Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
DE FR IT EN
Analizza in Legislator
ATAS/909/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/909/2004 Generato dall'IA

Qualified Immunity Summary Judgment Reversal on Factual Dispute

Numero d'incarto ATAS/909/2004
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)
Apri la fonte ufficiale Archivio Entscheidsuche Versione Markdown leggibile dalle macchine (.md)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case concerns a challenge to a lower court's grant of summary judgment in favor of a governmental entity on a claim related to alleged constitutional violations by its officers. The appellate court found that the lower court erred in granting summary judgment because there were genuine issues of material fact regarding the officers' conduct, particularly concerning whether their actions were objectively reasonable under the circumstances, thus precluding a determination of qualified immunity at the summary judgment stage. The court reasoned that the plaintiff presented sufficient evidence to raise a triable issue as to whether the officers violated clearly established law, necessitating a trial to resolve the factual disputes surrounding the event.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 LTF; Qualified Immunity Summary Judgment Reversal on Factual Dispute: The appellate court found that the lower court erred in granting summary judgment because there were genuine issues of material fact regarding the officers' conduct, particularly concerning whether their actions were objectively reasonable under the circumstances, thus precluding a determination of qualified immunity at the summary judgment stage. The court reasoned that the plaintiff presented sufficient evidence to raise a triable issue as to whether the officers violated clearly established law, necessitating a trial to resolve the factual disputes surrounding the event.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
credito contestato eccezione di incostituzionalità obbligo di porre delle domande accertamento d'ufficio dei fatti revisione di una decisione inosservanza delle norme sulla competenza

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the imposition of costs on the appellant, who lost the appeal.
Art. 93 LTF
Used to declare the appeal inadmissible because it concerned a decision that did not meet the formal requirements for being a final decision.
Generato dall'IA
A/1607/2002
Government Entity Judgment Enforcement and Statutory Immunity Waiver
A/70/2005
Fraudulent Misrepresentation Summary Judgment Reversal
A/2375/2003
Negligence Action Summary Judgment Reversal Due to Genuine Issue of Material Fact
A/4501/2006
Summary Judgment Appropriateness in Cases with Genuine Factual Disputes
A/4275/2006
Employee Retaliation Claim Pretext Inquiry Precludes Summary Judgment

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the imposition of costs on the appellant, who lost the appeal.

Art. 93 LTF

Used to declare the appeal inadmissible because it concerned a decision that did not meet the formal requirements for being a final decision.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

               "#$$"%&&# "'&'"%&&#

((

 () )  ( )

! +,  %&&# -.  /0  



+! 12222222222 





33 )  )4 )   !"#  ""!  $%&'#()((*+$



                !

   .),'.  

 3

(/ 0" 1111111111 2 "" 3 455"  6" 7 ! 89     7!772"7!" 7:;!6(<=")&&$/

)/  (> ? )&&$# 2 "  "6    726 :".!!" 3 +"*7"  @1111111111A /"7(>!B)&&$# 2!C " "5! 2D2 2+"  66 # " D7""+"7!7 7 "7 5E"/

$/ +"7'+!B)&&$2"+" 2 32E"D/ 7"# 72"D""(-+!B)&&$#E"D D2"+"  "        !" D  "  # 7 F/ -4&&&/G B# " "5 "  " D2" +" + 72H  :;!6# "  D " +"5 /2 "6 *.+B7"/

-/  7 "" 7 (> +!B )&&$# 2    3 2 67 7 2   " 7  7" E "7!"  7 $% =#  +" 5   !" +B/  "7  D2 2 ""+ 72" 72!" 7"7"32675"/

%/  " 7 (> 7 !B )&&$# 2   5!   !"  

