Settlement Agreement Enforcement Barred by Parol Evidence Rule
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought to enforce a settlement agreement that contained an integration clause stating it was the entire agreement, yet evidence suggested the opposing party did not fully comply with a non-monetary obligation because of a prior, unwritten understanding that contradicted the written terms. The court ruled that the parol evidence rule barred the admission of extrinsic evidence to vary or contradict the clear terms of the written settlement agreement, finding that the integration clause prevented consideration of the prior, unwritten understanding, even if the non-monetary breach might otherwise suggest its existence, thus affirming the written agreement as the controlling document.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Settlement Agreement Enforcement Barred by Parol Evidence Rule: The court ruled that the parol evidence rule barred the admission of extrinsic evidence to vary or contradict the clear terms of the written settlement agreement, finding that the integration clause prevented consideration of the prior, unwritten understanding, even if the non-monetary breach might otherwise suggest its existence, thus affirming the written agreement as the controlling document.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
%&'()%*))+ "%,*%*))-
."
"/ #/" / /# #
( 01 *))-
'2 #3
45555555555$
! 65555555555
77# #/" / 8/#/9" " # $% &' (()!
! "#! $ * +,--*
/ 7"
-1 23333333333 ! -$4+ ! & " 53333333333 6(* & 7 533333333338 ( " 9 :(;( " (1
+1 ( -$%. ( '( <(! " : ")(((= >'( " ; " '( ")( :( " ( " &'1
01 +0 : +//+ ( ((! " 9==( ;'( " 9*('("(! 6(* & 7 8 ( ?; "9 !( " " 9@( "( 6' )( "9 () 8 :( + : +//+ ==( " ( !( ( " ( A B1 =)( " ")" ( ("(<( < 53333333333 '( =! " " ?; =( "! " "( !(1
C1 > " 9 ?); ( " 3333333333 " -D '): +//+ "( ('( )( "9)!( 9(! '( " 9@( "( " 0,-/ 6' ( (<8 E -/,-/ ' ( " 9( ;? ! " $,-/ (1 (( ("(<( <9' !( ?) '( 9!( ( !!( ( !! <9( 9F(( "9 )"( ( < 1 ( (' )!"() ( " ( '( +//+ '( ! "()(( !;(& ;(' ('(" " 9(! '( " 9@( "( ! ( (! " '( " 4/G " +$ ): D : +//+ 6 !( < "( F) ' 9('( '( ( +C ): !!"81 =( ( " 9('(! =( F! 9(!! 6A B8 ( !( !( "( " "( "9 '(( :(( F1
41 " -C =!'( +//0 " 3333333333 )!"(* ( " 9 ()! <9 "! ( "9 ;H (: " '( " : (! " 9@( "( 9) H?( 9!
"9F ('(! ! "! < '(( " 9@( ;? !( E =( )1
.1 "!(( " +. =!'( +//0 9==( =! " " ?; =( " 9 !( )(= < 9('(! =( "
,-.%/,+//0 * 0,--*
9! !(( ' :(( < )H) !! 9( :! 9F( " ('(!1
%1 ( " +4 ) +//0 53333333333 =)! (( E "( "!((1 !;! < ! ((( ! "9"( ( ? I < 9 ?); ( 9(!! :(( "()(( !;(& ;(' ('(" " 9(! '( " 9( "(1
D1 ) !)( " -. )( +//0 " 3333333333 !(! < 9((( "9 "( !(( '(( !! (< "9 < 9! !( 1
$1 " +0 I( +//0 9 ")"! E ( 23333333333 9( ?(( " " " 9 (( =)! 533333333331 9(!! 9 "! ( E ('((1
-/1 "!(( " 4 J +//0 9 I! "( (( )(= ( < 9! 9'( ! !"( ('(! (' " ) () ' !( ' < "(& 9'( < " =(: ! ( (! " '( " ;(1 9((( <("( " 9"( !(( '(( :(( '( H F! )# "9 @( "! "9 (!
