Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/881/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/881/2005 Generato dall'IA

Breach of Contract Claim Negated by Plaintiff's Proximate Cause

Numero d'incarto ATAS/881/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The litigant sued the defendant for breach of contract, arguing that the defendant failed to perform under the terms of an agreement concerning specific financial instruments and resulting losses, while the defendant countered with several affirmative defenses, including that the contract was voidable due to misrepresentation and that the plaintiff failed to mitigate damages. The court ultimately ruled for the defendant, finding insufficient evidence that the defendant committed a material breach, and instead determined that the plaintiff's own actions, particularly concerning risk assessment and timing of transactions, were the proximate cause of the claimed financial harm, thus negating liability for the alleged breach.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Breach of Contract Claim Negated by Plaintiff's Proximate Cause: The court ultimately ruled for the defendant, finding insufficient evidence that the defendant committed a material breach, and instead determined that the plaintiff's own actions, particularly concerning risk assessment and timing of transactions, were the proximate cause of the claimed financial harm, thus negating liability for the alleged breach.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
ricorso per risarcimento danni violazione positiva del contratto responsabilità contrattuale danno patrimoniale procurato con astuzia transazione finanziaria perenzione in diritto commerciale

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for ordering the appellant to pay the court fees.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

                !"#$ !$$%  &&' !$$%

((

 ( ) ))  ()  

*+  !

 '& ,-,  !$$% 



 ! "

"

#   $ ##  %   !"&'"( "./ )*!+*,-   

            

   %*01%  

) . 

+2    3%45  "6  ".  #7 & $%.&3%45# 6!44&*89/7*,,1!7&"(" .4:""("..(*,,;2"&"7<9" ="&""&/4.">;)*$)?192"<7 =".">)*$?1?92

*2 """ <  7 &/"." & " /"" & -?$+;@ 92 38,A & 7="*,,;B+0+1&9"="*,,;6!"&4/ ."&1,$,,,9!# 4+17*,,1&/&9&$"& =&2

;2 "9"44"*)7*,,1!/C"<7&4 7"&./&++$8,*9*,,1!">&"&"72

?2 &/44"&*+D"*,,1!# D"/$44"2

12 &;E"*,,1!"5C<&"C74/7" 4.4"&7""&9"""2 !7" & ;-$-8) 9! C."/ & +15. &  9" ""! <  ." > +;@$?)? 92! &" >  "" & ?-$?8; 92! 9/   ." 4.""" $" &$ =&2

)2   /4 & ;+ E" *,,1!  #  "  D" & 2 F.  4"&/"."""9>"(".4:""( "..(*,,?4&"4"(>!"( &*,,;!&">7&/"."&)?$?;89!4/ ." & 1,$,,, 9 44= >  4  GC /C!  44" & $"*,!2*&&$44"& 3 6!"&"+, " +,= &  5C." &$(/" 3%45  62  99"!  7 &  9" & 4!  " " 4/./  4 F" & &" /.< .&"2  $" & 4   = & $" +,  ! 4"  &/"7"9""!<&"(=&&"F"(./ $45!.=&$"+,!2; !<4/7"4 &/" &$ 7 " &$ 9" =" 4  4 7/ 4 $"*,2*&!.."2

-2 4&14".=*,,1! =".""/""!  &.&"   (4" 9 4  #   "9"!  $ .""2

82 4&+?4".=*,,1!"&</."! ="(4"9C""99&$ ""&57!"7



0*-),0*,,1  %;01%   ( =& &$%.& *,,1!  <$ "(" & $" +, & 5C."2  4  &/" & 7  " " 9" "" & 4 &"  $45! 4 *,,;! >  7 &/"." & ?@$;1, 92! 9/."2

