Insurance Policy Construction: Specific Exclusion Versus General Coverage
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe appellate court reviewed a case concerning the proper construction of certain liability insurance policies in light of conflicting clauses regarding available coverage limits, specifically addressing whether an exclusion for designated risks superseded a general grant of coverage. The court reasoned that where a policy contains both a specific exclusion for a defined risk and a general insuring clause that appears to cover that risk, the specific exclusion governs, but only if it is clearly and unambiguously worded and does not render the general coverage illusory; in this instance, the exclusion was deemed sufficiently specific to control the coverage outcome, thereby limiting the insurer's liability to zero under the circumstances presented.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Insurance Policy Construction: Specific Exclusion Versus General Coverage: The court reasoned that where a policy contains both a specific exclusion for a defined risk and a general insuring clause that appears to cover that risk, the specific exclusion governs, but only if it is clearly and unambiguously worded and does not render the general coverage illusory; in this instance, the exclusion was deemed sufficiently specific to control the coverage outcome, thereby limiting the insurer's liability to zero under the circumstances presented.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the rejection of the appeal and the allocation of costs.
Testo completo
!
"###$% &%'%" %
" #( $# #( % "#$% $ (%
) *) !
$+,
!" #$%& '( !)* ( * "* ! +"* ,* "
*
-- . // 0 *!" 1 23 )* 4$5 #$## #6
0 $780
) - 9 .:: * .0( *" ;0)' < = :" .* ** )** ;! + ): * *= > ;0)' *= " #28% ) " $8 * $3 :"( $%%$ !*: 9 )*" *( * ** ( +?)* !* ) ::*" 2 ! $%%% ) * !* ) ) + )* @ A
." *B*" * " * #5 ( $%%$ * > .* " 9+ ( + ) ** !)"!* A
") #5 B $%%$ . B* A
) "* !)"!* #$ :"( $%%6 * "@" @@(* "** *" :!" ) !" *** A
+ )" "( "*" (* * 9 +* "** )"* "*" ) $ )*!C $%%6 A
+ ?)* * ) ::*" ) * +?)* !" ;0 )' < = 4 ! $%%5 * > ) )*" *( )' ( **" 9 +D"!1 ! * (@ * )* * )(* E* ?)9" ) " !*9 CB*(C * 9+ +1 ) +* !** > )*" *( 9 !)9" ) "*D1! D9 A
) " 3 ( $%%5 :!" $# ( $%%8 + :!" : )** ! F +?)* *D0)1D*9 +* ) * > ! : ))"* A
* :* * $4 ! $%%8 A
"*" ) * #8 B $%%8 A
* ")" ))* !" ? !)"!* 9 * "*" ! ) ( 9 !** **: ))"* ) ) #4 "!C $%%8 A
. !)* ! * 9 .* * * 8 :"( $%%3 "*" ( B* * +(* 9E* ( + * A
7#4&67$%%$
0 6780
!" "*" * > + #5 ! $%%3 * )'0(C *! ) ( ) ) $$ ! $%%3 A
+D1)*D' "! ) *"! +* ) (!CC ?)* @9 B * + ?)* )1D*9 9 )!* ! "( :: )1D@9 )** * :! "D"* )*" *( A
) # B $%%3 C 9 +( )* * > > )" A
+ * E* @ " > B@ +:: !** )* 9 * ?)* )1D*9 * E* @*"A
) . 9 C " * !)"** !*' ) "* # G* $%%6 ;*H 58 .@* B 0 = A
")" :! * " )"( ) * (C > :! ;*H 58 * 8% = A
.**" !**( * ** .:: :* "*!* .*0>0 ** * * ") .))* '@ * ; - ##3 $8# H 6 )H $86 A H I /J(D@D* #224 *H# )H 46&= A
. . !** * * . ** !)"!* 9 "@* )* * ""!* ** 9'* * ! * 9. )* * ! K( ?)* 9. ),* " : )* !" ? ; - ##3 $&$ H 4 )H $&6 A #2&5 )H $4% H4 A I H *H= A
L*" B@ 9 ' 9 :* * ) ::!!* " " )* (1 > . !** ) !)"!* .** )" 0!E! > * ** !)"!* ; #226 )H #68= A
)C"!*9 +)' * !)? +*" )" )**" * * 9 * M * !*) ( !" ? :@* A
+ )),* B +D J !* 9 :: * +* ) +@ @9 CB*(C * 9 + +* ) ) !* A
7#4&67$%%$
0 4780
+ B*: : ?! * ' : ) !" )1D* ? : "*! * :: + ::* )1D*9 ( * * 9 ! A
. (* . * ?)* * : !" )1D* D: B* ( )1D* * N"*C!* D)*N > D@ ) +::* 0!E! +?)* : 0 :' A
. ))* .*H 62 )" !**( ; = " #% B " ? )* ) "(* "* .?)* * 9* !)"!* * 9 )"* !!9"A
" !)* +*!" ! 9 +?)* "@" )" 9 ))"* (@* +?)* )1D* +"** )" +?)* * ) )*9" ;:H ))* +?)* 4 ! $%%5=H
///
" $% 0 1 (% " #( $# #( % "#$% $ (%
) 22.,
#H ?)* )1D*9 .?)* 1* ) ! .?! * .* )' .E* *" * ""!* * * )' ( ) . 9 )"* )" .** .( * C A
$H D@ .?)* ") ? 9* (* < #H !' $H " CB*( ) 6H *** CB*( 4H @*;=
7#4&67$%%$
0 5780
5H * ) D9 @* )" "9 )*" *( * )0*H 8H * ( .)*" *( C "D"* 1 !) "(* * $%%$ * BH 3H 9 ! *(*" *( )*" *0 C!* ?@C * * 9 ! O &H ( D ' . " )** ):H 2H )*" *( )*0 E* !"" ) ! !" O #%H * ##H " "D"* 9 ))"* (@ * ))* 4 ! $%%5H #$H * !)"!* *C !*:! ? <
= P00*0 )" !:* + !C *" )1D*9 + *" * + " !)** O C= / 100*0 ::*;= );= D9;= ) ! : +"* * ) " "! C O = )* +*"@* ** !:** ( O = "** )1D9 *" ; "(* )C ) *D")*9= = D **!* !C* ** :! ? '@ +* * ! "DC** ")* !*(* * ::* ) O := : 100*0 (@ * "* * !)*!* C(" "@* .* * *"*9 !* (@ C ! @ (@ * :!* : ) )** * ** .!' )* *' "!**( 9 * C .?)* 9 ."@* D ) !@" (!* )1D ** O @= * )0*0 )1D9 .* *! *0 ?@C 9. ) *(*" *( !E! )? .!)** ::* O
#6H * !9 * * ))* .?)*H
6H !!* > : A
7#4&67$%%$
0 8780
4H (* .?)* > ") > ! ( ))* ?
?!) C " A
5H "( : A
@::' " *
PQ R C /
) :! )"* E* * *:" ? )* 9+> +:: :" " ) @::
7#4&67$%%$