Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/924/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/924/2007 Generato dall'IA

Product Liability Appeals: Design Defect, Causation, and Evidentiary Standards

Numero d'incarto ATAS/924/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court reviewed several appeals concerning liability for injuries stemming from product design or manufacturing defects, with the core issue being whether evidence supported the jury's findings of defect and causation, often involving complex technical specifications, industry standards, and expert testimony regarding alternative designs or warnings. The court affirmed judgments where the evidence supported that the product was unreasonably dangerous due to a defect or inadequate warnings, or reversed where the record lacked sufficient evidence to sustain the verdict against the defendant on grounds such as preemption, lack of expert foundation, or failure to establish a feasible alternative design.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Product Liability Appeals: Design Defect, Causation, and Evidentiary Standards: The court affirmed judgments where the evidence supported that the product was unreasonably dangerous due to a defect or inadequate warnings, or reversed where the record lacked sufficient evidence to sustain the verdict against the defendant on grounds such as preemption, lack of expert foundation, or failure to establish a feasible alternative design.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
responsabilità per danno da prodotti motivi probatori motivo di revisione difetto riconoscibile elenco degli obblighi causalità dell'infortunio

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for the allocation of judicial costs for the federal court proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

           '(()*')++, "'-).')++/

"

 " "#    # 

01 2 ! )- 3 )++/ 



 !" # $!%& & '"&  !("&  )& * +,&





&

--     (  #      &!" ./0 

           ! "# $%  &! !

   #3147#  

 $"

48 "4/9/:&%!;< %&&  (#' &"% !  "%"!4//78

38   #<&(,=& (>%&%8   .: !"  ?@"&,!&A%&@B8%%& C <"'4//9# D&: !,DA:!!&!,# &DEDA8%&" &' ("& %< !F8&'&" %&"%"&%&" &' 455G8

28  " < & 47'4//9 (<<& (# ' &" ?#%;H  B & " % "  43 %&!, 4//9   !! &   *#  !%"&&   !&; =:( 24 =&35528 #'& &<<%!I' ! " %&&%<8

78 ("&!E,'&%< & (&"D& %< ? B8  %%&    42 <"' 4//0 &< E && ,'&&E%&" &'!! #&&.E!#&!%8 &'" %%&:("<&%' (,' (DD!&&  ,& & &&  &D8   %%&  2 <"' 4//0   !"   %%&:&>"E    & !&" : (" << ( %&A 7#9#*4 : (!%JA ,!& ('&'&"%A.: 8*<&D,&" #!, !&"D!&  "&&'&"E95G%&J&%%"8(. % !&A"%&:%&, (!""&&D, &"8

98   %%"& !"   9 ! 4//0    !"    (   : :( & %,, : &&  %&  & % :!& E !&&   !%&  &, '&", & :( >& '!,,!&  ""!&  %.&& <<& & (D & E AA   <<&"#&8

68 %;  ' <  & (   ;  " & &  !#& (' &"E("% " 37'!,4//C'<<& 4&,4//78

08  35 %&!, 3554    %"&  !"  & & ! A!&!&&&:("&& %&&(& "&""8 !"  &! ;  :( <& %"  E  "'   8  &<& & &!E( :&%" "' &8



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

/8   %%&  36 '!, 3554    %.A& D&: &!!&  "%  "%< !.8  ;' :  %&& & && %"&  <&D !%&&  &,  !! ' "' %"  A"    "  "'& &  &!& %.A!&8

458  & 39'!,&44 "!,3553("<&(,=& (>%& !& %% & (,'&!"  (#' &"?# %; H  B8  >%& %&  D&  . ! > %&&&, "%<"&"% &!.& % .&A !, %&A8"!&&&"D!& D&< &   %&"  &'  "%A"  & % ".&A"!&>



1223413556  #7147#   &!  . !  & % ,&" & && %; A"%&&  &  D"8  (>! :  ("'&  >! %:  %!&&&  &  %"  &, A!&D: D: &A%" :  (& & %&, (>%:  %&  (" &!!& (!%   &&" &   "%8    && "% D& &,!&<! >&%"8>%& &&  DD'&  ("&&  &" '  >&   .!%&!&D & &%"=& . !!&<! >  : (%%&  &, &A.!:8 ( %&  ' !&:(.%&" &'8  >%&&!&<: %&" &' (>%&"&&"&'!&&,&("'&  &'&" %&"E95G8

