Easement Obstruction Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe litigant sought review of decisions concerning a contractual dispute regarding a right-of-way easement across the property of another party, alleging that the construction of a fence and gate interfered with their established access rights. The court determined that the language of the recorded instrument establishing the easement granted an unrestricted right of passage, and the subsequent erection of restrictive physical barriers constituted an unlawful obstruction that substantially interfered with the intended use of the easement, thereby affirming the finding that the obstruction must be removed.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 1 LTF; Easement Obstruction Dispute: The court determined that the language of the recorded instrument establishing the easement granted an unrestricted right of passage, and the subsequent erection of restrictive physical barriers constituted an unlawful obstruction that substantially interfered with the intended use of the easement, thereby affirming the finding that the obstruction must be removed.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe provision governing the allocation of court costs is cited in the final order (order 2).
The provision governing the payment of costs to the opposing party is cited in the final order (order 2).
Testo completo
"#$$%"#&&' (")'*"#&&'
(
(+ +(+ +
,- $ #* .- #&&'
!"#$%&&' ( ) "#"
"# !"#$!%&*+
,
-- . - /- 0 "$<" 0 1 0!23"-,4567!8, %9'!%&%% 7
1 -- !3"" :$;;!%&*'
!
&=+
+ /(
%0 >5#,"%%#&'!?@#:#2" 2"8#@, 8$ ", " #5 ,,$ %? >, %??' 8 "# !$% &;#%?'7!, !$ %+<$3%?''0
&0 - :<< + " "8,< " >5#, 8$,$! 2 " 8#@ ,"$8,58#,$"3"8$3A8< B8/$8C",#50
60 >5#, " "3 , "3 "$<,< &; > &' , $,$ ,# "/<< 2"$;>,&'8C$,"8,50
;0 2 " $ ,$ " "#" # " ,,, " 8$3A! 8 ,8$ ,,, "$<" 8, " ##B#,,"3""#"B",#5! ,,%?>,%??',&;>&'0
+0 /,,<<,$8 2"$8#"/$,2<,3,D
• -""8 - - "&?E,&'! "#"$,$<<$"%#6*3%??+!8"%3#26% # %??70 - 8,, " , B ##, " #5! 5#,$ " ,$F, >B/ "3! /$@3 G &+% <0 ;+0 8,, " , ##,""3/$@3G%/?79<0?*0
• "%;E,&'! -- . /- - H I<#$ 2B "#" 3, $,$ <<$ 8@ "/ " % ,2 %??7 &7 8,#2 &&!88,"2850-3"8$3A!,%&/+7*<0+* $,$ ,<$$ %* "$#2 && G -- . - - /- - 1 - / - H48@ I0
• %6>,&'! <#$3J#,,"%&/+7*<0+* ", " %* "$#2 &&! 83, " " 8$3A 8< " #$, " ,,0 "#" , <<$ 8@ "/"8%,2&&,8,,",##,""3 /$@3G6%/6'7<0?*0
• "#"<#$ 2"$8"%7E,&'B/ 3,$,$:K#5"%3%??76*8,#2%??70
=&;;+=&' 6=+
'0 "#, , $,$ ,# C 8, ", " + 8,#2 &'! 3 /", B 8,, " , G 8,5 /$@3 G 66/%*+ <0 6+0 "#"$,$3,$G3#8,"285,>", "B$ B/G "$<, "/23, "/ &+ 8,#2 &'! F, , ",,20
90 /2"/2>,""$<C$!$,$5"$G>50
+ (
%0 /,0&+"<$"$285"8$3A8<! 3!33,,3",$"%9"$#2%??6H1I!,$35 %>3&!@58$"""30B>,, 8"L"8,,",G8,5H,0%&&,%&6 " 34 I! >5"""3#8$,,"/,0960%"<$"$ 8$3A 8< " &+ > %?7& HI! , G @3 2 ,""8%E,&6!",!8@B/<< $,$,#H,0%;& I!C$,"/<<8,52" $" $8,,"$,#$8>5""30
&0 -/,0&&1H3,35"8%>3&I! " "3! 8,, " , B ", #5 , 8,5$ <#$#, C,0%&&!%&6!%;%,%;& M,06G+ 1/88B, 85#,,G,<$H0%I0:B>,!8,," ,G8,58"G"<<$,8,,",!5#,$ " 3 " 2 85 C,, $3,#, ##, " "3! , 8,,",!5#,$"3"285C,,$3,#, ##,""#5H<0,0&;1I0!>, G 8,, " , , G /3 " 2 85 C,, ##, " " #5 ,$F, " ##, " "3 H 1 %&7 &6*M 1%&?;;;I0
L8@! >5 " 8#@ , "$ 8,5 8 #,$ " 8,,", B",#5 8"#"!,8", 8$""%?>,%??'&;>&'!",GB>5#,""3 ,"3C$,0
60 - "#, 8",! 8,, " , B 8 "#" /$@3G66/6+'<07*H6%/6'7<?*N%/?79<0?*I0 8@"$","8,, " , B ##, " #5! 5#,$ " ,$F, " >B/ "3!,&+%<0;+!8,,",G8,5#,G66/%*+<06+! ,$F,A,"$>G$,$$8,,,"8$3A"$<"0
=&;;+=&' ;=+
"#"",GC4$8#,,"%'/++&<09*H66/%*+!6+D &I! G 3 #8, 3, 8 "#" 8@ " 1", " 285"B,"@30
;0 <#$#, G >8"! "8 > "$,#, 8 8,5 >B/##,",<,"8,,",""#!>, "3$2$$<",,8,,",G",$F,#8, #,,"40 ,$F,,$,C###$5/,0%& "/"8$3A8<3!33,,3",$ " %7 3 %?7; H &I ,C $5#,! 4 , 8$ H 182$6'=*&"%7>,&6I
+0 $##, 8J! 8$" $,, 5,, H,0 96 0 & , 7?(0%"8$""#,,3"%&8,#2%?7+I0
OOO
=&;;+=&' +=+
(/ (+ +(+ +
01232-- 4 .22 2 5! 6'# 7
%0 3, -- . - - /- - 1 - / - 4 G ,<$! " #8," !##"%'/++&<09*G1"," 2 85 " B , " @3! #8, P ( 6&*&0&+0 <3 " "# ! $ % ! B " ,$F, #8,""$,!"@&;>&'>B/##," ,<,0
&0 LA"#,,B"20
60 ,B8$",5,,0
;0 <# 8, " B/ 83, <# , 8$, F, " "$ " 6* > "@ ,<, 8 8 ##"$ "$ 2 <$"$ " ! -:QR:<B '! '; ! , C#80 "$ 8, F, 85$0 #$# ", D I "B C,#, B "$ , "$ 2, , 8 " "$,,B$M2IC88B#,<,#83"#",, ,"$MI8,5,"8$,,0-#$# ,, 8 , $$#, $#$$ ,, I 2I , I 4"! 2<$"$"88,#,@B/ "3"$320#$#"#,#A " 83! B , >,! B "$ ,,B$ , /388 " B$,$C8$"$,H,0%6&!%*',%*7I0 5<< $",D S"
8<#"8$,F,,,<$C8,BLGL<<<$"$ "85<<
=&;;+=&'