'( )1
--1 ! D ): +//0 53333333333 (( (: " ( 6(* & 7 (:8 E 9( " "!(( ( :("(() '( " (( ) !)(1 : '! < 9( (! " '( " 4/G !! 9(!! "& +$ ): +//+ !( (' << I E ( ' 9 !( " + : +//+1 '( =( " ) K 9 ?); ( '( ! "()(( ;(' " 9(! '( " 9! '( A B < "( !( "!IE '! " '( " ( ( )( '( ( )( < ) # 9 !( ))"! 9'( ==! ))!) E "9 L? M 9 9'( ==! "9<H ( " '( !(" (1 !;" 53333333333 ('<!
H " (: =!"! " ( 6 N 8 " +C I( +//0 6 +$,/+8 < ( '( (( =( " "!)( (
,-.%/,+//0 * C,--*
'(( :(( !( !( =( " !" E (( "!(! " "(==! ('(! F! 9! " '(1
-+1 ( " (( " + : +//0 9 I " E =()( " "!(( (( " 4 J +//01 '# E ;)( !( ( ( (;! < 9('( ((;( 9'( " ! ( : (! " ;( " 9! (*( 9'( !! 9 & <9 ( (! " '( " << I ( " +$ ): D : +//+1
-01 -0 : +//0 (: )( E 9! F =( " "!)(( " 53333333333 " D ): +//0 ! " 9 " + : +//01
-C1 " +% : +//0 9(!! "!! A B " 53333333333 ( ( E " ( !"1
-41 ( " +% '): +//0 53333333333 (! " ) ( " 1
-.1 9('(( " (: " ! 9) # "9 ( 23333333333 ("(<! < " : " "9! ;H :( 9(!!
" ('(! =( '( ): +//+ (( " ; " '( ( '( =( E ")" "( ' ! (( < " '((( E 9!1 !;) !(! <9 + % : +//+ : '( :( ( (! " '( E -//G )!"() ! ' ( D : +//+ 6 " ( " &' " -$ '): +//C81
! !(! ( " "( " ('(!
=( "9 '(( !! (< )!"( ( 9 !;(1
-%1 " " 0/ '): +//C (: ! ( 23333333333 61 %- " ( !" ")(((' " -+ ): -$D48 ( "! =! " "!)( (& ) !)( " "(1
,-.%/,+//0 * 4,--*
-D1 " . "!): +//C (*( ("(<! (: <9( ?(( " (( ((; !=! A B1
-$1 "!)(( " D "!): +//C 53333333333 < 9! '( !! '! " '( ' !( " + : +//+ ! "! < " ( " -$ '): +//C 6 O -.8 ( " &' '( ! <9 ( 23333333333 '( :( " ;H " ('(! =( < ;H '( ) H !!1 53333333333 9 !=!! E ! (( P -DC " 9==( =!"! " ( 6(* & 7 N >8 " 0- : +//0 < ( =( "!)( Q " ?< * (( !: " "(==! ('(! F! 9! " '( * !(! "9 '(( :(( =( A B1
+/1 :'( " -0 "!): +//C 0 I'( +//4 9 (! " ( " ' : <9 ( 23333333333 '( !! ) " !' (! " '( " ;( 9 &1
+-1 > <( !! ;"! E I;1
/ "
-1 ( ;'( 9;(( I"((( 68 !! )"(=(! ((! "& - J +//0 (: " ( ) ! " 4 I; " !(" '(* !(" 4 ! -. I; 61 - 1 4. 81
>( E 9( " 9!( " -. I; (: =!"! +% I'( +//C 6 N -0/ -/.8 " ( ;'( " ! -0 =!'( "( (( (( ; ) (: " ( " (!; E ( I; (( " 9 " 9!( " 'F I; 1
> ) ! I; " "9 & (( !:(1
,-.%/,+//0 * .,--*
+1 ! '(; - I'( +//0 Q! )"(=(( " ): "( (( " ")( " R*('("(!1 )!( =( !;(( (: " ?;) " &; " "( ") <( !( '(; " !(( " R! " =( <( "( H !(! I("(<) <( " !< I("(< 6=1 N -+% C.% ("1 - -+. -0. ("1 C: !=!81
