Easement Obstruction Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a dispute over rights regarding an easement, initiated by a party seeking to prevent obstruction of their access across another's property. The court reasoned that the established prescriptive easement, evidenced by long, continuous, and open use for a specific purpose, conferred a right that could not be unilaterally terminated or significantly interfered with by the servient estate owner, even if the dominant estate owner had alternative access, because the interference materially impaired the established right of way, leading to a finding in favor of the party asserting the easement.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Easement Obstruction Dispute: The court reasoned that the established prescriptive easement, evidenced by long, continuous, and open use for a specific purpose, conferred a right that could not be unilaterally terminated or significantly interfered with by the servient estate owner, even if the dominant estate owner had alternative access, because the interference materially impaired the established right of way, leading to a finding in favor of the party asserting the easement.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe provision was cited in the dispositive orders concerning the allocation of costs.
The provision was cited in the dispositive orders regarding the reimbursement of expenses in case of legal aid.
The provision was cited in the dispositive orders concerning the granting of legal aid.
Testo completo
#$%%#$&&' (#)*%#$&&'
(
( !( ! !
!+,- .
/ 0,- $&&'
!"# $ "%&' & #&!!"(#&!!)&!
&
++ ( *',!- &"# .!.'/
!"
.1055.
1 (
56 7(#&8 #59:1 &'#!5" 5993 ;5 !#"< 1335 && - .!& =& !#& %>!?%%7*8* 7.%>@$8 'AA&5,'13356*&&!&'#&### 14%&"< 1335 'AA&;5!#"<13356
16 5;!#"<1335 B# !#%#!"!!B!"&#!CD"=E %& ! 5 ,' 1331 %> ! ( & ! "" ! >'6 !-#-('&%!& * !%E&!(%%&! &'&-(('&%<##A#!(&&&%#6
;6 (.CD"= F& '& !#.! !(!"& ! 5 ,' 1331;5!#"<133; #&#"<##A!B!"&#,>! 124A653!,'1331E!#"<133;6*&"!&D E -&@G'H.'!"!#&C#& *!%&&! (.'!&# !( & =G (# #%! F&#"&-"&%#=&' A%"!(&<&!'"<I #%!%(AA"&'6
:6 5/ ,' 1331 E & ! !"! ! (# ! <# A! ! <.%= $(A"#- >="&!+!& ! %#'F A' ! % ! <- $ (#&& % %<!&"&&!%&&!<.%='&/3 5;,'1331 !&-(!'&J&!##""%#&K%-# -&&&&&%#%&AA&5,'1331''"&!( %& ! L:2(9/5A6 & -( '& #="& !& E & %& * !( "&&!1:(413A6 %&'"&"!1(3/3A6
L6 %> ' K# "% &"% ! 5L " 133: 5/ " 133L B#!#%# 15"133L !"!!B!"&#!CD"=%> ! 7.%>@ 8E%&!54"133L6!-#-( '& % ! & * -( %'& % ! 1(3/36 A6 % " !%5,'1331E&!(%%&!&'&-B'&&C# %&&%&!B"&&!L:2(9/5A6
/6 !#!52"133L #"#&&&!%&& %M&%!B.CD"=!,'1331E!#"<133; E' "&&!515(113A6/L6!##- %-('&%&& &%# 5 ,' 1331 "%& % !& "" &' E %#! ! && & % #-& B'& % !& E ! %&&6
012201334 .;055.
