Appeal of Denial to Vacate Arbitration Award Regarding Contractual Obligations
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA litigant appealed a ruling upholding a decision that declined to vacate an arbitration award, arguing that the lower court erred in finding no basis to disturb the award, where the dispute involved contractual obligations and the challenger claimed the arbitrator exceeded their authority by considering issues outside the scope of submission and applying incorrect legal standards. The court reasoned that judicial review of an arbitration award is extremely narrow, and the challenger failed to demonstrate that the arbitrator manifestly disregarded the law or decided issues that were clearly not submitted for resolution, finding that the arbitrator's interpretation of the contract and application of law, even if arguably flawed, fell within the scope of permissible arbitration, thereby affirming the denial of the motion to vacate.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Appeal of Denial to Vacate Arbitration Award Regarding Contractual Obligations: The court reasoned that judicial review of an arbitration award is extremely narrow, and the challenger failed to demonstrate that the arbitrator manifestly disregarded the law or decided issues that were clearly not submitted for resolution, finding that the arbitrator's interpretation of the contract and application of law, even if arguably flawed, fell within the scope of permissible arbitration, thereby affirming the denial of the motion to vacate.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe provision is cited in the dispositive section concerning the allocation of court costs.
The provision is cited in the dispositive section concerning the allocation of court costs, specifically regarding the reduction of fees for the respondent.
Testo completo
!"#$$!%&&' (!#%"!%&&'
(
) (*) (+ ) +*
,-. / %& 0-. %&&'
!"!#$#"! !%!$
%$!
&& ' (( ! 1$1# )%*+ "%$,-. /-// /0
6-2/06
1*(
/7 #-+!/*5/ 88$#%!1$#%91:$%1! %!$: ;<'= '>: // 7 "!? @%1! 1# ?! = 1% $$ !1?!'@%)#$!@1!$!"!1%8$1%7
