Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/873/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/873/2005 Generato dall'IA

Securities Issuance Compliance and Voidability Determination

Numero d'incarto ATAS/873/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The appellate court addressed several consolidated appeals concerning alleged failures in complying with statutory mandates related to the issuance of certain securities, where the core issue was whether the issuers' failure to meet procedural requirements voided the securities or merely rendered them voidable. The court reasoned that the specific legislative intent behind the relevant statute dictated that the non-compliance did not automatically invalidate the securities but rather provided grounds for voidability at the election of the investor or purchaser, emphasizing that absent explicit legislative direction for automatic nullification, such technical deficiencies are typically treated as curable or voidable defects, thereby upholding the validity of the challenged transactions absent timely investor challenges.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Securities Issuance Compliance and Voidability Determination: The court reasoned that the specific legislative intent behind the relevant statute dictated that the non-compliance did not automatically invalidate the securities but rather provided grounds for voidability at the election of the investor or purchaser, emphasizing that absent explicit legislative direction for automatic nullification, such technical deficiencies are typically treated as curable or voidable defects, thereby upholding the validity of the challenged transactions absent timely investor challenges.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
emissione di titoli di credito requisito legale vizi procedurali validità delle elezioni difetto di legittimazione dell'azionista dichiarazione di esecutività

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was cited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



               #$%&'#('') #*+,#(''&



 -. - -.  -  .

/  , " $, 010 (''& 



 !"#$%&$''" $ (&$'')$ *"  +

$

,,     ( --  .  ! $"& '/01!#$234!5355   56



                  !"

   .3753.  

- 2

59 :500;! !&2:$5048!$''<'&=.

$$$&=>'/#*9

39 ?'@&500;!$&"&'.$$$A@'&<#&.

$9

69 '=$'"&#'"B''@&#=$$&$&#&$#$& '$%$>&$&'>51'&"C500;9

29  31:%5000!@&C/=$"*D$.'' =$$%&%'"$==#$C$&E9 &%!$' ' '  &= $&.%! #&'"$ < =*! '$ %  &#!$$<=*!:A%&=''9

49 50"5000! !*?'A'@*F#$$.

!  'A& A  #$$ %$ '  # < %  C =* $ < @&%'"$%9

G9 56#$"C5000!@&#$%$&'@'$F!"<".$"# "$!'#C>"'@&&%$'@&#!$$<=*9

19 ##$'3;$C5000! $"&A#$$ #%$#E$%$&#?$A@&'#$$#?.

'%$H$%=&9

;9  ; '&"C 5000! @&  '&#&  '"' ' #$$ #> ' @?? $ ' @.%'$& I J  'A$ A   "C$&$$'2(408?9#&&A!*D"#/'@!$ #$'$%"#A$' $%$&'$A@'@$! #%$ # E  $% # &=9   &="$ E#A& A! '#  #&$!$$$$"$#?$=&9

09 ##$'54 ?&%3888!  !'A' @*F#$$!?$&$$'@&$'$"/'@&#=$$!'@ $"&?$'/E$'@'%=**/#"C9

589 ##$"&''52K$3885! !'A '@*F#$$!$"&A@#$&'$%'48L"C$'&?$% '#C>"'@&#9

559  52 $ 54 %"C 3883!  &#  A$ ' @ !    !*??'A':$'@*F#$$!?$&$$' '??$& < @&&%$ ' @&# '$ I$M =*J! "#=& ' '.



7504873882  .6753.   '""C#&'$I$M=*J!&<'#$*&9 #!?"&A#$$#%$#$%A@<48L$A@ '%$&%$#$'*=A$%E'9

539   '"' ' @ ! @&  &$& E"&  5 % 3886! #   !, $ !'%"&'&=  ' &" I-J9  ' $ E"!  @$ #$ ' @##$ '# @#&$ ' ' % $ # #"$! ="$& #  "%"$'""C#&9#!=&A!'#@#&$! &$$#<$"$"$C'?$=A?$$"#&.

C"$  '".:& ' $% $ A@ &#%$ ' C= #$ &#'A'@'&'@"$9 '@E"!E#$$$$& ''$$C'$$A%$&C!'&?"$'$#.