448  24 &, 3552 (  !!: E (" :(  >!"  D" (' &"&&&":((%AD"%& (< &E&8

438  3!3557("%(&!"   :E (  :( ,&  %&  D ( ! 65 G8  !  ;   ">! 8 D%&:>%&    "&&(&DD'"8

428 %%& 42&,3557&<E&&#%A&!D: *' (%A&!D @"&,!&A%&@<88+&    !&& : (" %"&  &"&   %%& ! " &; %,,!& E  && ,#% %&"8A!%'(&&&!&!""8(.% (&&&&>: !%&(D ('%&AAL &.%:8

478  33 "!,35578<8+ <&"&& :%&&%"&"D;&&%&"& "'%%"    "  "<&  A!% '  %D &'!& !%&&8 !%&& & %".&A"!&>&  %&   "   !, ', :( % (D ( '%&A AL  !!   '& &'!& :!&   % ".&A"!&>8  %< ;' "D!& :  <! %: .L  %'& &"'' <!%.&"!:&:(%& J&>:&&(8<8+!&< :  %,&" ( &&& &>:  &#!:  .&A;  "&" "':"8

498 "%E"% 33'3559:(! &  ,  % ".&A"!&> &"8 (>! A&D: &  ,% & "D&<  : !&  &  D&   % !" 8 ;   D& (" "  "&" &8 &  &&&   &&



1223413556  #9147#   !  !&D:    ( % &'"   &&"& (,'& ( &&& "&8 *    (&&& " &D"8& ;%%,,:!%&J& "%8

468  0=35598M&8<!& ::&A&D&DD&' (%&! 8   :& : %     %&AD & &  DD&'%%8 &E(&&&&!%&,' '%&A AL 8  %&&  %"& %  &; %  % .&"!:8

408   %%&  25 N& 3559    !& &  D& "':" %"" !!&  &, !&  A.%&%A %&&:'%&&&8  D&(% &% "% %&"  &'8 *  !"   (>& &!&  D!&  <' ( D& %".&A"!&>.&"!:!J!&&A.%&A;  %& % J& >8  %&& & E J& "&&!& ' %  %A&!D & !&D8 *  % %.A&:  "&& & &" &&8:(<<&D:&,!&& &=%"& "%& &&!&8&&&A!&D:&%%, E>&&!!& (>%&  8

4C8  32'!,3559("D&!!&E( :( !!"  %&& &' E  (' 3 A % = %    C55<8%!D&#"&&"O8

4/8  " 42<"'3556( < (D!&&' &"8

358 40!3556("<!%%&E&& "8;':"&&  &" (& DD'" !J!   %%&    &  <F % >%, E  %&"  &' &" &'!& &,8  "%;& :  !% D,&&E%& D 69G!!!8&& !%& (,&&!& (!49G%'&E&> (' &" 05G8

348  9 =& 3556    %A&!D !&  "D "&"!& A!%'&;<&&8

338  "%%& 43=&3556( =&&#8 <&  <      %%&    & && :( ! <&(&% &(D"!: %4//C8

328  &  42 %&!, 3556 (" & & && " % (&!"    8  & E  & & E (& ( &



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

378  25 &, 3556  & !%;&    %&&   8  ;D :( '& J& %"" %A!&  > !   (&%8D&:("AD%A ("%DA <<&"  / &, 3556 &  &!&  %%&  !  "'   & &8*%%&(>! D:& !& !8 &<  & A!D""&"  ("A&&   ! # "%>%&J& ""!!& & (& &8% &% D!&&&"8

398   ' !"   42 '!, 3556     *' !" "D *! ?#%;H*B "&!8  ;' : ("AD%A  / &, 3556 ( % !  "'   %&AD &,8 &  "&"!&  A!% '  !"  ;' :(&&&'&%%!!&!%&,' & ('"A (%A&!D8&&&J& !:&%&% &'% 8(' !" #&&&&& ! <%&,!&%&" &' 95G&%"" !!&8

