Statutory Interpretation and Administrative Procedure Review
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns various challenges to the legality and interpretation of several statutory provisions and associated regulations concerning, among other things, administrative procedures, environmental protection, and jurisdictional boundaries, with the lower court decisions being reviewed on grounds relating to vagueness, overbreadth, and improper delegation of authority. The reviewing court largely upheld the challenged statutes, reasoning that the language, while potentially broad in some instances, was sufficiently clear when read in context, the regulations were a reasonable exercise of delegated power within the statutory framework, and the challenged actions fell within the agency's established jurisdiction, thereby affirming the judgments in part and modifying them in another to clarify scope of application.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; PRÉVOYANCE PROFESSIONNELLE SELON LA LPP ; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR LA PRÉVOYANCE PROFESSIONNELLE ; PARTAGE(SENS GÉNÉRAL) ; AVOIR DE VIEILLESSE ; LOGEMENT ; DIVORCE ; JUGEMENT DE DIVORCE ; ACQUISITION DE LA PROPRIÉTÉ | LFLP22
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for ordering the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Testo completo
$%&'($)+ $'+,$)+
- "- . -. .
./ 0 + ! ) 10 )+
!"#$!%&'( )*++,! "#" #-./$.""#0$.""1. 2.-2
"# !"#$!%&34,!#-. /$.""#0$.""1. 2.-2
.
++ 0 ++ + "$8" ++ ++ + * !"5('!
6 7* !/"#&4! +
! " !#
&9:
2
%< =>#."%:/&443!:?#2#@" @"-#?. -$ "/ " "# ! $ . !#$".";=/%((A<
&< + 288 %% " =>#. -$.$! @ " -#? . "$-.>-#.$"/"-$/5-8B- 2"$-C".#><
'< =>#.""/."/"$8.8&A#&443.$.$##B$ @."%=&443<"#". ."C-$.$- 2.-2 <
A< D..#$- @"$-#"D$.@8./.E
+D>."# E
• %3=&443! "0"-""?/. "+/". "?/F G...$B-.."@ -> " "#" 0$/. '% # &443 H 8< %%%0%%A!(I! 5 #- --. " @ -> " 8". " @ -> "0+ JI/&44%</."0=.H"$". " " .. "0 "- #.. " 8< A%0444<* .8 H /#. .-$ " " " 0>#. " --$.$ " >#. " &% =. %((I 8/ " "#"< 8! .= ".. "-!-.."@->B ="#>!/.$K.=B0'%#&443!0$/.H8<I%04I:!&I<
• &3=&443!L"."@->"0++ 8#$B0 /. /$ I / &44% 0/ " @ -> " "#" #.."8<I&0;4(!3IH <
• ' =. &443! L". " -$/5 "- ...$ B "#"/.$.$88$"%-.#@%(:('4/#@%((:< +-..".H"."#>0$/.H8<'&0:'%!%4< /. 88.$...-$"8<A%0444<*&%=.%((I""" 0>#. H --$.$ " >#.< /. 88.$ ; =/ %((A " 2. H 2. " 8< %04'I<*< -.. " @ -> .8$$ '4 "$#@ %((: H L". " @ -> "0+ + 0$/.H8<&;0A34!;4<
• %; =. &443! "#" " @ " $! -$$ B0"$-"##.".."8<A%0444<*!/."#=0.
