Statutory Amendment Retroactivity in Monetary Threshold Determination
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over the proper application of statutory provisions regarding the calculation of a monetary threshold to determine a class of offense, where the court had to interpret whether successive statutory amendments increasing the threshold should apply retroactively or prospectively to the defendant's conduct occurring prior to the final increase. The court reasoned that penal statutes are presumed to operate prospectively unless explicitly stated otherwise, and since the legislature did not clearly manifest an intent for the increased monetary threshold to apply retroactively, the lower threshold in effect at the time of the offense controlled the determination of the charged offense level, affirming the conviction based on the applicable statute at that time.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Amendment Retroactivity in Monetary Threshold Determination: The court reasoned that penal statutes are presumed to operate prospectively unless explicitly stated otherwise, and since the legislature did not clearly manifest an intent for the increased monetary threshold to apply retroactively, the lower threshold in effect at the time of the offense controlled the determination of the charged offense level, affirming the conviction based on the applicable statute at that time.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
"#$%&"'("&" "$)'"&''(
+ * +, ,-, +*, -
&. /0 &% 1 &''(
23333333333 ! " # $ $## %&'
-44 ,-, 5+*,6 ,7 ( $ #" )*+,-!
!
/0.1/
, 4
23 4# &5555555555 6#/- 7( " 2*89( #:## $ ;' '# $# 2*1<3 4= $ >#( # ## " $ !#$#2<!?09993
03 $ $0< ?0990( $""$$$ #$ %/#!#$# "-$%>># $%/#!#$# "6#/- 7( !# % # $% ( # $ $#3 !)# @ "$# 5555555555 55555555553
<3 5555555555( "## A4& "$# :""( $ - $ " $ 2B C!# 099<( $% ## " $ !# $# 2 ? 09923 $#: # ! "# # " $ !# )$ ! "? !# ?# D#E( " $"#> D#E ? > $@( D- $# " ?E $ %# :D( : ?# " " # D# $"? 3 %" $ " $ ##3 ># #$#E"3 -! D"#( # ( $ D(##(!#!#)D# #E #? #3 # $">!?3%" @#/$"#> C" 3
5555555555( )D# ( $" "$# E ##" # ?)D#E,% $ $F !# 099<3 $#: #E )$ ! "? !# ?#( " $"#> ! )$ #E A<0322( $# " :D( : ?# " " # D# $"? 3 %## " $ !# $# 09923 -! D)# # ! "$#( :#( ? $ #(##( # $%# ## " #$"$ ($) G )D #E3 # #/$"%HE":- $#>#" ) :#I( # "!"3 E%## " $ !# $#E ,$>> #D)#E (> @ "##:3 ?)D#E $,& "!-( /#$ !2F3