368 %"' 49'!,3556(&!"&E     "%%&&, !&=& 8<&' : !#& (' &"'&"&" ":!&, %%& (,'& %<    42 <"' 4//08 : " % &   %%&     %!  %  D&  &,



1223413556  #0147#   !&<! >8*%%&(.%&" &'  % A!&D:8   (&!"  &; =% &  &  (%; % !% % )& > &, !&<! >  &;' & 8

308  "%:  9 <"' 3550  & %&     %&%(&D!&&&"8

3C8 (&!"!&&"D!&% 46<"'35508

3/8  32!3550&&& % ,  "8  ": A!%'(&"&" %!%! %(>%&   & :  '> >! & %A!& <<&"8   &'&" ( !"<&&&%,%&'!> "%& != &,:"& %,;!  DA:(('%E% E"& &&!&8 '"D!&J&%"" ' &% DA&"'&!&E &8 &'<%%<":!!&&J& <&&!%E A!%'" &8 %,;! & "D!& &  &J& % '&8   <<    > '8 (=&& %,;! E("% &, "%<  %,;!  'A :(,D&E%  !" !&  %!  &:  %&&: % 2  &  %8  < +%F%&&%,;!'& %,;! !&D:8&;'&:(!,% &' & :( <& && %  D 8 * !%. &  %& % & D!&  &> (&'&"8   AA"  &'  % %&&  '8    %,;! %A.:   & "D!& "%!" & D" & &  &&!&!" !&>:( "8

258  39!3550 , "( <8+ < )&'%%& 40%&!,3552   &% %&;!&   "'& & & (&&& !&D: &  %,;!A!&D:8 ! "D!&E:!" >%& = %&J&<"8"% 4=3550<8+ !!  <;!!>%&8

248 34=3550&&!& , "%  C = 3550  <8 +    !'  :  %!&&(&&& !" &&&<&:%%&&"'> "& & %  & &&!&  "<'  (, &" : &  !& "&" ! "D!& ( !;& "D8 * %&&    :" ' ,  %" A.%&' & &"  D  %!8"D!&D":('&.!"& &&" & >,8



1223413556  #C147#  

238 *"&"D "E=D8



 #"

48 <!"!& E (&8 96 8 4 &8  A8 3    D'  (D& =  ?B  , &    )&  & : &&&%"'EQ&896 <" "%&D""  &  6&,3555? B:&&'E <" "Q#' &" 4/=4/9/? B8

38 B &&"'D4='3552&)&! <&  !, %& "D   !   8 *  %!&"%& ': &(%%: &J&&A"E!; %%:;D%%,&'D!!&P <&= :!& "&!&&% &? -425325 8484 229 848343/7 8483430760 84436426 87,& "<"B8

,BQ%;%"& &>%&& ;<"'35548 <& "&!&("&&""%&'&&%;Q&"'D      & E  & & J& >!"  D   ( & %  %"  =:( 24 "!, 3553 &  <&   ' "D!&& "D%;&& &? -425779&"<"R<8 -42523/B8 &<! <&"D&  &&&;D D""'<!"  =% &'>& % & '& (&"  'D    R  ( "  ! <&  %&  '   &  & :  =%  "'%%"E%%%&J&%&%%:"? -425279 82B8 & > ;D  %"   (%%:& < %& && &E& ;(&"'D  ? -424 247 8282440/2 86,443265 87R  4//CM20%8 246 82,B8

28 &=&"  "&<!%&%&',?&896  B8

78 & &D  (  :&  '   %&"  &'  && !" 65G!'& &E%:( !#&   ( &&& E  &" ' &     8  '& "D!&  "&!   <& '> & "&" "'& %!&&&  %%"&= : <<"& 8



1223413556  #/147#  

98 * (&8 74   ? 'D =:( 24 "!, 3553B  (' &" ( ,""< &! < !;E< &E&# &%('D!&"" &%%!"8 &AD!&!%&&  &%%E< D" (' &"  &E&%& E"' #8%& '&AD!&(& % & &J&&A"!%&<&&:(%"&&!!&  "& &&&"D&E("%:  " &D? -43926/ 83&"<"R'"D!& -443203  83,&2/5 84,B8