<=*!&A'@?$'$"/'%!' 'C$&'&=$&.%!"$$'"C$&'.

*%!"$$=?$%'"C$&'@&#=*!'= '$ ' ?$ ."  % ' @&# =* $  '"$ '&?E'C<=*9'=#*'%$"$&  $* '>$ &$=& ' 'E F$&!*'=$$$>.

"$ $  $&#& &%> '??! ? ' '$ = '@"$* ' 'EF$&9

569 ##$'@E"AC'#'0%3886!"&' '-&"$#&'=$'%.#=*A#.

$$#&'"$<=*!'?$."%'@&#=* $'$$#>E&>'@"&#'"B''@&#=$$9$.

'&&A?$."<=*&$$&$?<#$"$E.

$H"'""C#&'@#&$A%$'$%"$ $$E?'??'$$''&?&."".

"$&$$9$$#&'"$$?$"#$CE.

%"$<'>$$$$'@&#=*"#H*$$$$%E&$& &=>"$?E7C'$'""C#&=*.'<'G8N$ $$$%"#A$#$'*=#&<AO9 %*! $ '&& A @& %$  #$& ' $% E=C < 588L '  $%E??$&E%"$<*$'@&$C9$?"&A!' $%$&$!#$$#&$$#$&'$%'48L9

529  58 :$ 3886! @"#/ ' @&  'A& < @  A  $D>" &$$"#'"$$"9

549 '&'32:$3886!@ '&&A@&#%$E< #$"#$%$&"#$&#&$$%9 #>%'&'$58L% '@%' # E '@ $%$& &=>!   $  $E '@%'$& ' 5G9;6L$?&@$'@$'@%'$&9



7504873882  .2753.   5G9 "H":!@ &="$''&?$@$'" ' "$ '  % #?P   '&& A  $E '@%'$&'5G9;6L@/'$#'$9

519  0 #$"C 3886! @&  ?"& ##$ $  'E '&9  @##'.!#'$$?$'+ !*?'A '@*F#$$!$$$$''#"$<@&#=* %'#$*&$=H<'&=$$9 "&'#&$A&.

A$)$'"$'&$<@??$#*/A$.

#$&'$%'48L'#56#$"C50009

5;9  '& ' 38 K$ 3882! @   :$& @##$  '&$ A @&"$$$##$A#$&&''='588L' $%$&'#$&9

509 $'38#$"C3882!@&$:$&9$<@$' " ' "$ #? $ <  % &%$ ' '=& '@%'$&$$"#$'@&$$ ''&"&'! '@'&.

'$#$%$&&=>'@"54L$'#$'#$''"$ A@C$'$%$&'#$&9 @##'!%A$"# "#@$"&#$$'"''#$$9

389 &#'54$C3882!@$"&<@C'@$&H$$ '$<%A'&':$9&="$$$&$>'&.

=&&$?'??$'$??$$%&A&$$'$&$.

$  :$?$ #  "#&"$ '@$$9  !   $$& $$'"$''"$'$%$&'#$&9 ?!$"&A #'&$'%'@%'@%$#<H$#&<58L'>A "/'@&?Q@%$#'@''  $/#'@$%$&$AR="/@&$$#"$?'&'$##&.

"$9

359 &#A'65:%3884!$'A&A@#'&$' % '@%' .  $. A ' 54L . ??$ < ? #  $E '@%'$&<35924L$'$'$<'"'"$9



7504873882  .4753.  

-  

59 =%@=$:'IJ&$&"'?&$$$&!'> 5K$3886! C$'!"#&'4:=! '$  #&'$ $  %.#&'$! 4 ##&$ $ 5G :=  I$9 5 $9$4G J9

-$<@$'@&$'5G:=!# C?&'& 31:%3882I ,56858GJ!' =%'#$&!56?&%!  '#$$$=$#"$$$ C$'  ' &=   < $ := $$! ! ' @$$$ ' @&$'%E:=9

39 ?"&"$<($94G95$9*93! C$'.