46 & ! A"# % (# 5; ,& 133L & !# %%&!5,&133LA"&!#& <!# %J&!4A#'133/7 01L1L0133L8 %&"&!"&,=# -"&&!&&&(#'&E555(41LA6436!##-(# ('& % !# ! A !& E ! %"> !"! !(!"&# ! CD"= =& -( & ' ! %&& ! %#'F %A " - % & E #%& ! & & ! %& ! (&&& ! %#'F "&& ! (!"&# & !N J& =# ' %%"#6 %## - " ! (<=& ! && E -(#&!%%&&A&%%&! (<,&!&=&-(%%&&E !&&!"!!"6 (F&#&#A"# &J&&&#A6
26 13A#'133/ A"#(#-(E&!(J&! < '&#(!"&#!CD"=E-'&!&%%#!! ,' 1331 E !#"< 133; - A& %%)& &% %M ! 99(91:A6/3-(!'&"<6
96 1: " 133/ (# !# E !"! ! " ! (<=&!&&E!99(91:A6/36
536 52 ' 133/ " && !"! ! " E & .CD"=!(AA&!("%7.%>@ 8%!# !(&&#&6
556 !#!;3N&133/ ( A#!(!"-&&# (AA& %A E #'& %%&6 !## - (# '& ""#==='&&C="&!&&&' 5/,' 13316 K%# - !> #%& ! ! $ ! && !& (# & !N "!A !#& A& !"! !(!"&# & %%& (&&& # K -& %# & "!&D'&!(F%%=&6&"#-(#'& A&<=&!="&&&""&&'&"& !!#C="&!&&!!!(C#=&""& !&-!&!<A(#&&%##6
516 12 %&"< 133/ (# A"# %%& & !& !#6 E&&&!(AA&%A&E"!(<=&!&& "&& ! 99(91: A6 /3 <!"& ! :9(::3 A6 ! "&& %#&&&%& *'#!5,'1331;5!#"<133;6
5;6 %> ' &&# (AA& %A % !# !& ! L &< 133/ ( ,&# (%%& % !# %%& !5;!#"< 133/6 !## - (# '& "" E && " #== =' (A"&% !(&!>5,'1331!(&%& *&
012201334 .:055. !(%&!%#'F-&&&'&#&#&&#("%& !%&&%!#&"&!!&E(!"&#C! & ! &D -( '& =# & 5 ,' 1331 & ;5 !#"< 133;6&&!#-!&!<A(#&&%"% A"# A!(!E(#"!""!99(91:A6/3-(AN& #!(K"&&A>6
5:6 &!1:,'1334 (#&!&!#%%& %> ! < ! #6 %#<"& E -( "%& % ! %& & !# & A! E " ! (<=& ! && "" ! 99(91: A6 /36 K%# -( ""& ! "% !"!!%&&!CD"= =&-(&'&%& *&%&.&&&-(&%#A##'&E(O=!/L "-&F%!%&&'&#&#"%#6&-&%& *(#&&%& * "'&#&#%#'#!K>"%- %#&&#"-('&"#&&=!'&'&- #&&'6%#&!-(#&&#="&!<A""&I '&M!%&&!%#'F%A '&!## E && - %&& %#'# #" #&& !N & -( ('& ! % E J& !#!& ! !"&# ! CD"=6 '# - F&>" #&& - (& % #&# &# ( '& M %&.
&&""&1334&%13316&"#-('&&&% #&##==& "-((=&%!#==='6
5L6 #%!14A#'1334 (&"#%%#-(&&&%- ! %& CD"= &< 1335 & =& ! !"!!(!"&# '"<1335 &=&-(&J&" <##A!(%&!&&&!%#'F&!(&%& *6 !## -(%> ' %% 5/ ,' 1331 -( & <##A ! %&& "& && A"& & ! &D &%'&%%#'!<A6
5/6 < %#!# E "%& % ! %& - 52'13346!&&! &&-('&#&#!< A"%&&!&D.A&#A#E& *&!%&&!(.'!&#!(&= A&%E!%&&!('&!""=& - = & - & %& * (#&& % & *6 (&"# '#-&!-&A=&&!&D%"&&&! "%! -( "%&& ! ' (# %'& ' - & !(&'&#&'!(&&6,&#-( !!& (#'&%<&#!=%>! ! -( ('& % A&6 & & -( ('& !&!#&-('&%&&!(--
012201334 .L055. 6 %& (&"# &"# - && # %# ! "J" &&#%!AA"&'"&E-&%#6
546 * <=!#E,=6