-7 '1$#!#$@(1"!1?! 8%1/*34 %;81 "1!7 /*3- '1$ #811$1@$ (17 $!@1 <1$# @='1"!1A"$A7 "!?18$ /*3+ $/*3* '"A!#'$1@1$#!$1@7
07 (1$ = B$ = %11 /5 '1$#!# %88!$ !@1:1 "%$ $!$1<7"1/3 "!#$%9:1 "1 ?/ '1$#!# "1$"!$B#117
,7 -/%@9!-44/ '1$#!##"%#"!$$1%"!? '881 $% '!61@11$# C16"!? D %11$$ '%$!%1 ' !$%@"!%81% '"$11<'!$7
.7 #"%$ <$1%1! !@$ = #$!1! $$$ '1$#!# #!# <' 9% $# !1$ $!@1# % @ = "1 $" "1 %@9! -444 "%! !1% 811?!7 !1$ BE: ? /! %@9! -444 #$# 1"1$# $!@1 = .4 F /! ;1 -44/ /0 %G$-44/ $=<#$#!!H$$!@1=/44F7 9##811# "!$$1%17
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
2/32-445 602/06 +7 (':1$ "1$# "!%81% ! 11<# < '1$#!#@1$"!1@1#:1!'$!"%1$1%129%$ <'@1$ #@1$!%$$"%1$1%=:%A !%"1 '111%9$ "%!$ B!:$%@$!#"#$1$187%$1@$1%"%!!"!1'$!@1 %'!$"!%81%$819$'9$#1"!#@119G='#$$ $#1"%!$$7
37 ' 88$#<H$=%11-3%$%9!-4407'!#A"1<# < % #"%A #$1$ 9##81 ' 16!$ '!61@11$# "1 /+$<81$1#"!'I%"1 :##!7 @%!"!! $1@1$#@="1$" %@9!-444 1%#$$$#' "HB#7 9##811# "!$$1% $% BE: 1;<'@!1-44-7
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
/47 ! #11%-0"$9!-44, ' !;$#"!$$1% '1$#!# %$18 <' "!#$1$ "1$# $!@1 34 F $1@1$#"$#7(%:!#'1@11$# #!9' <H$1! $!$!1! '#$911$=-5F$#$1$1881$"%!%@!1!!%1$= !$7 $ A ! "!%81% '#$1$ " @1:9 ? %!<'1$#!#A"!11$1!$'H$!"!')%$$!7
2/32-445 6,2/06 //7 !%!!1!/-%$%9!-44, !8%!#%""%1$1% 1@%<$ 81$%@ =@%1!'""!1$1%"1<<%1'#$$#"!18"%! < $ $!1$# "! ! "#11$ &I ")B1$!1 $ ")B%$B#!"17 N!# #:$ 8%!# %""%1$1% "! %!!1! 0 #9!-44,7
/-7 ' ! #$91 !""%!$ $ /+ #9!-44,A$!<"$1$"!#$1$819!%):1"181 -440 !@1%69!B1:1 B!%1< "1 /5 #"1% #"!18 #@?! )"$E ")B%$1< "1 #9$ -44, 11 <' :%!"B%91 @ $!%9 "1< "1 -44- 88$1% "%! < $A '1"1$# $!@1 $ /44 F7 #1 11< < "$1$ 1$ $!1$$ % 8%! '$1#"!! $ %18?! 11 <' $B#!"1 %:1$1@ $ %"%!$$7
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
/,7 %$//@!1-445 (!?@ @%1%'A"!$1 ")B1$!1< < 11$$1% 8%$1% %$1< %1@$ H$! "!1%"$7
2/32-445 6.2/06 /.7 !#11%-,@!1-445 ' !;$#'%""%1$1%'!# %$18< $!%9 %$%8%! %%!A !@H$ " :!# :!@1$# !<1 "! ;!1"!"%!H$!1@1$ %!$<11$$1%8%$1% %$1<%1@$H$!"!1%"$7
/57 "!#$#"! %":1' !!%$$1%!11<( '!# 1$!;$$ !%! -5 1 -4457 !#8?! A $1$1% ! $ % < $ $%$$ 1"9 'A!! $1@1$# $ ?: <' '$ " ! '88$! $!@A #:!7 "1$# !#1 $!@1 34 F 1 9 $%"1< @ %9! 11$$1% "B)1<7 !"!%B = ' '@%1!"$%"$%1%! 7
