ruling concerning damages, interest, or the underlying liability determination for the various distinct claims presented by the parties.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to rule on the costs of the federal appeal.
Applied to rule on the application for legal aid for the respondent.
Testo completo
$%&'($%))& $*++$%))&
, -, ! ,! !
(. !/ 0 # 12 3 0 %))&
!
"
##$ ## # +, ## # # # %& '()*&
! "#
0)-%0
4
(1 + (%)2 +"+ 33+ 4 56 ( 76 (%.(1 "" +"" ,,+ 5 "" " 45 ## $ ## # # # # # # 80459 :1
)1 &*76(%;. !<",,+=!4 6=""""+63(76(%;.80459""" (%;.:"3+>"= ""6"3!"+1
&1 );"?(%;2@+ ! +<A"!<""<4" (,+6 (%;;1
B1 / 76 (%;; ," < @+ 44" 4 !4"6 # ()$(*.10,1 "!?!"+"" 4+663>@+4"+1
.1 +!4" 4 6? 5 ( ,+6 (%;; +"? 4 / 76(%;;!"4 ? ,1)$.;)%."6 # ,1($;2. >"9C8!?!"63:D1
/1 (;6!?(%%) ,"6<+>@6 #>6"+"+ + 6"A"!?+635!" 5!> 6" /.5! 61 !"" 4 +"" ! ,+ +>1
21 (/ ,+6 ). @+ ! + < A" ! ?++, @"1(% """ (%/)"(76(%2/80459""" (%2/: > 4+,"@A" "45() !?!"1 4"6 !4?3"6 1
;1 +4 ); ,+6 ). >+ < @+ > !?!"() 6"A"E!!" +4"<"" >@6"4+"+1!?!"4"""4?1
%1 (. ! ). @"++ +"++ ! @A" ! ?++, @A" " 45 () !?!"1 @6 < @!? 44+ 6" +"+ .2$B2*10 ,1 " !?!" 4++ @+6" < 2)$2*.10,1<,,+6).1
(*1 )&!). +4 <+">"""63< @+4> ""+""="+63(76(%;."( 76 (%2/1 44+ >@ @6" 7! !,"+ + ?++, @ 6 !?? () 1 @ " ," >
-).&/-). 0&-%0 !?!"+""636"+"+44+ +!4" ,+6(%;;1 , 4 !?!" ,,+" @ 4A" 4>@ @3" @ " "" !4" > 6" 7>@" 4??"+ +5 "61
((1 < (( 6 ). @+ 6+ > """ (%2/!"" +4, ! !?!"() ">@"+,+"<"6351 ! "<6< A"!?++, @"(% """"1 +E+" 6" A" ++!!1
()1 + )B7). 7"+ ! @+"" , !?!" @6 #1 +," @6 ! + !?!" () 6" ! ?++, 4 "" !?!" 46" A" > 63 ,!+!" = 4" """44?<1,">!?!"+""636"+"+ 44+<44<@+1
(&1 " (( 7" ). @+ "7"+ " "" + 40 6" ?" "<> + "+1,">6"44+ 6 C< !?D 6" 4 + 4 @ "1 # ! ?"@"1(% """ (%2/"3"@=" 6=""" (%;.1 4 @6" 4 F @,!" ! < ""<@G3 /.1
(B1 +4 &(H"). 7" 1""" @44>" @+ +"" = "+ 63 (%;. > 6" +"+ ! < " +"1 """ 4+" ! "+ ,!" @6 #"4+,">@< +," ! +" +4+ 6"!?++, 4!?!"+""6316"4 +"+ !"+ < 4 4 < @+ > !?!" >@ 6" ,," +"" 631 , +3" " >"+"+ +4,"4+""63 "" "445 1
(.1 (% 4"!? ). ? + " 4" !4"41
"" " >+ >@ ," 6" 4+ @6<@!?16" " ,>+""4"+" 4 1 6" 4+ >@ @3" @ 6 !?? ! 6 "+A""5?1,"6"44+ ! !?!" ,,+" @61 6""6+ EI=!4 """ (%;. >@ 6" ? ! 6" + " "!!" 44" @"1 %%