(
56 A"#"& E (&6 L/ 6 5 &6 C6 2 ! =' (=& ,! 78 < & ! )& & - ! &&& %#' E B& L/ ! A#!# %& =## ! !& ! ! / &< 1333 7 8 - & &'EA#!#B.CD"=<=&&B!"&# !B'<&#!1L,59217 86
*"%#&%,=!!B%>&#&<6
16 & &# '= 5 ,' 133; &)& "!A& ! "<!%&#=!!"!(.CD"=6& %%<(%>-&E-&!".#&#- 133L7A6 +5;3::/!65 519:!6561P + %<#! 1/' 1334 /:03/ !6 :6586 'C -& ! < A ! & !& J& K"# =! ! !%& ! ,-( ;5 !#"<1331&! !>5,'133;6"J""&A !%& ! ' ! 11 " 1331 "!A& - "!A&!( !12"133; &#'=5,&133;7 133;54L;&52L58 &%%%<6
;6 #&# A"# &"% & 1: ,' 1334 ! !# ! && ,7&6/365 8&!5L!#"<133/19,'1334%- !#&%!52!#"<5,''"&7&6;265 &:&6 86&,&#!A"&!#%#'% & '<7&6L/ 86
:6 &= %& %& ! ' & %& <& " ! (<=& ! && !"&# ! CD"= !N"& %M !& %#!!,'1331EA!#"<133;6
L6 *(&61L65 %&&!N"&&C#!'&J&& &&&%&J&K=#-(&###&&!<A&-( "&&&!&&!AA6(&6L65 %#'&-(F&& !AA-!#%% &!#%%%#"& ! (6 : & %# K ' !#&"& 6
012201334 ./055. ""&I!#!&&&&K#&&!#&"&%%%# (F&&!AA7&6:61 86
&!&6:465 *7!&!"!(<=& !&&8&4965< *7!#A&!&&!AA%'E 8 A"& #&# % % (& ! &6 1L 6 5 & L 6 && (F % !(<! ,%! #&< '& (&# '= ! &' E & ! < A 7A6 + %<#!13,'1334 9;03L !6L6;6;6186
(= % <##A ! A& -( ('& % !& K %&& AA& % % !"&& -( #&& ! < A6 A& < %&D& - <##A ! %&& & ! %< "& !( &&" "!(#==='6(&-< A && - !& ! " & K !("<# - A& - !& E (<=& ! && 7'& ! !' !( ! =8&"%&<E"%&"&!AE#==='6 'C (&## %& '- < A - (& (" A&A &&& -( '& #=> ! (<=& !( ! =7 +55153;!61 553523!6;P 133;Q19%6 1/3!6561&#A#P* *5999%6;2:86F#==='-! F&!& A"%E -%& <"& J& K=#!( %%<!!"&!&&!&-&!"J" &6,%!&(K&!(#==='- (#'&!#!#%K&K-&>&!(A"E "%7A6 +553525 !6;!P 592/%6//26!;!86
/6 *(&69/ 7'=,-(;5!#"<13318 <##A! %&& %#&&#=K&"%F&&!AK & K &&# "%#&& ! A#!#& & ! & & ="& & !"& # 76 586 & E (# 1 "% E (# =&"%-(&C!%&& !(%&#"&E & A& "%&& % (K ! !& % ! %&& &""&K-%&A!&K&% A&&!A"&%A -"!A&!' !=&"#!6
'& ! (<=& !( ! = & & ## (# &'& E !' !#& ! (&6 ;5 6 && !%& "%E(F&!& E%CK&K-%&&&'# ! ""- E ( E (= "%#&& && "!A& "%&& ! & !#&"& % (& !( %&&76586
012201334 .4055. !'!(A"(!"&&(#&!E&A&-&"%& % !& K %&&6 *& "%&& %& && A"&-&&&E(%&&!%"& -&#%,= !&>'<!("%-&CC% ! &'6 "%& !"& - ="& AK "%& & ,# D % (& ! %&& 7 + 51; 5L5 !6 5<P 599;;%615!6;<86
46 & && -( #&& ! < A && ""& ! !#%D& ! !"! =& -( & ' & %& * & %& ! && -( ""& I M %&& ! (.CD"= '& !## - %&& # E && ! && &%# %#&&#"-('&"#&&=!'&'6