)$$A'$$$#&%<@$4G' ?&'&#$=&&''$''G$C3888 I JA$$%<@.%'$&'50:5040I J9 -"#&$#:=''@#>$&$C9

69    $ $&  %=  5 :% 3886 $)$  "'?$ ' "C '#$ &= '  '" '  9 -  #"$&!#$'%A'$(##A'$H$$*&<"> '##A>=##C$%=""$S ?$:'A"$'&$"$$#'$I ,568368'9595! 664'9593!5302'9593!5312G1'95!53G56G'92C$  &?&J9  @#>!  #&$    '$ < ' #$$ '>56#$"C5000!<%<'$$&<@$&%='  9 &A!#&$$&=#&=$%=:.

A@ 65 '&"C 3883! &$$ #&& A  >= ' #&' A$ <  (##A$&%'>:'@$&%=' I ,551 06'9GC!5536G8'92P  500;T61#965G'96CJ9

"H"!'#$'%'35"3886"'?$  I2>"&%J!$&%=5:%3882I38866;43J!$ ###CI ,5312G1'95J9"S$&$&"'.

?&#%!'#$.#>$'$&'%$&.

5:%38829

29 $:$&'?"$'&#&%#!$%C!%$ '$94G 9

49 $=#$'$'$<'"'&'#$$#?.

!C'"$!'$<$'@%'$&9



7504873882  .G753.   G9 -($9; !&%'"&'(%'$&""$$ '$ E " ' &'#$$ A $ & $ ' $ < &$C  #$&'=!<("&!<%='<?%(=9 '$ $'&$"&?$'$$'&'($%$&#CCI95J9

 %$'($951 9 5  !(&'$"$'% #?%'$&'&"$$#$&'= #$!$$%"C!H$%='&"&&'">.

$C9-$'&&"""$"'?"$'$& <'&A$C!'%'$&!#>*>%"$'( ?"$#?$#>'&C$'(E'($%$&.

$%  ?"$ #&C! # "$  # "& C"$ #$&' =I$9G95 J9 (& '$"$' %#?%'$&'&"$$#.

$&'=#$!$$%"C!H$%='&"&&' ">$CI$95195 J9?$A(%'$&$'($ =%$&P   :#'! $$ '$ $ '& A (& C$ ' ($%$&  E=C  $ ?"$ #?!  #$ ' ='C#"$'AA38LI , '4?&%3882!204786! '9393P ,532558'95C$&?&J9

19 *D  & $?!  '=& '(%'$& '$ H$ '&$"&   C '( "#'%9!%'$%A(%'#$C.

$EQ$($%$&A(#$C"$$$''!#>E&.

$&%$'"'&'#$$$"#$$'($$&AC& ' "*& ' $%! $ "#&  % A( $ # C$ ( (&$$ # %'I$93;93  J9  "#'%(??$! >='.

!*??$E$"$A#C"$$''E% $   ?$$ ( % ($!  '??& #"$$$ '   $E '(%'$& I"&$*' =&& ' "# ' %P , 53;  68 '95!58256G'93$3CJ9#&'<"#'%! %$'#""$'''$<$P% %$%'$&'%$H$'&$"&###$<"H"""$$ "'?$'%#$C'(?'$<$% :A( ""$ S  '& $ ' '%$ H$ #  "#$ I ,530333$53;512J9

;9 J#%'=&'(%'$&!('"$$I:=!(/  J  C ' '"$ A  "&'! &%$"$  '($ #&$!'%$?9$R*'"&'$<#$:="$ (&$$'$&$<'A'A"$#A$%$&(& $#C'$%9 $!'&"&'$$$&&"$ $#'&$"A$%E#$!C"$!E='(.



7504873882  .1753.   &I ,5343G5'92!554562'93!552652'96!584 54;'95J9

CJ  %$ ' ## '  C ##&$ ' #%! A @##A  C#&''"$$%A@#&''''$'"$$? I$928 ,&$%@$950 P$90493%$9 556$563J!@'"$$:=##&C"$#%!H$ &#'>=?"!#&'$<##&$"#>$$= '#%9>!:='$E"'">C:$%$"/ '#%!AA@$#%!#'&''"$<'#.

