Administrative Penalty Review and Remand for Re-calculation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe litigant challenged an administrative penalty imposed following an investigation into alleged regulatory violations, arguing the penalty was excessive and unsupported by the agency's stated rationale. The court reasoned that the agency had correctly identified the violations based on substantial evidence, but ultimately determined that the application of the penalty schedule was arbitrary because the agency failed to adequately consider mitigating factors presented by the litigant, warranting a remand for re-calculation of the penalty based on a reasoned application of the relevant guidelines.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Administrative Penalty Review and Remand for Re-calculation: The court reasoned that the agency had correctly identified the violations based on substantial evidence, but ultimately determined that the application of the penalty schedule was arbitrary because the agency failed to adequately consider mitigating factors presented by the litigant, warranting a remand for re-calculation of the penalty based on a reasoned application of the relevant guidelines.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs.
Testo completo
&'()*&)+++ "&,(&)++(
-"
" #" # #
% +) )++(
'. #/
# " 0 1 &' 0 " " 2# 3 &() !"# $%$$ $$ *+,,++
+'
% 4444444444 4444444444 )-'# . &'' .
&,+/' - +)) 01111111111 2-3
! "#! $% %4$5
0"
$8 +)) 01111111111 # ',' *',' .,+) + '+ ( 91111111111 : 01111111111 ;8 / ,+' < -<'+# *&,+'+# *.,+'+# +&&' ',')+ *,,' )'= &'# )) ' >' +&&' %?
,&<' $!"$8 +)) ( + @> A @( ' A '/ 2+ 38 B+' B1111111111 ->' >' +&&' =) *&''# ' * >' ( , C(' $!"%8 B& B1111111111 )) ' A &D& # <))- * ,'+'+ (8
%8 +)) + )' --) -@' @ )< *) $!!"# A > = ++ *+ , )) (') ) )>. , -)('' $!!" E + , )) ,/) C=*A ++<' $!!"8 , ,& )) +') ! C $!!! A B+'
B1111111111# &) * )++ ,)8 * = " C $!!! = B+' B1111111111 '& *+ ' ,/) ' *) $!!!# = ) ')&) ,' 8
F8 ' C>& %F -)('' $!!!# '< ,'&@' ,'++) - 01111111111 =+8 *) +++ )) ,<) %G ++<' $!!!8 '+' = ( ,')(< ,+' F@& ),' , F#?H8 *-- - +-'&)
( $#"FH %% +I %7778
58 %6 ,&<' %777# ','+-+ -))'+ ',' '+& 2 ,'@ 3 ')&) . )-' ,& +&& FJG$7#?? -'8# ',') +&&> < '+ + ,& ++ ,'' +'<+ K ,' +)) 01111111111 / +&,' -'# )'D
4$5%64%777 F4$5
&+'+' . +&&+8 )') + -+'&) +,,++ %?
++<' %7778
?8 %$ +(&<' %777# '= +&&+ + '+' () *+,,++8 +@' = ),+.
B1111111111 + ' +,< )>> >'(# ) ,'))
= B& B1111111111 ( &D& +<>+ = + ),+.# =*&,+/' -8
68 () A )'&'# )') .,= = L--' *--' *','# ,' M)'+ +'= , *+ &+ 01111111111 ( )) ','# *) )(+,,) C=*A ' &+ %J5F7J777 -'8 $!!F8 L--' ')C+ ( )) ' ,+< >'N . '+ ' ( &+ & )'> 8 ,# ,'+,' --) '+') ,' ',' ( &,=) ,+' +)) 01111111111 *+<>+ *L' +O &' &# +' = ) C= A A ,++ +>+8 # - $!!6# +)) &)' P1111111111# A = & ( ( + ),'& )'># ( ' .
' *,,'+(+' ' =*,'@ ' ,'+,' &>8 B+' B1111111111 +> =* $!!"# ',' ,' ( +<+'+ ( &+ '+ &# >' @8 ),+. + (+' +&& )>> >'( + +# - = ' ,' ,'+ * )() A ?7J777 -'8 , *+ A F56J7!$#%6 -'8 ,' )- <8
G8 >'--@' C' +' L'> +' '= ,'++ < +&, ,' ,'+- +)) , $!!F# ,'+@ ('<. '@' &<) >))' +& '- .