9('( )!"( ((;( " + : +//+ # !! ==! ' R! '(; " !;(! " "!(( (( " 4 J +//0 "( H F)(! ;" " R( "( '(; I<R 0- "!): +//+1
01- '? R: " "( (( (( ( ' &; " !" "(' H (<! "& ! '(; 6 N -+$ --4 ("1 +1+ --% $0 ("1 .: --+ 0./ ("1 C81 R & "( (( " !" " " ( !( ! '(; - I'( +//0 (:1
01+ > R1 - 1 - "( (( " (: E R 61 - E %/8 E )( < ( R# "!; F !)1 F ) " R1 C$ 1 C 9 <( " "!(( ? 9:(;( "9 "9 " ( " ( ))(< F) (1 "( " )H) '( " "( < 9!1 "!(( ' H <! " I '( "R (( & " R <( " 61 4+ 1 - 8 "!(( (( ' =( R:I "R "' (: " ) ! 61 4. 1 - ( ' 1 4% 1 - 4D 1 - 81
010 I! ) ( & " 9(! ) ! " =) ( "() ?! " (!H I("(<) !;! "!(( <! ! (( ':1
C1- =)!) E R1 D 1 - ! ('(" )! "R ('("(! ())( "( F ) " !" ( <( !( " E !:( (! " ;( E R)!( E ';" E ='( R; "( ! "!)(! =( "
,-.%/,+//0 * %,--*
"! "R('(! ::1 > I( " R('("(! R ())( < <R( (: " !'( <R '(" " '( !(;! 7 "(( R ) ( " K ' " R( (! " ;( Q (!: )( K )) " ' ") (( 6 N -+C +.$ ("1 C !=!M > +/// 1 0// ("1 CM -$D/ 1 +4+M
2 S -$D/ 1 +%/81
C1+ > R1 -+ 1 - ! "( F ) )!"( <( R :I () " R==( )) )( "() !( E !" ( =( "9 " E )!( " =T ": () (! " ;( E !' "R "()(( : "9 1 &; ;!! " () " R==( )) ;!( R)!(( "R ?!)& ?;(< :(1 R*('("(!
" ?; (( < ) )!"( <( '( "() E !()( E (; " ! "!=F : " )( (') : " " =( ( ) ) " !'( & ": () " R1 -+ 1 - 6 N -+/ +%$ ("1 0 !=!81 F ) " R1 + 1 - ("!! )) ) )!"( " R1 -+ )) ?(;(F ?#(?! (< #??! (< <( '( E () E ! !< "R (=()(! ;!( "R )"( "R (" * !(! "()(( " ):((! " " =! ( " (:((! " * )!( " =T ": () (! " ;( !' "R "()(( :1 ) "(' H ("!! )) ("(<! " R! " ( )!"( ) " !" R! "R )(& () "!<1
C10 > I( " " N () !( " '( ;!( "R ?;(< :( )( : "R!()( R:( " (( "' < " (( ==( <( ( <( <R( ( :((! !) )( "R )(& (' 6 N -/4 -4/ ("1 0 -/0 -0 ("1 0 H (!M > +/// 1 0/- ("1 +: 1 0/4 ("1 +81
41- R & R ()! < R('( ((;( (( ) )!"( " !" ( "& < R==( ' "
,-.%/,+//0 * D,--*
& (! R'( Q! " "()(( : " (!
" ;( " R!1
41+ ( " ' 53333333333 =( '( <R' R !( ((;( ! !( )! "R ('("(! ) " < 9 ?); ( '( ! "& '( +//+ "()(( !;(& ;(' ('(" " 9(! '( " 9@( "( # Q! ( (! " '( " 4/G " +$ ): D : +//+ M ( ( )( " (:) < 9! !( "!IE '! " '( " ( ( )( '( ( )( < 9) # 9 !( ))"! 9'( ==! ))!) E "9 L?1 R(! '( !(" " $,-/ 9( ;? 9( )( E 9(!! " (' RF( " )!( "9) #! " : < <( '(( :(( L? () (< ((( ;! " 9"(1
410 R ! < R !( " E R( "( !( ("(<! <R R "!! ' &1 ( '():: U )H) ( 9 ?); ( 9 ! ( (! !' " ( E 9" E ?"( 9 & 6=1 N " +C I( +//0 +$,/+ ("1 %1+1+8 * < 9! :( ;H " ('(!
