Issue Preclusion in Boundary Dispute Relitigation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court considered whether a prior judgment barred the current action concerning the determination of a boundary line between two properties, where the prior suit involved a similar dispute between the same parties regarding an adjacent segment of the boundary, despite the earlier ruling not explicitly covering the exact section in dispute. The court reasoned that the prior judgment conclusively determined the underlying issue regarding the legal establishment of the boundary line based on a prior survey and recorded plan, and because the current claim involves the same fundamental legal question and parties, the doctrine of issue preclusion applies to prevent relitigation of that already-decided boundary determination.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Issue Preclusion in Boundary Dispute Relitigation: The court reasoned that the prior judgment conclusively determined the underlying issue regarding the legal establishment of the boundary line based on a prior survey and recorded plan, and because the current claim involves the same fundamental legal question and parties, the doctrine of issue preclusion applies to prevent relitigation of that already-decided boundary determination.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive regarding the imposition of court costs.
Testo completo
&'(()&'(() "&*+,&'(()
"
" #" # #
-. /0 % ', 1 '(()
% 22222222222
# #" 3 #4 ! " #$ %& ' ()
! "#! $% , +*- ,
5"
./ # 00000000000 "!1! . ) +&&% " " 1( " 233 " 2 1 4,1( 5 ) 2 "2" ! " 67 8 "( "/ 91:! :2 ) )! "1 . +&&. :! " " 1( " 21 ;00000000000 <'= :2 ) !! ! 1 " .> 1 $ +&&? ) 33 ?. "! $ +&&?/
+/ "! " - +&&%= 2 2 3 ! : " " ! @!= 3 :2 ! "$ :! "2 1A "2 1A!/ 33 11 :2 ! 8 " :2! " !!
;00000000000 <' 1 1 " 1 " .BC&&& 3/ "1 +% @ +&&./
?/ 2!! 3 ! 11 .> +&&%/ (8 : D
E F " . +&&. ?. "! $ +&&?= @2 !! ! " ;00000000000 <' 1 " !! "G "!" " )! 9 1"
E @ 1 8! " 21 @ 1 , !
E "! " 8! 1!= 3 " 8! $ )$ !!
E 1 "2H 1A! ! "2 H 1
E @ 3 1 1! : @ "!1 )! 1 !" " !! I/
@ : :2 ) 8 86 " " 67 8= !! " : 2! 8! " = ! 1 ! " 1!" ' " 68 1( " 8 " /
%/ "! 11 " ?. G +&&%= 1 ! 3 !
: 2! 2) 1 " 9 " ! " 67 8 ' 1 " . ) +&&%= ! 1" 1!! :2 " 1 H "( +J +&&%= 1 : " !/
J/ 2! 33 : " 8 " " " 1 +% +&&%/ : @ 1 7= .B +&&%= ) !"! 1 " 1 ' # K00000000000= :2!,8! " 21 ;00000000000 <'/
*+&&%*+&&% , ?*- ,
-/ " > ) $ +&&% 1 $ " != 2! "!! : D
F 2 "G !" ' 3 )! " !!= 8 $!!3 ") " 1 1 !"/ 1) 1 68 "291/ 19 " := " 3 : @2! 2 11= !!= = " 3 )! I/
1 1!! : D F @ 1 1!1! " " 8 " 1 7= 1 : @ 1 : 2! 1 1= 1 : G 1 : @ 66 " ) I/
L/ < := !! 8"! ' @8/
"
./ 8) 28 @" 45 !! "3! != "( . G +&&?= $ " = 1! " J @8= " 1!" ),1!"= J 11! .- @8 4/ . / J- 5/
< ' 2 " 2! " .- @8 = 1 $ 3!"! +L @) +&&% 4 M .?& .&-5= " 8) "1!= .?