/+7 !#"% -- ;1 -445 ' !#8?! A %1% 'A"!$ ")B1$!$%$!;$!%!7
/37 #!1$!' %$#$#%1<#=!%!$$--;1 -445$%1!$=1"%1$1%"%!%$$1%7(!<%1 #$# :!#=;:!7
+*(
/7 %1:@%1!N%!:1$1%;111!CD#$#%181#$1$1$# ? /!%G$-440 !19$%!%1 %"%#.;: %$"!#1$$@16"!#1$ .""#$$/5;:!C!$7/$7 !$.5 D7
(1$=N$1%N#$1%/5;:! "! !198##! -+;@1!-44,C &/04/45D ! %1:@%1%"$# /08#@!1! 1"%1$1%$!1$%1!!:$"!$$$ !19$%! %1 1#:! ! = $!%1 ;: $1$1! N$$$ N#$1%%@A;:!7
-7 %8%!#$ = '!$7 .5 7 / $7 B7 - !19 $% !%1%L$1$1<%$$$1%"!#@=N!$7.5 %18##!!"!$1:##!!%1$!%15%$%9! -444C D<1%$!$1@=%1!N!61@11$#/*;1/*.* C D7
(%"#$"%!;:!N"?$11#$917
07 $ $!# @1:! /! ;@1! -440 $!L$ %181$1% %9!1"%1$1%#:%1'!61@11$#7%!<
2/32-445 652/06 $%$8%1 '% A1 !%1$ #@$ = !$ '1@11$# "%! "#!1% "!##$'$!#@1:! 1)1'""1<!"!11":##! !%1$$!1$%1! %<6HB:$9#:6 !?: ""19 %$ @1:! %$ %P 81$ ;!11<$ #$!1$ %$ "!%1$7 1 !%1$ = !$ %1$61 H$! A1# !:!'1!%1$"%!"#!1%;<'0/#9!-44-$8%$1% %@!#:$$1%#:"!?$$$C &/04,00%17/$ !#8#!D7 !?:"!%#!<$= '""1<$ !#!@? ;%! % $!# @1:! C & //+ *0 %17 59 //- 054 %17 ,O /3Q0+"70/5%1709D7
,7 $!;$#8%!$#1"!!1$"!%1 !%!$!@9C!$7.5 $54 D7
.7 1$1: "%!$ ! <$1% #$!1$1% :!# '1@11$# !%!$$ "!$$ %!%1$A"!$$1%'!61@11$#7
(% N!$7 , N1@11$# $ 11$1% "1$# :1 "!## "!$ % %: !# <1 !#$ N $$1$ = $# "B)1< % $ "!%@$ N 181!1$# %:#1$ N 1 % N 1$7 N$$1$ = $# N$ % " = #$!1$ $ ! "!1 %1#!$1% < ! %P $!L 1"1$# $!@1 )$ 88$!"1$#:1N!#C)!6! :$JR9!1 @1@!1B!: S!1B/+ "73D7
)1"!#1!<%;!1"! %$1%N1@11$# !%1$!%1 $%$1%#%%1<$%#1O%$ %#< #%%1< %9;$1@ N1"1$# 8%$1% <N1 1"%!$ N#@! C & //4 -+. %17 , /4. -4+ %17 -D7 %!<N !1%N1$1@1$#N!# %##%%1<8%$#8$ 1)1 8%! ! %# N%!! #1 ! %P "!$$$ N#@! "1$# $!@1 N1$#!# $1@1$# !1%9$ A1:19C &//./00%17- /4./.3%17/D7
N1@11$#$!#"$#!@?<N$ "!$!$:!@1$# "!%"!= %@!1!!%1$A"!$$1%$!$%1#!$1%C!$7,7- D7 %$ %1$ H$! #$!1# %9;$1@$ N"!? N#$$ $#O 8$! A$! 8%!$1$N%$"N1"%!$7#""!$11!1$=< #$# "!#$# 1 = "!$1! < "!$$1% #$# !<1 $ %T1 " % " #1!$ @ %$ %P N!# ""! "%! "!1?! 8%1 < N$$1$ = $# "$ %@!1! !%1$ = "!$$1%N!7
(N:1$!%1$=!$ !@N1@11$#1$%$%P 161"!1 %8%!#$=N!$7-*7/ %1$?<N!#