( +<+'+ ( &+ )&=8
4$5%64%777 54$5
"8 %G +I %77F# ),+. B1111111111 + ,'+ ,@ +&,< '( . ) $!!F A $!!G E ,'+@ ('<. &<) >))' *+ '(L , , D' (') +'8 )-' )' +' = ( ( + +<+'+ ( &+ 001111111111 991111111111 . / + ') +'8 C+ = : *&'' 8 B1111111111 * , ))
') A ,'' $' C $!"?8 *&'' 8 B1111111111 +L ' <' %J777 -'8 , $' C(' $!!G ;8
4$5%64%777 ?4$5
"
$8 + -))' ' ,' >))' '+ ' + 6 ++<' %777 2 3 ') (>' $' C(' %77F 'Q &+-+ +&<' ,++ )> +& * 8 *,@ ' +-+ ')> ,' ,++ (>'
C=* F$ )&<' %77%# )>' ,', + = '@> ,,< + (>' &+& +R - C'=& )'& + ,'+ 2 K $%G 56G# +8 $ E $%$ F6638
%88 . '& J' "%# ) $ '@>& ' J' ( '(( F$ ++<' $!5G 2 ' F$ )&<' %77%3# '+ &' '),'+ J +&&> ,'' +'= +&,+ - , (+' ,' )+ '),'+ ) J ) A +&,' &+& +R + +&&> # + # A J.,'+ J ) = A +&,' - +&&><8
+''& A ' ,++# J> J+'' J ) ,)'&,+ A +)'' J+-- 2-8 K $$% "# +8 5E $!"6 ,8 5!F38 +'= '+ )'( J ,< +& ,' + ,) A ) ,'',+ , +> ')# ) ,,< 2' "%# ) % 38
%8<8 '< -))' ' 2 K 3 ,+) ,', =J +&,+ S+ +&&>S ,++ ,'))# A ,'' &+& +R + '+Q'# / ,'D J+ =J+ '+ J' J +&, ,'=# = '+ ,'& , '+('' ++# &
4$5%64%777 64$5
,+'' C-' +<>+ '),'' +&&> 2 K $$6 G?# +8 F<E $$F $"$# +8 %E $$% "# +8 5# $?"E $7" ?%# +8 ?E $!"F# ,8 $7"38 - )'& + +' =J J/ S' + + , '' ,'+-# ' A '<'S 2-8 T SL<'<> U+O' # %@& )8 ,8 $$%3# J+R ') ,' ') 8
%88 - + ++' ,' <+ J-# J , )'& + +&&> &+& & +R , +' < '<+ +&, - )< ,' J-- - + ='# + A A = 'V+ )- <8 --# = < ,' - + ,'+)' ++'' ( ' + +&&> )'D # >))'# + ,'= '<.# )CA --&& + +&&># &+& +R +++ ') +-)# + A +R J) +++ J(' + )) ),+) ,( D' +)8 &+& A# ')' # + (' D' >))'# &' +Q' J) -# +++ ') ( ,'+<< 2-8 K $$6 $6$ +8 5E $$6 G?# + F< W $!!7# ,8 5$?# K $$F $"% +8 % ( ')-8 W $!"G# ,8 67G38
%88 + C','# +&&> '),) '( +'= ++ ,( , D' ,'V# ,+' &+- C'= + - 2 K $$F %?"# +8 FE $!""# ,8 $FGE $7! !%# +8 ! ''D )E $!"F# ,8 5GG38 +'= ++ &' &,/) '+ J+(<) J&,+/' 2,'+ &+'3# +&&> '),) '( &+& +R ') ++ + '')+('<# J A ' &+& +R# )>' A J+(<) J&,+/'# ++ ,( , D' ,'V + ,'+)' +'' 2 K $$% $?G# +8 %E # LXM'L +M('L'>'L# (+& # ,8 6!38
4$5%64%777 G4$5
,'+)' +'' ,',+ ++ '@( '@> ,,< ' ' $5 ( 8 + J'8 $?# 8 $ # ++ + (') ,'@ +&&+ + ,'V ) ,' (+ ,+'# A &+ =J , D' +&,) ( ' )L8 ++ '+# '@> >))'# '+(') ,' (+ )>& +' )<' +& A ,+' ,' (+ - 2-8 ' $?# ) % E ' 5F 38
