Contractual Delay Breach Interpretation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute centered on a contractual obligation requiring prompt completion of work, which was allegedly breached due to delays caused by an external condition beyond the control of the performing party, though the contract contained a clause excusing delay for such events. The court reasoned that the language of the excusable delay clause did not encompass the specific external condition that caused the performance failure, thus upholding the finding of breach and rejecting the defense based on the literal interpretation of the contractual provision regarding force majeure or similar events.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Contractual Delay Breach Interpretation: The court reasoned that the language of the excusable delay clause did not encompass the specific external condition that caused the performance failure, thus upholding the finding of breach and rejecting the defense based on the literal interpretation of the contractual provision regarding force majeure or similar events.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the payment of court costs.
Cited in the dispositive regarding the principle of proportionality for cost allocation.
Testo completo
#$%&&#'(($ #&)$#'((%
!!*
+ !,+ - +! -,
% . / '((%
01 2 /
3333333333
-44, - 5+! ,6,, ,,-. !"#$%&'#(&(()*(+
! "
/&0!/
4,
(3 4, 5555555555# . - (!%+# 6. $7, 8-$ . 9: ;< =5555555555 > ?:8 +2 *, (!!13 , ;-,# , ., $9 8-,,, ,3 > *-8.*,@A3!B%'23//$%2;*,;9-,3 > -$ 7, $.,. : , $, $ -8.-,:8,,*,..,9.,,.3 >*,...,,.$,.C$,)+#7' D3
&3 !9(!!1#4,5555555555.$.-$, $)B77,B/,*,,.C,/$)E8 D#@8$$, : , ,*:. $ ;, F # ,9) ; $,3
+3 5555555555# $$ -., +( .-9 (!!! . @ 8 # ,,:. : ,G, $,,$ ,, ,9) ,,/.$# 6, $, *,G, 8.# ,. @ 8,, 67,$?#-$,:..$;$;,$ $;,,,*H ,G, , ,* .. $.E $ ;, F C$,(!"'D#; $,.,9.,.3>,,9).,,,#, .. *; ,G. : -, ;* , 8GG*3 >-.,#, ,,$,.*,$7,8-$ . 9: $, &1 *, (!!1 $99- -,) .7,,,*3 .G- *. : .? .$- -., , 8;I$,.-9(!!"#$,8.,*,$ *;-G$:,-,$,-7 :8,,G.@,$$-$-3
%3 $98 +2*-9&222#8. 6$,:.:8,*,..,,.$-$ #,*,,-:8, *, * J$K @ $ .-; $) B/ ,*,,.389-,:8,$,*,#$*,$.,@: 6#$,,-.: $,,$ ,$,.*,*, 77,;-G,:37,$*,. ;-G$,(!!13..**8.:8,$, </**-.,;-G7,7,9,. .#:8,8$7,3
'3 45555555555# ;-G# .G- .9, $$ -., L-&222#,:8..$,.,,,
0(%110&22( /+0!/
:8,,.,,-$,97,,,,M:@$,. *, $7, 8-$ . 9:3 -., ,G. $ 8*,*$,(&?,(!!1#@:877,-.9,: .:-,*,,$,.*,3 ,,:-#877, ;-,- -9, -# , -, *.9 ., ,6, $,, : :: 7G -,G, ,, $.,$;.,:3 -., : $ ;G, 8., $, $, *, $I N -, , * 77, -.9,:#-.:,,9.@8.$:#-,:8,86,,*; ?,7,,8;-G,:@,$,.$G.,*,. $7,93
L3 5555555555#8,.,9.G,8;I$, #,,:. :8..8.8.,GG*.$,(!!1:,, .$;$;, ,9.,: $ ;, F 3 > ,# , 6,, ,$,. *, $,# @ 8, ;-G,:3 8, ,C*.,D,$$.38$$,,,-,9) ,$$,--,,/,*,$O97, $*,-,$,.*,-.,.?@6.C$$(+ $-9&222E$,)L#7+ D3