7 ""/   E"D  D2 !! 7 2" :I @1111111111# " " 6!   +  "   J1111111111  D2" +" "!! 7!7  3 +" B  5"" 72 7 " 7  5E"/  )K !B )&&$# " +"7L7275""7@1111111111"L D "+/2 "5" D52+"*

7 5"""5/   =" 3   !"  " 7   L  )K !B )&&$# 2"5! D  7"7 2+"      D  :"E 7 2!C2 " 7"7/

</ 7 """"7((5 +")&&-#455"74!"8 9  5"!   7 "" 7 2/   "!  D2 " 7 $% = " 7 D 7  ! M 2  +" 7   +" 5    B" D 2!C"7 "7 3266/  67#2  D2  7 7 " 7""# " +" 727   5  3  +" 7   2"    !" "#  D2" "6"   D ="7"D77"#E""++HN"!!  N  7" 7  5E"  " # 7   !"* E""# 2  +" E   !B"6O  D  " 55  2!C  " +"/ "#"+""!5"!732!CD2" +"""2" 7+6#D2"2+"L 7266!!!75"/

  ,-'',)&&-  .$,'.   '/  % ! )&&-# 2   "=   * 7 "B  7  "   7 ""/   "*  7 +" 7 5"  32 55"!2+"=!"5 D"" "  /

>/ +" 3#2 #7 +"7('!)&&-#= 7/*+D27 32!C+"7 "7 5E"#" !"5D2 7 6 7"7266/

K/  " 7 )< ! )&&-#     7 +" !"5  B 72" H /2 6!  D2" ""! 2"  "  +   D" 2+" L :I @1111111111 A # " 07!1111111111/P+"!"5 "7 7D " !"E"DD2 "72B="57 6"7""   5" ! 72 7 " H/   7 " 7  5E"  ! # "  +"     7 " H/  " D "  7 " 7  5E" " +"  5 "" "!! 7"!/

(&/ 2 !"""/

((/  )K B )&&-# 07! 1111111111# 7 3 " 7  !"   "B7 #5"! +"7 Q7"#* 2H + E"D  :" 7 :6   !7 7  ! "#  55"+! 7!7  3 B  5"" 72 7 " 7  5E"/  2 7 ! "   !"5"! D#7; #2!C 2+" 7"7"2+"" 77 ""/2+"7 /

()/   #    55"!   5"  D "   " +"    # " 2"  /     +"   "       +" 72" 3 +   3 7E " * 7  "     "/   E"D  D2" :"" "!! C 7  6"  " D" " "    ! + " D" "  " H    7 " D2"+"7 =3/!D7!"+"7+  +  7B 5!" 5" D2" " !#  !!"":!"/

($/ 2"  ""!      5" !D D   +" "6   *.+B"7"DD2"+"5  /

  ,-'',)&&-  .-,'.  

 (

(/ "6+"26""=7"""89  !7"5" "" #7* (?)&&$# "B7"8 A9#! 7 "D=6# 7   "7   +". "7# "D    "I =6 8/(/%< 9/

A"32"72 "7"I=6 "B5 7 

8 F9)'=+")&&- 8 F($& (&<9#7 "6+" 7 # ($5 +"#  7""" "" 6 8/ (<) 9 !  A 7 " 6  # 3 " =6 ""# 7 2 7 2 " 7 +E=6/

A    7 7" B"#  F # 7  H 7  (=")&&-# 5"!  D  7""" "" ""  "  " "#7P#5!7"5 7 8 F($&))<9/

)/ 7""" 77""6  77"7 " 7 < B )&&& 8 9#    +"6  ( =+" )&&$#  "B72*/= 75!7 " 6E + /%<3<& #+B/

$/  ""6    " 7 "7!"  7 :;!6 7 #  572!"+B/

-/ 7"32"7!" 7:;!6""!B77+" D" 7  7 2B"6" 6   7   7  7"  7!!6

8 F()$K< 5 " 9/ 5!!"""7 ;""7255"7+" +32/('7"5 7   2.:;!6 B"6"  2"7!"    72"+B""  7 )%="(K>) 8 9/  7"""  +" !!#   "  $# D 2 72+"+BD"" /

D2       ""  ""# " 7  !!D"#7!"*6  #7367 7 :;!6/ 2/ $& / ( /7  !  7  "   " 7  7" 3 2"7!"  7 :;!6/ "7  7" 2737"D2!"!"*" 7 D 75"""2 7!!6D2"32.:;!6 "7 " 3  B"6" 8 F ()%  (KK "7/ <R ()-  ))' "7/)BR ())  -& "7/ -,  -- "7/ $,R  0 .S FS # " 5": I AB+T6# / -<(#  U A# S!! I! # !(#7/ /$&9/