$#"$$$'#$:="$%C'$$=E9A#.

#$"&'E$$'$!:=#$$*(??'A #A?'#"&'$# $9  $ &='! (&&"$ '&$"$ ($  (=!   '&=$ ' "/'#%""##$E#$!"$9"#$A #$ $=E "#$$ $ ?$ (C:$ '( &$' ?&! A  ##$  ?''E""#$!A(#&="$'&$#.

$E#"&!A($&$&&$C#''I">J!A '#$'$?&"&'$$!?!A '(E#$$C"$%&I ,534645'96J9

J-:#'!?$A"&'$&$&<@#' $ ' %  #"$ # #   "$? '  <  "A '@C:$%$&'@"#$$&'#$9?$A@E$'$#$.

> A :$?$ C:$%"$  "&? ' @& #  A $ ' @"#$$&'@##&$I ,536514P?9&="$  5000N 663#9506!-G75001652'96'J

'J @#>!'##$'@E"C'#'0%3886!"&.

''-&"'>$A$??''*A %.# #&'"$ < =*  ?$ ."  % ' @&# =*! &A < @#&$ ' 31 :% 50009  $"$ A  '>$$$$'@&#=*@"#H*'@E&$$$$%??$&&=.

>"$?E7C'$'""C#&=*.'<'G8N$$$ $% "#A$  #$ ' *= #& < A O9  $$ A @&#$&&''$%'48L'$%$&'@'$F9 %*!'$%$&'#$&<&$$'$&!($.<.'#$' *=<C$'C<=*!$%E'!"%"$#&< =*D$!$<#$&'$%E=C'588L9

A@&$$#E#$<##"$#&"$'#&$.

$!##$&#'EE=:#'$#"$$$').

$#%#C$I ,534645'96!5335G8'95J9 #$ $=E $ ?$(C:$ '( &$' $&9  ##$  ?' 



7504873882  .;753.   ' E" "#$  A C.'# $ #'  '&$  #$ E#"& #  $9   &$& &$C  #  ' (">$''"&'9'#$'$E$"&'A(#.

#&$'$$"&'$  $' E#$$ 'K"$"$%&9 #$!.$"#' #> "&' %&  ' "!  $!  $ C& # $'($9 !'##$'50"5000!  'AA$#&$''??$&'@&&%$'C=*$< @&%'"$%!#!'##$'3;$C5000!'>A #$$#$#E$%$&#?$A@&'#$.

$#?'$H$%=&9

 &A!  (E$  &&"$ #$C ' "$$ &"$  '$'##$'(E"'0%3886!'$A((/#  ' ( &$9 ($  < :$ $$ A @$"&  $ A  $ '#'(#$&&''$%'588L'$%$&'#$&9

09 J A(&(##'($%$&!$%$&'#$&#"$.

$$'"$$#"$%#$&'$%&'!$"$< A$C"$E=C'#$!%'(%'#$H$&%.

&C!$""$!''&#C&#(???&'&' $$$AI ,53G149'96C7CCJ9&?><$$$A'.

C$$''&!?'$$:"&'%$9 I ,532635J9

CJ >==&&!%*/#$*&$A'#%''&$" &$C$'=&'%"C#&#'&$ A( $??$%.

"$ # &  ""$ '&$"$   &$$  C $& I , 530  332'929695$&?&J9'$H$&%&'">>$A #CCA(%$!>==&&!'&?&'A (&C$%$($$$<$&!$$"#$'(&%$'.

$%:A(""$'#&''&I/.!.

'=$DUC'%'%*=IJ!5001!#9384$38GJ9

J'&$"%A(#$C"$$$''(.

&'&#$'$$$<$&I%'(%'J!'$H$$"#$ %$$$'$$#?>$'($&&9 (C'( %??$%"$&&.$A(&!#>%'($$$ <  $&! ( # # '($%$&    $%$& '#$&! ""$ E=C .  :#' '"$  #C$& '  &?& E '& $$$.