"3 .# -., , 8 *. : ,*,, ,9.G,8;I$,#..:,,9.,-,7-M6,77,. $,@-@,-:.?#,8.,$ $, $ ;, F 3 .G- ,G. :# ;-G#,86,,,$G8,$,. *,3 8 , .7.. $$ 5555555555 :, ,,:. : $ ;,F .,$.$,(!"'.,,,- -.,-6$,(!!2:,/.8,-$,9,,. 7, ,,, M : @ $,. *, 8. $7, 8-$ . 9: / .-, ,-. :8, 8 *, $ /,,, * $7,3 > 9 $$# -., , 8 ,-. : ,- ,9) 8., $ $,- , -$- 8. $*, ,9- 6,G 773 > ,# 8. . 8. ?,7,, $ ,$,. *,93
13 .,,(!-&22(#8 #,.:8..8. 8,-$,:, ,-,, $,. *, $7, 8-$ .9:#,,.,6$,3
!3 , (& *, &22(# 8. 7-. .,,3 6$,:NN-,$,(9(!!",. .3)G:,9)#-,;*8; $,.,
0(%110&22( /%0!/
, , ., $, ,- -$,:. ,77,, @ 3 ,,: : -., ,# 5555555555# $, ,@7,8.(!!!H:5555555555,,9) , ., 45555555555 -, ;*3 8. 6$,::,9):,.,,77,,@-O, :-,;*,,9G$: $- # --9# ,, G ;,:3 ,*:7,PG*.#:,,-9$..,$,8*, .G,3
(23 *,.@$#8 #$.*,+?,&22(#? 3
((3 ( M &22+# .. -, ,9 ,3
(&3 @ , :8, *, .. * : 8. $, *;-G7,$.@9,-$. .# ,9.8:,*,,8.*,-$, .-;3
(+3 , L ?*, &22%# .$ : -., -, @ ., 86- 8 , -:, $ 7,$*,.,93
(%3 ,(!-&22%#,,:.*,-,..- -.,645555555555:,,,.N,,,, 7,$$3
('3 +2 M &22+# 45555555555# ;-G# . $$ -., ,93 6$,: :8$) *, $, * ,77. $.,,# , , .. ,77,, $. @ ;)# -$ ,*,. $, $,3 > ,# ,77. 77, , $, $ $ @ .: $, .$.- -, $.# -9# , G* @ .3 > ,# ,*,,.$-Q,#8. 7,G;,:: * 8.# , ,-$,9 86,G 8,,. $,. :8 -$ , 8 8 93 $ ;, F .*. $, (!"& * :: $. ,7--,./,,,-,8,*,.;-,- ,7--, .-, $ ,-$3 -,7 $ , -, *.9 :, $ 6 ; *,3 ,9),77,,@.:,,98-$G-$,,E ;., $.,$;.,: , @ $ $;, )- *$.6
0(%110&22( /'0!/
.,7 @.$;$;,*$.,,3 @8; $,# .G-,77,,@.G6,G7-.,,3>8 ? - 8$.--,.*)3
(L3 .. ?, $$ .9, $ 5555555555# $-G# 5555555555#,G3 ,7,-,*.*.,.$. --,8.:,,-$$,:.3
("3 $$ 45555555555 .. -, @ 8,. ,,-. :,# $ ,'9&22%#-,$,,3>-.,,77 ,-.:8.$.,,-,,7,,-$: G*6$; ,:,/,,:.3
!-,
(3 , G*, 8G,, ?,,, CD .. -,7,. ,,.# ) ( M &22+# ,9 , C >D# -$.,:?G#$.,*,/$.,#,:$$. ,<?GC3(3'L D3
>,@8,8.,,<?G$ ,97.. C AD&"?*,&22%C A(+2(2LD# ,G*,$.# (+7.*,#,$,,,,GC3(L&D$- > ,.G # @ , ?G ,,# 8 8., *6?G3
> , $9,# A # N (?,&22%#7,-.:,$,,,,,,, $,.,#O#7-,7..C A(+2&&LD3
&3 7-.-@83+3+,$,,,,#,, *8.*,G,$* --,, -,) 8/,*,,. .. -, 877, ,9,#,,:#-- ,-,)8 >/ C73,'LD3>-$. $?G8$),,.9,3
+3 , 7.. $, G.. , , L9&222 C D . *,G ( ?*, &22+# O -9 -,7,, -, 8/,*,,.3 8$) - 7, .G, $ ,$,, *,G ?:8 +(.-9 &22&# .G $,,$ : ?G
0(%110&22( /L0!/
,8$@$,.,-,7,,,8. 7, $., @ .-, .,, ,,G, C A (&" %L"#,3(#(&(+1L#,3(9H73.G-,$,,,,#3 1&3( D3 $.,,G .: 6-,.@-,) ,$,,,8/,*,,.C H1+(3&2D)G- *,G?:8+(.-9&22&C H1+(3&2(D3,$,,.G ),.,3
%3 #,?.-$,*?,,,-$.#*9# 7-.-63L! 1%,7..8/*,, *,* &2 .-9 (!%L C >D# *9 ?:8 +( .-9&22&3
'3 B,*,,. .7,, $ , -- ,-,, $,. G,# $.-. $- G .# :, . B , @ . $; ,:-$*B,7,-,.G.,#B-,B ,C3%3( D3B,$,.G,,,-,,- $.*,,9 $,9,,. G, $ . B-9 -;.*,.:,,9.$*,.,$3
