Prior Testimony Admissibility Under Confrontation Clause
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns the admissibility of testimony under the confrontation clause when the witness is unavailable, focusing on prior inconsistent statements made in earlier proceedings. The court reasoned that the declarant's prior testimony, given under oath and subject to cross-examination in a proceeding with similar motivation to an earlier preliminary hearing, possessed sufficient indicia of reliability to be admitted, notwithstanding the witness's subsequent unavailability, because the opportunity to cross-examine at the prior hearing provided the necessary procedural safeguard against unreliable hearsay.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Prior Testimony Admissibility Under Confrontation Clause: The court reasoned that the declarant's prior testimony, given under oath and subject to cross-examination in a proceeding with similar motivation to an earlier preliminary hearing, possessed sufficient indicia of reliability to be admitted, notwithstanding the witness's subsequent unavailability, because the opportunity to cross-examine at the prior hearing provided the necessary procedural safeguard against unreliable hearsay.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court orders the losing party to pay the procedural costs.
Testo completo
$%&%'$&''( $)*+$&''(
, -, ,
./0 % " +% 1 0 &''( !"#$% "#" "# !"#$% & ' ( ( !)#% "$6"
( !+",-.%
( * * !"#'' "#/'"0/1!/'2334%5 &
!"#
789
2
-< =1#'">6$?7::;!-;@#)#0" 0"/#@' AB/@ C/$"?""# !$ ! ->2>!' !$->9:!#$"'"-7#->47<
7< *)66>"=1#'/$'$! "$'D/'"+, $''","?/'1/#'$"?"/$?E/6 +/)"$/D"'#1<
3< /$ " "? ' "? "$6'6 73 # 7::; ' =1#' " 0"/#@'$'$'#2?7::; 0"$ /+B/@""#''%'6$<
2< 0"$'$"/'#"'''"/$?E! /'/$'''"$6"/'"##+ #''"?+"'#1!''-7#->47' 73#7::;<
9< ,''#$/ 0"$/#",$'06'?'F
C ,1'"?""# F
• "#",$'$66$%'''"/$?E?'->>-! "'%+'$/@"G &< B'6$$ "$#07::9##"39,>.96<.9%( ( <
• *"( ( "9/'#07::;!#/$'$ /'$$/"->'07::;!?+,$@?'%3.,;-26<29! '$H'E#/73#7::;<
0C ,1'"?" F
• "#"$'$66$/@"( I A(C " - '0 ->.9 3- '0 ->>7! " - 6$? ->>2 3: ? ->>9! / " - =? 3- ='->>;< '''''"/$?E?$/''"0 /1?'F;2,7:46<-:->>3!-,7>.6<.9->>4'.,.;;6<-: 7::-% A C!/;,39;6<2: ->>;%( * * "5 &<
• *" 4#7::;!?+/"#" ,$@?'%-:7,>346<;9!'$H'E#/73#7::;<
8-7-:87::; 389
• * " ( * * ! "#''"#/'"0/1%5 &">'07::;! ?+,$@?'%-.,:2>6<.9'$H'E#/73#7::;<
• * " ( " 3 '0 7::;! ? + " #1!'$H'E#/73#7::;!'"7.,2.26<29<
;< 6#' 0' " ''' " /$?E ' $'$ '# D /'<="'"+$+,%"$6'",0?'",3:'0 7::;!H''"''0<
.< ,0",0='""$6D$!$'$1"$%=1<
-< ,'<79"6$"$0/1"/$?E/6! ?!??''?"'$"-."$#0->>3A(C!'$?1 -=?7:::!@1/$"""?<+='' /"J"/''"'%/'1A'<-77'-73 " ?B C! =1"""?#/$''",'<.3<-"6$"$ /$?E /6 " 79 = ->47 AC! ' % @? 0 '""/-K'7::3!"'!/@+,66 $'$'#A'<-27 C!D$'",66/'10" $" $/''"$'#$/=1""?.
7< *,'<77(A?'?1"/-=?7:::C! " "?! /'' " ' + "' #1 ' /'1$ 6#$#' D'<-77!-73!-2-'-27 L'<3%9 (,//+' /1#''%'6$A<-C<)+='!/''" '%/'1/"%"66$'/''"'!1#'$ " ? " 0 /1 D'' $?'#' ##' " "?! ' /''"'!1#'$"?"0/1D''$?'#' ##'""#1A6<'<72(C<!='% /'' " ' ' % ,? " 0 /1 D'' ##' " " #1 '$H' " ##' " "? A ( -74 73:L (-7>222C<
2< J/@!=1"/#@'"$/'1/#'$"? /$?E /6 + / ) " $/D "' #1< "'/'''!"J/'!"#1-7#->47!"J'/' 73#7::;!"'%+=1#'""?'"?D$'<
8-7-:87::; 289
3< * "#' /"'! /'' + / "#" ' " -->,>446< 2: A' -:7,>34 6< ;9 M -.,:2> 6< .9C< ?' ", "$" ??'#1'7.,2.26<29!"'+#''%/'1/ "#" ' " >7,9-3 6< >9 A-->,>44 6< B 7.,2.2 6< 29C< + / "#" ' " 3.,;-2 6< 29< '$H' ' "$=% $'$ $ / '''"/$?E"$6"< "#""'%DB$/ #'' " 2.,.9. 6< A>7,9-3 6< >9 F7C! ' B "' -4,4:. 6< 7: A3.,;-26< 29 F 7C! " ' + ,' "#" + "' % DB$/ #''"74,>2>6<4:<
2< 6#$#' % =/"! "/ = "$'#' / /'1 =+,##'"'6'"/''"'""#!=' "?$0$$6"''/''"'%"'$H'#/' #''"B< '$H''$'D###$1,'<-7 ","/$?E/6?!??''?"'$ " -4 ? ->42 A 7C 'D $1#'! B ' /$ A (/0$3;8:7"-4='7::3C<
9< $##' /N! /$" $'' 1'' A'< .3 < 7 ' 4>&<-"/$""#''?"-7/'#0->49C<
8-7-:87::; 989
2 -, ,
"
31 4 // 5 6 7 # %(& 89
-< ?'( % '6$ " #/' " ! ## " 74,>2> 6< 4: % ( ( ! 6? " "# ! + " '$H' #/' " "$'! "@ 73 # 7::;!=+,##'"'6'<
7< JE"#''+"0<
3< '+/$"'1''<
2< 6# /' " +, /?' 6# ' /$' H' " "$ " 3: = "@ '6' / / ##"$ "$ 0 6$"$ " ! *)OP)6+ ;! ;::2 ! ' D#/< "$ /' H' /1$< #$# "' F C "+ D'#' + "$ ' "$ 0' ' / " "$''+$L0CD//+#'6'#/?"#"'' '"$LC/'1'"/$''<*#$# '' / ' $$#' $#$$ '' C 0C ' C B"! 06$"$"//'#'@+, "?"$?0<#$#"#'#E " /?! + ' ='! + "$ ''+$ ' ,?// " +$'$D/$"$'A'<-37!-:;'-:4C< 166@ $"'F B 5 G
/6#"/$'H'''6$D/'+J%J666$"$ "/166
8-7-:87::;