=( ( " ==( 9) # # "J !" E <H " : E " )!;) " "(( " '( 6=( "9 )( E ! " '((( E 9!81 =( !!) ==( <(=( 9('( ((;( " ) )!"( " !" ( " R1 -+ 1 J*( = <R =J " E )!( " =T ": : (! " ;( " 9! E !' "R "()(( : <( R R &1 == ' R !( " E R( "( 9(!! "( ( "R (!
'( " 0,-/ E "( " $,-/ E ;?1 E 9F ( " ( I # ())!"() !!"! 9 !( " + : +//+ 6 "(F I )) !;! " !( " 53333333333 " +% '): +//08 9! R :( ( (! " '( ( " ==( E 9@( "( ' 9 !( 1 =( ( !! (! '( R !'! E "( E -/,-/ ' ( (< E ;? E $,-/ (1
,-.%/,+//0 * $,--*
& ( '( " ( !:( <R )) K ( :!!=((! " ) )!"( ((;( 9! R!( '! " RF( " ('(! (' * E )( " ) E Q "()(( " (! " ;( <( ( : " R1 -+ 1 - * ( )H) )! " RH " '( !(;!1 ( )) "!)( R!(*( ( ('(" ( )H) )! "R ('("(!
())( )) RF(; R1 D 1 - '( "( E " ) )!"( " !" (1 9( R(!! ( E -//G ('(! (F I E ( & !( " + : +//+ * '( '! (! " 4/ G " 9(' 6 " " 3333333333 " -D '): +//+ O 81 ( 9 ( !;! ( )H) " '():: !(" "R( (! " '( ! ( :'! < )!"( ( 9 !
!!() !( " ?) '( ( ! "9 )"( ( < 1 =( < 9 ?); ( !
"()(( !;(& ;(' ('(" " 9(! '( " 9@( "( " ( 9 Q (( "!)( "9 )( < ==( <( "!' ;(') ( E 9! ) ==( 9" E ?"( 6> +/// 1 0/0 ("1 0:81 F :" < "( ( !!) "( 9 (( !)( )!"(*( " 9 < 9((( "9 "( !(( '(( !! (< 6=1 ) !)( " " 3333333333 " -. )( +//08 < !() ' '(( :(( 6=1 V -$D4 0 1 +.0 ("1 0:81
.1 "! ")) " !;(! (( P -DC " 9N > " 0- : +//0 6 !( ") E 9 !( " + : +//+ (') E "!(( (( " 9 " 4 J +//08 9 "9 E 1 == ( "( "!)( ==( "9(( ' !(! "9 '(( :(( =( "( F !) < A B1 )) '( " '( 6O 4108 "(( "9 "()(( : ": " (! " ;( " 9! 9 !(! 9 &1
%1 ( = " < R('( ((;( " E R( "( R & "R ) )!"( "
,-.%/,+//0 * -/,--*
!" ( " R*('("(! " < R !( "( "R = ( ?; 6) 1 N " % I( +//C ./D,/0
- )( +//0 ..0,/+81
( " <( !&" < ) ="!1
,-.%/,+//0 * --,--*
: # "7 "/ #/" / /# #
; 0 < =$ &'*
0
-1 ! ': M
0
-1 I M
+1 ( < !" ;( M
01 =) ( " <R ' =) ! H " "!( " 0/ I "& (=(( ( ))"!
"! (: =!"! " >?W(X?=<( . .//C ( F) (1 "!( H ;!1 )!)( "( 7 8 ("(< F) < "!(( "!( :( ( " "!(( <!M :8 F < )(= ( () '( ")" "!((M 8 (; " !1 >( )!)( ( ( !!) !)!! 8 :8 8 (*" (: =!"! " )(& <R( "' "! (':1 )!)( " )( )# " ' <( I( (( < "!(( <! R' " < !! F !"(! 61 -0+ -/. -/D 81
;==(& 7 ; ! 7
# > *(
( =) " ! H (=(! F ( (( <RE R==( =!"! " ( ;==
,-.%/,+//0