Contract Breach and Performance Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute over contractual obligations and performance, stemming from an agreement where one party was obligated to perform certain services or deliver goods, with questions arising regarding whether performance was timely, complete, or satisfactory. The court analyzed the terms of the agreement, evidence of communications and actions taken by both sides, and applicable contract law principles to determine liability. The ruling concluded that there was a breach of contract by one party due to their failure to meet specific material terms, thereby justifying the remedies sought by the non-breaching party, though the extent of damages or required rectification was tailored to the specific findings of fact regarding the deficiency in performance.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contract Breach and Performance Dispute: The court analyzed the terms of the agreement, evidence of communications and actions taken by both sides, and applicable contract law principles to determine liability. The ruling concluded that there was a breach of contract by one party due to their failure to meet specific material terms, thereby justifying the remedies sought by the non-breaching party, though the extent of damages or required rectification was tailored to the specific findings of fact regarding the deficiency in performance.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the judicial costs.
Cited in the dispositive regarding the granting of legal aid.
Testo completo
#$%&%#$&&% #'()#$&&*
!!
+ !,+ - +! -,
. / % 0 1/ $&&*
!"#$%#$&$!' $"$% ( %)*!%"!!
"%$
+, !%!*
! "
&.-1&
2,
23 4#"!% 5 %!%$ !*#% " $!" "! 6 7 7 8 9 "$%9 %!:$ "%!;3 %!%$ %$*#$:+(#$%#"$ !!%* <"$!:$ #$% 9! ! % (%$ #$% =%%!;% "%$!%#$"=!"%"#$"=!"" "%$%($"%!=3
.3 #$!%#.00. ($**;"##**%%*#$!=!%59$;"=!% "<93
/3 21<!%.00. "$)(#!%;=!"*#"4 *%*=$##*#$$!$%#$"=$:$ )!!;"%!" 4*# 5>>%49"4%*;!%!"?$##"$%*! .@<!%.00.#"!!!)>!$$9!AB3
C3 $%"$5:; *#"*#!%#*"%$"*#"43 &!*%* * #$ "$" ./ #%D$ .00. 6; *$%!" "%$!%"!$8%6"##"$%!%*83
@3 D$* #"!% ; #E>!) ($* ( # $#$$ " %!;!%* $%!;3 !#!%* %$;! %"% *%* %%%* <)( .1 <!% !!;%3
F3 !!%* <"$!:$ ! "% *%* ;$* #$ + #"$ !#!%* %"% %$;! .. "G% .00. /0 #%D$ .00. "#% % (*!$/0<"$3
H3 20"%"D$.00. ($*$#!*$%!"(!%3
13 $*!!"C";D$.00. +, !"$*#$%%!" !$*!%$!:$@0I"%!=)(!4!%!%$%!"!%* %$*!""$#"$D!%$!4)($*;!%*%*( #$"%9"!%3
J3 ("##"!%!"="$*#$($**%*$<%*#$+, 3($* "$!%$<%*$"$ $!D!!%$%!=2C$.00/3 $"$*%* $9!%$*"*$" -C0/-.00/3
203 $";*!!"%*.C;$!.00/ +, !=!4 #$%%!" "* 5 "$% %$ 5 ($* ?%$!%% *! % !!%* <"$!:$!%B;==%/2$.00/ "!*$%)%$"D"% "==$!% (*%!% # $%!" !%* %$ ; (!% % $;!%*"$!($!3
-./0/-.00/ &/-1&
