Water Rights Allocation Dispute Based on Statutory Priority and Beneficial Use
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed challenges to the validity of several prior decrees regarding the division of property rights in water use among various claimants who draw from a shared source. The reasoning focused on interpreting the controlling statute, which established priority dates for water rights based on the time of initial beneficial use, and applying the physical realities of water diversion and use to determine the extent and priority of each party's established right, ultimately affirming or modifying the earlier allocations based on adherence to these statutory priority principles and established factual findings concerning priority dates and actual diversion volumes.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Water Rights Allocation Dispute Based on Statutory Priority and Beneficial Use: The reasoning focused on interpreting the controlling statute, which established priority dates for water rights based on the time of initial beneficial use, and applying the physical realities of water diversion and use to determine the extent and priority of each party's established right, ultimately affirming or modifying the earlier allocations based on adherence to these statutory priority principles and established factual findings concerning priority dates and actual diversion volumes.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to order the payment of court costs.
Applied to rule on the allocation of legal fees to the respondent (who did not file a response).
Testo completo
%&'()%*++( %,,'%*++(
!!
- !.- -!
/0 1 2 # & 3 2 *++(
4 - - ! !' " !#$%$&! '(! )*
!'
56666666666 ' #
! "#$
1/+21
4
,3 /4!%#5/00/67777777777'8 $'! '95' 9# ' ' #:! !%' !$;$( !%$;8%!< 8!9 ! % % %' ' % $ ' $ '!%' = ! % %9!$' ! $8' ! >8!; ' '' !88' % ! ;' 40 $ ! 9$ 8%!< 8!9 ! % % %'' % $ '$/*? ,.@/11A 18BC; ' '' !88' %D3
''!%' !''% ,!%#5/00/3
/3 /. ?% /00) ;#8!< #8 % $ #'' ! $ 8! ;/00)#' !'9#8!<3
)3 /*!%#5/00); ' '' !88' %$=;#8!<5!$ $!' 5' !#!''$93,)E.,@31' 98 !$$;!'!5=$#5 /00)8!9#8!<$!'93,E-/0318! &3&77777777773 ' '8 F#!''$% 'G'%$)0?!3
-3 .9% /00-; ' '' !88' %%!< =;#8!<!##' ! $ % ##$ '#' #!'' $ 93 ,-E/-@340 F !8!$ ' > 8 # #8< ! 5!$ $ /* !%#5 /00) #?! $ 93 ))0340 $; 'G'$5!#'A),$#5/00)D3
#=;#8!<$9 $!##' !$93,0031'; 9!#F $ 9 $ !'' > ' 8% = $9' $ 8 #' $ 93 ,0031 = 93 ,*0313
*3 ,@ 9% /00- ; ' '' ! 88' % : $ ;#8!< % $ ' !$88!'$'% $;#8!<&77777777778!)0% /00)3
43 /*#/00-; ' '' !88' %F 8! '$93,-E-.@340 F93/*031$9 $!##' !'!'' >3!##$#'$8< #!'''!' 9 =;#8!</.% /00-F9 '!88! ' !3
23 ,? /00-; ' '' !88' % '=;#8!<8! $#$$ ?' 9 $ $ $ ,0 ?! ! !88! ' ! ! 8! ' 3 ;#8!< ;88!$=! 3
@3 /*? /00-; ' '' !88' % 5'!$ ! $;$#$!'=!$#' !$;#8!<8 #' $93,-E/-@3408 'G'=*H;$B/-9% /00-'=93/*031$9 $!##' !'!'' > F;=%$;!88! ' !3 !'##' % F 'G' 8% $ !#8' !' 8 # = I' ' '$%'$;' -$!%' !$;$( !3
+,)-.+/00- 1)+21 .3 /* ? /00- ; ' '' ! 88' % '# = ;#8!< % $ !#8'!'!'8 #$,4?% /00)/*? /00-9 ' 88J'!$$93/*E4//319%$; ' '' !88' % F; % $ !#8' !' 8! ' 9 ' 88J' !$ 9% $ ; ' '' ! 88' % $ 93 )*E-.23,*3 ' ' #' ! F $ % ' ' '!' 9 ' ;!5?' $; 8! ' F %#''5! 9 ' !$!8' !3
,03 $ ,0 !K' /00- 8!! ,0 8'#5 /00- ' #8' = ;#8!<8 5$8!8!$=$#$3;#8!< ;'8>'3
,,3 /0 8'#5 /00- 5 $ $#$ = ; ' '' ! 88' % 8! F #!' 9 #!'' $ 93 ,E-/031 ' ' # = ;#8!< 8! &3&7777777777$B!F 1 % 'F '';'8 )0% /00)3
,/3 4!'!5/00-; ' '' !88' %8!$F;!'$$ '9% $;#8!<% ''99'/-9% /00-!##''' '8 B< ' %#!''$93,E-/0318!8 !$$;!'!5=$#5/00)= '$;!8;#8!<,@9% /00-$ ' !$!''$ '% $&3&77777777778!)0% /00-3 $ '% '9 ';!5?'$; !#8' !%$!' 5' ! $!%$!#8'$4 !K'/00-8!8 !$$),$#5/00)/0# /00-3
!