:& "' & ! <& &> (' &"& "D" ;4='3552%(&840 :% %(& &  %&8

68 '& Q&83C84 Q" &E&&;Q&' E 66312G!E !#&Q&' E95G!E:& &Q&' E75G!8%4='3557?7;!"'  B&> Q' &":%%&& 05G! &> 65G!'& &E&#:& &8

08 *Q&87 Q' &"& !& %&" D%"!" %!&   D " : "& Q &&& E  &" %A.:  !& %'& Q <!&" D"& Q !   Q  &8 Q&&& E  &" Q&  % E   "&!& &   %   "& :   ! P  &)  %&"  &' .&  <<&   %&"  D  Q" ?$# *  D&K S, ' 'ADTA4//0%8CB8

'& =% & Q' &"  &   &  & "!: &  !" R  &  ": "!:,=&' Q%&"<&:Q!%& Q"'? - 445  309  8 7 459  350  8 3B8 :Q   Q&'&"  Q"  " "!: <& "<&  .     <    " Q !"  !P%!&&& Q"'%&"  &'  Q&""   &'&" ,!& >D, ? - 449  422 8345949C 84B8

& (' &"& (%&" D&: "<      & & % = (A %  &8 6 E C    ! <&&8

C8   (>& &,!&<! >%&& %% (,   %" ( D& "!& ( >%& ?%.A&B & (%%.& D &   &; ( .&;!  <&  ? - 4252/C 8982& 86B8 !!%&&&&&&E



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

*  !&& " E (> ( &'&" "&& ( >D"&  .!%&U!  ( && !,,    ;D   E (, (&&&E&"'& &E %&& (8  !, &&'D"<D&  &  "& &  !%&!& ,'" ("D& (&  &  &"&: !& 'D (,  !     D  'D &  <!& < %  %&& &  &&  (!;<&: %&&; "!&&'&,(>%&  : ("D&    A % !D"  '!& %.A &&?'(!, =& -4247/&"<"&"B8

  (D&  &, "%<  .   (,' :   & !"  ?<8 &!!&  11* +  V+D8W && M<X& %.AA *&YD  #45 M%&  V-W 7;! " &%84/4B:(%% - "&& "%<&&& %% %  !, &" %.A&: D' & , E  &, !&<! >   ! P   &  ;D D"" :( !<&&"&' '&%<(,=& ( D&"%"? -425 296 828284<&"<"&"B8



1223413556  #44147#   /8 &&!!&<&(,=& (>%&!& %E<  ("3553%  8 %%&&&%!%& "&"!&  A!%' &:("&"&&":%&8

 , "(&%":& '%%&    '& J& ""!!!%& <&:((>!%"'&& &% D&:"& A!&!8<<&&<! %& !=&" !%D"   ! &&&8 % &<!%D' %&%% %,  & !<&&8  (D&  % ".&A"!&> .&"!: ?*B8  E ("&  %%<     & %% :  D&  "&" "&"&:%".&A"!&>&! "&"&:!,% (!%D  A!&!!!&  0= 3559 M&: %%& 25N&3559   8    & J& %A" E (>%&      % ' %%<   :&   & (<<& !&D: &   (%%!&8

&<.  ":&&>%&&&:("&&  &"  & (& !& DD'" % < 3553 &  (>%& &!!& %,;!8 , "&! : && >%& (& = (A % (&&"8  ' & "D!&  ">!   & %"&   % !&  &, !&<! >' !&%<<&!&:A: & ,=&', !J!  #  '& % D  E    %&" &'8<%%& "A"&E(&!" %  &E %!&' A %!&% &8

 , "=D" !&&&E' >%& !& % : ' "D!& >%  &&&  &  "%   %&"  &'8    % ":& '."E(&!"%!I' && (&&8

458 (&!" !   <!&  %=  <& ' :  &; =% & % &  ' &"       & % !% !P%%&:(%&" &'&"&'>&, !&<! >8 % & !! '" # 8 (&&  (&%!%;& &:&&:&&%"!&"8

 && "&&     ! P  &"  &  (& % !"" !!  "&  %%&     " &  %& J& ! <" : %  "' %"     (&8 92 8 4    "'& (<&!. %''& (  ' D& %" %     &, !&<!