223 .1 ! .00/ ($* ="$* "##"!%!" 5 %% *!!" *9% ) (*%%*#$!="%"==$!%;!%%"<"$*%*#$!$#"$%) " $!% G K%$ %$!%* " (9 ($&! % " " $!%:$ #$"#$ 5 ($&!%3 !;") 5 % *9$ (;! " *! %$!%% $ 3 ," %$%! #>E!) "!"* #$ (9$!" " *#"4 ( =!% )(99$;$ *%% *#$!= #$*4!%%#$";")*#$"=!%"<93
2.3 (##!!$ "%%#$"!%"$$!$%*.F!.00/ *% $ #E>!%$ % #E>"%>*$#% 'A3 &! "=!$*!;$($*#!"!!.00.!%5"=!%"<93 )!=!* %$%! #>E!) G 5 (9$!" 6# 9$;8 ! "!9* ) ($* ;!% *;"##* *%% %$ #"%&%$%!) % )( *%!% =$9!!* #$ #!$ * "=!% "<93 *! "$#$*!*) ",% 6 ,8*%!%"!*$*" ! !*#%*>%3
2/3 $ *!!" .J "G% .00/ + "=!$* *!!" %%% =! 4#$%%!"3 "!*$*)#!2$;$!.00/ %%)"!" % ;!% *%* $*%D! #!)( $% (; K ($* %$"D #E>!) ;!% K%$ ! "#% #$"D: "<94 % *%!%%*$!$5(!%3+(%="*$$##"$% .2 $ % .F ! .00/ $ !! ) $ (;! *!&"!20;$!.00/3 #$*!*)(!#!%*%$;!D! #"$%$"D#E>!)#$*4!%%5(!%(*%!%%"%# $##"$%;!&!#!2$;$!.00/3
2C3 $ "$$!$ 2$ *D$ .00/ !%$<%* $"$ #$: $!D *3 * #$*D% <"%!" #$"*$ D!!!$%(##"$%#$"*$#%;% $!D !!%$%!=3
%=" "%5(%!"*!!"$"##"!%!"%5) #$*%%!" "!% 4!* " (9 ($&!3 (*;%!%*"L $!D$!%(;!)"%%!4;!%K%$9*$*" (9 ($&!% $"$% "% 5 ("%$"! #$%%!" <)(5%/2$.00/"!3
$"$% :9 "==$!$ *#$!" 9$; #! #$!%# .00.3 (9$!""%*%*;!%!99$;*!%%!"3 $*=:$5(;! *!&"! + $ " ) *;"##* *%% %$ #"%&%$%!) !% 5 (9$!" %!"* !!)(5!$ ")!%*%%"!%K%$"!*$*" ! ,&/ % ,&C3 $%% $"$% "% )
-./0/-.00/ &C-1& +$!%G"%!$5!;$$!!%*<"$!:$#$% 9!!#%M%)(!!%$5="$$*$%!"!!%$!%3
2@3 ;!%* 5 #$""$ + " #$*;! 2F =*;$!$ .00C " $<% $"$3 =!% $$)$ ) ! (" !;!% $!"% ($* #$%%!" "* #$ + ;$!% K%$$D"$*%"%"#$%!%K%$#$!>$9#$($$! #"$%%)(!%!)$*!%*(!#!%*%$;!!#%D5 !"!%*%D!3
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
2H3 #!)2/;$!.00C *=$"!9*)4$$ *%!%!#!)*(==!$R(#$% +, ?$$ B% (%$ #$% +, ?$$ ! %!:$ (!!%* <"$!:$ $*9! #$ B3 $:; )(! (9!% 4 #$" <$!!) !%!%3 #$!:$ %$!%* #"!% ; ($& !% % $ *!!" !%!9!3 $ "L "9 !;")* (% # $%!" ; !%3 ! % 5 >$9 ($$& !!!%"!%!"9**$3$($$&!(%# 99*#$"*$3
213 $"$$!$.C!.00C $"$%"$=!%;"!$)!%!%!" %$4#$""$$"$%!%%"%)!! ;!%*%*!!%!%$!3 ==% #"!($&!%"%!; * + "$ ) $%!=!% ($&! #$";!% +3 $:; ) 4 #$" "$ "$* "% K"9""$;$% !*%%%$5$*$"=!""%
-./0/-.00/ &@-1& (#5$*#"$3 =!"#% ($*%)$*(*:; )(5 2PCH@ =$3 F@ % ) ($&! (% # ("D<% #$"*$ 99* ! #$!% 5 ==!$$ ) + $!% G %$!%$ #$"D*%!) "$* #"!% ; ($&! *>*%5*>$9($&!%3
2J3 *=$(%;"$$*!2.<!%.00C#"$$*#"$5 "D$;%!"3$"$$!$2@<!.00C*$#"$%*! /2<!%.00C )!!*%*"$*3*!!#$%! (%# !=%*3
.03 $*!!".2"%"D$.00C $!D!!%$%!= "%%%) #! 2$"G%.00/ !(*%!%#"#*%%#"$%$!%$#$"*$!%$"!% %!:$($&!% $<%*<"%!"3
.23 $ !$ J ";D$ .00C ! $ $$K% #$ ) ! ! $"$ !%$<%* #$ ($* "%$ *!!" $*!$ #$%%!" % $;"E*5+=!)%%$!:$!;$(!%*9$!%* #$%%!"3
!-,
23 "!9;"!$("$9!%!"<!!!$?B*%*"!=!*%!%!%* : 2$"G%.00/ $!D%"$"!? ,B "#"* !)<9 "% #$*!% % ;!&#$*!% !) ##*% % !S <9 $?$%32%3$%@F B3
