Interest Accrual Date on Remand Following Conditional Judgment
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute concerned the proper method for calculating interest on judgments under statutory provisions, involving multiple prior judicial interpretations and differing lower court applications concerning the starting date for applying the statutory interest rate following a conditional judgment or a remand for further proceedings. The court reasoned that where a prior appellate ruling establishes the right to a judgment but leaves calculations to be determined on remand, the statutory interest rate begins to accrue from the date of the initial judgment, not the date of the final judgment on remand, as this preserves the litigant's full monetary award from the time the liability was first legally established, thereby harmonizing the application of the interest statute across various procedural postures.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Interest Accrual Date on Remand Following Conditional Judgment: The court reasoned that where a prior appellate ruling establishes the right to a judgment but leaves calculations to be determined on remand, the statutory interest rate begins to accrue from the date of the initial judgment, not the date of the final judgment on remand, as this preserves the litigant's full monetary award from the time the liability was first legally established, thereby harmonizing the application of the interest statute across various procedural postures.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
%&'()%)) %+',%)-
.
" "/ /#/ "/ #
)' 0! )-
'1 2!
/3#4#// 5 4#/ /3 # / 64 7 0 !"#$%& 8
'!
#9999999999 :9999999999'()!) ; **'+ ,-!. - !'( /
'00"( !!' -!-12222222222 . ! '/
! "# $
"34#"
/ 4
5/ 12222222222 . ! ' & ! '!((! )' 9! :9 ! ' (; (- ./ -! !( !-)! )2222222222< 3= '&(9 5##> 36 & 3885? 2222222222 < 38 @& 5##$ 36 & 3885? 2222222222 < 38 @& 5##$ 37 @& 5###? !' !' ! ! A!'! &B0/
3/ ' -!- -! ! :: - . !- ,()'C ,9' B !' A&' '()! ' < ")%D ? ,& 5##6 B -(9 5##7 ) B )! 5 @& 5##$ B !)': ' ,"
& ! & &! E--! ' '( C ! )!'0 <@',; D E--! ' !) '( %& ")%D E *?/
=/ ' !!! E * ( ! -A(! ,'! ' :( ((9/
F/ 35(3885( !!12222222222 '!. 9 )( % !%&( : !' -!-/' 3>(3885 '!9!0)'-. !B(! )-(; -9!-'!'95##$ & !)'9! '!'93888)G!:/ 788H888/" . !' %& < ")%D ? AI B ! '(! . :'! ' +2222222222 & ! '- )% ) )! )! '(@' ! ) !"! ')J2222222222 ! < "
)%D J2222222222?/ *;(! ' : 0) .- !! % ' -!- & :' '()-(! 12222222222 ,& ! : (!));'''((/
>/ @A(! 36 & 3885 9 )( % ! )''- ,'&!: !' -!-/-)K!,-!!''! '-!-)9 - E ,& ':: ='!'93885/
6/ !' - '#'&(93885<L)!K!53'&(93885? E * :'(- 2222222222 2222222222 ! 2222222222 ., !)'9)-@ .,& !9 : !' ! )! &(!:/35FHF#7/F8<)'0)( ?!:/5>7HF>$/3><)' ?!'!C'() !-G!('!' : A! '!!0 '((! '/ ('!! A'9! '! ! ' " " -- )) ! ',!/>3 )')- ''&(9!-(9 5##$ <'? -(9 5### @& B -(9 3888 <'M! ! )!(9 0)!-? @& B ( 3885 <' ! )! &(! :/5=6H6$5/F8 ! :/ #$H55#/5>?N'! ! ',";K(A')'!<)! &(!