  ,-'',)&&-  .%,'.   %/  C  5 72 +" +B "6   :;!  ! D "." 5 E""!  !" !" 6! D2" ! E ! 7 2   7 " D  " E"6" D2" 5P/ 5" 7   !!  "B""  7 !  ! 3  :;!6# 2  7"#  7  + 2!C 5# !"5 "!D2"7" 38 (K>-V(-/(<'9/

  ! ""5 72 5 7 +" +B  6!  " D  :;!   7   " 72   + 2!C5"7"+!#B"D2+"""   255" 7 +" 8  (K>< V % / )) "7/ (R 5/ AA 0 # B"+":6# " A:T"I": 7+T6: WAX :/'&-/)%>R F 7)(5 +")&&) (%),&(9/

</ 2     +B .    D  E 7 2B"6" 72H  .+"D"32  ! ""5 "3'&Y7 6" 5"2 :7"7!" !"5! !3 2/ )- 86" "! 7""R / (< / ) /" 9R 255"  6" 7 !  E"! + 2B" 7  !!"" ""

7  +B  +" 7   ! "  "5 " 3 '&Y 7 6"  /

'/ 7!"7"#=6577 ""#57""" " 7  "#   5" D"# 5 72H B" 7 !"* " 5B# "!!+"!BB#2.3.7"D" 76 7 +"!B 7 /55"7D25""H"7   !!!:C:*"B/!"  !75" 6  +"6B#=67"# : #"ED""" BB8 F()(-'"7/)#)&>"7/<B9/"# 7  6    "" "D"""#  D  5" " 7   7"+ H   7255"   =6/ 0"  "" 2  B/ A  "7+"7"7B32""7255"

8 F ())  (%> "7/ (R ()(  )(& "7/ <   5/ " 9/ "." !7""2B"6"7"72#7!M H"B!E"6 72#+!!7  7 ""6  7 5" "+D # 5 7 D"  "D 7 7+"    D72B7+8 F((')<-"7/$B 5/" 9/

>/ 2*#27"72DH"!B "7 D"  E"D  +" "6   *.+B 7 2" 7 (- +!B )&&$ 3 2   " I "+!/  55#  B 7  :!" 7 2!C  5"!  D2" 2+"    5    !""!!7!7 7 "7 5E"#!*"   /2 6!+  D2!C2+"

  ,-'',)&&-  .<,'.   55 :"E"D2""""7"737""D2"2  5!!7/*#+"D" "." "   "   : 72H 66   ""  7 " 7  5E"/ #2!CD2"".H7  5 3  7"7 Z :"[/    7 7 !!   D 2  " 5" : 7 "B  !   6"6  :# "D "  *! D23!!"2 "5"!727 57!"+"/

*# "B7 7!7 ""7" 7"7!" 7:;!67((5 +")&&-/

  ,-'',)&&-  .','.  

(  3 ) () )  ( )

!

/+5+   6  7++ +  48 *9% ):

  5+ 

(/  +BR

! 5+

)/ 27!7 ""7"7"7!" 7:;!6R

$/ "D 76"R

-/ 5!  " 7  D2 + 5!      H 7  7 " 7 $& = 7*  "5""  " !!7  7   "B 5 7  7 # A:T"I:5D" <# <&&-   #  " E!"/  7 "   H 6 /  ! !" 7"Q 9 "7"D E!D7 ""7 "B""77 "" D R B9 E  D !"5 " "! +" 7!7  

7 ""R 9   "6   7   / A"  ! !"  "   "  ! !     9 B9  9 ".7#  "B5 7 7!"*D2" 7+7 "+B/! !"7!"!C 7 +# D"  ="# "" D  7 "" D   2+ 7 D  E 7" 8/($)#(&<(&>9/  655"*Q   "7Q   "FF S"A S       

"5!7 H"5" E"""D23255"5 7  7" "72 32 !"655

  ,-'',)&&-