L3 B.,@B,,*,@%2R-,3 #,* :3>B,,*,@'2R#,* -,/#, ,*,,.,LL&0+R#,)C3&13( D3 $.,9# ,*,,. %2R -, * , @ -,/ C3 &1 3(9, D3
"3 .,7#G.B,*,,.,N.-,.9B -$,*E-$,:B,*,$,9, 6QB,*,.:8$,9-,/$)6., .*-.$,-$B,,.:,,9. -;.*,/@,:B,,$9,B,B.,$,*,C3&13 & D3 -$, , )G G.. 7, -,) : 6*; $;.,:,;,77.$6-$,9-, $)#,77.$-.-,G.B,*,,.C-.; G.. -$, *H A (&1 +2 ,3 (# (2% (+L ,3 & &9D3 >, - $ N .-,. * $.,,# , *,.*..-$,, -$ * $$6,-,* ,, C> &222 ,3(91%H>&222,3(+(LD3>.-,$-$, * $$ 6, -- , , @ # ,,:-,7,,.**?:8--.,, :,.:,@C A(&!&&&#(&1("%H73 , A %%202(&&M&22& A "L(02((19&22&D3
0(%110&22( /"0!/
13 8,,7,8-.,7$$.$CD -.,CD ,CD @ 877, # 6$, -., ,.$ 8,,, 8# 6- $,:. $ 89*, -., 8 # 6$, $, $ $, ,, : 6$, -.,.$?G38.*,8,*,,.# P;-.,,@$?G-8..8.#@ ,,::,*,.,,$986:-3 . -., , ..- , $ .-, : *6 $ # ,9-# 6,G 8. C A (&' &L(,3%#(('(+%,3&#((%+(%,3+#(2'('1,3(D3
!3 >$,,$,9$$.,,$*#?G.*$* -,) -$) ,G# N ,. $ )G 7-3 , $6-,9?,*-- $*#::8, $*#$,.,,-@,$,,$-$ ?G- *9 , ,,G,63 >, $$ -.,6 ,,#,$;877,$$.,8-9$* ,,:,$:,7$,, -., $I:8C A(&'+'(D3
8..- .,,7 $ * $9 8 ,7, -., 8 , ,G,,7,:8,,.,G.--$$6$,-.,# -,99,3 :,.-,#8:$,,,G,6 ,-$,7,89?8.7,.#:$$7 6- -$# :8, $ .G- ,., $, 6$,-.#:8,,...9,$,,,C-)D#: ,$, 6 -., , , 7, : , 86$,9,-,*.C A(&&(L2,3(.73D386$,, N 7. -, -$) ,G, $.,# N GP @ ,, *, ,. $$ .$ 6;,* .:,*: 6 :, $. C3 4 # 86$,-.,>,E,7,/66,G:,.S# , >;T,<,; ,;G<,;,7# L"0(!!!# $3 +"D3 -N- # U 6$ :8 6$, , N -$) : 6 7, # @ , 6 .$ 6 :, $.3 , N -$.;,9# $ ; $, , CVU # TG,;>;*W,G#, (!!!$3'L"D3
(23 8$)# ,G, .. ,- $. $N $ @ ,E 8. 77 ,9)# $ ;, F # 8; $, .,# 89.,. # .G-# 8$. --,3 $-, $$ -., .9, $ 45555555555# ;-G# - &222# @ 89 ?,7,, 8 ;-G,: @
0(%110&22( /10!/
,$,. *, $G. ,*,. $7, 93 -.,7,,,:.:8,8*,$*$,$,?,(!!1 : $$.,, 9, : $$,,3 5555555555# ,9.G# $ $ @ ,$,. *, $,@8,;-G,:#:8,8$$.*#/,8. $ 3 A : .,, ,,G, .. 89 8..- -.,6 77, $ .-, $,. *, 8.3 $ $ $ 7, $; @ 8,. ,,-.# 8. 7. - @ 86- 8 ;-G3
((3 $, # 6- ,# $ 45555555555# :, $$ +2 M &22+3 $$ 8*) $ ,77, $ ,,:@$,.*,.8.3 77# -.,# $., :8, ,77,, $. @ ;) -$ ,*,.$,$,#$.,.:88-, ,77.,:,$.,8-9,G*@.# - .* .$, ,) $,. *,3
(&3 ,:8.77,*-9,9,-3 * $ $* $$ -$ # :, ,,:. : , *.$,$-*.,9-$ .-,,*, ..,9.,,.3
)#,,-$.-,8*).,7,.-, .$, ,77. , . 8. $,. *,3 ,9.,* @8,.,,-.@;G$ ,)86$,-.,-,,,$,,7-6 )G $. $ ?,$ $$. ,/3 *, .-, : ,-,, 7, G. $ ,77.,@.8.3
7 7 7
0(%110&22( /!0!/
! -,4 !,+ - +! -,
89 : ; 5< $=' -
9
(3 .*9H
9
&3 8-$,-H
+3 .,, (! - &22( *, @ 8,. ,,-. $ ,, -$.-, 7- 86$, -., -,,,$,, *.,,H
%3 7- $, :B $* 7- $. N ., +2 ? ) ,7,, $ $, --. . ,9 7.. # >;T,<;7:, L# L22% # , 6-$,3 ., $ N $G.3 -.-, , E D ,,: 6- :B .,, ., 9, , $ .,, :.H 9D 6$ $ : -,7 , ,- $*, - .,,HD$,G$.3>,-.-, , $ , ..- .-.. D 9D D ,/# ,97..$$-,):B, *.,*93-.-,-,- $*# :, ?,# ,, : .,, :. B*$$ :..6$.,.C3(+&#(2L(21D3
G77,)E $.,E ,AA X,> X
$.N--,:.$,7,,6$,,,:B@B77,7.. ,$G77
0(%110&22(