Property Conveyance Validity Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe petitioner challenged a decision related to a property right, arguing that an alleged prior conveyance of the property interest was invalid due to a lack of proper execution or delivery, or that a subsequent conveyance superseded it. The court reasoned that the evidence, specifically a recorded deed and related testimony, sufficiently established the validity and precedence of the later conveyance, rejecting the petitioner's claims regarding the earlier document's deficiency, and thus affirming the lower court's ruling in favor of the respondent.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Conveyance Validity Dispute: The court reasoned that the evidence, specifically a recorded deed and related testimony, sufficiently established the validity and precedence of the later conveyance, rejecting the petitioner's claims regarding the earlier document's deficiency, and thus affirming the lower court's ruling in favor of the respondent.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAProvision cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of procedural costs.
Testo completo
"#$%&"#$$' "()*"#$$'
++
+, , + ,
- '
! *' ./. #$$'
!"#$!%&&' ( ) *! , #+,-$,""#.$,""/, 0
,
11 * * * *!," ,#$ 234'!+,5674!%&%% 5
!
)&8%%)
0
%: !$%;'&!"-$"+#%;<'!+=",>,! ,?$$>".,"#+".-",$:
&: =%>$-%;<5!$,$#?$$>"+,,#+$#,:
6: *.@,,".11 !$,$"#$ "&%A%;<46%#%;<<7;!,"*,)B)),+ "=%A%;<<%!2#" B 23)C:
': %7 - %;;7! 1 * * * * ** *D1 E!,,F?".++,#,%!2# " $$?++#,"G#"&49>:,:
,,+$".+?,:
4: %'A,&996!1 >#$.11 * * * *D EF"=%+,#?&996!,B",-@"$-, ".##?!.$+,,C#,B#3#"G" ;79>:#!2C#+!,6+='=#$,CH'6:
5: &6 >$- &994! 1 $, B . F .$ .2?,, + %! 2#"$)") -,!.++,#,$,,-"I,">,IF. -,$,$,=#,$-$&996: F+2,-,$,$+"+ ?"-:
7: % # &994! . >#$ 1 F .$ .2?,, + C#, ! , -#, " G "= % # &994 , $,"?$,,A,>$:
<: '#&994! 1 F". -#,"GAF.69 A&994:
;: %7 # &994! . >$ ,, "#" , +$$ F , " -#, ,-, " >, F 1 -, #, "F$ .? " .$ " .++,#, "+ + #: - " F3,$,,$#2C$""$,#"$"".$:
%9: && # &994! 1 $$ ? " .$ + 69 A &994 -,.-I,>#,".++,#,,"$2CI:
%%: ++,"'A,&994!,",J,". -$ F.-,,,$>".$!"# F>>#,F +=2?,,B:.$,,,"-.$%'#&994:
8&94'8&995 )68%%) )-,",-F,,$C#,B",-@"+>$-&996: "$,2?,20,20+"+A-&996:.$,,CC$ ,B.,,B$,$C"?#,"#:+#,"G-, $,$ + # ? -, $,$ ,,$ += + +C B "#,,C,"-: @)-,>>#$F..G2?,,+ "+ C,#+ , >, " ?> +C: C! "# !",F++,#,-,"+"B,!B,K" " A@ , F. .-, ,! = , 2?,, 1: ! .2?,, #>,#, + " ++,#, , ##,".$,,$G$,,".:
%&: "$ " < A, &994! . >#$ .$ F.+= F3, ,#,F.$",1,++#$,,+,,>-:
%6: "&L,&994!.$!+$,$+. * !>#$. F $, " ? -, $,$ ,,$ "-, A", " @ , G,"#",+F#,>+,,$,,+-$:
%': &; A, &994! .$ >, ++, B "$ +$,$ , ,# B . >,"-","=-D*E#""#
1 !"#$B!-,F)$,,?"#$B =-,F.C,20"@B,,+#:
%4: " &; L, &994! . $+" B .$ F +,, -,$,$++#$"$"1-:
%5: "&#&995!1 ##$.$"+G!".%4# &995! #,, " <.769 >: +", @ G #+G$ , . -, F @$,$-,##,F:
%7: &' # &995! $, B . ! B "#" " .$: $,, A" , .+, " "- +,, ,-@ " ?M,#, " F.$$,,,:+-,,>--)+,F#,, A:
%<: &4#&995!"# !$,B. F.,>,F += 2?,, ? ++,#, , F. +, ,= $C=#, " -,!"=F.2?,,+="20:
%;: 6#&995!. +,#, "#.++,".$: F. $", + %! 2# " # F +#,,, ".>># F. $", + ,, C- , + $F, $+,,#+$#,,#+,"G!->>, % A, &994: =- F " - 2?,, .##? -, >>#$ B .F3,F.$.2?,,+++,#,:,,">,"
