Negligence Per Se and Contributory Fault in Vehicular Accident Litigation

 



 


  

&'()*&+,,) -
&./+&+,,/

-

 -0 - 


 

 0

12"  3 % 33 42"  +,,/










!"

#$#%
 &
'



'




(( 
 

)  +   


'!"

,
-.
 

       !   "  ! # $% % 

+
$/#%
+

 50-

#4 

"

#-13

'5"
!!
!6,"

78
6
!!
9::

';
6
#-<#4


"6"

#%
'7
#--1

! 
6=

)(( 
 

)  +   
>+6=
) ?
5'
@

6

9A
)
!'


5
6:4

$4 
$.
!
#--.



!" 
A""'
'''

 "
@
) 
5
!'
!" ;
'!!'

66'


8
A5

'

$2
5!7
#--2
;
'!
8

A'
)7"'"
>
B
%#%
CA/!$?
5'
"'"
'
5

!7 '"
5'
D
"'9,+'7A!
98
''
6'
:'
:"

#--3
9,69'""!
''"
!7A
98
'
'"

A
!'8

66'



6"'
(E

 A

$3
'7
#--0
8
'
@

"''
':'
6=
5
6" "
@

"' A!!
A!"'8

8)
66'



6"'
(E

 A

.
F'
#--0

8
)"
::
)
9

1+*#

::'
!6:


:

'


)
'"69,'
6'"!" 

5

*#
'
)
"

9A

:''
'
6'"4

%4 


!" 


) 

6



!'
'
''"
8)
),
5'

!''


6'"

'5


!"'
;"
>!6,"

78

9::

';?


8

)::'
 8G


'

!H!
6

'5'"
5
::'
69,8
!,
>6'

9A

$3
CA?4



66
=

8
)"
'
;!"
6

:4

6"'
(E

!" 
69,8
'
"" '
! 
9!'!4

04 
66'
);6'
"'7
6

:4

'"

#%
!
#--<

'
8
I 6

<
F5
#--1
)"
'

H'

'5
@
#33J4

A
8)

99"

'5
"''
"

"''
!
)

6
'5"4


"A!'
5


):!'8
>K?4
'!'


!7+ 'A8
)!6H9'

6'

9A
'

6'
'
6
'

''
7'
'


=
"''

6
:'74



''
6=
:'
6'
5

'
''


9A

'54
6 '

''
)::'
!
::'"

%#
'7
#--2
 8
8

6''


7
"6"'
'
@

:'4

)
)
6
8)
''!'
6
64

!
!7
)6=
)!=
'
);!
8

8
)!A
8


!'
8)
9

6'"+!" 


'''
'

:


:
8

6''
'
6'
@
'5
@
13J
!!
9::

';4
*)

'
8
8)
:'


'
8)



/012%/$332

+
%/#%
+




5'
'=
6"7

6
8)@
13J

6
'

!!'

6
5

!!'

'5
>K?4I

*)A'

67'"
)!"

6'"

'5
6

!'

:4

=5
8
)"
6'
6'+H'
'

:!'
8)

'6

):!'8
'
5

5
::!!'
"5"
6
'5

''
6"'"
"''
6 '
6""
8
I@

!!


'
L
6''

5


"A
!7

5'
'

''

'
7'

8
:'
8
''
!"'


6'"

'5

6'
H'
8

$1J

6
6
66'
@

67'"

:

';


6'"

'5

.1JI4

14 


$3
5!7
#--<
'''
8
)"
5'
"'"
67

'5
@
#33J

#
F'
#--0

%3
'7
#--0
@
13J

%#
'7

<
F5
#--1
6
@
5
@
#33J

-
F5
#--1

#.
5!7
#--2
'
@
8

6'


:4

6 

'5'"

9::

';
@
13J
) 

:!"
+
8)
'
'=

'
5

#
F'
#--1

%#
F5
#--2
'

!+'
@
!6'

#
:"5
#--.4

24 
"

#
!
#---
%
!
#---
'
$3
F'
#---
)'
)
'
'=
=

#
F'
#--1
'
)
!+'
=

#
:"5
#--.
'

'
!6"!'
6
F'
'
:'


"'"
:!"4

.4 
$<
'7
$330
)"

'"

) 

"5



"A'

"'"'


"''

'"4

6"

::'
8

''

6A"
>5
;
9?
658

6,

99
)!6H9'

!9
8
=
$33#

"''
7"'8


"

"9
!
'
' 

! 
::'
> "9

F!
'
"9

' 
'

76?
'
6''

6'"

'5

A
"
8
=
$330

67=!
'
A


F!7
'
'M"

'
7'"
!'

