Appeals Regarding Statutory Interpretation and Application in Property, Contract, and Procedural Matters
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court considered several appeals involving various claims, primarily concerning the interpretation and application of statutory provisions related to property, contract, and procedural matters, with some appeals involving challenges to the sufficiency of evidence or errors in legal instruction. The court's reasoning across these diverse issues generally involved a close textual analysis of the relevant statutes and precedents, upholding verdicts where the lower court's application of the law was deemed reasonable or the factual findings were supported by substantial evidence, while reversing or remanding in cases where clear legal errors or misinterpretations of the controlling law were identified.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; PRESTATION COMPLÉMENTAIRE ; PC ; JETON DE PRÉSENCE ; REVENU ; PERCEPTION DE PRESTATION; RESTITUTION(EN GÉNÉRAL) | Les jetons de présence pour un travail de parlementaire sont soumis à cotisations AVS et font partie du revenu déterminant pour calculer les prestations complémentaires. Sur le montant des jetons de présence, il convient cependant de déduire 25% à titre de frais et conformément à une jurisprudence du TF. | LPCC5; LPC3c
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
&'()*&'++, &--.&'++,
/ # #
01 )
" ') 2 '++, ! ""# #" $$ % % % &'% "# # ! ()*+
!" # $ %" "
2-,/02
$
/3 !/4.4# #! 5 #6758 /-9 #/4:03
-3 " #6 2"#; 5 #! !#!"7/"95 "/44-3 #"5 !< #!;8=!>"6 2#88"7? @!5" "/44+695 "/44A3
.3 8"## 8!# "@!!"## #!#!5"!8 /"9 #/44*3
+3 "88"#;<)#!#!!#> 8"; /0!>"-00/3""#< ""; #!"!8### 5#B 2 # @"3 *.0300 2 # "5 75 @"3 /300 2 #8"!##< 7" 8 5 758"8!" /"!>" /444./ -00/ @"3 1;A/0300
2 "# <8"# 5 #!" #" 2 "!#" #8#" "; $C$D;8(>!# # # !E @# 2!" F"!675 C! "/4442-000D3 $"3-0;/-+300 ; #!"!#8"8" !# "8 /-@!5" "-00/;88"##< (> # 3 ;(# ;88"## 8" E ./*;000 @"3 !#! @ ! 8" ## 5"! 8" ;$ 8" 8"# -/*;000 @"3 8"7 ;%#8"8")#*0;000@"3@#3
*3 ; " > !!# "8" 8"## 6 ; #!"!/"95 "/444# "!!8"! -1@!5" "-00- ">"# -+;0A- @"3 "8"!## 8"## 5"! 6 #"#/"95 "/444-:@!5" "-00-3
A3 ; #!"! @"! 88 # -- " -00-3 "8"( 6 ; ;5 " 8" !"# 9#8"! <-0;/-+@"35"! @5" 8" " @!!" ;!F #! #" @ # ( " ""8#E.0G; "!#" ># 8"#"5 @@#! ;$3 #8" "" ;> F# ">""3
,-./*,-001 2.,/02