+' ,+' ,' (+ # ')' = J , )) ,/)
)>'& ' ,'+ ')+ 'V+ )- < )-- ,'@ = -+) ' ') ')+ A --)' J )- < ,'+(+' ,'@ # = -+)
' J&+ J+-- ,+' &+ &,/)# J A ' ,+' &+ + )+(' 2-8 ' $5!# ) $ E +' ,+' # - ++'# ++ C'= '+&# $!"?# ,8 %%538 , ''(' =J )- < )-- ,'@ + )(') ')+ ,')<8 # ,'+@ ('< ( )- < )--# +'=J = = < < -+ @'& )- 2' $$?# ) $ '+ ( J' $5! E K $$F %?"# +8 F 3# $!""# ,8 $FGE +,8 8 ,> $G!# %%538
%88 *,@ '< '&@' ,'++) - %F -)('' $!!! *) +++ )) ,<) %G ++<' $!!!8 )+ -+) ' *'8 ?% +-) ,' %6 ,&<' %777 * @ +' )) ) 8
)-' + + . -+'&) +,,++ ' C+' A +&,' %6 ,&<' %7778 ),+ ,'@ +&&+ + '+' '=D &() +,,++ %$ +(&<' %777# ',) ) )> ' C+' 2'8 "$ 8 F 3# +' =* '(< A -+'&8
4$5%64%777 "4$5
F8 )) '& *+-- ,') '< +-+'&)& A *'8 F# 8 F + $5 +(&<' %77% &+- + '
*+'>+ C' 238
588 . '& J'8 ?% 2' F$ )&<' %77%3# J&,+/'
+ +('' +&&> =J ) (+ ,'',+ +& + ,' )>> >'(8 ',,' = J'8 ?% ,++ ,) 2 $!"! ,8 $$G38
58<8 *,@# +&&> + ,' ') ++ < ,' - +)) 01111111111 ,+' &+ F*67%#?? -'8 ',') ++ ,'' &,/) ,+' ,)'+ +(&<' A )&<' $!!"# ,+' C(' $!!!
,+' +&,)& C(' A )&<' $!!"8 +&&> ') + ,& +'<+ K ,+' $7" -'8 -' *+<C * C>& 8
?88 J' $5 8 $ # +'')+ ( '8 F5 8 # ,'' J+<>+ ,+' J&,+/' )' ' L= ' ++ ') ('' A +&,+ ( ,'+,' ++8 &,+/' +( (+/' . ,)'+=& ,@ +&,< +' ' (') A ' ')# &@' A = ++ ,'' , D' ) -' J+<C )+8
J+<>+ ,/' ++ -+'' )+&, # ,+'
J&,+/'# NL '+ ,< ,'' ,' +8 )>'# '< -))' ' 2 K 3 )')# A '))') ','# = ',+<) J&,+/' J'8 ?% ) '+ ,< 2 K $$% $??# +8 ? E $!"G ,8 %%738 J&,+/' = J= , NL +&& (++ ,'',+
4$5%64%777 !4$5
J'8 ?% # = 'Q ,+' J+<>+ '),''
@'& +&&> ++) 2 K $$$ $GF# +8 % E $"7 $"6# +8 $# $!% +8 % E $!"? ,8 656# +8 F38
?8<8 K --'&) .,')& = *+<>+ )> '),'' +&&> + D' '+ = +R +&&> I A (++ + + ,' )>> >'(# ,' *&,+/'# ,'',+ ')> * 2 $!G"# ,8 %?! E $!G%# ,8 6"G38 +&,+ = + =* < +&&> ,' + +<'(+ ,'',+ , &' = *&,+/' (+)
+& + &+ ,' )>> >'(# &' +R *. , * - '+' A )>&) + +&,+'& + A *< * - 2-8 K %" C $!"%# $!"F# ,8 $7$38
?88 +'= J&,+/' ,'+ &+'# +'> '),+ +'&# A ' <'# +&&> ) ,' # +&& = ,'+ &+' J. , &+& +R ',+<) >>) 2-8 + 677F '( JK ' ,',+ ++ E K $$5 G!# +8 FE $$F %?6# +8 FE $!""# ,> $F6# +8 FE K $$$ $GF# $!"?# ,> 65!# +8 %838
' S+'>S# - ' + ,'+ ,L/= = ',') ,'+ &+' A J.)'' + = , .'' - )( '