9%(:;9&443 '9:
"-.."@->H"."#>".$K."=B0H ".""/<
+D>."< E
• %( = &443! L". " @ -> "0+ + /$ B L"../"0+/.$.$--+M8<
• && = &443! 6..2* # ...$ B " " "0 .. &9;::;(9 -.. " @ -> " "/ $.. " 8<&&;0((;<*! B " #>! / .$K. =B0 "/! 0$/.H8<';0'4:!AI.B!"..N&9%I(349 !-.." @->""/$.."8<II0(:I!%4< "#"" @ "$!6..2* #8#$&(=&443B-.. "@->#$".#>$.."8<&A303;'!3I."B$ B "C #$ " .. -$.$ --.. H $.$ +2M" + <
• &3 = &443! +M8 ...$ B0 /. .8$$ / " -$/5 " 8< I&03;&<* . 8< I30(A'<* '4 = &444 H 6..2* #<
I< &I =. &443! @ . " 8#$ "#"BD#.."8<;&0:4:!AI/.H"#". #-."$8BD-.<
3< (O.&443! $-"B%(=/&443! /....$ "0/"-$/5""#""8<;I03'4<*'%"$#@&44I -"8<%%%0%%A!(I'%#&443!B-.-/#@@< ! #.. " 8< A%0444<* #@. 0/ =# $.$ #@$< +#.$#.H/.""#=>!".-"."/./. $.$ -.>$ - #.$ . C*$-C! #.. 0/. $.$ -5$ - . C ... ! 0-. . / /#. .-$5.$.$"$">".</.$B""$" #.."8<A%0444<*"/"-$/5""#"<
;< %; O. &443! -$$ B0 /. # " > %( =/ &443""$"."--@"8<%I0I%%!(I'%"$#@ &44I< ./#..-$!8#.-/."L". " -$/5 "0 "- . $.. " - -@ " 8 ..B.H"."..""."0$<
:< ' =. &443! L". " -$/5 "- -$$ B # /.B..$8".'4/#@%((:.B0/."? B">.8"."..""."0$
9%(:;9&443 A9:
C..8/./.8"."@->"0++ HPB0 --.."-$"H/-.#<
(< %: -.#@ &443! 8". " @ -> "0+ + 8#$ @ " $ B0 . "#" "0-. " ..""."0$/.$.$.#"-."L"." -$/5 "-<
%4< +B!$.$>"$H=><
%< 0.< &I " 8$"$ @ -> " -$/5 -8!/!//../".$"%;"$#@%(('FLG! .$/>%=/&444!?>-$"""/<B =..-"D"-..".H-.>F.<%&&. %&' " /* G!=>"""/#-$.."0.<;'< %"8$"$-$/5-8"&I=%(:&FG!.H ?/ @.""-%O.&44'!".! -?B088$.$.#F.<%A& G!C$."088-.> @"$"$-.."$.#$-=>""/.
&< G+0.<&&LF/./>"-%=/&444G! ""/!-..".B".#>.-.>$ 8#$#.C.<%&&!%&'!%A%.%A& Q.<'HIL0--B. ->#..H.8$F<%G<2B=.!-.." .H-.>-"H"88$.-..".!>#.$ " / " @ -> C.. $/.#. ##. " "/! . -.. " .! >#.$ " / " @ -> C.. $/.#.##.""#>F8<.<&ALG< !=.H-.."..H0/"@->C.. ##.""#>.$K."##.""/F L %&:&'4Q L%&(AAAG<
@G .-$.."--."-$/5#H @ -> "/. -- K. -.>$ " "/ .< %&& < 8.-./"-$/5-8.$- B$ >#. H .. "0>#. H 0 " --$.$ C ". -$/ - .< '4 . /. . 0" 0>#. H --$.$ " >#. #5 " -$/5 -8F G"'.@%((A< #5"#.88.$H @. " -$/5 F L %&: &'A "< & . $8$Q > " 8$"$"%I/#@%((3.$/""/ RLL%((3%%'SG<+0.<'4<3!B$-C"/./.
9%(:;9&443 I9:
/ "0 " -$/5! /#. .-$ . "$$ ## -.."@->..-.>$8#$#.C.<%&&!%&'. %A% ! . H 0.< && L< /#. .-$ J " 0... " -$/5./."@##@$B/.H-.."@ ->"0.<&&<&LQ"."K.=.$C./ B."$.#.--.."."0.<%&&<% < + . - "$. #.. B 8. 0@=. "0 @>."#@#.##.""/Q.H#-.@" -.. " . ##. " "/ F L %&: &'I "< '@ . $8$Q L "&&=.&44I!%:94AG<
"88$"-..".!/#..-$-0B. "0>#.//#=B0"/F 2# + ! -< .<! -< ;'Q B* "$ + 7 9 2. 7 T! -< .<! -< &'4G< -"."-"0.$K."0.<&&<&"C?#-2 L< 88.!.$K.!$2".#>.B-8..=. 88$H0..."-$/5!.".$H#-08.F#> -$.$ " 8$"$ RLL %((3 %%4SQ / 8 ! UV2.>> / @WU> 8U 62>.# @ " > " ....> 2 .< %&& T! T %'39&444! -< I'3 /<Q L " %' #&44&!%9&44%G<