3!)= "1 8 1 $ " " !8 ' @8 = = " 2 " 2! " )9 @8 /
< " " 1$= $ 3!"! = " H " . @ +&&%= 3 ! : "1 1 ! 3 = " N= " 3!"! 4 M .?& ++-5/
+/ 3 ! ' C/ J- / . / 6/ B = $ " N : " 1!) ' 2 J- : ) ' 3!"! 2,67 8 $8 2" ! "2)$! " +J @ .>B+/
< 1! 1 @8 " "21( !$/
?/ @! " "! 3 !89= )$ 4/ J- -& " 3!"! 1 8!! " " " " - $
*+&&%*+&&% , %*- ,
+&&& 4 E < B?&/.5 %> / + " 8) ( " 67 8 4< + +&5/
%/ 9 " 2/ ?. / ? / = 2 1 " ' 2" ! " !" " 26 " )= 1 : 39 "! : 1"
2 1A E 1) 3 "!$ E :! "2!= " $ "28 "8 " 21 " "! "2 11 3( ' 21/
< @1"= ) : @ "2 13 1$ ' "2 1A 2 1 " ' 2" ! := $ : ! 3 1 1= ' 1" "! " 2 1A 3 , " ( "! / = 33= "! 1 $ "2 "1 2" ! " 67 8 !8 ( "2" ! " !" " 26 " ) 4 M .+? +?%5/ !8"= 9 ! 1! " ' 2" ! " !" " 26 " ) " '
2" ! " 67 8/ " (8 8!! : 1 : " " 8 ")" " 11 " 21 2!() ' +&O 1= !1! 1 9P 3 "! " 2 1A 4 < K &.*>+= 1/ % Q .-5/
1 " 2! : ! , H 11 " ) : ! E ) 1 "2 1A E : 1!" '
" " ! " 67 8 3 " " 1!" " "33! " 21 " 1) 1" ! )! ! " 1 : "29= $ " " :2 !8 2" ! " !" " 26 " )= : 9 !8 " 1 " " A " 4 .>>B= Q ?= 1/ B5/
)6 "33! : ! ) " 1 $ ' "2 1A : "!3) 21 " 3 " , R 1 1 "2 1 ) ' !" $ 3/ ) " H :" 21 "29= :2 != 1 " ! " = 1 "!3) ) !! 4 M .+? +?%5/ 1 )! "2! "1 "2 1) ! " !! := 1 " != 66 ' $ " " ! 3 " ) !! 1" 1!" ! : "33/
J/ 21(= 2! ! ! " !! ;00000000000 <'= : = 8 " / ! 2 8 @= 1:2 ! "2 1 " .BC&&& 3/ +&C&&& 3/ 8 2) 1 :! "2!,8! :2 28 "(
*+&&%*+&&% , J*- ,
1 "2 , / " " .> 1 $ +&&? ,, !! 8! 1 2!,8!= # K00000000000= 3 1" " : 2 2! : !! ! " !! 43/ 1(,)$ " 1 1 " > ) $ +&&%5/ ) " $ "$ :! "2 1A " !/
-/ ' "! 2 ) 1 " "2 1A : "!3) 21 " 3 " ,/ $ 3!"! " " :2 2A 1 " 1 ) ' !" /
33 ! " 1 1= :2 2) 1 ) !! "1 ?. "! $ +&&? : ,= ) ! ' "= " 3= )!/ 1"= !
8 " @:2 +% +&&%/ 2 !"! 1 " 1 : " " 8 " :21( ) 1 :2' "!3= 2$" " !/ ":! : 2 2) 1 8 1 7= 2 1 :2 1 : 2! 1 1= 1 : G 1 :2 ! 1! ' 66 " )/ 91 2 1 ) $ " !/ M 1 " : # K00000000000 : ' ! = 1 ( 1/ "! 6 2 2 ! : 1 !! " "!3) )!/
:2 = !! 11 " " 33/
*+&&%*+&&% , -*- ,
# "5 " #" # #
%
/6 7 8 9: -+' $
6 ./ ! )$/
% 6
+/ @/
?/ : 1!" 8/
%/ 3 1 " :2 1) 3 1! H " "! " ?& @ "( 3 1 1 "! "! $ 3!"! " = <6ST63: -= -&&% = 9 1/ "! 1 H 18!/ ! " D 5 ": 9 : "! "! $ 1 " "! :!R $5 91 1 : 3 1) " " "!R 5 1 8 " 1!/ < ! 1 !! ! !! 5 $5 5 ,"= $ 3!"! " 1 1 ( :2 ") "! )$/ ! " A " 1)= : @= : "! :! 2)11 " : !! 91!"! 4/ .?+= .&- .&B 5/
833(D !" D
#, U V
1 3 " 1! H 3! 9 1 <! "2 ' 2! 1 833
*+&&%*+&&%