6'"

!9
'
:
8)
::'

:'A
"'
A "
6

"''
7"'8
'

''!'
!" !';4

<4 


#%
"!7
$330
 "
@
) 


(
6"'
(E

!" 
'

:!"
8

6''
6"''

AA5'


"''

'"
8)

65'
'!'
6
'5
@
6

$3J
8

7='
5

!6'
 5
"5=
>'''
 8
'
'=

!!7
:"?
5'

A5
"6


"''
A""4



66'

$<
F5
$331


(

6"

A'

7='

',6

E
6
$33$
)
! 

5

:'

#--3
)
'"6'9
6"69"8

!!7
:"
=
$33%

/012%/$332

+
0/#%
+


'
)
"9

' 

76

$3304


"5"
)6'"

'5


6''
@
.1
J
6

$2
'7
$3304

 =
8

6'
'
6'N'
!7
5
)'''
!5

6''
7"'84

::'
+
8
:'

" 5
):'
'

''

'=
6"69"8
'

6
" 5
5
67'"
)
54


6"
8
)"
)'
67
);

'
'5'"
!
8)
I6'
'5
@
$3J
''
6

!I4

-4 )"

!!8"
@
) 
6


7
'

!6'
);6''
6

"
$33$
@
$3304

#34 5'"
@

"'!

*

''"
8)
),
5'
6
)""!'
67'
5'
6

AA5'
''
7F'5
,"
6
)!6'9

!" 
'''4



 ""
8
)'5'"

9::

';
 "6 '
"''
 6'"
'
65'

65

!H!
';4
>
4
'

#1
!
$331?4

##4 
"

$1
5
$331
) 

:!"
)"
8

! 
)A!''

'
"''
F'"4

#$4 )"

:!"
66'

#-
!
$331
'

"'"
' 

$3
F
$3314


""
8)
"''

H'

'5
@
.1J
6
'7
$330
8)@
)"68


6!=
"

::'
'!'
)'''

8

'
!6"4

66
);'

67=!
 +5
),'9!
 8
'!!'
)'9""
'

7='4


6'
6
'

7
'




6'

76

$330

8)

76

7AA
@
6'

''
8
9::

';4

A
:
8

!" !'
8

'
6'
'M'


!

'7


''

!'

":;

)9,6A,"!

8
):'
'

!'

)'"
5
6 '
6
94

#%4 )"

5"
@



#%
F'
$331
6
)
66'
"'7
6

:4


*5

9!'A

E

0
F'
$331
8
:!

6"

'7
"A""':
;68'

6'

6'

6''
> '
'7
''8

9
!7
5
7

7
5

A9
'

6'9
0+1
"
5

!A

9
'"
A9
'9'
677!'


0?
'
)
66'


E
 A
(E

%3
F
$331
'

'
8
)"
6"'



!
!'
:"
@

!

0+1
O
)
''

6'9
"A""'5
@
'=
6':
)
6'
'
)'
6'

9
'"
A9
@
!6'
:!
'
@
! 
A"
;'+:!4

#04 'A"
6
) 



6"'
(E

 A

:!"

##
P'
$331
8)
5'

6''
6
5!7
$330
6

67=!
 A84


:!"
8
6

:
$330

;''


/012%/$332

+
1/#%
+


AA5'


,!6'!'A
5
66''

6" 
@
)::'
'
5'A
8)
'
)"
6"''

9,6'
'"
'

,6 "!
'N"

''!'4

!" 
'''
8


 '

A!''


'
'
F':"

6'

5
 A8

6'
5
)'5'"

6''
>9::
6:?4

#14 
"

#%
6'!7
$331
) 

:!"
)"
8

"

$1
5
$331
"''
"
'
8
)''


"''
64

#24 


##
'7
$331




!!8"
@
) 

66'


A69

)"
::'"

2
'7
$331
@
)

8


5'
'
"'"
6"
D
! 

!'
''A'
66!'