4567343883
"=4#"
:/ F8,$55/58 ! :/ 3#HF$5/#8?N '! ! ' -A ( '! ' :( !'<!/=8 E?)- '@& B@ !5###'!'9 B -(9 3888 ! @& B ( 3885 <)! &(! :/ 38,=67/3> ! :/ 5FH6F8/3>?/
7/ '))' ! ' 7 -(9 3885 L ) E * 58 -(9 &! 2222222222 ! 2222222222 '! : ! &' 9! ., :! A& )'& ! G! )';- '()! ! '()'!(! O P ,J2222222222 . & ! ' ! B ! ''! : /
$/ ' '!-L6-(938852222222222-A(!:'(- '))' ! '/0)'-G!&( !!' -!-38@& 5##$ ! &' -( '- & ::! ((- ! ' ,( !! ' ) !! '((- 37 @& 5### <&- ' ? (G( ! ' A !'((,-! ! !&.55-(93888/
#/ !53-(93885E *-- '-)! ' '((A'! : -#'&(9)--!B2222222222/
58/ - ! -)- 33 @& 3883 E * , '(( ' !' A&' ' (! % , < 4567543883? )! &(! ,'! ' :( < 4567343883? '! B ( &- '))' ! ' :'(- B ;!,'((!'!:/35FHF#7/F8)2222222222!2222222222 A-'@' !(!!' (!/
55/ (-(' -)' 5> ( 3883 -: '! ' B ,! '- '-)! ''((A#'&(93885 .,-9'!(!(!'!)-!! '/
53/ ', '()! ')'3F( 388FE *! '))'!'!) !-' '/
5=/ ' 3@ 388FE *)- - 9-. !-G!('!' --:/38H=67/3>! &0'! ! ' -A ('! ':( !',-& !B:/5H=$$/>>/ )-!! ' !'! B ! ! ,-& ! B :/ 35H7>>/$8 <:/ 38H=67/3> Q :/5H=$$/>>?/
5F/ G!56)!(9388F<0)- -)''! : ! '0)! 7'!'9 &!? 9!'' '-BE * ) ' ' !! ., ' ! '! ! ' " "
" / %(! 9 - B !! @.,B ,!-
4567343883
"F4#"
:' ! G! ' ' ! & 0 '! ' :( ' !!' '-:!)- (&' ' ,)% ! . '! ' '! !' . )'& ! -!/ &-,'))' ! '-:B':/5#3H7F5/68 <' !:/35FHF#7/F8(' :/38H=67/3>-A ('! ':( (' :/ 5H=$$/>> B ! ! , !-G! ('!' ')'!?/ :' 9' --9:. 2222222222!2222222222& !: ! A&(!&' 'R,!,!/>3 /
5>/ !G!!!-:':!'/
56/ !: !!('C'!0( -!!.9' ' -!. &!/
/ #
5/ ' A&' ,'A ! ' @ <? -!- (' : - ! ! !- %5'M!388= 9!'' '()'-> @A'!)- !!& ")- !>))-!!56@A <!/5!/ ! >6 ?/ ! B ,! ' ,-! ' 56 @A ) 9:--37@& 388F< E5=8586? ' A&' ')!- 5= :-& &! )' ! ' ! !' A! )(!!! 9 !' ' -A B !' @A ! ! ,!!! ,-! ' '&0 @A / !!! ' ' ! )9 9 :-- G!5@ !388F': (-. )' ! '! !' '! ! ! '! ' ) ! ' ! -! ! ':'( 'S! ' ! :-- <G!5/5$=4388F?/
':'(-(!B,!/=/=' A&' (' : !' ,'A ! ' @ 5F '&(9 3883 ! !- & A 5 'M! 388= )-! )! &! '(( '!' ' (! % ,'! ' :( ) 33 @& 3883 -!- !( ,':: 9!'' <:/ !/>6/5!/;/5 !/3 !/?/
,'9@! ' '! ! B ' !' '! ' :( 5 ( 5##6 < ")%D E? <:/!/ >6 / 3 !/ 9 ?/ !! 9 - ! (!- (! '()-!! )' !! ,)%/
4567343883
">4#"
3/ ! ,!/ =8 / 5 E ' -& ,0)! ' ' )! ! ,)%-A ! ':--,"& !& &!,)) . )'A B)'-: 0! '!))! ''! 9! 'B -! ' .,B )-()! ' ' ! -( '! 9! ' -- ) ()'C :: - B ,'! ' :( <!/3= / 5 ! 37 / 5 E?/ ' ,!/ =8 / = E ,()'C . !! '(! ' ) -A A A& ,'9& ) ) )! ' ! '((AB ,'! ':( !!-)/ ,! >3 ' :-- ,"& ! & &! ,)) . )'A /
=/ ' :--)! A--' !' < ?6 '!'93888!-& A5@& 388=!S-(' : ! ' '(9 )' ! ' -A '( , / -'( )'9 !-H()'C!-A-( %)-! -.H)&!B H!/ >3 ' :-- ,"& ! & &! < ? ! !/$5!$3%A(!T"& !& &!< ?'!-!- 9'A-/ H)% ! !'!:' -A ) )' ! ' & A @.H =5 -(9 3883 -A ) ) ' . @A ' H)B) ' -! '(' : ! '' ! 'H-!!: !)'!- B!-!( !- ' ! A # '&(93885< E537F67' /5535=66' /59N:/-A(! )' ! '! !' D!/$3/5 ?/
F/ 0!(,!/$3/5 .&' ,!/=8/5 E' ! ( -)! ' '((A O) !P '. '()! ' : ! ) &' ) - ' -)! ' H- )% .H ' '((A ! !'! B H0) ! ' H - .B'()!: !'((A9</5?/'.' !- & H !) 9'( )')-B - ) )! ' ) 'A-- !)) 9</3?/ -) !!( ''A '! !/$3 - ! !-)!!'('!!%)-()!' 9 ., '& !,0( ,':: .! ')!< E536 F>5' /3535=$$' /=9!-:-?/