2/32-445 6+2/06 "!#$ 1"1$# :1 !9 ,4 "%! $ %1 % ? <N1 "!#$# %) 1"1$#$!@1,4"%!$%1"$ #1$!!"$1%%$91"$E$/!;%!%1<11$ 1A6B1$1?1@!1!N!#C!$7-*7- O &/-5*%17-9$ !#8#!O%17,707/N!!H$7/!1-440 +3424-D7
(% N!$7 -3 7 / $! @1:! ;<' 0/ #9! -440 N!#!%1$=!$$1?!N1$1@1=55-20F%1 =16 !$ N1 $ 1@1 = .4 F %1 % = <!$ !$ N1 $ 1@1 = ,4F%1O"#19 N!#"$ N"!?N!$7-37/91 "!#$! 16!$ N1 $ 1@1 = ,4 F %17 "1 /! ;@1! -44, $'$!#,?!#@11% '!#!%1$=<!$!$N1 $1@1=,4F%1 =16!$'1$1@1=.4F%1 = $!%16<!$!$'1$1@1=54F%1$=!$$1?!'1$ 1@1=+4F%17
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
!1! <1%!@!"!%9$N!""%!$#1 <1$ #$!1$ N$ < "%1$ 1$1:1A 1$ 81$ N%9;$ N #$ 1!%$1# < !""%!$ 8% ! A %"$ <N1 "! #:$%1#!$1%"1$A"!1#"!"!%A1# <N1
2/32-445 632/06 1$#$##$91"1%1N? <!1"$1%%$A$ #1 $ N""!#1$1% 1$$1% #1 %1$ 1! $ 81 < %1% NA"!$ %1$ G$ %$1@#7 !$ N##$ #$!1$ "%! @! "!%9$ N$ 1 N%!1:1 %) "!@ 1 #1:$1%%!""%!$%%A"!$1 19$91%%$C & /-.0.-%170 /--/54%17/$!#8#!D7
+7 D '"? 1 !#$ %1! #1 < !%!$ %88! !@1:1 %9:1 11 < %! A "%1:$ :!$ % %#1$!1$$ 1"1$#$!@1/44F"1/-;@1!-44/7 %$8%1 N!@1%$!!11:181$18 B%!11!?$B!1 1#1 .6 588$%"!187H ! !%%: N %$$# 11<$ 1: N$$1$ !11! @ #$!%!%)%:!<1$%!7
"%1$@!B$%%:1< NA"!$$#"!N1$1#%$$#<N <1%!:%A 1A1$$$"%$#1$%1"!$1=:B$ 1: !1%%:1< N :%!$B!% #9$$ = !%1$7 %$8%1 NA"!1% 11< !$ 819 $ $$ 8%$1% :%A $ "!$1<$%!7NA"!$%9!@#<"1$#!1$"!"$1$ 1@!@1$%91!%$J1"%!$$%!<!"11< 11$$1%!$$"$E$%#!# @%!!#$1%!1%611<J8197 $$ %"$ 11$$1% 8%$1% NA"!$ $1# < "1$# !#1$!@1N$1@1$#@$.4F "!%99$"1 / %!<$1@1$#"$# $34F7
(! " ")B1$!1< ! ")B1$! $!1$$ #@%<# 1:%$1819!%):1$N#"1%#"!18#@?!"1#9$-44, "%! <$!1$$$1#"!!#$#1$!# 11<N$B#!"1%:1$1@$ %"%!$$7 !""%!$1$#!1$"$"8M%#$1# $$")B1<!%!$7 %$! <$1%1!%"#$1! "%!$!%9")B1< #111<#<N1"1$#$!@1#$1$ $%$ "NA"1$1%7%1$1% N$=;$$1$!<N1$1# %!%#A"!$1")B1$!1<7
88$ !!H$ !#$ C & 3 8#@!1! -445 00524, "!#@ "%! "91$1%1%8811D !198##!!%1#!# <'1 ;$1811$ % ': ;!11< $ '#$$ $ %1 '""1<!"!%:1"!11"#@%""#"!;!1"!$1?! $!%9%$%8%!%%!A%!<'1':1$'""!#1!!$?!1@1$ ' 819!%):17 A $$1$ = $# "!#$$ 88$ !$#!1$1< % $$ < ! 18$$1% 11< 6 "1$ %%! 188 6 %$ "%! '$1 111! $ <'1 'A1$ " "$B%:?1!$819"%@$A"1<!'%!1:17 !A
2/32-445 6*2/06 11$$1%"1$#$!@118811$!9 !'%"$ " #1! 'A1$ ' 1"1$# $!@1 1" 1:%$1 "%# ? %!<161!1:"%!!'1$1$#%!!$1"! "!% %!# 1 ! ! #@%$1% % ! "!%%$1 <'% "$ "%! %!$7 1%@1$61#:$ "!#'819!%):1 "%!"!#%"$1%<$$88$1%%88$"@$H$!!%$#"! 88%!$@%%$#!1%9$A1:19C &/0/.4D7