'
G
!6''
)
''



'
5
7
"''
AA698
G
'
'
:'
,'8

5'
A9
!4


!" 
"6='
8
)'
)
'
@

';

.1J
'
 8"
"''
"

9A!'
'

5


6'9A
4

#.4 'A"
6
) 

*5

'!7
'


5A'

""
8

4

!" 

5'
 ""
)"
6'
@

 '

5"9
@
!'
6=
)5
;!"

-
5!7
$3314

#<4 ) 

:"

 



6" 
@

;6'
!' 6

)"4

66'

"'"
"'7

##
P'
$3324



'
8
)"
'5
'!'
@
$1
J
66!'
6
)6




';
)'+@+ 
)6


A'
'
:

!6'
'
88

4

*

6
'"'

!" 
'
5"

6"

!7A
98
5
'A
A9


6'


!5!'

6"'9'


99
A9

!,'69

8 6
A9
'

6'9
0+1
5
9

''

:'
5


0
A94

'
"A!'
''"
8
'
@

"9

76
'

!
7'

!'

:4
)"
'

66!'
!'"


6'

6A"
'

6'

9A4

),

'':
6
)AA5'
7F'5
!F
6
66'
;
6"" '
"5'
"'



G

),


6

F':'
@

!'


6'"

'5


'5'"

9::

';
6
66'
;
13J
 !
'"!'4

*

6
!'8
A""
)
,

 "7!'

6A

'''
"

7='
'
@


'
6'!

:'

8
 5

!
'9"6'8
'6
F8)@
6"'
6!'''

/012%/$332

+
2/#%
+



!'
)
6'"

'5
!6='


6:
!!
9::

';4

*

6
 5
)"
6"'

!'6
:'

8
 5
6,5
68)
'
'''
''

5

Q
5

:'

#--3
6
"!!'

A6'



'
8)
5
6"69"8
68)

7"":"
)
A6'

)'=
8
;'
A9
'

)'=
:"!
6:
6;!
A94

!" 
'
 ""
8)
),
5'
6

'+ '
 5
@

6'
)
'5'"
6:
8
5'
'
!6'
)
!''

6'' 
@

!94

*

6
6,98
)!=
'
);!
8
6!'''


@

''

6'"

',6
7 
'""
6

'7'"

)9!

!65'"
'

!5
'"
;
:''4

',6

:'!'

6'"
)5=
"6'
'
P';

"A
6,98
'
6'
 
@

!'

 !'
6:4

!" 
'
=

'!"
8)
,
5'

!'

 !'

%3J




'7


6'"4


"!"

;6'
'
'
@
''

A'
,'

"6


6'"

'5

!7'A
A9
98

"9

76
'

$330

6"'9'

99
A9

6'"

',6
7 
'
@
''

A'

"6


6'"

'5

7='
',6

"5'

$33$

 6'9
9"!8
'
9,6'5
''"

#--3
'

'"6'9

!!7
:"
6
$33%4

'+ 

@

6'"

'5

13J


'5'"

9::

';


6
!'8
'

#33J
5

!'

 !'

%3
J


6
6,984

#-4 ) 

!!8"
@
)"

$
'7
$332

6F'

"
;
'!
8

! 
)A!''


'
'
F'"

!':
8)
I
'

""!'
!" ;



 

5'
! 

8

);6'
::'"

'
);6'
!" 
8
)AA5'

!7A

F':
6

! :'


6'"

'5

5'
'5'"
97'
>9::

';
@
13J?4
*

6

7='

!
'9"6'8
'6
6!'''

!'

''
6'"

'54
*

6
 5

),

6
)"5 

)AA5'

)'"6'9

!!7
:"4
)6'' 
69,8
'
!,
!
::'
6
);

5'
6:4
:


6
6,9'8

7

 !'
"

"F@
"'"
6

!6'
6
)"'7!'


6'"

'5
!'"I4

/012%/$332

+
./#%
+


$34 


$.
'7
$332
)"

''"


'
66"
8
''


6
 5
8



7='

!" !''
7A'
'''

6'9A
A '

::'
;'

 '
6:4

$#4 
"

2
5!7
$332
) 

:!"

:
)A!'

!+ '
)5 '"4

$$4 )"

'F'"


1
"!7
$332
'
 '
"4


":=
;6"!'
@
)5


;
!" 
'''


(
'

8
665'

! 
)A!''


