Statute of Limitations and Presumption of Payment in Pre-1980s Obligation Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed several points of error raised concerning a judgment involving disputes over pre-1980s obligations, primarily focusing on issues related to the statute of limitations, presumptions of payment, and evidence sufficiency for establishing the continuation of liability. The court reasoned that certain claims were indeed barred by the statute of limitations as they were not timely asserted, and that presumptions of payment, while generally applicable after a long period, were rebutted by documentary evidence indicating ongoing acknowledgment of debt or payments made during the relevant period, thereby keeping the underlying obligations alive for the purposes of the claims presented.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statute of Limitations and Presumption of Payment in Pre-1980s Obligation Dispute: The court reasoned that certain claims were indeed barred by the statute of limitations as they were not timely asserted, and that presumptions of payment, while generally applicable after a long period, were rebutted by documentary evidence indicating ongoing acknowledgment of debt or payments made during the relevant period, thereby keeping the underlying obligations alive for the purposes of the claims presented.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe provision was cited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
$%%&'$'(() $*&+$'(()
, !-, , !
. / % # & 0/ '(()
! "
!"
## $ $ $ $% & !" &"&. '( )* + ,-
! "#
3 1/4 3
1!
05 % . 0671% .". & 8..9& : ""&! !:."& "! 0 !"!8 066* 70 12225 "" "% ;" - :: & !&" + : ""&!% ;<" : 9! & ="&9&"&9 . : ;99& "! : ! >?. @&3: , A5
15 .:!. !- : ""&! : , ; 0B 12215
75 0C - & 1221% ; & . : !"&! ;""""&! ; & 1221% -. "! -!& 8& "/! :!"D $& ! + ;." ? % -& !&9&"&! !< ! ="&9&"&9 "&!" !< " 1221% ="&9&"&9 !"" " : .-!< : !9&! 1221% ="&9&"&9 ;&" : ""&! :&" D&, ! " !&&, :&& % && E ="&9&"&9 ;&" &8. "&! 8! & : , ;$5
*5 ! & 16 - & 1221% ;&". . !&E. + ; "& !"% " : .&. ;?&" ;""""&! ; & E; ."&"
&"&? - 3& :& 066B " E; :!.&" & ="&9&"&9 & 8! ;&"5
)5 12 & 1221% ; ;" ."!. E ;&". . ;&" : !. &" + ! ! & 0C - & " ; &-&". + 9& .& ;&& 12 =& 1221% =!"" E F :&, & ! " &:!&8 + " ;." -!" !& G5
45 7 =& 1221% ;&". . .:! D: ." :: ; % ::" !"" E; -&" H" .:! " 16 - & 12215
C5 1* =& 1221% ; : &". + !"" E I F ? . !" :&, 0C - & 1221 " !" :: 12 & 1221% ! ;-! "!=! : J !" .& + ;." -!" !& G5
B5 16 =&" 1221% ; 9&" ! -!& J ! & " EE ="&9&"&9 -!<. : ;&". . " . . " ;""" !" E"% !&" F -!" """"&! ; 3& 1221% ="&9&"&9 "&!" !"" -!" " : .-!< : !9&! - . : 9! : .-!< &&E ?"" :! 1221 " ="&9&"&9 ! " !8&?"&! & E -! ."K G5
65 :: .". . + ;&". . 04 :"8 12215
/00*1/122)
3 7/4 3
3& !&&". 1) :"8 1221 .& 9& E F = :& !8"& !" .& G5
"& .& & .". &: "& 0) !-8 12215
! & 11 !"!8 1221% ;&". . 9&" ."" &99&". + !8"& !" E& " . E & !&" + !- ! . .& ::."& 5