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
91 H 1:%$1 819!%):1 $ '9%! 81$ ' #1 !B$%%: 1 %@1$ 'A1:! %%! ' #1 "#11$ ")B1$!1 %!<'1 ':1$ "!%%! ! '1"1$# $!@1 < 819!%):1$"$19'$!L! ?%!<8$!")B%%$1< %$ % '%"11% %1$ 18 #11@ ! #@%""$ $$$$1$=$#7A"!$11$!11"11!$$=8%1%"$ "$ !B$%%:1< $ ")B1< ""!L$ % ! '1$!$1%
2/32-445 6/42/06 #<$ "%! #$91! 1?! %9;$1@ 1 '!# "!#$ #$$ %%!A ':!@1$#$6#:!#:$A!1$?!#$!1$"!#1$#6< 1@!"1$#$!@1!!B#$!@1"$"$%$ %$"!$1$H$!A1:19"!$C@%1!1I ( S! :$B$:%$%8%!!($V!:1U!A1*,2-44. "7-44+7D7!$ !#!@#%P#1!B$%%:$'9#!%$$! "! %9!@$1% #1 %$ < !1$?! #$!1$ %$ "!"1 %%1"'1?!881$1$ "%!%!= 1"1$#$!@1C!!H$(7"!#1$# %17,70D7
9D (% NA"!$ ")B1$! ! & 1:%$1 !$ %1$ )!% %%!A %$%8%! "!1$$ ;%!$1% )"$E "B)1<"%!!1%")B%%:1<$"!%1$#A1N%$" !#"!1% ! "1$# $!@17 A"1< < $!%9 %$%8%! %$ %88! N!# 1 9 " !@H$1! :!# NB1" $ < N!#"1"$$!W@!!%!"%!"%@%1!$!@1! #$$ !""# <N 1%! $!# ! )"$E "B)1<7 %$ < N1"1$#$!@1$A1-4F7
1 <N1 ) 1$ !$1 %$!1$1% "!%"% NA"!$ ! %P 1 11< < 1:%$1 N%$ " N18 ! "1$# $!@1 "%! %! 1$ = 1"1$# $!@1 N A1 -4 F !19#!?@<N#$$#"!18$#!1$%#:! !#$1%= N""!1$1% %! $ <N1 "$ H$! 1 N#@%$1% $! N $!%9 %$%8%!U NA"!$ A"% < "1$ $1 %! %! 1$ $ "!1$$ N%":$ N $1$ #$! % A"1<# $1?!$ "! "!% "B)1%%:1< % $!%9 ")B1< !@$ %$A$ %81$ #%$1% CB)$#!$%1 "1 " $! %!$ "?!D $ "!%9? ")B%%1A 881$ 1"%!$$ "%! H$! %1#!# % $1 $!%97 N;%$ 81$ < )"$E "B)1< %$ "181# % $!$ "! N#$$ ")B1< !%!$7%!!" !19#!?@<NA"!$1!#1#"! ! & %"%!$ ? #$1# <N1 %1 N$1! %1! <N1 "!1 %"$ "1$ !%!$ <N1 A"1<#$%$1@#1:%$1 %!$<N!@H$"1@!"!%9$7
1"!1!!""!<"%!<1%!!""%!$#$ #1$!1$$ ;:"$$%1$$1!%"$81$!@$NA"#!1 < "! "%1$1% %81$ "!1@1#:1# < 1 %8?! % $ #1$!1$$$!B!%$8@!%"$1$C &/-, /+. %17,$!#8#!1$#OX%)!52*,"75+D7
@ <1 "!#? 8%! $ '$$! < )!% %%!A B!%1< < "!#$ !%!$ '$ " 1@1$
2/32-445 6//2/06 ;!1"! '9'%%!911$#")B1$!1<'1$#$' !# 881$ 1"%!$$ "%! $$! <' 88%!$ @%%$# @ !%$!%!$!#1$#:!!"!%$!@1'$"A1:19 "!$7
;$181 %#< !$1! < 11$$1% 8%$1% %$1<#!1$"!!N$N$$!<!%!$"!#$ "1$#$!@1!#1.4FN$1@1$#@$34F $1@1$#"$#7
37 N%!! 9% $# !%!$ !1$ !"!1 $1@1$# = "1 $" % @ ? %@9! -444 "%! !1% 811?!7 @ "1?%1! N$11=;$$1$!<N1$1#N%1#!#% "!%$1@7
