Monument Control Over Erroneous Metes and Bounds in Boundary Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case addresses a dispute over property boundaries stemming from conflicting land descriptions in historical deeds, where the description in one deed provided fixed boundaries that matched physical monuments, while the description in the other deed contained erroneous metes and bounds that did not close and conflicted with the established monuments. The court reasoned that in cases of conflicting calls in a deed, physical monuments that are clearly called for or are in evidence control over courses and distances, particularly when the course and distance calls result in an impossible or closed boundary, thus affirming the boundary line established by the fixed monuments referenced in the deed with the fixed boundaries.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Monument Control Over Erroneous Metes and Bounds in Boundary Dispute: The court reasoned that in cases of conflicting calls in a deed, physical monuments that are clearly called for or are in evidence control over courses and distances, particularly when the course and distance calls result in an impossible or closed boundary, thus affirming the boundary line established by the fixed monuments referenced in the deed with the fixed boundaries.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis article is cited in order 5 to impose the court costs on the appellant.
Testo completo
"#$%&"#$$' (")*%"#$$'
( + (
( +( + +
+,- # ! %% . #$$'
!"#$% !#&'( ' $'""#)$'""*'+,
'
-- . .. . . ) ! '#$ .(/"0!(1 "#"2345!&'6477! 4844 8!... -- ) .. !" &&$ 9:;!&'<8=!4844 46
! !
28><2
(( / (
?2&@ 'A! $ 4:B;! $'$ ('# 5"$#C4::4")D("'"'E
' $'$ # C$$F ") ' '@ ")("'$ & "$ " )FF " $ $"' % )$'D ?2&@ ) A " 4: /' 4::<! ( FF'4"$#C4::8!C")'G")("'$";7HE
4#4::B! '")"'?2&@. A# 'C$$F")'")("'$"477H(FF'4&'#C4::=E
&&$"$("''''C'%#' /0)%'9#&$("8774E
&"$"84F$(877=!) F#$'0)&$"'% $(""'%''&&#'2%''"#&("@ 4#877=!'')FF'&F%$('E
& "$"<#877=!. &&#$'"'''$ )FF' &F ") $(' &&'! "#"' & ''' " #'''&&I"&4&'#C4::=!'B56)8:8F1E
'F'&&'%"$". !'&$C#'% '''")FF'&FE
. " "$ &&' "' "' " 47 # 877=! F#'''")FF'&FE
& "$ " 8= ( 877=! ## F$"$ " #'@ ")2(!((''("'$&&$"'%)$'D '# )FF C " $ ## C/' " #&$'! "' " 8:(877=E
' ' "$ " . " 86 # 877=! C " $ " J' "' " 8= /' 877= & 0 "# ' "$ ''' " )FF' &F ( ' " "$& ? >4;4<>877=! '#'&"'"(' CF$"$"AE
) C'! C "$$ 0) G# " 3 " @"!F'$D#'0'$J'". )$''&&$ ("$$#'"F'"'!'F'0)'"G2!'$J' "'$''&$!($''#'$%577F1&#!'$'' /'F'E
>874;>877= 26><2 ' J' F' '#' )C/' ") &$" &"' "(' C F$"$"E
"&$'! C"$)&&")FF' " )2("'$ ?2&@ ) A ' FG$ " " #&' " #"'E
)% ) " '' "! 0 )' ' "' " 67 K' 877=! ) "$$#'J'#&$''#'@E
&"'! ( " #' " &$" &$ '"' % )' " '!(D'"$("'&#'!39&'3@" 0"$"'''$E
) " $'$ ( 0) "$ FG$ % #2&'#C $'' "$ & "$'#'") L'"$"'''$!'!" #'!'&"C")'4<"' &$""#''(!()FF&"'#'@" E
& $' " 4= &'#C 877=! ) "0$ #' "$ ' /'"E
+ ( (
D(MD'/"?A$'$#"F$'''$!"@ 4K'8776! C'"!#&$"=/D!"' &$"''(2&$"'!=&&$''4B/D?'14'1'=B A1
'%M'"M$'"4B/D!& CF$"$ 8;/(877<? -46747BA!" D("&'$!46F$(! "&'''D'&#''' C'" " $D % ' /D ''! ! " M''' " M$' " (G/D1
#&$'&/D""M&@'$'C1
)G'#"M'14<"D(&$""#''(? A! &$"&'J'&"0'"$&""'"M0'" '(!&$"#''(&"'"(''''$!/0M%"' 0'1
))&@!/'F"&"&$'/0)%"'" >4;4<>877=1
>874;>877= 2<><2
+ 0( / ( +( + +
!
1.2-- 3 4 56 %*# 7
41 " & " &$' &&' " )' 4< /0)%"'" >4;4<>877=1
81 $('"&$"1
61 '0&$"'D''1
<1 F#&'"0M&('F#'&$'J'" "$ " 47 / "@ 'F' & & ##"$ "$ C F$"$"!.3NO3F0B!B77< !'G#&1 "$ &' J' &D$1 #$# "'L A "0 G'#' 0 "$ ' "$ C' ' & " "$ ''0$E CA G&&0#'F'#&("#"'''"$EA&' D' " &$''1 . #$# '' ' $$#' $#$$ '' A CA ' A 2"! C F$"$ " & & ' #'@ 0M "( "$ (C1#$#"#'#9"&(!0 ' /'! 0 "$ ''0$ ' M(&& " 0 $'$ G&$"$'?'1468!47B'475A1
DFF@ $"'L .9( + P C.
&F#"&$'J'''F$G&'0M%MFFF$"$ "&DFF
>874;>877=