%& (&"#&&%-&#&&!<A! %&CD"= "!>-(#&&%!>""&I '&-(&'%&!&&&!%#'F&& %& * "&&& ! "& && A"& & "!&D &'&"" E&&" #== ='6 (%> <A!&!&J&K"#&'"&E%#! !& - M !"&# ! CD"= ,&& E &&& & %!& " ! ,' 1331 E !#"< 133; 7A6 $. * RS&&&='*H'C=&= T599L%6:25686!& &&%#! &(&'!!"&#!CD"=&&#&& A"# % ! "%F ! 5/ ,' 1331 -( & ' %& ! &&& ! %#'F !( "&& ! L:2(9/5 A6 & & " %& * ! 1(3/3 A6 !> 5 ,' 13316 &A ( % "&# %&& & ! &D " -( && &""& -& @ %#! ! &D !-# &!&D7"8 'H.'G<8!"!#&C#& *! %&&!(.'!&#!(&=UG
(&6 52 6 : %#'& - %&& ! ' ! %#'F %A&!#!&!%&&'#'&!(&6461&6 < 6(&6;1 !#A&-(A&&!%%&&!' E%!!#&!&&!%&6#- A& % ! !& - %& ! %#'F &C# % & &"< % ! && !%&6 !"& (!"& "J" K%#"& &&-&%& *(&%& * "%&&! ' ! %#'F %A6 % ,%! %# - %%#!&%%&!"&&!&7A6* *1331%6 :9/ !6 ;< & #A#8 ! (& ! %&& ! %#'F ' '& (O= ! && &&& #= (& < ("%F
012201334 .2055. (&&&!%#'F-'!%&&%#&!A" % K"% !(&.%&,-(E(O=!& *!('"& %&7A6 + %<#!52"133L 9403; !6;6;6586
&!-%#>!-&"!=E !& %> !K (K& ! %&& M ! %& ! &&& ! %#'F6=#A"&K%&!-&A=&&! &D & # ! A" -( "% ! ,' 1331 E !#"< 133; ' &C# -- & * ! %&& !( & =6 "%&%- &! A" &#&# "%%%!>-((&#&#!(%>!&!#% &-&=#& %=& -A"& !#%!&E# #&& &"!!#E (!"&& (K& ! '"& ! %&& ! %#'F %A!&!#.!!(!"&6
26 F!(K" =&!& &A&%'! (&&& -( %'& <"& K= ! "%& & ! &6
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
% &&-.!&=&!#& E'%#&! =&!A&F&%#-&!"&>!A! ! %#'F & %'& % !# - %&& ! %#'F %A '& #&# %#'# #" &
012201334 .9055. %#&& !N6 AA& !'& ' - %&& &&& "&A&!#" "&'#% && -( & E && " A# E ! L3 V % ! && %F#%("%F6 !"& &(#&&#"&&'#! & (& % "%#C< -( 133: & "&# !"!!%&&'&C#&&%&&%&!&&& ! %#'F -( % E & !( %%& ! &' !> 5 ,' 13316#- ,&A&-(!E(&%%< &!#"& & -((%%J&#(&&&-(#&&!&!(&&! !%&%"%&"!&D6
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
&"&E-&&& #==%&"&J& -A# ! #=> ! " I '# !( "> A=& <=& !( ! C="& & -( =& !' &
012201334 .53055. "!&D&(%A&%'!"""!(&&&- (&!&!(&&!!(.!&!<-&'&!=& !#& %&& C<&# K A"&# !"&&' & K & ! %#'F%A7A6 +55354/!6;&! 592L%6/9& 4386
96 "%&&!-%#>! ,% %#! &=&&7&6/5&6 86
012201334 .55055.
! 2( 1 ( !( ! !
3,
56 #'<6
3
16 ,&&6
;6 &-%#!&=&&6
:6 A" %& ! -B %'& A" & %#& J& ! !# ! ;3 , !> &A& %> ! < A#!# 7*CWHCA-/ /33: 8 %'!"&>!!& %< A"#"&K&621!A#!# <A#!#!54 , 133L 7 +8P "#" ! !& !- "&A & "F!%'&%&=&!&!"!&P!& J& !# < A#!# % ' %& % ' #&- K !& ! (&6 :1 +6 %#& J& & %> % ! & '-#"""F!%' !'&J&,&E('6 =AA> %#!& *F' X ? #&.,&@ C%% $
% A" ! %#& J& & &A# K %& -B *#&& !(&&E(#"%=AA
012201334