G + 0.< '4" ! D$ 2$. "/. #@ #.. -JHD..."-$/5E <>#.--$.$./"Q @< " ". $B/. $#B#. H $. . $"$ >#.--$.$Q <-.."-$/5D.C>@""$?"D$F< %G< D$-.#@...#-#..-J!H"."-. "-.8C$HD<'F<&G<
#@#...$E <=BDH./."".C-.."/Q @<=BDH/"D."-$/5Q <=BD-#.-?"-.."@->F<'G< +!""$""C!D$."/.H/"--$.$ " >#. -". " /. " >#. $B/. /#. .-$!-..8$#..H..."@->F<AG<
" /. " >#.! D@>. " #@ #. -". $$< -".! ." -C " /.! "$". 8. " ".. 25-.2$."2>$>--.$-/"F<IG<
9%(:;9&443 39:
" #@#. " /#. .-$ H D... " -$/5! *".1.HD$".H"-..--.#. -$/$!"$.#$-?>#.F<3G<
/#..-$"..$H0##@B<.>.!"0 -.-..""."0$"0.<'4<%#.$ >.8.!"0.-.!-0@>."#@"/. "0.<'4"!"C#/.HB/#..-$ . - .$ " " -$/5 F L " && =. &44I! %:94AG<
'< D-?! => " -#? . "$ -.> - #.$ " /"-$/5""#"<".-...!"D-.! " #>! ; =/ %((A! "D. -. &A # &443! ". H B =>#.""/."/C$.<
A< 0/.""#"..$88.$- "# X * =.. H 0/ " -$/5 " "#" /#. .-$"8<A%0444<*<
. $>"! =-" -$.$! /#. .-$ ". #-$./#..$H0##@B".#?B0"/. " *! . #@$ H 0... " -$/5< .! " "0-?! 0@ " .. ". "0$! " BK. "."8"."-$/5 "-!##$BB ". /#. 0 - $.$ #@$ H 0... " -$/5 $ -?/.">#.< .8!0@>."#@"/. 0.<'4"-#B#..-$BB0... "-$/5"-"0$H2."#.."/#..-$! ".#?B*.""-$/5< !0.H =. .. B =.$ H 0/ " -$/5 " "#" #.."8<A%0444<*<
I< + "#. -".! -.. B -". #> - < . " 8< &A303;'!3I ." B B - # . " 8< %4%04I3!;4 F. R8< %%%0%%A!(I Y 8< A%0444<*S * 8<I%04I:!&IG! .$K. 5. "$=H $.$ $ - ... " -$/5 "$8"< . $>"! C-B$ %; O. &443 B 0/ " -$/5 " "#" $.. @ " 8< %%%0%%A!(I "0""$"."--<
$B! < ". H C*$- #.. " 8< %&'0''3!:4F8<&A303;'!3IE&G.*".#.."8<I40I&:!'IF8<
9%(:;9&443 ;9:
%4%04I3!;4E &G! " . B D. < B ". H # #.."8<;&0:4:!AI<
3< 8#$#. H =-"! "- = "$.#. - -.> =B0 ##. " .8. " -.. " . " "#! =. "/$ @$$8 " .. -.. ". H " .$K. #-. #.. " *< .$K. . $ .C ### $> 0.< %& " 0" -$/5 -8 /! //. . /".$ " %: / %(:A F &G .C $>#.! * . -$ F L -@$ '394& " %: =. &44'G<
;< $##.-J!-$"$..>..F.<;'<&. :(7<%"-$""#../"%&-.#@%(:IG<
9%(:;9&443 :9:
. 2 "- . -. .
!
314 5 6 7# %+) 8
%< /.6..2* #H.8$!"#-."< ! ## " 8< ;&0:4:!AI H "0 " - " " ?/ . " +/ ". " ?/ 8/ " # !B".$K.#-.""$.!"? &A#&443=B0##.".8.<
&< D5"#..B"@<
'< .B-$".>..<
A< 8# -. " B0 -/. 8# . -$. K. " "$ " '4 = "? .8. - - ##"$ "$ @ 8$"$ " ! +2MW28B 3! 344A ! . C#-< "$ -. K. ->$< #$# ". E G "B C.#. B "$ . "$ @. . - " "$..B$Q@GC--B#.8.#-/"#".. ."$QG-.>."-$..<+#$# .. - . $$#. $#$$ .. G @G . G *"! @8$"$"--.#.?B0 "/"$/@<#$#"#.#5 " -/! B . =.! B "$ ..B$ . 0/-- " B$.$C-$"$.F.<%'&!%43.%4:G< >88? $". 5+ $ -8#"-$.K...8$C-.BDHD888$"$ "->88
9%(:;9&443