B5 .&&! 14 !-8 1221% ; ; &9! . E : ""&! ."&" =".5
65 ;&". . 9! . ."&! !" &" .&&! B =-& 1227% .?" E F =;& 9&" : -& "! !" . ! = -!& : :! E!& ;! ;8 : ! & " E = -! & & 9&" : -& % E& " 9D L G5
!&E. + ; ="&9&"&9 "&9 + !8&?"&! &% -. !:" 70 .8 1221 " 1220% && E !:& ! !- 8& + !< @95 ! & 16 =-& 1227 " 12 !"!8 122*A5
" !?. : ; " + E -&" J .&&! 14 !-8 1221% ;&". . 9&" E E I F !. E& ;."&"
"&. -! .". "! . : :!" 07 .8 12215 ! -K ! H ;-!< ! & -!& ! + 9& .8 1221 9 : " G5
025 .&&! !::!&"&! 1* 122)% ; % !""" E ;&". . & -&" "!=! : 9&" : -& ;""""&! ; & 1221 && E; ="&9&"&9 "&!" !"" " : .-!< : !9&! - . : 9! : .-!< &&E ?"" :! 1221% =". ;!::!&"&!5
005 ;&". . &" =". ! 06 - & 122) !" &" .&&! " : !&"
"!" ! :! .'?. - ; 5
015 &8 . ; : &. & 9& : -& D !" E" .. : ; 5 0) =& 122)% ;&". . && : !&" :!& ; !" ". - M$ -8 + : "& 0 =& 1227% : !:!&"&! ; - "" ( & & :! ;. 1227% &- ! & + . : % ! & $ ". 4 .8 1220% D " E & " : & !" .&&"&! 70 .8 1220% ! & ) 9.- & 1227 M $ M% ;&9! " E F ! -! -! - . -!" " &" ! 9! :&" " ! : " G% && E; -& -& " 9- 0*
/00*1/122)
3 */4 3
!"!8 066* :! !"" )BN)C* 9 5 02% " ! & 9!"&! : .-!< 9- : ! &&E ?"" 14 =& 1221 !9& " E; -&" J "! !" :!&! "&9 + ! !:" ;.: ? " !- " :. &! 0661 + 066*5
075 -&". + ." & % ; -. E :&, 9! & 12 =& 122)
;-&" .". :!". & " D 9&" <" 8!"& + ! 9 ;!" !& : ""&! 14 !-8 1221 " !" , ! =" ! % .""
: .&. E - ": .!. :& .&&! 9 : ""&!% & "
!&&8 + ;&". . .:! !- : ""&! @95 ! & 0) :"8 122)A5
0*5 ! & .". " & :! &9! "&! + ;&". . " .". ? . + =? 5
!
05 !& ?-!& ;! ?&"&! =&&& @A .". !&9&. " &"&".% , 0 !H" 1227% &8 "! !&% !:!. )
=?% !" : .&" " -&3: .&"% ) ::." " 04 =? @ "5 0 "5 " )4 A5
$&" + ;"&! ;."&! 04 =? % : &8 9.. 1C =-& 122* @ # 072 024A% !& ?-!& !:".% 07 9.- & % &:!&"&! " &"!& ?" : """ &8 "! !& &.? + " !& =? "&"& % % ;""" ;."&! !-D =? 5
15 !9! ." + N "5 )4 5 1 "5 % &8 "! !& !O" !"""&! : .- + ; "& *7 !& "! : ""&! "! !:."& + ; 3-&& " -&-" " + ; 3&-&&". 1) !"!8 064B @ A5
$ !:." :! =? ;:, " && ."8&5
75 ! % &" =". ": "&% " -85
*5 D " ; "5 0 % : ! >?.% --% ! :'& " &-& !" !&" + - && "! ;& !&% E& "
? "& : - " : ""&! "! !:."& + ; 3 -&&% -&-" " &-&&".5
/00*1/122)
3 )/4 3
- && " .9&& + ; "5 7 % !:.". : ; "5 7 ,?"
@ A5
)5 D " ; "5 76 5 1 % & E& 9&" -!& ! !&" + : ""&! !&" 9! & ? "&"" "! &?" .& :! ."8& !&"
" 9&D : ""&! 5
; "5 00 : .& E 8..9&&& ! ! : ."" .? !&" . + N!99& "!" 9&" !- " + " O !&9&"&! !"" : ""&! E& & !" !. ! :: &!5 !" % & !&" &? + N!99& !&" E& :-" & .'!& : : " &!% ( ! &E&.5 ( !8&?"&! N::&E + "! ? ! !"&!5 N!99& :"
: ! :: & - " : ""&! ! E 8..9&&& 9 9! & ! " + "" &?" .5
)5 #! " !"" ;:, E; !" !P ; .&&! &"&?&% & &:!&" : "! !" "& :! ." & !&" ! " + : ""&! !:."& 5 ;" && + 8! !&"
E;& =". : ""&!5
45 !& "!"9!& -!<. + ; 9& E;& D&% : "" % 8& 9!. % "! !" E& <" + : ." .". - . !& 5 & ;!::! , ! : + E;& ;E&"" ">'5
/00*1/122)
3 4/4 3
!1 !-, , !
#
203 4 5 67 %+' "8
3
05 . ! -85
# 3
15 ;" : "&"5
75 -!& + ; !&. "5
*5 &" E : !. " ? "&"5
? 99&, : .&"
&3!& Q ! & R
!:& !9! : ." (" " !"&9&. D : "& : ? 99
/00*1/122)