F3 % $##: "@)D# #E-$!#"$#":#$ % 6'4 4 7E##$ $0+!?099<3 ( # $#: #E" " @#/$"#> " # $# 0992 "## # AF<300( ! ? > $@ # 3 %"! # $ %" J >!?( # % !" $ $"# C( $ $" # )D #E( $%@#" " :""#"( $ ? D?#E( $ ? $ # " ?#$( $ ? # $ %!# )D#3%" $ "$%"% "#"$#<###(
. /<.1/ # $ E# # # " $ !# #- $# HK 099<#I3
83 $"##$29C#099F(% $" #- "#$$2C# 0990<2K 099<3
B3 '# ,%# #$ (% >#"$"##$"## # #$2BK 099F3'">" ,C#$$ #?>"$"$ 6#/- A 7 #- $ ? > $@( E%@ # "#$ (% #$-E% %- ?%$ -#!#$ E$ "$#@ $# $%# #% $%"" !@3
+3 $28 ?099F( ,E$"## $% # " !)",% @ #"$# )D# #E3
# E %# @ E C#$ $ A #- $ ? > $@ $# %#E( $ $ # $ 4'4 #!#( > $ E %@ $ '4 4 % ! ? E#( $% # % " " @#" 6 @ :!# " $ '( - @#:#? $% # $ !#(# - $$>$ 7($% $% "" " " " " #! #( %? $ ? #$%!# )D#(E%&' E !#!# #"#/L3
13 "$0* ?099F(% C $( $>="": 3
*3 #$29!?099F( #?$" #@ ##$ "# ( #>"E" # :$",C:3
, *-
23 #:!#%:# #C$###67" "$#>#" # # "($- 2K 099<( #? $#("$8C:( $ "#$ !#/"#$ (8" 2BC:6 32 3 8B 73
'# ,% #$%" #$2BC:( #?>"$" 0+C!#099F6 A2<929B7($ #:!#$ "(2<>"!#( $## # # #: #? $
. /F.1/ # $ #": , # C: # #( ( $ % $ %" #$!@C:3
03 >" , M 3 8B 3 2 3 D3 0 ( #? $ #J # #E$ #"!,% # 8B E# #!,#%/#!#$# "$2*C#2*8*3
'" C:$$%- ##" ?#3
<3 #>"$" #:""$$# $#$B ? 09996 7 " !#: 2 C!# 099<( J $#># # $?$## #":$$#$#3' "#(# $!#E$# M#E$# L D",#- $##E-:#? !#: N ># C#$#E $" # $# 6 A 20+ FB+ #$3 2( 20B 2<B #$3 F? ">"73 -: $ "$ E , %#E "! $- C $ " !#:6 A 22+ *< #$3 B?( 220 <B9 #$3 FO 4 21 ; <+ 3 <2B #$3 <?73 %#E$$%-3
F3 $#( " "#!#$# "M## "$:# #E# "" $ : $"( E# " $% #>## " :"# ($%$#$%#$ 6 3132 F 73
' C#$( $ ? > $@ ! ( $ # # ( $# , ## " $ !# 6 A 209 22* #$3 0.O 4 2B 08B 3 02+ #$3 8 B73 ? $ ":# $ >> # )D#E( E @ # )D# #E ## "# E$ # M:# $ M## "$ !#EM# #?$M J6'099932B9#$3 F?OL 3$20099F($ #",?# #(B1<.9<(#$303030 L # "73 $$#>># "( #-$!(," ?#M@# $ $( # # ?C #! $ M" >># C #>##!#$# "6 #- #73$$M@$$# @ #$M#(M": #$$$# L >#" $ ?! # "$# ( , $"> $ E# "# # $ $# @ # L " $ #- > , M":# " $ # $"6L 3"# "(#$30303073
$M@ # "$M # )D#E) !$ $#/ $ ? >$@/ $# #C#$#E "#( # # ? >># E M # $ EM ## # $ # " $ !# !L - #!#$ 6L 3 "# " #$3 0303<O #D 4)/( D ?:#>> $ ?# >PD#:Q# $#$ :#$'R#!#D:( #D>S
. /8.1/ $ #Q!:#D # $ !#$# P ?:( # T " 'D>>D.AR'D#6"$37('DR$ ?# >PD#:Q# (' 3099<( 3 BF!3( *<73 >> (C#$( ? > $@# M J (-::""(## #$: $"$# "$ !#! $#,#!#$# "$M 3F 32 6 1 76!## 4)/(3# 33+B( "3312!373@ #,## $#$N( M # #$"$#( ? >$@#> ! "!"# "E($M# $!?C #>(#!$# "$ !# ( #E (/"!$$# #$M@:" # 6'099<230#$3<?.??O!##4)/(3# 331<("3 1+ !3 7 / #? L @#:" $ M"( EM # L # ?#" "6 A2902B8O'0992300F!3#$30? ">"O L 3 "# " #$3 0303< L # "O >3 # A 20+ 0*1#$3F#>#73