'4

6"
8

! 

"5
)'
6
!'5"
6
)AA5'


!7A4

'
8

7='

+!H!
)'
6

'
@
!6H9

 '
)
'!7
!
A
8




)A'

 

5"9
@
''
6:

8
'
::"'4

69
@
'
"A
@
) 
)A

::'


!" !''
7A'

''!'


6'9A4

''
:
8
) 
A

6'
7F':

! 
 5
'
A
8

 '
'!7
6:
'
A""'

'
+!H!
:'

8
):'
6
8

'
''"
!" !'4

$%4 

"6

1
F5
$33.
) 

":=
;6"!'
;


);6'

 
'
'

F'

4

$04 )"
A
6


$1
F5
$33.
8

6'"

'5
" '
@
$1J

'
'''"
6

!" 
'''
'

6

$.
'7
$330
)'
6
!6'7
@

9;
6
!!

6"'
) 4

=5

'
8

! 

"5

"'"
"6"
6


(4

$14 


%
5
$33.
) 

!'

6'4

$24 


"'"
'!
@
)"
'


A "
@
FA4

 0-

#4 :!"!'
@
)'4
12
4
#
'4

94
$



A5

)A'
F 
>?

7
'



M'

'
8

'''
6"5
@
R'
12



:" "


6'
A""

'




2
'7
$333
> ?
8
'
'5
@


:" "

R+5 '"

#-
F
#-1-
> ?4

*
!6"'
6
FA


R6=
'

"'74

/012%/$332

+
</#%
+


$4


'
'"

5A

#
F5
$33%
'M'

! :'
"A'5
'!!'


'

)+5 '"4

6'

5
'!6
'

66
667

=A

'

5A

!!'
O

:'
F 8!'
"'!'

'
6 '
'

FA




: 

66
6
66"



)"''

:'
""
@

'
"'!'


"

66'
'A
> (
#$-

0
 4
#4$G
#2-
 4
#
G
%12
 4
#
'

H'
'"?4

*

: 

7

"
=5
8

"
'A
,'
"'"
 

'

2
5!7
$332
'
'''


"''

:'
F 8!'
"'!'
!''
@
)"
$330

6"'
'A

;!"
@

!=

6'


 4

5'
8
8)

'

5
8

6'
)'
6
! :"

'
)5 '"

)
 
'

F6 

(
,
'5
'
'F
)''"4

%4


8


6" 
'
@
":'

=A
''
'


'

 
)66'
)668'

"5
=

F


'"

5A
> (
##.

-%
 4
27G
##$

%23
 4
0G
 
#--<
S
%.
64
%#2
 4
%7?4

"6"


:!
'
"
6"5
6



6"'

'
57
>'4
23
 ?4

04

'A
6'


8'

5


';
)5 '"

)"
)'
! :"

:T
'7
@
5


'
8
'
6"5
@
)'
)
!+'

'
! :"


!
F':'
)A!''


'4

14

5'

'4
<
4
#

'
0
4
#
 
'
"6'"
5 '"
)6'"

A
''

6'
6"!"
6!'


A
"
'
"''
)
:!'"
A"'
)
! 

)
 '4
'
@
)6'"

A

'
":
@
)'4
.

!!

!'

)!7

)
6'

67'"

A

)"


!9"

'5
"87"

''
!'
"'
)
'''
@

'"
69,8

!'
'
8)
6'
6=

''!'
'

!

" 6''
;A74 
,



6"
8


F6 

'
R5 '"



'



'

'
"!8
'

!" G

'

"8
"!8
7F'5

R6'"
:'
8R
!6'
R"5
> (
##3

$.1
 4
0
G
#31

$3.
 4
$?4


'''
@

'"
6,98
65'
!!

'''
69,8
'M

5 '"



)'4
0
4
#
 
>

5
)'4
<
 ?4


 =
6
!!

"8
)
"''
6,98
! :

6
!!

::'
@
6 

9A
6
)+5 '"

!'


6'"

A
8
)"
6'
!6H9

:'
65

/012%/$332

+
-/#%
+



7
5'"
G

!


8
'
;A7
'
H'
"'!"

