Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/884/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/884/2007 Generato dall'IA

Negligence in Rear-End Collision Based on Following Too Closely and Speed

Numero d'incarto ATAS/884/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The plaintiff sought to recover for damages sustained when the defendant's vehicle struck the rear of the plaintiff's vehicle in a chain-reaction collision, asserting negligence based on following too closely and excessive speed. The court upheld the jury's finding of comparative negligence against the defendant, reasoning that the evidence presented supported the conclusion that the defendant failed to maintain a safe following distance and operated the vehicle at a speed inappropriate for the conditions, thereby causing the collision and subsequent harm to the plaintiff.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Negligence in Rear-End Collision Based on Following Too Closely and Speed: The court upheld the jury's finding of comparative negligence against the defendant, reasoning that the evidence presented supported the conclusion that the defendant failed to maintain a safe following distance and operated the vehicle at a speed inappropriate for the conditions, thereby causing the collision and subsequent harm to the plaintiff.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
tamponamento velocità eccessiva responsabilità per incidente stradale sorpasso non consentito delitto di fuga corresponsabilità della vittima

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision governing court costs applied in the final orders.

Art. 64 LTF

Provision governing legal aid applied in the final orders.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

           %()*+,(-..+ %%(,(-..+

%#

  &%" %&&%" # %%&#  %"#

/0  - ! -) 1 -..+ 



 !"#$$% &!'( ( )"(  !*"(  +(  ,-("'.



(

//     * -- 0      (!" 12% 

            ! ""#$ ""#%&& '!   !

   0$320  

#& % 

#7 80'9(:"#2;5(0(<( ='(>(" *"&"(  /(?>*!' "&!(>(" "7

$7 #$)!@#222(*(@"?* = (    ()7

A7   ''(  $ ! $666    .&   ! (((((?=!'9( !"(''.& * = (   '(( " ?  (!"B( ( )( >  =!  !((( '  ")  *("( (@ ! >* "(( ( >* )   'B  '(( 0 "')  &C " (  '("D*1)(' ''((."'(>!'"!(7

57   '.& * (- !? !" 0(7 0(( ''( ; E$666!!'@>" (  !("&"'(   'B (  ?  " "   >( ((B C( @  '  !((  .BB    !(  (( ((7  "(( '@ "&!(>">(B! *" (! ""  !@("  B=  *(( " ')>  &C  ( ()(" ( > *((  !( *(  '".  B   !'(  ' 7   ''(  #; F( $666  !" 0 B!(  ''"( '"" ( ( (( !! G '@ >  ( ()(" ! ( @'  B  *!'  & " *( B''1(" (! "" * (  !(H7

;7  (  #A F( $66$  (  "'"  !   '(( *0) (" )( *( * ( ? *(&(   -  8B7 !>!'"!(B&( !  '((:7

I7 *//     * -- 0    80'9  :  (" !(! - 7

%7  " %E$665- B"((( *) ("( !(B>'( &BB()(B"?#6J7-(?*''(  (  -   B!" (( " ' "  ''(  $A '(!@ $6657  (( >  !'  & 85A*I6% B7 ' (    #222 "(" ' $66A !'" ?  5$*666 B7 ""$66A: (?) (" A%J7(B(   ""&=7 @ "((>((("



3#4%53$66%  0A320    )  ( '  '     *(((  (   '" ' ( )(* 7

47  )   > '"9  ( BB  &("  ='( (.'" >  (7

27  (  '"(  .& (.'" >     ''(#6!$66I7 '9)'" "?*!9'B!(  "(  '( ( '" "  (( >  >*? *=!   &'. B&(   *='(  '" !! &( ) "''(" ()(('9($ ! (  )!@ #222 .K  '(( ( )  "  @E()7 *='(   > *()(" =" E>* "(( G (( ? B( =&@!((")(!('(9&BB()! (7   !( '( ")(!( C( (9 9(!( !"   .& )!(!'((*(($ ! (H!)*@ "@E()&B()*='(''>*B(!'(    '(( (  ' *( '  (!(!7 -*1 E( *@ (( '! *(@$666>B('?*='( >  (( ( (@" (  E(B  C(  () !C!  *()(" 7 .">!(((*'>*!"7

#67  " $)$66%* B"((( *) ("( @  *='(!" 7

##7  #5!$66%(('"@!(?>* ='(( "''!(?*(  "(&? > (= *) (" ((B="(( ")(  "'7@((9&'9?*''>BB(B ( '"  AI*666 B7  #222 ? #4*;2# B7  $66A ' $%*AA$ B7  $6657  ''( *='((( ." !L*='( +(  ( '@  ()   'B ?   #66 J (((( *('(>((()("'(C(!?(( (  !((  & BB( )  ! (7   'B  (<0 (?  (<?*  !(( *( B''> "( *&   B7  !"  (" 8 (  B7 ': ( '   ! >  (@ ')( ) !!">@  !(( * 7!! ''((."'(>')(C(B((*1' (!!  (@( *"(( ("B(>**1('  ((!" 7