$##? $ $ @ #( - @#:#? $M >> $ ! " ! $ $ $ "# ": # $ $ !# ( $ DE ( # " #> $M ?#$# " )D# #E $M # " $M $" # ( # $M # -" ## # " 3 627$ >> #D#E$M$#>M" $ # ""##$?(607$M $M# ": ##$ #> #$!#(6<7$M" )D#E# #"("! ##? D" #E(E # " M"D #?" #$ $" #$># )D#E6># ## #"$$#7(>#6F7 $M"D$ # ? # ##>@-:$M $$ "D?## #( $"# $ #! # $>> $ " >> $ ? >$@ 6'09993288#$30OL 3"# "(#$30303<#>#O4)/( 3# 33+B("31973
' C#$( UD $ %@ "$#( E #/# $# -#!#$ $ ? >(# , $#: #$$$%#># # $:" $ :!# " $ %>> #3 $# "! - @#:#? $ # %"$% #!# " #!3 # #$ $$#!# -( $# "" $ # "?#$(?#$# " )D# #E($>> #D#E( $%# ": ##( "! ># #" $ $#( - D#E $ /# "##$?($"$#"$$#!$) G ? "! #( %"D $ # > @ -: $ % 3 $ # - "# " >$ # $">!?3 >#( %@ $# %@# $ )D# $ @#"3 $ (
. /B.1/ $ #$>$% $# ": $#>>" # -3 ? $ @/# >#: $#!: $ $"# ?!"( %": # $%# $ $ "# #E $ !:( %? $ $$ $ #( :$ $#!: #> #># # $%-(># E $# -$" #!# ##?%@ (##E%": #$ $ D$# :" !# )D# # 64#( ' >' V:T#D $6)D# #D7 D (' '2(32 298O'0999328F73
E#!? $% "$#(E# $" # % E # # #:#@ # ># %?C $% " $ # #"( E >$ $ @ ( E%# ": #$" ## @#"@#"(E%## " "" ?# # # $ %-( E $# # $ @ "$# %"# #$# #"$## # >#E#$ %@ # $K #!"3 $ ( %"" $" # ! ? % # %#:# $ ) $ ! # $"#: # @ #(#? ?# 6 A208<80#$3 <(2002B9#$32 ">"73
83 %-( % % $" $%@ # )D# #E( # #E @ '4 4 $ "$# #" $ !# ! M>>#3 % $"C, C:" #? $ "( ># M-! ## !? $@(##> !$ EM# M:# $ "$# #$"$ ( "## ( $ C#$( $ E ) ! @ # $ C#$6>3 '0*8.9<$0+!#099F73
( @# %# -$C#$ >"$""D ( %$!? E#3
>> ( "$# , # # " $ !# )D# #E( # E# $# # ! "$#@$#( ###$)D# 3 $# ## #>># !? $ "$# $M$## #%#%)C # %?$ : #(, ,$% "" "$# #" "3 #("$#>># E%" $ "$ % "#" $# H # # #I @# # #> E# $# , #( LE$@"$#$ # "# #3 @ ": E # # -( @ #>,$ #$>$ (% " "@#"(##$ "$)D#EDR 3
. /+.1/ B3 #( % # $K , @ # )D# #E E C#$ % $( @ #$"$ (D:"$%@# "" #"D 3 $ '4 4 ( % ! E $ #! # #" $( #! 3 "E( $"## $ % " # !)" @ # )D# #E ! $"##3
+3 "$ : # (E%#% =$%" #>#@"$ $"( " " "%&' 6>3 A20B 2273
WWWWWW
. /1.1/
* - 4 * +, ,-, +*, -
8/9 : ; 5! #)& -<
9
23 "!?3
9
03 %$ 3
<3 $"##$% $29C# 2BK 099F( !#$#, % !# #$#$" 3
F3 # E"$ : # 3
83 > # $ E% ! > " L $ $"# $ <9 C $- #># # # $" $" #? >"$" $ ( 'DX#RD>E# B( B99F ( # @#3 $"# L :"3 "# $# T 7 #$#E @ E$"## $"#? ## $$"## E"O ?7 @ E #> # # !# $$ $"##O 7 #: $ " 3 '# "# # # "" """ 7 ?7 7 #/$( #?>"$"$ #-E%# $!$"#!?3"#$ #) $ !( E# C# ( ## E $"## E" %! $ E" "@"$#" 6 32<0(29B 29173 :>>#T "#$ T ## ??#
#>$" L #>#"@ ###E%,%>>#>"$" $#:>>
.