13 ; #!"! !#! # 8" ; # # #! !#! 5"! "3=#"5!<; #!"!>5 "8" ; ;F # " -0;/-+ @"3 "! ! 8" # 5 #! ;$ # "# @ 6 ;88"## # # 8"8" !# "3 ; #!"! 8" # 8#6##"<9#8"! 5#)#"8" !"# 3 8" " " 6 ; !8# 9# 8"!"H!>"/4446 -00-3
:3 """ "/- -00. @"!; <@# 7" 8#" #.0 -00.3
43 "! .09 -00*; 88" !8" 8#9# 8"!7/"9 #-00*3
/03 ./#>"-00*; #!"!;!#8"7; <; ;"# @ # 7" 8<8 /"9 #-00* .0 -00.3
//3 " ! ./ -001 ; "9#! ;88 # -- " -00-3 "88<"5 ; # E!8" ;##8" "7F# #E ! ! 8" @!!" 8" 8"## 8!# " @!!"3 %;F # 8" !"# 9# 8"! < "-0;/-+@"3"H8"# 5 #!6;$-000 ; 7" <; ## < F " 6 # # % 5#)#" #!F"!"5!#" #88 # ;"#3* " 8"## # 8!# " 6 I"25 # "5 5# # 6 I"2 5 #! C D3 " " ; 8"! <; ##" " " 7;#"!@"! "88 # 3
/-3 ; #!"! #"9#!""/-9 -001#" #! 3"88 <9#8"!8"5 #8;# 5 #!"# 5##8
5 !8";"#3* <"!@7"; 3"888" "< F##>"#" ;$=#"5 #>!!53
/.3 "!8//9 #-001; @ #!##;"")#-J#-00+E #"< " >@!!""9F!<9#8"! # # # "!!"# 8" #"5 "! ! "# # !# # 8"## E # # " !## ##@ "!# @"@ # " -*G 8" @" "3 ; 2#2 8"!! E)## @ !6; #!"!5! /09 #-001 3 ;# @! " !8# 9# 8"! !#> 8" 8 /" !>" /444 ./ -00.3 ## # 8 ##"!!6; #!"! !#!"! #6/;410@"3
"5(; 8" # ;F #-0;/-+@"3
,-./*,-001 2+,/02 5 #!6!#" "; #!"!8""" "-19 #-001!"!<; ## #88" 8#-0;/-+@"3<8"#"# #< 9#8"!5 #8)#"8" !"# 8 < " 8"## 8!# ";=@ #8 3
/+3 "" "!#!#" 6; #F"!69F"3
#
/3 F5 "I"F # 9 "CD!#! @ !# # #!7 /" J# -00. " > # " ### @"!# 6 ;"#3 *A 3 / #3 (3 . # < " ### 8"!56I"#3*A @!!""8"# F!!"" # " A #>" -000 C D < # "# 5 6 @!!" "8"## 8!# "6I"25 "5 5## 5 #! /4"/4A*C D3K#!F#88 # ;"#3*A3-#3 ### 8"!56I"# +. #"8"## #8!# "6I"25 #"5 5##6I"2 5 #!-*#>"/4A:C D3
%8!#8"9F"I87# !#> 3
-3 @!!""8"# F!!"" #" A#>" -000C D##"!5 F"/"95 "-00.#"K# @ # >" 8 # !F"!F 8"## 8!# " ; %, C"#3/ #/ D3;87"#8#"!F 8" 8 # 5 F"9<;./!>"-00-!F"8" 8 < "7F 88 > # 5 F" # L @ # 9" <#!#" ##8" #3 <# "# ## 8"## 8!# " J# 8"H "# 8!" /" 95 " /444 -: @!5" " -00- #2 )#" E ! "F" ; " # C $ /.0++*#"!@!"M@3 $/.0.-4D3
.3 "7F 8"!" <# 6 ;88 <# "!"5 7 9" #"! 5 F"C $ //1 4. 3 A>M //- .A0 3 +M /44:N.183./A 3.>D3
#"9#! @" # ! 8"" # 8" "" # "5> C@3"#3*A#A0 M"#3+.3/ D3
+3 = 8"!># ##" < !" #" -1 9 # -001 ;"!;8" 8" !"# -0;/-+@"3
,-./*,-001 2*,/02 *3 = # "5"<! /09 #-001!#!"9" 5# !#" # ; # "" # @"!# 6 ;"#3 *. 3. 35! ###@ @ # F<" L ""8 E ""#3 % 2 ;># # 8 # 8 # # @# ;#" #! # #"" # 7" " "" < ;"! 5 ##<" 5 # #"# @ C "# 5 8"! #! O -0+/D3 ;87 ; #!"! ## !F# 5 ; 8 <; 7" < 9# 8"! 5" # 8 )#" "# ##3 >7" " >!;#""# 7"3
A3 #" #E8"## 8!# "#8"#"5 !#" # ;## # 8 "5 # ; 88 >3
13 E#";"#3* "5!#" #8"
D "" 87 #" 8"5# ;E" ; # 5 #! "# 5M