7F'5!'
8
67
> (
#3$

#21
G
*
$33#
64
$$0
 4
$7
'

":"
G
:4

(
#$.

$-<
 4
0

:?4

24
;
'!

R'4
$<
4
#
 
R"

'
@

'
R+
'
5 
@
22
$/%J

!
@

!+'
R+
'
5 
@
13J

!

@

8'

'
R+
'
5 
@
03J

!4

.4
*
)'4
#.
 


';
)5 '"

7"":


'
7'

! :'
'7

'
'
)::


! 
"5"
6
)5
@
5
A!'"

" '

"8


66!"4

6'

5


'
9A!'
)'
6 '
'
H'
'9"

!6'

:'
'
8)

6"''

!!'


"
'

'
'

'
"A'
@
)"68


"
'A
> (
#%3

%1#
 4
%414$
#$1

%2-
 4
$
'

":"G
5
"A!'
(
##$

%.$
 4
$7
'
%-3
 4
#7?4

'
9A!'
!6''

'
66
@
:

A"
)5 '"
'


'
@

'
6'
!'5

"5

)'
#.
 4

'
6'
H'
"5"

!'



! :'
7

)"''

'"
!

8
+
'
'"



!H!
!
8

"8


6'"

A
'
7

9A!'
!6''
> (
#%3

%0-
 4
%41
##%

$.1
 4
#G
5
"A!'
(
##$

%.$
 4
$7
'
%-3
 4
#7?4

8)
! 

"5
'
"6"
+
'
"'7

:T
67
8
)5 '"

)!6'

)"
)'
! :"

!=
@
:

'
>:4
'4
<.
4
%
 ?4


),

'':
6
!'=
@
"5
8

'
'
!"
9A"
'
8

!':


66



!'


'
" 
8!'


5
66"'


> (

67"

#$
'7
$331

</30
 4
$G
(
##$

%.$
 4
$7
'
%-3
 4
#7?4

!':

"5

)'4
#.

'

!'
'


> (

67"

#$
'7
$331

</30
 4
$G


!'
'LA

'5


5 59A
'9=
(7A
$33$
664
#%%
?4

"A!''


"5


'

'

::'
''

: !'
F 8
@

";!

 '

'
@

'4

<4

65

"'!


'
@

6''
) !''
>

FA



?

7

!'
8

!" 
"5'!'

)'
6"'
5'

:4

'U9

!" 
'
@
6'

FA!'

)"''

'"
'
@
 8

8
!
'
6
8
'5'"
)"
'
67

'54

'

"
!" 
'''

""!'
'
6
"'!
8
'5;

6'


/012%/$332

+
#3/#%
+


7!'
;A

)"
> (
#$1

$2#
 4
0
##1

#%0
 4
$
##0

%#0

%
#31

#1<
 4
#?4



8


5
67'
R
66'
!" 

8
'
"'!'
R'
8

6'
'A;
'
:'
R7F'
R
"' 
'"
8

66'

: 


;!
!6'
8R
6
"A!'

 "'

6'
;6!"
6

6
;!"
8R
'
"'"
"'7

6


R!=
8

6'

';'
!" 
'
R66"'


''
!" 
'

'
:
8



R;6'
'
P!'
!'5"4

!'
R""!'
"'!'
6

5
67'
R'

RA

!,

65


"A'
!!
66'

!!
;6'
!
7
'
7

'
> (
#$1

%1$
 4
%
#$$

#23
 4
#
'

":"?4

:
)A'


5
67'

66'
"'7
6

!" 
'''

FA
6'
'
'
'
!6'

:'
8

);6"

!" 
'''
'
A""!'




'
@
6 
6'
6

6''




'

:
8
)'
@

4


F6 
 
6

6 
;
'''
:'
6

6"'
8)@
)66"'

)6'"

'5
6

!" 

:!
> (
#$1

%1%
 4
%7/
'

":"

#--1
64
00
G

#-<<
64
130
 4
$?4

-4
)"68


"
'

'
)"
::'
)
9

6'"+!" 
'
)
''
6'
:'4

:4

)5'
 ""
!!
67

'5
@
13J


'5'"

9::

';4

!+'
)5 '"

5'

"'"
 "4

#34 )"

! "

"5




'7
$3304

=A
8

"''

'"
)'
AA5"
6

"

) 

','

!+ '4



::'
" '

'5'"

9::

';
@
$1J
6
'7
$330
)6'
66!'


