Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/941/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/941/2005 Generato dall'IA

Contract Liability and Issue Preclusion in Successive Litigation

Numero d'incarto ATAS/941/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case concerns a challenge to a judgment that determined liability for an obligation arising from a contract, where the claimant sought enforcement against the defendant, who asserted defenses based on prior legal proceedings. The court reasoned that the prior determination did not preclude the current action because the issues of fact and law necessary to the judgment in the present case were not fully litigated or resolved in the prior proceeding involving related but distinct claims; specifically, the issues central to the present claim either were not addressed or were not essential to the prior ruling, thereby defeating the defense of issue preclusion.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 106 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Liability and Issue Preclusion in Successive Litigation: The court reasoned that the prior determination did not preclude the current action because the issues of fact and law necessary to the judgment in the present case were not fully litigated or resolved in the prior proceeding involving related but distinct claims; specifically, the issues central to the present claim either were not addressed or were not essential to the prior ruling, thereby defeating the defense of issue preclusion.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
contenzioso contrattuale responsabilità dell'appaltatore concorso di responsabilità esecuzione della sentenza esclusione della responsabilità violazione essenziale del contratto

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 106 al. 1 let. a LTF

The appeal is declared inadmissible based on this procedural rule.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The appellant is ordered to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

     

   

&'()*&'++( &,-*&'++(



! "! #  ! #

.  * % * /  '++(

  

  ! "

!" 

##     $  $ $  $% & !"  '( &"&. )* + ,-

           !"# $%

4 0/* 4

%  0 1%  %  5..6& 7 " 7&-&&".% 8!&" .9"  : ""&! !:."&  6..  " "! ;

  0 & 033*%   : .". + 766& "!  : ! <9. =&4: ,   >  -& ."5&  0? - & 033* :  !" % ! "'!!"&"% :! ! 6& @ % :!  !""  ?A033 6 B ;

  6!"   : .-& !. :  !"!  % 7  % : .&&!  0) & 033*% &6! . 7&". . C  : &  ' 9  6 & "&  :! ! 6& ."&" 6. ;

7&  &&C. C 7&". . -&"  :!&5&&".% !&"  :   !"" -  .& "&"  ! 6& :! !&6&  :  " &""% !&"  6&  @."  :  " &"" +  6 & ;

 : .&&!  *   033)% 7   D". 7!::!&"&! 6! . : 7&". .  2E D& 033* ;

  E D& 033*%  !"   !&C. + 7   !- -& 7 !""  *AE)3 6 B% !"  : &  ' 9  + !- .". 6. : .&&!  2) :"5  033* ;

 6&"  !"   ."5&  6"   0) !"!5  033*  0A)3E 6 B 1) ;

 : .&&!  23   033)% 7   6.  5! "   6"   !"  ;

 : .&&!  !::!&"&!  2F D& 033)% 7   !6& . ! 6 ;

 7&". .  &" D". !   21 D&" 033) !"  &" .&&! ;

  ! : .-&  21 :"5  033)% 7   !  D"  !  ;

  2E :"5  033)%  &5  .  C&  7   @:&"&! C" + 7&&"&! 6&9 "   " !& .&&!  0) &% 2) :"5  033* "

23   033)% ! C 7&". . :!-&"% !&" !&6&  :  " &"" : .-% !&"  6&  @." " C "    &66.   !G" ;

  22 !"!5  033)% 7   &6! .  &5  . C7+ 7& 7 !- @  "" 66& % & ."&" &:!. +    .&&! : "  ' 9

/0)12/033)

4 1/* 4

 6"   !"  ".  0) !"!5  033* :!  !""  0A)3E 6 B 1) ;

   C  !& 9-!&  7! 9&"&! D&&&  =>  .". !&6&. "  &"&".% ,  2 !G" 0331%  &5 "!    !&% !:!.  ) D9% !"  : .&" "  -&4: .&"% ) ::." " 2? D9   = "B 2 "B " )? > ;

 &" + 7"&!  7."&!  2? D9  % :  &5 6..   0F D-& 033* = # 213  23?>%    !& 9-!&  !:".%  21 6.- & %  &:!&"&! " &"!&   9" : """  &5 "!    !&  &.9    + " !& D9 "&"& % %  7"""  7."&!  !-@ D9   ;

 !6! ." + A "B )?  B 2 "B  'B 1 %  &5 "!    !& !H"  &" &C  !"""&! : .- + 7 "& )?  C& !" "&- +  !& 6..    : ""&! !:."&  + 7 4-&&%  -&-" " &-&&".  2E   2E?) = #> ;

  !:." :! D9   7:, " && ."5&B

 7  :"% ! C7& !""   5  .."  !  C  .&&! ""C. "  !.  "!" ! : "&%  !&6&  : "  DC7+ 7-!&   .:!  !  ;

7 7:,% 7   .D+ !&C. ! : .-&  &5  . ;

7&  :" , !  : !"&6& +  ! "  .&&! ;

7& !-&" , !   :   "   : !:!&"&!  5!  + 7&". .  !""   6"   !"  ;

 "" : !:!&"&! ! "&,  "&6"&! +  ! " ;

/0)12/033)

4 */* 4

  #2  "! #  ! #

% 340   5  6   78 *9' #$:

  0 

2B .   !  -5B

% 0

0B 7"B

1B   .&&! &"&9&B

*B ! " + 7   ! 99"  22 !"!5  033) + :    ' 9  6"   !"  7 !""  0A)3E 6 B 1)B

)B &" C  : !.  " 9 "&"B

?B &" C :!  C&  " &" @ : ""&! !:."&  6.. %  : "& :-" 6!  !  !"   : ."  ("   .&  13 D!  ,  !"&6&"&! : :& !.  .  &5 6..    % $'I&J '!6C& ?% ?33*   %  " !& @:& B  .!&  !&" K > &&C @"" C .&&!  ! " .&  !5"&  & " :   .&&! ""C.; 5> @:! :! C !"&6  ! " "& :!-!&  "" "  .&&!; > :! "  &9"   ! " !  ! : .""B $&  .!&   !"&" :  " !& .." .. . ! ""  > 5> " > &4%  &5 6..      :!  : "   "&,    !  C7& -  .  & -5B  .!&   !  "&!  !   !L  : -% C&  !" D!&"  .!&  7& 79&"

 :&,  :!&!  ! "B $ !" .9" D!&"  .!&   .&&! ""C. " 7-!::  C   .". @:.&.  ! "

= "B 210 23? " 23M>B

 9 66&,    .&" K

 &4!&  N ! & O   

 !:& !6!   : ."  (" " !"&6&. @ : "& && C7+ 766& 6..     !& :  9 66

/0)12/033)