('(!O' '((AP,!/$3/5 :!!%AA--('(!'R '()! ' !M '()! : ! )& H!!! ' '9(! 0 A 9 . '! ::! & )(!! ! ) H0 A ) (! '! ! ' ( )'& ! !S H'9 A! ' -) '((A < E536FFF' /=?/
4567343883
"64#"
: ! @ ) (! A--(! ., 0 ! ' :: ! '((A '. - '! -!- & - ''! '-'.,-!!''! ')!G!'!-<388= )/##N E536FFF' /=?/
>/5 ,)%E *' '((A)!K!='!'9 3885 ' ! ' )9 ! ' -)K! ,-!! ''! ' (!!! - ! -&-! ) ., & ,-! ! )-& 9 )' - ; 'A); / - ' -)! ' '((A # '&(9 3885 L ) !K! < ? 53 '&(9 3885 '! -!- &'C- 0 -: - )-& ) ,!/ $3 / 5 )) .-)'A <!/=8/5 E?/
>/3 '! : ! '))' ! ' ) ' 7 -(9 3885 L 58 -(9 &! )! . ( . ( &- ) !33@& 3883/
E'(- - -A !! @' <!/ =$ / 5 EN !/ $5 / 3 ! = ?'()!!:- : ,-<!/33 )) 9& ,!/#6 N5##$)/357?!!'))' ! '..G!( &-'! &9/
6/5 &! H!/ >3 )) .- ) 'A (! % ,'! ' :( <!/ =8 / = E? H()'C . !! '(! ' ) -A AA&H'9&)) )! '! '((AB '()! ' <)! &(! ,'! ' :( ? ! ! B -)! '/ H()'C ! )' (' )'9 !- )! H-!B! !9 0'A. '!A ''(< E53=5> ' />953366' /F55#F8>' /3!-:-?/
6/3 H!/ 5F / 5 '-! ' & !/ =F ) ! . H()'C ' ! - ' ;. ) '! ! ' - ! & " B '()! '(G(!().)')'! ! '/ ()'C ' &! (!! )- ' .(! 0 ) % '()!9 '! &-B()'C-( %B.'! ! ' ) ! ) ! G! - ! : H'9@! - '/ H'9 A! ' H()'C)&' '! ! '!-A'()!!!I; ' !)9 ) !)' / !-A 9:-- -- B - !-- ) . . -A A H'() : ! ) )! 'H!/>3 !' !)'-.!-)!'! !- '((A ' '-< E55$5#>' /3!-:-?/
4567343883
"74#"
6/= ,A ! ) )! %(! '! ! ' -A ( '! ' :( ,!/ 37 / 5 E ()' 0 ()'C )C '! 9! ' : 0-)'"! '( B'! ! ',"& ! & &! :-- &- 0 )' -)! ,-!9 (! !9 ., )'%! !'/ ! ,!/ 5F / 5 %A(! ,0-! ' ' '! ' :( < D > 58/85? '! 9! ' '! )L ' (G( (' !- ! (G( !&.'! ! 'B,"& !& &!:--/
7/5 'G!56)!(9388F< 4567543883?!-:':! ' 9-'(-2222222222!2222222222B)C BE *:/5#3H7F5/68/ ('!!A'9'! ! ' " " "
--)) ! ',!/>3 )')- ''&(9 ! -(9 5##$ <'? -(9 5### @& B -(9 3888 <'M! ! )!(90)!-?@& B(3885/
9! 9 !' ' ' -- . -:& !: !A&(!&' 'R,!,!/>3 !) (!'! ! ')'&!G!('! &-) '()'!(! 09 ' @! : - )!/ ! -A )') !) '!'95##$&+2222222222": -(!0) ! & ,'&! , A - ! ) '!'9 3888 " )'& ! @! : '") (! '! ! ' , ' ) 5##$/ (! )) !.- !.! ' 0 ! 0)-(! (9'(! - , ' / ('(! 'R & ! ) - ' ::- ) (! '! ! '' -:,& !) ':: !) . ' -!- )' ! (9' " - '9/ ::! 12222222222 ':: ! ) ' , (. )'& ' . !- ( -! ! '(! !!-/ ' & -''( . -) ! !'! ! :! . ! '! ! ' 0 ' B &' '!((! , @! ' ,!) '& ' : % ,' ) ! ( : A - !:/788H888/",-!!)'S!&-- :: !,)%/
7/3 ! )-! ! ' . . '- B ,G! )- !- '! -!- !' !)(G(('!(G(-:'! : ! (G( ! ! )'!! .! ' @ . '((/ ,!/ =8 / = E ! ) 0)-(! ,)) ! ' 'A . ,!/>3 (! % )'9 !- ,()'C < A %(! 'A,)'('?. !! '(!')-A AA& , ) '9&- ) )! ' ! - '((A B '()! '
4567343883
"$4#"
7/= , ! . '! ' B . ! )& 9 !' ' ' G! 56 )!(9 388F )- !- )! G! !)'- (!! (! ,)% (! % ,'! ' :( ' !!'/
7/F '-.) ! !-('! :& !G!0' -!. :: ! &'C <!/ =6 / = )) .- ) 'A ? ))! B 2222222222 ! 2222222222 ))'! -A(! '((A .H '! -:! &(!B(! &(!0'! ! '-A ( '! ':( !'' !:/35H7>>/$8<:/ "U5=?/
4567343883
"#4#"
3 #4 "/ /#/ "/ #
< ; = 8$ &') #
;
5/ L' !.G!( &--)'-)E *33@& 3883/
; 3/ %&'))' ! ':'(-)-:B':/35H7>>/$8/ = !.)'-!A! !/ A))-!D A:: %D "' C ') ':'()-!G!!'! : -0)! )A::
4567343883