#$7   "'  #$ E $66% *  (  E(  7   "B9 (!(?*='((.'" >>)C(')'@((



3#4%53$66%  05320   > B! * *) "!  #; F( $666 '  (  !" 0 - !"&!('"(.&(.'" >7

#A7  (  $$ E $66%  )    *='( (.'" > (  *((  *BB(* ( @  " ";E($66%(' "(!!( (( 7

#57 ' $4E$66%( >"!(7-> "("& "?E&7

#;7  C(  #I F( $66%  @  "  E("    !(9 * (7

#&  

#7 B!"!( ? *(7 ;I 7 # (7  .7 $    &)  *&( E  8:  @ (    +(  ( >  ((( '") ? M( ;I    B" "   '( &""  (     I (@ $666 8 : > ( ()?B" "M0) (" #2E#2;28 :7

-!'"('E&  M'9("(@7

$7 B" "'(&""  (  I(@ $6668 :((")&#E)$66A(+(! B( !@ '("&  ! 7- '!("'( )> (*''> (C((."?!9 ''>9&''@()&!!(L B(E >!( "(!((' (8 /#A6$A6 7#7#D AA; 7#7$D /#$25 7#7$D /#$%5I% 7##$I#AI  75@("B":79& '" >(?*''>( ") 9E (")&8 /##%2A 7I@##$AI6  75D  #224NA%'7A#I 7A@:7 M''>   M'97( !C! *) (" ( # E) $6657  (   B" "  #I "!@ $66; ! B(   B" "*0) ("((")&#E($66I8$66I $66A:''( ! B(>((!!('"  ( )(  @ (   8(7;$ ;4 ( I# (7   :7  '('"  !(9 ((('((*( B '(( *  )( @ "( "!! ? B E(> )((($66B7(#*666B78(7I27#@  :7  *'9  '"(  ( !  ) ( 8.7 (7  '(((()?! B( #I "!@$66;:7



3#4%53$66%  0;320   A7 (E(" B!( "'")'()@8(7;I? I6 :7

57  >( (&  *'9 (  "(!   (  ( ?  ( *) ("7

;7 = (!  *(7 4 7 # ( A   ( "'(" ) (" M'("  & (('(>('"!"'!( & "7-M(75   *) (" '( "( * B!(" &"( * !   *  (7( "'(" '("  () (( '( ((  '(  M'((  M"? !' 'B ! M()(" () > '( C( @!( C( =&"    (( '( "(   ("'.1>!(7 M'(" () & "M()(" >'(C(=&" '() M('B M( ! M()("8(7I :7("'("'(" &(( !( M!@ M'( '@(" & M"!."  ()">@">( "((( !("( M((( ?  (" '.1>  !( ( >M '( '9  ((!( (  ! " '((=&@8(7% :7

-  E'   ( *) ("    (    (  ( "!> (  !" D  (  "> "!> @E()  *'(" B( >* !'( *") 8 / ##6  $%;  7 5 #6;  $6%  7 $:7 (B ' ')   &" *) (" * !(( 8  E& * 1    :  @  !(>*!" ")(!( *('"( )(B7 (O. !" (?'(E&!(*"(( ("(? > >!('>()("*"('@ ()7 (  " !"  (((  ""!( ( ' "(! > ()= ( @!( =&@   '(  *" 8 / #$;  $I#  75##;#A5 7$##5A#5 7A#6;#;4 7#:7

 *0) (" *((  B( *  !"   B    ''( !" ((( ("?*BB *0) ("='( !"  "' ( *((( *=!'(>"' ( *@)(!"  *  8 /#$A#%;:='(' ( ''(>='(!"  "'E& '!9   9 ( 8- #22% '7 A#4  7 A@D    '"   !(()  0) (" (.9 /@& #222 '7 #5$:7   *")(  *) ("  (O.  !"  ( ? '(  E&!(  *"(( ("(? > >!('>()("*"( '@ ()7( "!" (((""!(( ' "(!>()='(@!(=& *"

8 /#$;$I# 75("B":7



3#4%53$66%  0I320   I7 -  ''  @ ''"(  ') '!( )@  '" E    ! 8B7(7I# (7 :E&*('"' 9&B!! (=!  !9@E()(!1 ')>>*(')' "  !(? '('!((( '(E&!()@  ( (&=7    ''( !" = ( (  E&  '( (.*BB''"*!@ ')( > ' >   B    ' !"  (  '   (7 *""!( "(!( '  ) '@( * ''( !"  *(   & "&(!(7 ("& !'(>'( (&=!'(((B(*@E( *"( B">''(B   =! !'( >* ' "&!(   "(  '( ='!">*("(""(@'  8!9:> '(  (B" !"  (  ( B >    *='( ( @ !()"7 - !((    ''   @ ''"(  ')  @ B" "    '"  & (>!9 *''"((1' *='( ''(!" =8 /#$;A;$ 7A:7