A'
'


!6'7'"
'

88

4





:!"
8
6
:
$330

,!6'!'A

6'

5
 A8
)"''
AA5"
'
""
8
5

9A!'
5


6'9A

)'
)
'
@
.1J

F':'4



(

"A!'
""
8

6''

65'
6
'5
@
6

$3J

7='
!68"
)'''
 5
"5=
,'

A5
"6


"''
A""
>:4


#%
"!7
$330
'
66'

$<
F5
$331?4

##4

!" 

 


''


5

5
'''
'

59
 ""
8
)"''

'"

)"

)"''
6
AA5"

6'
):

6'"

'5
6
66'
@

8
5'
"'"
''"
6

:4

/012%/$332

+
##/#%
+



'
'

@

6'"

'5

13J

)'5'"

9::

';


6
!'8
'

#33J
5

!'

 !'

%3J


6
6,984


'
@
'
"A
5"
8
I

6
!'8
!H!
'
@

6'

76
@
'

),

6

! :'
!F


6'"

'5
6
#--.4
)"
!'

AA5'

!7A
!

''
'
9A"
6
);6'

:4
4
*

6
6,98

),

6



@

6'"

'54

"!"
)
,

 "7!'

6A

'''
"

7='
'
@

+'
6'!

:'

8
 5

!
'9"6'8
'6
F8)@
6"'
6!'''

!'
)
6'"

'5
!6='


6:
!!
9::

';I4

)'
6

6
'5"

'+  '
 5
@

6'
)
'5'"
6:
8
5'
'
!6'
)
!''

6'' 
@

!94

#$4 


)"

8
8)

'
6""
8

! 

"5
)"''

"'"
6
!'5"
6
)AA5'


!7A

6

7='

+!H!
!
6

::'


!" !''
8

"''
6'
6

''!'

6'9A
'

"''
'''
8
" '
7!'

6'"
@
 
6:!'

5"9
'!74


"A!'
69"
@
) 


6
'
!6'

'
A "
6

 '
)
';
'
8
'''
6""!'
6


8
):'4

#%4 
7

"
''
6''
8

!" 

 
'
6
'

6'

)"

'
5

::'

!" !'
6
'

'
"'


66'4
(
'
)

8)

'
P!'
'
!6'


66"'
:

4

!H!

'+

'
'"
6

9::
6:4




66
@

' 
8



66'
);6'
"'7
6

!" 

'
H'
!

'

''
8
'4

6'
'A;
'
:'
)7F'
)
"' 
'"4

66'

: 


;!
!6'
'
6'

 "'

6'
;6!"
6

'4


"'"
"'7



)!=
'


!" 4

6'

';'
!" 
'
)66"'


''
!" 
'

'



);6'
'
P!'
!'5"4


'

66'
6"'"
!6'
''

 '
;8

F6 
!'

5
67'
)
'
!'
> (
#$1

%1$
 4
%
#$$

#23
 4
#
'

":"?4


7

"
''
6

8

!" 
'''

:'
!'
"''

::'


!" !''
6'


6'"

'5


6''4

/012%/$332

+
#$/#%
+


#04

,
+'+


 "
8
)'
@
7
'
8
) 

:"
)A!'

'
"
@
)"4


'

"8
F'"4



/012%/$332

+
#%/#%
+

 
6-05
  -0 - 


 

 0

%

  7 2

#4 "


574

% 7 

$4 
F''4

%4 '

"!!'

$33
:4
@

9A

'4

04 :!

6'


8R
65'
:!

'

6"'
H'


"

%3
F
=

':'
6=

7
:" "
>*9VL9:8
2
2330
  ?
6

5



!'=

'
67
:!"!'
;
'4
<$




:" "


7
:" "

#.
F
$331
> (?G

!"!


'
 8


!':
'
!,

65
'
6'

A'

'



! '
G

'
H'
 "

7
:" "
6
5
6'

6
5
"'8
;
 '

)'4
0$
 (4

6"'
H'
'

6=

6

'
58"
!!
!,

65
5'
H'
F'
@
)54


A::=


" '




+
W

X 


6
:!

6"'
H'
'
':"
;
6'

8R@
R::
:" "



6

A::


/012%/$332