+&,+'& 2-8 + 6775 38 +'=J J +)) +/&# K J +C+' ')-)') A J' G?5# $' )# +'')+ ( J' G?!# $' ) 8 +-+'&)& A '# + ,'+ L'>) J&'+# >+ + +'Y# '),+# A J)>' +))# &D& =J(' L= +' + ')' +# +&&> =J ' &= +& + ,' )>> A ' (+' ,'+ =
4$5%64%777 $74$5
'),+ J &D& +&&> + +'&8 + '),) L'>) J&'+ + >+ J' G?6 S+ & +'> )+ )>) .,')& +&& # & )>& ,'+ = ,' --(& )+ '( +'># + = & >+ ,'+,'& + ,' ,'),+)' A -+'&+ (++) +))S 2 K $7G F?F# +8 ?E K $$% $!"? J''D %$ (' $!"" E K+'&+'# O'LL 'X+'LO# %@& )8# ,> %7! 38
688 *+''# + *.' '>' +&&'# B+'
B1111111111 ' =) *&'' ( >' (8 @ +' <& =) *+'> -+'& +)) +/& 2-8 # +,8 8 Z 6?5 6??# ,8 %7"! E # LXM'L <>+'L# G@& )+# ,8 6!$E K "6 %G$ !F %%38
68<8 A B& B1111111111# ' ->' '>' +&&'# & , =) *&''8 +-+ '()
=* <))- * ,'+'+ ( I& '8 / @ +' )'&' =) *+'> -+'& + )>& D' '+8
+'=* ') *.,' )< ,+' <+ *'+ ,) = )-' )) '' +)) C=*A -# =* &) >+ +&,<) +))# + *<+' +C+&# , # =) *+'> - + D' '+ 2 K $$5 %$F +8 F 538
* , '),) (+' +&& )>> >'( = *( , ,+(+' - +))# &D& * ) ') ' >'
4$5%64%777 $$4$5
+&&' 2 K %%8$%8$!"%38 '< -))' ' ,' .&, '+ =) *+'> '> . .
+' * +))# = >)' . &D& # , * &'' = +&&) A ' -'8 )) &D& * <= + ',') ,', &@' --( A ,' )+ * # +&& . ')+ + *&'+8
&+- = + A < * .+ ++ *+'> '+ ( = ,'+@ (++) *+'' ,'++ -- .
')' +. + + (< *> ',+<) '+ ,< ) ,' *' ?% 8
*,@# ,,' )'+ )-' = B& B1111111111 ( &' >+ : =* )- ; + ),+.8
@ +'# ( C',' < =* + -- )'&'
*,@ = ()'<& >') ,()# =* )) ,(# - = *+,,++ )'' ( + ))
),+) ,' . ),+.# =* *+ >))' , >) 'Y ,' L *' .# B& B1111111111 , D' +)') +&& +'> - +)) +/&8
G88 C',' +# K '+ =* / )>> >'( +'= J&,+/' +-+'& , A = , D' '+<& .>) + ,'+ ,< '&# + = &D& '+ 2-8 $!G%# ,8 6!738 &' = J+ '+ J.>' A )>' + + D' )() J,'@ = J+ , +''& '# &@' +&,<) >+# J &,+/' &D& )>+' = J)') 8 +'=*
4$5%64%777 $%4$5
*> * +)) +/&# + ,# ,' ,',# ,+' .> )(@' = +' *+ =* + +'' ', ,'',+ 2-8 $!G%# ,8 6!7 E $!G"# ,8 %6$38 --)'+ &<< *&,+ )>&# +'=* *> *,,')' ',+<)
<' +'> *&,+/' 2 K $7" %7% +8 FE $!"?# ,8 ?$# +8 % ,8 65"# +8 F<38
G8<8 B+' B1111111111 @> (+' ,'& A +)) *' L--' *--' ')C+ %J5F7J777 -'8 $!!F8 --) + +&&) @ )< *) $!!"8 +> ,' ' =* &D& < ,' ?77J777 -' , + F56J7!$#%6 -'8 ,'
)- <8 K>' -- ' +&,<) ,'+ +&& ') B+' B1111111111 +' +)) T
K'8 %5!J7G?8 $!!5 K'8 F$!J!G78 $!!?