,!%5(%!"(*%!"!S<9$#$ $!D=**$ ? 'B.H<;!$.00C ? '2/0 20FB $ "!9;"! "#%* 2/=*;$!$ !#"!%!"%$!%"!$$9%?$%32F.B#$%%% $!D %" $ "! !*9$ $ 5 %$"! <9 %!%!$ (%%%(*%!"";4<9$3
.3 $!D%"$"!%%!%!) "%% $ "%%%!" $%!; 5 "! =**$ .0 $ 2J12 $ ($& !% ?!&#$: T =3$%3 2 %3 $ % @F 3 2 %3 >3 @ B3 "#*% $!D * % : "$ *%D! #"$ "N%$ #$*% !%!93
/3 "!=**$$#$%!9**$$"!%$"!F"%"D$ .000 ? T 1/032B % %$* ;!9$ 2$ <;!$ .00/ %$N% "D$"!=!%!""!($&!%3 4%$ ($%3 2 3 2 ?%$ 2$ <;!$ .00/B !#"!%!" (##!)%5($&!% 5"!) (E*$"94#$*%3
-./0/-.00/ &F-1& C3 %!%$J>#!%$2"!!%!%6!#"!%!"#*!$%!;4;"! $"!%83 ($%3 20F #$*;"!% !! 4#$*% 6*! $"$ #*!8%$"!"!#"$*!!"$"##"!%!"#"$%%$#$%%!" ($ !*$"9%!"5($%3F0 3 ("$$ $"$*%* !%$<%*%#%!3
@3 *!!" !%!9! #"$% $ % 5 #$%!$ ) ($&!% *%!%$"!%%%$=!5#$%%!"3
F3 ,"P$%3F32 #$%%!"P$"%"*P!% #$"=!" P!%"#$"=!"%!#$"=!"3
$"!% 5 #$%%!" *"% P !% $* ##" PD"$ %$ P*;*%"9D$%:$!%%P%%!%5%* ! !%*%$3 %%4!9%$#!"$)P!E!P%%$) %*;*%!% "9$!%##$"!%%"% ")P! $!% # $; K !:$3 P% # *!$ $;> ) P!%"!%!)"!*!%P%%!%5%*T!=%%!==!% ) P*;*% "9D "!* *;%% 5 P%$ =%$ !% #$";")*P%%!%5%*#>E!)"#E>!)P$* P%&5&!$)P! #$*%""!%!"!)"&!3
$"!%5#$%%!"P$&!%##""%$P4!%P ! !%* *)% %$ P!% % P%%!% 5 %*3 !%* % *)% ! P#$: "$ "$!!$ >" % P4#*$! ;! =!% "!*$* *%!% #$"#$ 5 %$N$ ==% 9$ ! )! P% #$"!% $; $*%% #$!% =O" 9**$ =;"$!* #$ % !$"%? '2.J212"!3/3. C0@"!3.3. '2.@CF2"!3 @%$*=*$B3
,"<$!#$ !$##"$%!%*;P!%%*%D! P$$ P%*!*""D!9%!"P"%$"E$#$%%!")!P!%"%!% #%$%*)%P%%!%5%*3 "%="! K) #"$P*%D!%!!%*%$="%$"!%5#$%%!" !==!%)!#$!%!"$%:$P!%*9$5P%%!%5 %* P$* "!% *%D! 9$* >D!% ;$!D #$*#"*$% $)!%!:$P$"!3
H3 ("$$ ! (% # "%%* ) ! !%* %$ %$ (*;*%21<!%.00.%%$"D$"%$*#$$"$%(%# $*!*3$"L*!!"%%)**($$&!%"!% +, % % =! ;$% #$%%!" ;$* 5 %!%$ )%!"!%**)%%%$%5%$>$(*%%3$ $"$%%&K)(*;*%($!%#G%$N$"9 !#!%* %$;! % !#% %% $!:$ 5 *#$!" *<5 #$*4!%%3
-./0/-.00/ &H-1& ," #$"D*%!) $:; ==%!;% ($ ! *>*%5*>$9($&!%3:"$ #!#"$%;"!$! ($* *%* !!% $$$ #$ !9 " $$ !3 ( $ # "! ) $!$ % #$" <$!!) !%!% +, 5 ) ! $;!$ *>*% #$$ >$9 =$!*"$!3
(##$%!%#"# $!D*%$>$)%!";"!$! #$%%!" )! "% *%* "* #$ +, 5 $"$% $!% (K%$:*#$%#$+, :"$)(!%!*(#$ *!!"$*%$%!%%!"#$%%!";$*3
*9$ 4 "!*$%!" )! #$*:% $"$ % $<%*3 $!D *<9#%$9$%%D"=!")(!%!*%$%!%#$: $* % "% )(! $!% # U #$ *""! #$"*$ U %$%%$ !$%%"!$5+, 3
-./0/-.00/ &1-1&
! -,2 !,+ - +! -,
13 4 5 67 )0$ -
3
23 *$$"$$;D3
3
.3 $<%%3
/3 !%)#$"*$%9$%!%3
C3 !%)#$%!#;%="$$$"$"%$#$*%$$K%*! /0 <"$ : "%!=!%!" #$ #! $"* $* $!D =**$ $ ,>V!S$>"=)! F F00C %$"! 4#!$3 *"!$"!%RB!!)$4%%)*!!"$"$%*!$"D%!$ !%#*!!"%%)*TDB4#"$#"$)"%!=$"$% %!#";"!$$%%%$*!!"TB#"$%$!9%$$"$% ""$#$*%%3,!*"!$"%!%#%$"!**%**$* "%%$BDB%B!& $!D=**$$#"$$# %$$ %!:$ $ $"$ )(! ;$ *$$ !$$;D3 *"!$ $"$%!"$"$"E#$; )!$"%<"!%*"!$ (! (9!% #!: #"!" $"$%3 ,$"% *9% <"!% *"!$*!!"%%)*%(;"##)*%*4#*!* $"$%?$%32/.20F%201B3 9$==!:$R #$*!%R !'' W$!, W
"#!"="$#$*%$$K%%"%!=!*4#$%!!!)(5(==!=**$ %*#D!)#$9$==
-./0/-.00/