,3 ! %! ;! ' !?$ AD'#!$ 9 ' ' '$B ,!K'/00) 5'!$! !#8!$*? $!' 8 $' ' % 18 $' * 88' ' ,4 ? A'3 , '3'*4 D3
" '=;' !$;' !$,4?8 59$ /2?% /00-A L,)0,04D$ ! %! $!8',)9% $ 8! ' !' '! '8#''' 5'!$ ! $ = '! ? ' ' $ ;''' $ ;' !$!%>?3
"''' ! $$! '85 59$$G'$, ? ' /00- !9 # F $ 8! ' ! ' '! !' ' ' !' ! 8 ' !'' '!9!#$!J'$! '9$A L,)0//4D3
/3 '?'$%'? $ ' !!#8''$#$'%5A'3*43, '35'40 D3
)3 "!;'3-,3,' !!%#'$8 %'8 FF$8!''$!' ' !!$8'' !8 !$ F8
+,)-.+/00- 1-+21 $ > $ ' 3 '3 ,/. ' ,-/ $ !$ $ !5 ' ! !' 88 53 ;8B !' ' ! 88!'' = 8 !$ $;!'!5 = $#5,..)$$#$;'88 '3
-3 "! ;'3 / 3 , !' !# = ; !5 '! F !' 8 $ ,2 ' :! %' $; #G# #8!< 8 = 93,-E@@031'#'93/*E)/031A'3*$;$!$,@% ,.@- 8%!<8!9 !% % %'' % $ '$'$)0 !'!5/00/D3 >'#$;'344; ' '' !$8%!<9 >$ $ 8! ' ! #' #!'' $ !' ' ! $ ;#8!< ' $ $ 3 !## $ !' ' ! A!' 5' !D $ ;#8!< $! ' G' #! = !## $ !' ' ! $ '! 3 !' 5' ! $ ;#8!< 8' G' 9 > 8 (' F;% ! ' #' A3 ,D3 ;#8!< ' $5 ' $ '!' ' $ !' ' ! % ; ' '' ! $ 8%!<3 1 8' #?! $; 'G' #!'! !' ' ! 8< '$ %#' A3 /D3 ;#8!< $$ ' $ !' ' ! F $ 8! ' !#' #'''=($ A3)D3
*3 ;8B !%' ! $;$( ! %! ! '3 / = ;'''' ! $ % $ ' B#' $ ; ' '' ! 88' %3 B#' $ !' 5' ! /00) 8!' $ !!$! A 18BC B#'D8%! '!' 5' !$,-@H8!(!##'/*')- ,@/H8!(!##')*'--'/)4H8!(!##'-*' *-3
5 $ !'' F !' ' ! !' ' !'#' 8!#8!<!/00)88 ' !$B#''5$ '$;M$#8!<$8;#8!</.?% /00)$ ;% $ #'' ! $ 3 "! ' '> $ !' ' ! $ ,-@ H 8! #8!<'>$,@/H8!'! #8!<''>$/)4H8!F' #8!<3
%(!' ' !$93,E-/031!#$&3&7777777777;'8$ $B ! F 1 ' !' $ $ )0 % /00) ' F !' ' ! 88!' = 8 !$ $;!'!5 = $#5 /00)3 99' ;'3,03/8%! 'F;!5 ' !$;G'= $$! ' > 8'' ! $ % !'##' $ $ !' ! $ 88!' $ '% 3
9 ' %! !' $ $ ' #8' % $ !#8' $ 4 !K' /00- $#$ 8%' #8 '#' $ 8! 5 ' $ !#8 $$9$ $8! '! '93,E-/031%$ !' 5' !8!8 !$5F'),$#5/00)3"!$!' '? 8$!#8' !$ 8!F!' '8 8 ? $ F$! '8 %>'3,/0$ !$$!5 ' !$)0
+,)-.+/00- 1*+21 # ,.,, A D F '!% 88 ' ! $! ' $# '' 93 $! ' $ ! 8 8' B#' 8 8 ' ! #G# $ 5($$! 'F 8%! '8>8#'N$#'88' $! $;! ! '#'' !8 9 FA L,,0 ,@*! $3/D3
!'9! # B $ 8!$ $ $#$ ' G' % 3 99' !#5 5$$% 9 5 19!$$9 ' ;!5?' $ 8! ' ' 3 ,@ 9% /00- ! ' ' #' = F ' !$8! ' ''8$#$1 ! $ !' $ &3 &7777777777 $ ;'8 ' !F $ 9 ' F !' ' ! ' % = ' #8!< 8! #!'' $ 93 ,E-/031 ;' ' 8 $3 ;< 8 = !#8' ! $ ' $B ! F $#$ ;'8$5 ' $$9$8!#!''8 '3 '' 8 >#8 $9$;' 'F ''8$$ '#!''8B$ $#$F ;'8;8B3