8&94'8&995 )'8%%) *F##,$,,$$,,>$B".+: -, "$$ F. .-, >C! =! ,$$-! F. #C, B .@,$ , ,,, ". )L, B #" " ++,#,: @+,.$,,+-,#3#+$##"-, ,/##,".$,,$+#+,,:
&9: AC#, " %7 # &995! ? " @ , G ,,$ .>>,$ " C$ #,> F. # "# .-, $,$ C$ B .$:
&%: &;#&995!1 >#$. F$$"+69A&994 #,, B %9.579 >: , F .$ ,, .++,#, + " ,+C".##":
%5A&995!. >$"+"2C,$$"G:
&&: %A&995!"# $,B. * F.>#,F +=2?,,%!2#"$)") -,:+-,>,2 ")#3##C$#"#-,+>B#C,#, ,#C,,=-,20#:-,,#, ++?=##$"@"+=F-,?"."+#$C C#,"C#,:. .-,+"F+,:*+= $,,,#,2+,$:*"!+-,+GG,+ ">#+-,.20:
&6: %;A&995!"#1 $,B. * F.>#,F .$!F-,+>)#3#+,+-,,, "#",-!+,$C=#,+20:
&': 5A&995!.$!+$,$+/, !+)"-, ?,"B.,""$++, " . , B + 2C " G " " +,,: >, - F. $,, @,3##, $# " .,, " .$,,$ , F. "+, ". ++ $,F: #+,#, >, +, " +,2C: .-, ,$3, B 2 C#, B =-:. .-,+,,$#CC"# !#
1 ! # F#, @ " N "1 !"$,,""# F$,, " ++, " ?", - 1 : > >, " *O# ".,? &994 B A- &995 "$#,, F " ++ $,, >>,$"+#$",$$+2>@:
&4: 4A,&995!. A,":
8&94'8&995 )48%%) &5: %% +,#? &995! ? " $ , " " #+, +,".F3,:
,"$$P
I".##?"+%;<<:.,+?+".$,,$ $"-#>>,:""2#?"C2:># F A.G " 2# Q A , 20 # #: ., + # =,A.+">C:>#."$+,,=#A .,#3#+: 20#A#C>",A#C2"!B 20##>,)>"2B+!+00B . C".:-+">,$,".$,,$">:<%:)I:
# "$$P
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
8&94'8&995 )58%%) .G + + " #= " ++,#,: F A " # ++,#, A - + C , , , " .##?! A. $# -.@,$"+#,#:."@>,"%7,%& : # "#" +F : ., + , A " ++,#,.2?,$#,".##?I:
#F1 "$$P
I.#": :"#": ,A H %! 2# $)") -,: L " 2# # # " #$: (#,"#",F: $,$2+,$A -)$C=#,#0-,: #.,-$"> "+,, -GC-:: ",FF>20#!A++F , " ,#+ ", " ++,#,: #! : . + ".,"#:,">>+">B#C:#C,". -, 20 #: A# $ " ++,#,: #. ", F. +, +> + B .@,$: #. +$ " : ># ,"+=H<2C$,FA.#)#3#$,:.,$ : .$,$&99&:>#+",FAA#$20 :2?,,"$ABB":F.G",-@".##?, F.,,?$,++,#,"#3###?I:
# "$$P
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
8&94'8&995 )78%%) ->,F."F#+=.2?,,+++,#,:,B "F">=#+=+,"++,#,,A +Q+,--:*++,.+B. 20:*..C,".F,"."B#,".++,#,!>", +,J, " # += " +,J, F ".G " > F,, .++,#,:.A#+$BC# I:
&7: %' +,#? &995! , +", >, " ##, " *-","=-D*E++$""&<A,&994&7A, &995">:56!7':
&<: &% +,#? &995! .,#$ #, "$,#, "$, F # -, >#$ F , .2?,, + " ++,#,:>,"*>"$#,,##,"42 + #! F #?, ? >$ B ##, #G + #3#,G+"C#,:
&;: ; ,? &995! ? " $ ," ## ,$# : ? : )"$$P
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
8&94'8&995 )<8%%) +> #,! B #" .+=)#" - %4299! %5299 +> %7299:: #.+",F.-,#: C$$A+, -%5269)%7299!+>#3#-,I:
69: *!. #,+,,$,$C"$BAC:
+
%: C-TC,A"DE$,$#">$,,,$!"= %L,&996! ?,"!#+$"4AC! ",+$",,-)+$",!4++$,,%5ACD,:%,: ,45 E:
*,BT,"T$,"%5AC!+ ?>$"$ &7A-&99'D 1%69%95E!" C-"+,$!%6>$-! "+,,,C,+#,,, ?," " $C B , AC ,,! ! " T,,, " T$,"-@AC:
&: >#$#, B .,: 45 : % ,: 2: 6 ! ? , " /,,F",,,+$-BT, 45 " >$"$ +, C$$ " ", " " 5 ,? &999 D E F , ,- B >$"$ +,, #+$#,BT)-!--,,-",$"%;#%;54 D E: ? , " /, $C#, " ,,, +$- B .,: '6! " , +,, , #+$#,B.)-,--,,B.)-",$" &4,?%;5<D,:45:&,:E:
*#+$,+AC""T+=,$,?:
6: ,A,$,#+,!,-?D,:59 U'6 E:
': .?A,",C,B"$,#.,BA,,,F.,#$.+, #+,"#,,"G".++,#,"%! "" +,,#+$#,","+% A,&994:
4: E #,, " +,, #+$#, >$"$ +" B +, " "$+ F @=" - "$,#, D,: 6 : % E:
G".++,#,,>G,>>,+,""$+ D,:6?:%,:? E:
?E , ", @ +,, #+$#, , + ", -"$,#,.,,,+-###,"."