>D8" #@"###> 7"<; > 7"M
D( # 7@"### < 78"8"PF!8"7 !# 5#B
/O-*000$8"8"M
-O+0000$8"8M
.O/*000 $ 8" "8( # 8" @# # "" @# 8"## M
+O## #!8 #>#6# #"F# #!")# "!8"# ;8"!9 "8"M=8" ; # !5# #"#"M
D"#;"25 #"5 5##;"2 5 #! < #!9" 7";"2 5 #!M
D8"## 8!# "@!!"M
@D"#8 ##"8"## 8!" <M
FD8"## #(!5"#;#"#;#"# 5 F"###" 5# FM
(D# @ #@"# 8"@ M
D "H # #" ; > F# ;#"# 5"# " # @ M
,-./*,-001 2A,/02 9D""#=#" #;# 3
@#88"# "5!#" #B
D #@" 8"8"(5"#"# .-:# 5# 5 M
>D8"## ; #8> <M
D 8"## 8"5# 8" # ; # ## 8> < 8" 5! =# @##"#7"; #M
D# 8" 8##;"25 #"5 5# < ;"2 5 #!M
D >" # # ;!# < #" @ 7" 6 ; #"# 3
%;F #8"## 8!# "@!!";"#3. @!!"" 8"## 8!# " 6 I"25 "5 5# # 5 #! C D <<##8"## 8!# """8 68"#!8"< E7"5!#" #3
%;"#3. "5!#" #8"#
3 "" 87 #" 8"5# IE" I # 5 #! "# 53##/000@"8"8"#/*00@" 8" 8 # 8" < # @# =# # " # 6 "# # ! # "5 8"5# IE" I # 5 #! "# 5!##8" 8#6" E# "3" 5 I"#3-#3"5I# 5 #!"# 5## 7"#8" 8#M
>38" #@"#> 7"# > 7"M
3< Q 7@"### E 78">!!@ ""#
5 " L !8 -* 000 @" 8" 8" +0000@"8"8#/*000@"8""8( # @# # " # 6 "# 8" @# I % I 3 % >!!@ " 8"## 8!# " #" 8" 8" 8"## 8!# " # 8"8" !# " I > < "# I(> ## 6 I 8" 5" I > 8!" " 6 1* 000 @" #" !"# # #" @"#M
3 "# 8 # #" 8"## 8!" < = 8" "# I %#I M
38"## #(!5"#I#"#I#"# 5 F"###" 5# FM
,-./*,-001 21,/02 @3# @ M
F3""#8"#@"##=#" #I# M
(38 # "8"!58"" #@ 3 - @#88"# "5!#" #B
3 #@" 8"8"(5"#"#3.-:# 5# 5 M
>38"## I M
3 8"## 8"5# 8" # I # ## 8> < 8" 5! =# @##"#7"I #M
3# 8" 8##I %; M
3>"I!###" @ 7"# !6I #"# 3
13 ;87 ; 8" !"# 9# 8"! "H 8" ;"!< #! 7" 8/"!>"/444-:@!5" " -00- !"# < 9# 8"! # 8 # ! # E(# 5 !!# @ # 8 8"# "5 !#" # @ F"# 6 ;"#3 . 3 - # <; 85# )#" ! 6 "" 8"5# ;E" ;# 5 #!"# 5;"#3.3/#3 3"!@7"8" "6"")#"8" " >@!!""C $ D-J#-00+ CR3-1+,-00.D3
#"")# $ @ "<9#8"!5"!8"#" #! 8 # 6 # # %2 8 <; # ## "!!"# 8" #"5 "! ! " ; 8"#3 "5" < 9# 8"! #"#" # E8"!# 6 # # %2 C"#3 1 7F# ./ #>" /4+1 " I" 5 # "5 5#2 %D3 :3 ;"!##! 8" 8#9#8"!# @ <; ;#8!#!8"!58" "8"## 8!# "3
43 $" # @@# ##" < 9# 8"! @ F"# 8 E8"!# # "5 !#" # "# # !!#@ #88"# "5!#" #3
"5;# 5 #!"# 5F>;>"58"5#; # 5 #! ! < " ! !8# E"! % 6 ;!#"F" C "# 5 "# 8"## 8!# " O -01.D3 # 5" < ;!!"# !F !!# "5 # @"# 6 8"" 8# < !!# "5 6 8 8"" 8# # E(# 5 C "# 58"! #! O-0*:D3
,-./*,-001 2:,/02 @# 8" " @" " ##" 8 # C #"8"!## ##!"D3 % #E# ## " 7" ;# 8 ># " 8 " #"8"!## 2 #8 >9F"("("5!" #> 8"#!"!FF#"# 5;#" 8 # #E#C #"8"!## =#!# <D>#8" 5 F 7"#; #!")# 8"#!F! C #"8"!## #!!F <D < 5#! #" # <; ""# ## #"5E 8"!8"# " C #"8"!## ( #" <D3 <8" 8 # #E##!F# 8"##C $/./ 40 3+3//-4-A. 3*3/#"")# #!M5 " $/.01/ 3+3-/.0*0 3.3-3//-4.*A 3.3./-4/A* 3.3* -:+ 3+3-#"!@!"D3