-).&/-). 0B-%0 >@ +"" "7 ! = """ (%2/ " >@ @3" @ !?!"4+6()16"6F !""!?!"63!@6"4++>@@3" @6" #14">""" (%;. " " >>"4"!?!" @6 #1
>+ >@ !?!" () " +"+ 4+ @ " ,6< ,1B%().4+6+E>!4 @+1 4 4" 4 4? >@ !4'+ "44+"""!4" """ (%;. >6" +< !?= +?"13">6"3+ @+<@+4>1
#+"+3 +<731
(1 36@3"7 8:+"+! ,+"""+ 5 (H")& ?" !4+ .73 " 4+ " " 604+ " . 44+" " (/ 73 8"1 ( "1"./ :1
#"<@" @+" (/734 ?,+ + )276)B8 J(&*(*/: 36 4"+(&,+6 4"""3"4!""" ?" +3 < " 73 "" @""" @+" 6=731
)1 = "! @"1 2& 1 ( ,+ + 4+6' 4, 666""6 "+ ).7(%;)8:E>" +3 ? > K" 5 " " """ 44" """ 4+6' !4' " '" "1 "" !4+" +"+ ,++<56 ?" 6" @"1 ./ 1 ( "1 ? > ? K" " > """ "6 < 4+6' 4, 44" """ 4+6'!4'"'" "'!4 6> 4+""4?"+8"1&&(<&&( ?3"L"1.)./ 1 ( " "1 2& ,+ + 4+6' 4, 6 66""6 "+ ).7(%;)L"1(B) 6:1
# 74 !4+" ""+ 6+ 4 $"1 2& ,+ + 4+6' 4, 6 66" " 6 "+ 80 459 : " ?!" +,1 $" "" $? >" < " "39,">""""4"4" >"4+,> 4+6' 4, +"" 31 "
-).&/-). 0.-%0 44!" "3 > 4"" 4"" $ 4"" ? 43 8"!" 4"" $"+ ": " ""1 6E 6 " $"1 2& " 4 6" >""", !"7 >"> " 4+6' 4, !A! 6" 6 ,," 6" " " 4+6'8 J().(/; 1)())&)& 1)?"+,+:1
""!4+""+3!"!"+4,"> +3 !5 +>6>4"46"A"+<"""6""" 4+6'!4'"'" "1>4" " $""" 4+6' $"1 2& 1 ( $" 4 ,,+" +, < $"1 B; 1 $3" """ 4+6' 3"+>4"4"+3! $?3"8"1B;1(: 6 4?"+ $+" 4+6' 0 < 4"" !! 8""" 4+6' " M644"ML "1 B% 1 ) :L """ 6" 6A" ,! $ , " $ +"+ 4+"6 A"""" "4?8 J()2)%:1
""">4"4?"+ + " ! @+!""<"" !4"56 "4 <0!A! ""+7 "!"+<@"12&1
!4+" ? +" 5+"?4K" 4+" "3" ! 6?1
&1 +?!" 4 >" 6?"+ ! " 4"+4 +, 1,,"<" """0 44 4"+7 >1
#@3" 4"+ @" 7" @"!+ +7< +"+ ! ""!"474 ,+ +8 J((&(%;:" ?,+ + 8 J : +!!" ,!+ > "" 4"+ @+"" 4 "
8 J ()2 )%:1 ?" J " > 4"+ ! ,+" "?!"4"+ $37"""4"+46" A" 4 +3" < +"?!" 4? > " +!1 $$"1;/1( """" 8>"+"+ 4"+ "!!"4 !4 56"4 $"" " 56: 4+6" > 0 " 4+"+ 45 ""+ 4?>>$!"57 4+ " !"+ 3"1 "" 4" > ," H!" +,+ < 4+ 7 " ,,!!" =4"4""?< 4"+ $"7"1
4 +4+ ,! " + !4+ 4 """ ! "6?1
-).&/-). 0/-%0 B1 # 44 3++= $ 44> E3!" 53 " 4"63 +" $+"" ,"> "A" 44++7 >!"> +>7 >1 446" +3!" E3!" 4" +3!" """ """ 4+6'1 44" 56 4 ,,"+ 4+ $+6+!">>4"A",!"+ "!48 J ()(( 1("+,+L J()/(/&:1
! 4+6' > =5 !!! ?3" 8 " 4+6' 4+?3" 0?3" " ?3": $" "! 4+6'4+" ""?3" + !"5 4"" +" 44!" 53!" 4+6'1 >$,,+"6 $"446+53!""" 4+,!+ $ "" 8 3: " 4+6' < 6 " 3++ => $"++ !" =4+!" 4 " "1 """ " 4? 4" + " + "+4"6"+ " +4 "8"1.*1): "> 44" 7 > " $""" " $,,+ " 44 +3 4 " 4?,+ +"!!8 J();.*:1