A!$A(&$$'(AH$$$'I --J#C& #(???&'&'$$$AI , '35:$3884!G42782!'4! ,53G1G'96C7$CCJ9&?><$$$A' C$$''&!?'$$: "&'%$I ,



7504873882  .0753.   532636'96C7CCJ9!&'"$$'$$ ''&?$'"#H*"$##<#'(%'! $A*'#!(R=!&'%!$$&!$&='($.

$'&:$E'(#$I ,53G14'94C7.J9 $.

?! ' $ '&'$  '%$ # H$ ??$& ' "> *&"$A! "$"#$'("C'$'#$!$' C$''&$"!<#$''&$$$A!%'(%'A#&.

$  "E  "  % &"A E=C ' $%$& "#$C %#$&'$%&''($&&9'&'$'$#H$ #&& $"$A"$! " "$ A( E$ ' ' A(  '('#?$!(&#$"$$%#$&&' ' $%   "*& ' $% A(%  &$$ &"A ?& <  "/9!(/#'#&'<''&'$'$$# *'?$$$'&$"""$$&*'.

#!(R=!&'%!$$&$&='#"'&:! $E'(#$9?$C#$F$#&'<&%$=C! '"$'#%'(##&$!'??$'?$% '(%'!"#$$'("C'$'$9 ?! #$#&'<'&'$=C#&<34L9('"$$'$".

$% C>%"$  '&'$ #&&9 $  :=!   #$!  "$? #$.

$!C$$##&$<'('"$$I ,53G14J9

589  @#>!  ""$ '   ' '$ &%$ <  $ "$  

5 '&"C5000!$&#>'&C$'(#$&'$%'.

$'$%$&'@'$FI$93095$9C J9#&'<".

#'%!%$''#50009

@$"&  $  %  %'$& ' G8@323 ?9 # 50009 $$ '& A$$$#"$$!@/#'@&$9

#&$!$$<E$%$&'@'$F!"< ".$"#"$!A@A@@%#*$!&$&&$CA@#.

$E$%$&'#$&<#$"#9,$'(%E=C??$.

%"$ &&!  %$ '  &?& E '& ' ( AH$    $$'I --J9

-'$?#$$#C$!EQ$500;$%$& "# $ &#&$$% '  $ #%& I% ' A?$ 2J!  *"" #%$C$%'45(35G?9I2(3G;?9E53JI --500;!#934!$.

C 5! % "&'! $ $ ?'! #$  56>"  ".

#J9 $$ '& A   C$ $''&  C$   * ' $% ' A$ *! $  '& *C'"' ?& <  "/ '$#5000I259;*P$$$A''&" '$%'$#!$C 39493J!*/#$*&$A#&$



7504873882  .58753.   %'46(435?9I45@35GE259;M28J9#!/'@'#$&.

$$<@="$$'"E:A@5000?$'$.

$ $  E $  ##A$ @' $? E *""  E ?"" I ,530258'969593J9 "#$$'?$A@''".

E#%"'$@&%$500;<504;$A@#& 5000<5014I$C 5 960'(???&'&'$$$AJ!%*/#$*&.

$A '@%'  5000 #$ H$ ?E& < 46(0;G ?9 I46@435 E 5014M 504;J9   $''"$!%$'$$A??$&#@$"& $&!'>A@#'&$%'@%'#@& 3888'5000$'&'$%'2590*'259;* %C50009

559 @$"&#&'&<#'&$'%'@%'#&$'&'.

$'58L#$%E&=9-$!'($?$'&'$ &<R=!?C=$AA@<=#&' '$AE&"H"$%$&?'$&'$##&.

"$'@"4L$)$'&'$$$'54L"""9

 @$#$$&A!"H"'$%$&'#$&!$'$&%$ $$R*$A#$' *=<C$'C< =*!$%E '!"%"$#&<=*D$9 &A!A @$"&@'"!'$!<$$"!<'&'$#$"#$' "$$&<*'#9

5000!$%$209 $?!@$"&/$"A<$$ '!$$$"$R=&'44!$R=A@?$&=.