8&94'8&995 );8%%) ++?D,:' E: ,,"$+"$",?"-"$,#, G".++,#,!G#+>D,:5:%,: E: "$+ #@# + G .$=- + $ B >: %6.&99:) + +D,:':% E:
5: .+=! ?"$,"",,$#F >",B,, "C#,: ,"F3,F +#,"",""# >>,>" ," ++,#,,$ '=#$,C!%! B 23)C:
: ! #+G$ ## A" + 1 ", $ "$$F.-,$C=#,-,#,"++,#,, ""!F.,B"2">>$,#,,.+=)#"!F. ",, -, - : , -, A# +$ ". , ++,#,:*,B.2+,,",!: .,F$,$ "+-,.,,$,$$+2F#,BI$,?#,2+,I! F>#>,F.-,>>,.2?,""$C=#,!#3# !+>!-G,+",#">,F.,-, "+"=.##?:
,$#CC"# #,+>,"=F )"#,/,,"+@!->," .##? %! $)") -,! - - 22 , +,: >>#F,",+"++,#,-,+G -+=.-F,,$".+=)#",F.-,+-,"-, .##?"#="++,#,: ,$C"!# "$$ F. G -, , ,$ " .##? F +- F. +,,J,,$,-",:!,$,?F ,",+>20#!#1 !,"F., >>,-#, + , 20 : >! , $,? + >, ".$,,$ * + +$" A, &994 ) A, &995 F , ##, ,= >? ".$,,$ # $,$ @+F$ " >S -,+)#3#!F+>,#1 !+>, F. ., ++ $,F! F. A# " ++,#,+F.+"+B.@,$20#1 ,,! F. , ". + ? #, , , F. .$ CM@$"-:
7: - " F +$="! ., B ,, F .,#$ "$$ F , .2?,,+"++,#,B."%! B 23)C: "- " +" #+, #,, " G "", ++,#, " " +,, #+$#, >$"$ , , "= % A, &994:
8&94'8&995 )%98%%) <: $F "#! "$ ++, " 6 # &995 +,#, $ " # Q ,, + #+, " G " .++,#,+$,$,-G$B.,#$+-"$ ""$,:
;: "#,$">:%.499:)$,!B2C".,#$:
8&94'8&995 )%%8%%)
+ 0 , +, , + ,
!
1/.2. 3 4.. . 56 *'# , 7
2.
%: $-?:
! 2.
&: ."#,:
6: "$++,"6#&995"#Q,,+ #+,"G".++,#,","=%A,&994:
': -B.,#$+-"$"""$,:
4: "#.,#$B+G,"#,$">:%.499:):
5: , F + F ,, @ +,, #+$#, >$"$! +, +-, ># , +$, 3, " "$ " 69 A "= ,>, + + ##"$ "$ ? >$"$ " ! *2O02>F5!599' ! ,@#+: #$#",PE "F@,#,F"$,"$?,,+" "$ ,,F$U ?E @+ + F #,> , ,# +- "#" ,, , "$U E +, C, " , " +$,,:*#$#,,+,$$#,$#$$,, E ?E , E )"! ? >$"$ " + + , #,= FT "- "$ -?: #$# " #,#G"+-!F,A,#$#TTC, " += + " ,: *, $C#, A, #$# "$ ,,F$ , T-++ " F $,$ @+$"$ , D,:%6&%95,%9<E: C>>= +$", G* $
+>#"+$,3,,,>$@+,FTBT>>>$"$ "+C>>
8&94'8&995