K'8 %!6J?"!8 $!!6 K'8 F6GJ7G?8 $!!G
,'( L= ) )'D ' ') *('+ $"J777 -'88
B+' B1111111111 (+' ',' ,' ( @ $!!" +<+'+ ( ',' '+ )&=8 (# + # + ,' =* > &@' )= ( ''' &' ) + -@' +))8
') , ,' - = ,')@ = --) '+') ,+( , *D' = ,>@'8 --# .' +&,< , $!!? )CA *) ')>@'& +) ,' ,'# - $!!68 L--' *--' $!!G ( L) ,'=& &+) ,' ) A ( F"J?5$#7F -'88 B+'
B1111111111 ,+( , &=' '' +&, = + .> &' , '+8 +'' +)
.,++ )-'8 '< ) + =* * +)
4$5%64%777 $F4$5
, ,& =*,'@ (+' )) &) ,' ),Y * , ,)# =* * '& *+ ' $!!!
= '(&8 B+' B1111111111 *@> A &+& (+'
() -V+ ,'+'' ,& L'> +8 '# +&& - >'( *&'' = - ,' ( ,& ++ ' +)) - * , D' )<# ( L >') ('&<# = )+ ) + ,,+ '+< +<C(& ,< A '( +)) 2 $!"F# ,8 $7%# $!!%# ,8 %6$38 '# ' * )< *+'' '
&D& B+' B1111111111 ( '+ '+' A ,+<)
* ''& +# )>> ' >'(# =* ( '' )'& )L8 - =* &D& ))
(& * ,' )+-' +)) L> ' = A ',+<) -+) ' *' ?% # &' +R *> *+ * ,'D +') A +))8
K+' +)= +'# =* ( = ,')@# = B+' B1111111111 +&&# ,+' &+# )>> >'( =* '),+ +&&> (' +)) ,,+ *' ?% 8
# "0 " #" # #
% 256 7 8 95 '*) $3
6
$8 )' '(< '=D
4$5%64%777 $54$5
% 6
%8 +' A () *+,,++ -+'&) ,' B+' B1111111111 A +'' FJ67%#?? -'8 E
F8 - () *+,,++ -+'&) ,' B& B1111111111 E
58 -+'& ,' =J ,( -+'&' '+' +' ,') ''D ) F7 C+' @ +-+ ,' , '+&&) ') '< -))' '# LXM'L+-= 6# 6775 # '+ .&,'8 ) , D' ,'++>)8 &)&+' + T 3 ='
.& = )+ '+' )' +<' , )+ =)E <3 .,+' ,+' = &+- & ,+(+' &' ' )+E 3 ,+'' >' + + ',')8 &)&+' + , '+ ))& )&)') + ' 3 <3 3 # '< -))' ' ,+'' , '' &@' ' '+' =J (' )'' ''(<8 &)&+' '+' &+' +' &+/ ,'(# = '+ C+# = )+ =) J(+,, = )) .,)) '+' 2'8 $F%# $76 $7" 38
>'--@' T ') T
B' + P +' [
+, +-+'& ,') ''D +-) . ,' =JA J-- -))' ' + ,' >'--
4$5%64%777