= "5" < !F #" 5 # 8" ># !#" " " # "! 68"## 8!# " ; 8"#" "5# " @"# " 8" < ## E8"!# 8"!5 < !!#"5#@"#E< 5 #!#!"!5 #)#"8" 8#; ;=5 #8" # 3$#8"# #"5 " ! # " 87 # #" = 8" 8"## # 88!##<8"> "F"# @ # E8" #!"5 88"##"5 # @ C "# 58"! #! O-014D3
#< 8"# 8 55 # )#"8" !"# 3 < 8"# # !#" " 5!" #> ## ! < >!!@ " E 8"## 8!# "3 ;F # @"!# 6 8"" !"# ;>""; #!"!@ 8!#"" 8"## 8!# "">#< #;"""5 E >!!@ " "# ;"25 # "5 5# # ;"2 5 #! #"5# > C $ //1 -4/ 3 .>M % /441 O.183///D3" #7" F""@ #<;"!8"H 59# 8"!3 5 8# <; "# 8"# ## "H "8"!# ">"# @" 3 ;F # 7 " ; # " 8# # !# -*G6<8"!! $ "")#-J#-00+8# )#""#3
= ##"<5<8"!!; ! /09 #-001##8#9#8"!!>"/444 6 -00.;8"##;!# -*G;#"8"##"! #6/;410@"3 # ">"# # "!! 6 ; #!"! 8# )#" < @ "!3
/03 5"# I"#3 -* 3 / 8"## J# #(! 5# )#" "# #!3
,-./*,-001 24,/02 8 /"95 "-00.## 8 # #88 ># 7"8"## C"#3/"3/ ""!# 5;"#3- D3
< ";> F# "# #"#;"#3-*3/ @ # < "8"" "!F## ;"#3 +1 3 / % < !# # 9< 6 88 > # "## # 8" "5 " 8" F ;#" " # " C#" N" "# ## 8"## J# #(! B "# F!!" " # " -00.83/+488! #83/A13
//3 I"" ; #!"! 8"H 8"## E< I5 # 8 " #M#7"#"# #"6I 3
/-3 8" 8! ;> F# "# #" 88 @"!# 6 9" 8" "68"8;"#3+13/ %;"#34* C $ /-4//0 3/3//-A-. 3+>/---/ 3..A: 3.# "")# #!D < # "8 # ; " !"# ; "!5 8"!"! 2@"28"<8"## # !#! ! C N% 83 #3 # - "#3 -*M ( R "" %Q 5" ("F"(# " -00. S +- 83 -14M F" R$, (" # TU % "> #5" ("F B % % -00.83.0+53V68"8;"#34* WMX"F RUR#QF % @ ""F> , ""F Q F %Q 5" ("F"(# B F#Q X>" F %Q 5" ("F"(#V %W% #2-00.83-0:M $/.0./4D3
/.3 ; < ; #!"! 5 # "H 9# 8"! 8 /0 !>"-00/#6<!#!!#> "88"#;<)#M ;F #6;@ # 5 8"##!5"#>!<#3 # "!5 ;"#3*.3/ #7""! 3
/+3 %;"#3-*3- " #""# ## I!# #8"7 # L I # ## I" @ # 8 #" < 8"7 5"# 8"## 3 "!# 6 ; #!"! ">"# 8"## J# 5"! -1 @!5" " -00- ; F ! ; 8"7 5 " 8" "88"# ;<)# /0 !>"-00/3!F#"8#!! <3
/*3 "" #2 "9#! !## "88! < ; "" #Y# 8"!# "")# #"! @" ! 9## 6 "" ;F # " 3
,-./*,-001 2/0,/02
#$ / # #
"
3 4 0
/3 !""""5>3
" 4
-3 "#5! /09 #-0013
.3 @ " ;# ! -1 @!5" " -00- .0 9 -00* # ./ -0013
+3 9##""3
*3 #<8"!"#F"# #3
A3 # < 8" < #" # E 8"## 8!# " @!!" 8"# 85# @"" "" #" 8"!# "")# ! .0 9" 7 # @ # 8"7 " >@!!"C%(Z Q"(@< AA00+ D8" 5 ""# 7"" #8> @"!#E"#3:- @!!"" " >@!!"/19 -00*C $DM! """ # <" # @ # = 8"5 # 8"#" F#" ""# # "M # )#" "! " > @!!" 8" 5 8#8"5 !#" <E # ;"#3+- $38"!#"")## 8 78 ""# 5<!=8"5 5# )#"9 #6;5 3 F"@@ 7" "! # " 2 T " [
8 @"8"!#"")### @ !E8"# <I6I@@ @!!" " 8"F"@@
,-./*,-001