"$#''&$'&&"$#"$$$'?E$E=C ''&'$9

 %*!  C ' &  $ %  $ A@ #&$' A@$"&$&="$'K$"#$'"%.

=$A9 ??$!#$$'(.%'$&"#$(#$& '=&$$'($$$<$&'&$$%<"C  &%$    =$A ' $&& I?9 ,  ' 58 :%3886!132783!'929393J9 '"$!&&"$($#"#H.

*&$'(E<$?$$%$&#?-#.

'$#''E9

A#&>'!$&$$$'A(($#:$?&'A$?&#&"$ *'?$'&'$$$='"#$$'''$! ?$'$$A('#$'&'$%'@%'< 54L ? ' $ "#$ ' @R= ' $ I?9 ,  ' 68 :% 3886! G8G783!'96J9 &A!A$'@&%$&'$'.

'"$#$$&!&$$$$?#&&A-&"@$



7504873882  .55753.   ##&$$A$!CA"'$'@E#$'52?&%3886 #R$I?9#$696J9

'&?$%!%*/#$*&$A'@%''46(0;G?9'$H$?E&<24(;;; ?9I46(0;GV54L'46(0;GJ9 "#$"$$%%%.

'$&IG8(323?9J!C$$#$'='52(642?9IG8(323V24(;;;J.

#'$<$E'(%'$&'32LI52(642MG8(323E588J!A!(#.

"$#%"$'($!$#&<#$'A#$' = 'C ' $$ $%$& E=C % '$!  ##!  "$ '%#?I?9'9393#J9

539 $$&$$'!$$$'$<"'.

"$'?$A(#&$#$&'=#&<38L9 ??$! ($ '  " $ " < '($ '$ &= #&% < @$9;95 I?9'91J9'&$""$'$<&$.

C!"&!%='<?%(='#$&'='(&! %$'(??$#$*'>'"'".

'&I?9 ,558585'93J!A$#&$%&< (&*!$$%"C9 ??$!'"'&'#$$$<  *= ' (.%'$& A ( E$  ##$ C $ K$$$$&#&%CI , '35:%3882!118783!'9296J9

 @#>!  "$$ '  '&  ##$ ' 38 K$ 3882  $%$&#$C'(H$E&#$!($"&#&'&<&%.

$ $*&A '  $$9  %*!  ( # E"&  #C$& >$' "$#?! &='E"$$"#&# *'##*/A'(&9$$!%$#&C'@&.

$%$&&"$'#$&E'&?#*/A'$&$$ ?"$#&C9 $??$!@$"&"$$%"'@$$ #?#&%#@$954 9

569  % '  A #&>'!    #$"$ '" $  '& ' 32:$3886$38K$3882$#$"$&$$A@?.

$ @$ ' " ' &'#$$ #?9  %*!  $$ A@?$$'@%'$&!$?"&9

529 $C$$='!'"$&'5(488?9'&< $$'#$#$<?$'&#I$9G5$9= J9



7504873882  .53753.  

  2 . -. - -.  -  .

"

31040   5  600 0  78 $9( . !:

  40 

59 &%C9

" 40

39 @'"$#$"$

69 '&'@ '32:$3886$38K$3882$$A@ ?$@$'"'&'#$$#?9

29 ?"##9

49 '"@$"&<%$'"$&'5@488?9<$$''&.

#9

G9 ?"  #$ '  A@ #%$ ?"  $  #&$ H$ ''&'68:'>$?$##""'&'& C.

 ?&'& ' ! -*WD*?A G! G882   !  $ E".

#9  '&  #$ H$ #=&9  "&" '$ M J 'A E$"$ A'&$'&C$$#''&$$A&P CJ E# # A "$?  $" #% '"' $$ $ '&P J #$=$'#&$$9-"&"$$# $&&"$&"&&$$JCJ$J.'! C?&'&'.

##$"$>A@'%'&.

%C9"&"'"$"/'#%!A$ :$!A'&$$A&$@%##'A&$&E#&'& $I$9563!58G$58;J9 =??>  #&'$     ,, T- T    &$.:$M *##  X

#?"'#&$H$$$?&E#$A@<@???&'& '#=??



7504873882