@2  4 & *8 4".= *,,1!  #   4"/ &  2 "" /"/"/"."1"=*,,1"C&/>DC2

) ( 

+2 C7HC"D&36/"/.&9/"""/!&5 +E"*,,;! ="&!.4/&1DC! &"4/&""7%4/&"!144/""+)DC3"2+"2 "1) 62

#">H"&H/"&+)DC!4 =9/&/ *-D7*,,?3 '+;,+,)6!& C7&4"/!+;9/7!  &4"""C"4.""" ="&  & /C   > " DC ""! ! & H""" & H/"&7(DC2

*2 9./." > $"2 1)  2 + "2  G2 ? !  = " & I""<&"""4/7>H" 1)&4"C//&&"&3%45 6 < " "7 >   9/&/  H%.& & +8. +@@? 3 62

#.4/"4DC&&H45"/"=2

;2 "D"/&9."&/4/74!"7=3"21)> 1, ""2;) 62

?2  44" & " )1 " ))  !  " & 57 & & =& &"/ >  7" ""  4" & 4. & $% .&&/&&"/.<.&"3"2+@2+ 62 &/9" & / & &" /.< .&"! "  &/"." & .""&=&&/>/!"&.4/"& &$ "" 3"2 ;! 2 *! "2   62   4/7" 4  <  / < &4"&$9" ="&$7=".4"""4/./ 4F"&&"/.<.&"!>.<$47"< ""D"9$"&=&392"2*,2* 62

 5C." 4/ <$" &// .. .4""   & $" 4/"/9"="<(5&*1,$,,,9!"...4""7 ="<&/4+1,$,,,93"2+,!2+"* 62$/;&""



0*-),0*,,1  %?01%   4/7"<!44!$"%>%&/<&4"&$9" ="  &$ 7  =" .4""! " <  " & 4 &// ../""&&"/.<.&"&$"*,&! 9" 4&  7 =" " 45  &/&" 99" & *,A " $C." & +15. &  9" ="J   ."" ="  &/4 4  .""9C">$"+,=&5C."!/"&">=&2

 7G! < $ $" 4 &   & $" *, 4/"/!  7 &/"." " /C  7  " &/"."  "( &$.4:"   4 &.4:""("..(!C."/&$+15.&9"""3"2 +, & 5C."62  =& " &/ <  7 &/"."  &/44."9(/4 &$ ""!$1,$,,,94 43"2+,=&5C."62

12 "5C."4/7"&&("K4&$/!"4/<"!&( "K4&L/<!&$//."&9"&7! "44/./F"&&"/.<.&"2 "<$ / &4 &$ 9" ="  &$ 7  =" .4""! " 4//45C."J$"%>%&&$9"="<(5&*1,$,,,9" &$ 7  =" < &/4 +1,$,,, 92   /!  &" ( =&"(4!"$&/".47&/"."9(" &" ( =&2  &(5. "/C "  & / 4/./ & &"/.<.&"!$"%>%&!< $"4&$//."&9" &7.4""2 /"K"&"(=&"!47  =& " &E &   4"! "  /G/" < "  ."" & =&! $ 45&   & 7 &/"."! < 4&  7 "&/".""(&$.4:"!C."/&$+15.&9"""2

/"<"9"4"&4.5"/C&$/!"<$  & //." & 9" .4""!  $" 4 4/./ & &" /.<." .&"! " " ( & C4 & K" &" ( =&!   //." & 9" &/4"  ."" & *1,$,,, 92  $K  & 4  &   7 &/"."! " & " .4" 4 /<" & 7""&9"""2

 &/ & #  " 49"." 9.  &"! "  4" F" < 9./2&D"/2



0*-),0*,,1  %101%  

(  / .  ( ) ))  ()  



0-,1,++ 2   3, ,  ,  45 '#! 6

  1,+

+2 /7=2

 1,

*2 D""2

;2 9.  4" &  <H 47" 9.  "  4/" F" &  &/ & ;, D &5  "9" 4 4 ..&/ &/  = 9/&/ & ! #GMNG9< )! ),,?   !  " (.42  &/  4" F" 4C/2  ./. &"L 6 &< ("."<&/"&/=""4&&/ ""</J =6 (4 4 < ."9  ". 47 &.& "" " &/J 6 4"  C"   &  4/""2 #  ./.  "" 4  " //." /.//  "" 6 =6 " 6 %&!  =9/&/&44"."5<H &7&/7=2./.&.".K & 47! < " D"!  <  &/ ""</ " H744 & </"/(4/&/"3"2+;*!+,)"+,862  C995  /&"L             #K7 O P =#

49.&4/"F"""9/(4"<H>H999/&/ &"/4=<4C99





0*-),0*,,1