""" (%;.> ! @,,"6!"F" " 4 < @+4> @44>" @45 < 4+" ,!+!"<74 4+"+1,,"" +"!"<"+3 !!"<4" >@+4"""4+"4F@6 # "(,+6(%;;1
",@+ ! <A"!?++, @"(% """ (%2/ >4+6">"9
C@+!<""<@G3 /* "<!4+!" " +6?+34E!!</BN"4,!!<;BN " 6!4 #4+!+1 !4+!""4'?7>@!!" @6" " "" 6!4 #15!!"" "",=+44" @"B*"+ "4 " + () @ !"" +3 4"6!" < &/ N " (/N " 6 !4>+"++!4+!"1>" ""@6 45@G3 /*!4+!" #"+""!4" @G3 !<"""G3+""+4!+61"!4" ?"! ,"4 "D1
4"4+6" @"1%%(54E """ (%;.>"" "> +"6"+< " @"+63 """" >C"3"<"+"6"+< " @"+63 4+"""""= 4 ""!+3<>"
-).&/-). 02-%0 "@""" 4"+4 !4 56 )26!?(%/)1!O""3"@=3 " @,,"< ! ,++>16"= 4 ""4"A"4+<2*ND8"1%%:1
4 "6" "">""4+6" ">>@ >"= 4 """4! !?!" @6 #4+6<@"1(% """ (%2/1
+>""" (%;."?44? @451
.1 # @"1 && (5 4E """ (%;. ?++, @ 4 "" " 7>@< @6" " = 4"" @ # < 6+6?+," " 6!4 !45" !=!! @ #1 @"1 &B 4+6" > !"" 6+ "" @6 # " !?? " 635!" " () 5 > 4+ "<" 6 #1#@+ +"!44 6 +" + < !"" >" < + !?!" @6 #6"!?++, 4 ""!?!" ,635!"1
" > ! @@457! +4+ ! +" @"1 &B 4+"+ " > @" ? '"5! !?!"63>@44><!!+"+3,+ 44" 4" +!4" 4 /76(%;;1
/1 "4+6" ,">,"<>@+"" +(%;2 6" >+ >@ @3" @ 6 C< @!?D " 6" 4 + @,!" !?!" " >@ 46" > !?!"+""4+6()1 ! 6>4<44 ?, @ !""1
# 44 > 74 + " $"1 B 1 ( "1 " > 6" +3!" +3! $"1 % "1 8 J ()/ &;2 1 &: 3!" ++46"?3$ !""<" <$ !"+6"3"<" "0!"60 " +1 ," > $""+ " "6 "" 5" < $+3 $4 +"!+>$"3"+63 !" !4+" > $ !"+ $" 4 4 !4" !!+ "!" $="" 3!"?"">$", + 0 4 4 4" >$ " ! , ? 4+7 L ," , > $" 4 E3+ 4 !!" O 3!"+"+ +8 J()(// 1)"+,+L J 4?+ )&H")(B%-*(:1
-).&/-). 0;-%0 @45 @"" +!"+ > @+ @ 4 >"+ 4++!","! !?!" @6" 3!" + +"+ , < " +3 1 "! C6<@!?D>,"""+4!"""4< @+ >@@3" @6!??() $ !?!" 63 @"" >@ H!" +"+ ,!+ / 76 (%;;4+"4>@!?!"63+""4+61,," > ! " < @+4> < "" > """ (%2/ +"" 44?<4!"4 4+" <44"1
21 ! "+>A"7"+1
-).&/-). 0%-%0
# J# # ## ## #9
#"""
8,!+!"< 4""" @"1(/):
,!9
(1 + ! 6?1
, 9
)1 7""1
&1 ">4+ "3""1
B1 ,! 4" >@ 46" ,! " 4+" A" + &* 7 5 "," 4 4 !! + + ? ,+ + #EPIE,> / /B " =!41 + 4" A" 43+1 !+! "9 : > ="!"> +" +?""4 + "">+L ?: =4 4 > !", "! 46 ! "" " +L : 4" 3" 4+""1 # !+! "" 4 " ++!" +!++ "" : ?: " : 0 ?,+ + 44"!"5>@ 6 +6?1!+! !"!' 46 > " 7" > + "">+ " @644 >+"+=4+ +"8"1(&)(*/"(*;:1 3,,5 4+ " '# + +"07"9 Q
4,! 4+"A""",+=4">@<@,,,+ + 43,,
-).&/-).