>(  '"  !(()='(B"? !"   "' ( ( "(@ '  '"(    @ *@)( ''B  ( *)(&( !'9(  >* '   (>*='(@((? "(()(E& ("(&(!'>* ('!(  ( @0B "8 /#$;A;A 7A@3@@:7

*'(( (((  *='(!"  (! BB9!(    !"  ((( (!!( >* '9  ?  =! @E(B   ((!"  '='(">*''((((>* B( BP((("(>=>@(( *''(    "( !"  (   E&!(  )7 * '(  ) B! *='( B ') * ( (   '' @((()>')(=(  !!" ( ( E(Q ' =!' * ( ((  (." >  B( ' *@E( *   ( ((    >*  & (  ( ((  "> >(?7B''( *='(" &" !9@ ( @  (( >B( "'"(   (  ( ? (( @E()  )(  (( &> B >  ( ' !'   .!!( (( ( (B> ?  @  *) >* ='! 8) ?  E(   *='( ( *='( 0 (9  ) ("  *='(!" '7#7> R STE&(*='(0' 1 '!!'".'&#AA7Q*='(!" " ( "  U S1&9 $66$D "&!( / #$;  A;$  7 A #$$  #I6  7#("B":7



3#4%53$66%  0%320   %7  *'9 B (  +( > *='( (.'" > BB(" '  (  )C(  ' ) '@(7  BB(  '( (&=!'(((B(*@E( *"( B"''(B   =!!'('  "('(='!""(""(@  '    8!9 &"" ' B! ( :( *='(((@!()"7  ( B( !' Q *=!   ! (  ( ? (( *@  (!"B()@ *"'.!(''@(!@("!@'&C" *=(  &((!'9(!!*!() (''0 '!!7*=!( !B>* ! (  !")( ** =( *   0! B!@1!"(>@!(("&!((("7 *( '(" ()(91!' *()(" > (('*='(7 '''0(0'@(9")(!((9 "&9 !(   !(7  9) ((B >  (( * ' > *!" >  (( ( (@" ( >*  '(( (    (!' *(7

 ( '. =)!( ? *='( *) '   ( (7  ' ? ) ' (  >   ( ( (7*'( )@E(B*1' "> * (( '(" ()(!'9(7*='( !( @( 9) * ")((9"&9 !(  !((!()  "( (('(!'( 0>B(>B) '@( *='(7*!!9)* !" 0   -  )( = !C!   1  "E? '  = 7  (!"B( (("  *=(( '  !!(  *='(  > B! * "  *='( >  (( *( (@"7 V ( "&!( >* !"   '"(   (7   (9 "&9 !(   !((!'@'=!''*&!(( !@ *.  ()7  B( '' >  ( ( ( "  *(' ! "&!("0&"( 07

(  )  ( ( @" ' #222  ' =(!( ( B("7    '( ( > *( *((( ?  (" '.1> >  ( '@7*='(B!> BB(">+(( *='(( &&(' ?* (>"&!( "("( ()?* (7''"&!(> *'9  E'   ''>  !9 &""   !  *0) ("''>)  ()( >"  '(( *0) ("('  ''.B((>* '( @!( ((    ' (("  != '@  ">   ) ("D *( '>  " * ' ( ?  ( >*(!@.&( 'B *@()



3#4%53$66%  04320   =(  ) (" )( ( ?  ( 8  '' &""  ( ) /#$A$AA 7A##%$%4 7$@566  7 5@ (  C( (":7  " '(( ' 0!C! (  '(  *@&(  !  !!& ( '!  @  ( ?  ( >*?   !  " '(( 8(7 $# 7 5  :7  (  BB()!( )B"  ()("  "@((  !!  )( * ()("  >   +(  !(( B(7 ' (((()("*('(@) '9!'(@' (  ' >(' ( *) ("7

47 '(C(>E("7









3#4%53$66%  02320  

% #   "#  &%" %&&%" # %%&#  %"#

!

%  20

#7 ")@7

%! 2

$7 E((7

A7 ("!!( $66B7?.& (7

57 B!  '(   >M ')( B!  (  '"( C(   "  A6 E 9  (B( '9  @ B" " 8-.WK.B>II665  :') !(9  ( '@B!"!(=(74$ B" " @B" " #% E $66; 8 /:D  !"!   (  >   !(B ( !1 ')('(&( ( ! (D ( C(  "  @ B" " ' ) '(  ' ) "(> =  (  *(7 5$  /7  '"( C( (  '9  '  ()>"!!!1 ') )(C(E(?*)7  &BB9  '" (         RX , @-   

'B! '"(C(((B"='(>M?MBBB" " '&BB



3#4%53$66%