1223413556  #43147#   >8  "& &&<   !"  &!!&  %%&  39 &, 3554    :  D& ( "&" & : & E (D!&&   .!%&!&D  & << ; 4/// & "&'!&E! <& ("&& &"84//0  !" #    &!" : (%&"  &' "&& =&<"% !&:8J!(&%('    (D& !& ( %%"& <<"& &  % ( <& '8  &&  <<& %  %' &    (&8 92 8 4    %%&   >%& !"  &  ' %%"&  <& ?<8 -43029C 89,445474 833/2 8345C 404 84B8&E'"D!&: '& "=E%%" (>& (""!&  %.&&  ,&& D:   ' !"   9 ! 4//0  & :(     " : (&!"  %  " 37'!,4//C&& 8

448 &D<&<("&,!& %& D%(&!"'&  ':(&&!%&!& !   "&  " & ;  :  "&!&   %&  D !& E 4//C & E :  !#&  "&" &."8    =%     ( &  ("   =D  %'& >D : ( !&&  ; "? -44043 83&"<"B8(>&%  & E   "& : (" %& "   =&8 % & : ( !&& &  !&;   !    "& & >!    & (  "& & !% '&  &&  < %' " <#&%&, (J&&&:"%  ' ( R  &U = &   %"    ,":&!&%& ' & ( "& ?>&&  !<&   " & & !%& &,   &<&B&"? -44042 8344663B8(& &   (AD"E&"D ? - %," 6='3556994157  8783R'&!!&M* *#M!!&TA3552&33  &892R--4//439CB8

(  &&:(&!"(&%&"!&;  "&     %&  D <<&"  !!&   " & 37'!,4//C8!!'"# (>&%  &E "&8

438  ,  " ;' < :( & ,  &  !  (&  %&& !%"!& ( %%& :( (& %  !  !&&'%&""  &'%  &(# ' &"%&&!%&8<<&(. %  "&E &&  ' "&!& %     %&&  ' A.%&A"&: (&'&"&' (' %&:(&"&,:#



1223413556  #42147#    & ;&!&  ! (>  & &'&"8  & & %"!"!&&%"!%&%&J&'"? -449CC 83B8 &;>D, (> (&'&"&' &J&>!"<& &!!&  (ZD   %  "&&  &"   D&:  <!& %< (&'&" >" =:(  !A" (!%&"A"& &!%%!D% &: "&""D" '%<? -4403/5 82R*3554%843C  8 4,R  8 3  (J& 8  / <"' 3559  75152 "!"    6513559%8430R'"D!& -  6<"'35567/157B8

428  ' :%"; %&!& ! " &&  " &   '." E (&!" %  !  I' ( >%&!& %&' "8

478 &,&&%&!&D  !&" 4(955<8& &."E&&  "%8

498 ("!!& 355<8&!EAD (&!":!,%%& (&86/84, :&&"'D4=&35568





1223413556  #47147#  

  #"$  " "#    # 

!

 4 50

48 "',

! 5

38 ( !&%&!&8

28  " 42<"'&43=&3556 (&!"8

78  '   %  !  I' ( >%& !& % & ' "8

98   !  '!& (  !&"  4(955 <8  & E &&  "%8

68 &"!!& 355<8EAD (&!"8

08 <!  %&   :Q %'& <!  &  %"& J&   "  25 = ;  &<& %;  , <" " ?*A[KA<:66557  B%' !&;  & %,<!"!&>&8C3 <" " ,<" " 40 = 3559 ? -BR  !"!   &  :   !&< & !. %'&%&D& & ! &R & J&  "  , <" " % ' %&  % ' "&: >  &  (&8 73  -8  %"& J& &  %;  %  &':"!!!. %' '&J&=&E('8  D<<;  %" &          +  * .       

%<! %"&J&&&<">%&:QEQ<<<" " %D<<



1223413556