9 ' % F ;#8!< F !## ;8B % ! ! !5 ' ! $;!'$#!$ 9 ' !$;99' 9$!8!A'3-3/ $!%' !$;$( !D$! '88!'!K'' 'F ''$ % !' !$$%! $; 9!#A'3-3/8 'D3$#$8'$ 8=?'' 'F;!'$ %$!' $&3&7777777777$ $ '$$O!K'P!$O 'P$!%' ! $;$( !3
43 !9!##' = ;'3 44 3 / ;#8!< ' $5 ' $ '!' ' $ !' ' ! % ; ' '' ! $ 8%!<3 1 8' #?! $; 'G' #!'! !' ' ! 8< '$ %#'3 '> $; 'G' $'# 8# ! !%' ! ! 8 8' $ !'' $ 8%!<'=$9'!$ 8! ' ! 'G'#!'! $ '3,0/3 A",..-Q/83*! $3)5+N" ",..083,4,! $3 -5D3 >'#$;'3,0/3, $5 '$;!5 ' !> 5'# $# 8 ; '8' ! $ 3 !F ?! $ ;>' ! ' $'# $;!##!$!9 >8;$8' %'$;$! '= %'#!<$;%' #' $5 ''# $# 8>8 ' !$?!A'3,0/3/ D3$5 'F '$# 8!8 #'$;!##$;'$! ' 'G'#!'! =*HA L,/2 ).0 ! $3 *+55 ' 9D $ # !R '> $; 'G' 8 %;8'!%8!''A'3,0-3,'/ D3"!;'3,0*3) $ 'G' 8%' G' 8!' !#8' 8! $ '$ $ 'G'#!'! A" "/00)83*00! $343,N L $/4!K'/00- ,04+0)D3
;8B !%' !$;$( !8%! ' F#'F$ 'G' #!'' ! 8< !' $ A'3 - 3 )D3 !F !% ' $ 9
+,)-.+/00- 14+21 88 ' ! $; '> $; 'G' $ * H $B # $# $ ;#8!< ' ;> 5 '$;!5 ' !3 '$;'3-3)$!%' !$;$( ! 8%! ' F !' 5' ! !' 9' ' #' #' = '# (3 !' ( = (F , # , ? , 8'#5 ' , $#5 ' 8<5 $ )0 ?! F %' (3 $ '$ $ 8 #' ; ' '' !88' %8'$ 'G'#!''!8<3
!F$93,)E.,@31'''85!$$/*!%#5 /00)SF88!'>!' ' !$8!$ ' #'$;S '> 5$8 ),$#5/00)! ')0?!8B,$#5/00)3
''; 'G'$*H8'G'8%$B,?% /00-3 ' #'= ''$'$9$'!% '8'$$8 #'3!#!' 9 ; 'G' $ 5!#' #!'' $ 93 ))0340 ), $#5 /00)8$#$5$;'3-$!%' !;'8$K3 '8!#G##!' 9F>'$; L $/4!K'/00- ,04+0)!88!'=$#$1 ;'8! 8$! '$#=$9$$O 'G'$5!#'P %'$;!#8'!'8' ;''8 8!''$!#8' !'3 ' $ L ? F ;> '' $ % ' ' O!#8' !' 8 #P ' O!#8' !' 8! 'P ' F; !' #' ' '5 $ $;8B !' 8 99 ' 8! $#'' F 8' ' ' 8!''$!#8'!'A L 8 '! $3-D3
23 % $ F 8B$ $#$ ' 9!$ = (' $ #!'' $ 93,/E-.@31A! '93,-E/-@340ST93,E-/031U93))0340VD% 'G'=*H; $B,?% /00- F93/*031$9 $!##' !'!'' > $ ''8%8;'3-$!%' !$;$( !'$;>=1 3
+,)-.+/00- 12+21
! 4 !.- -!
# 78 9 : ;$ &/* "
8
,3 $#$%5N
# 8
/3 ;$#'8' #'N
)3 !$#677777777778 #'$93,/E-.@31% 'G'=*H;$B , ?% /00- F;=93/*031$9 N
-3 B%;!88! ' !!##$#'$8<8! 'Q0-,-2.*2 =(' $93,/E-.@31% 'G'=*H;$B/-9% /00- F;=93/*031$ 9 N
*3 9!# 8' $ F; 8%' 9!# ! !' 8' G' $ $ $ )0 ?! $B !' 9 ' ! 8 8 !##$ $ 5 9$ $ "(W X(!9F 4 400- '! >#8 3 $ 8' G' 8!!3 ##! $! 'C D $ F >'#'F$ !!'$ !5' '8$$ ! ''FN 5D >8! 8! F #!' 9 ' # 8!%! $#$ '' ' $ !N D 8!' ' ! $ ! 8''3 " ##! !' ' 8 '! #' # ! '' D 5D ' D 1$ 59$$8!8'#' B!F; $%$ %53##! $!#' !!#!< $ 8% F !' ?! ' F $ ! ''F ' ;%!88 $ F'>8$ !'A'3,)/,04',0@D3 99 BC $'C <" &
!8 !9!#$8'G''!' 9 >8' F;=;99 9$ $! 899
+,)-.+/00-