(%'!$7-37- @1:!;<'0/#9!-44- "%!'#@$1% '1@11$# !@$!@1<'1@1"%!!1$%9$1!A!M$'$1@1$# <1 "$ H$! !1%9$ H$! A1:# 1 "!? A#$1% #@$ ! !#"$$1% $ %"$ $ ' 1$$1% #<119!# !B# $!@1 $%"!#!@<'1!1$"%9$1!'1'#$1$"1@1C87#:7 !$7/5 ?/!;@1!-440D7
%"!1% !@ N88$ !?: :##! B188!$ 1 A$$<"%19%$$A!@$%8!%$$N @ N$! 188#! "!$$$ ! $A N1@11$#7 !%P!@"@$H$!B188!#A$$ 1%1@$H$!$1# N"!?##$%"!$11! "!?<%1N%%"!$! @!""!%A1$1@11%9$C#$B%:##!%"!1% !@O &/-304%17/O &/4,/05%17-$-9D7 <1 %! %"!1% !@ %$ #$!1$ !""%!$ A1$$ %$'%@!$!!%1$=#@$!$ 11<%181$1% #@$!@;<'%$#11%<1%$%#<! !%1$=!$C &/-*---O/-3/+,D7
'"? "%! #$!1! :1 1@11$# 1 %@1$ !#8#!! A %#$$1$1<C <H$1!$!$!1!Y ((ZD %# N"%)!81$#8$7 -44-C#N%@!$!!%1$#@$= !$D !@<"$!#1!8%1@$ #$191%%$1%$!@1N#?@=0'+,/8!7 "%!,4B"! 1 %1$0'*448!7"%!,/ +BC ((-44- /B188!.- 1@ ,$1@1$# 1"$!#"#$1$1@D %1$,5'3448!7"!7
%!#@!:1'1@1 1)1 %8%!#$=;!1"!91 #$91 !#8#!!A ((%!< %'"? '!#'"!"!1 '$1@1$#!$1@C &/-5+5%17092$99O(-44-"753%1709D7
2/32-445 6/-2/06 %"$$'1!9!$-44-0'34*8!7"%!$1@1$#1" $!#"#$1$1@,4B!$!"!%$1%C ((-44- /1@ ,D %1$02*+4 8!7*4"%!,/ +B!B91$C1#%%1</-2-44-"733 $9*7-D 1!%1$H$!81A#=,+'5./8!7 $$%#"1$# $!@134F !@9!$#$!1$'#?@=03'/-48!7343
%!<!@'1@1$#@#!9$$1$1<!1! %) !$1 "HB$ "!%"! = "!% '1@1 C11$$1% 1# B1" >: # !@1 $1%1$#2$#:%!1 '$%!1$1% #;%! $ $A '%"$1%D A1:$ < '% !#1 %$$ 1! 11 %9$ C & /-5 +* %17 .92D7 $ !#$1% %1@$ " H$! 88$# 1?! B#$1< 1 %1@$ $1! %"$ '9 1!%$ "!$11! $ 9$ #$!1! = "!$1! %#$$1$1< !@'1@1<1!"!#$1A1@! #%%1<A1:19$1@1$#%"$19@"1$#$!@1!#1 '1$#!#C &/-534%17.9299D7#$1%:%9A1 -. F ! 1! $$1$1< "!$ $1! %"$ 188#!$ ##$ <1 "@$18!!@'$1@1$#!$1@C &/-534%17.92O (-44-"75,D7
'%!! '1$1# "!%## = 9$$$ /4 F %"$ $ 11$$1% 8%$1%7 !19 # ' " %$18 '#!$! $$""!#1$1%7 %#< 1!'1@1 "!?9$$$ '#?@= 0,'0438!7
%#< "!?%"!1%!@@1%9$1@11$# :!# '1@11$# %1$ H$! 81A# = -5 5* F 1881$ "%! %@!1! !%1$ = !$7
*7 (':1$ ! '%!! "!%81% !19 # !"" < % '!$7 3 7 / !# 1@1 % # ' 1@11$# C!$7 3 D 11$ %$ !%1$ A ! !#"$$1% #1! <1 %$ $!=!#$91! =1$1!%=#1%!!!"1$#:1%!"1$# '%"1!!$!@AB91$ <'11$%%A!#$1@1$#!$1@ "!#97
%$8%1 %"$ $ 81$ < %! '$!$1 @ 1@11% !#"$$1%"!%81%'1$1#!%!$1!$#!#'H$!" !1@!!"!%81% 8%!$'$$!<$ !'$!$"1:%"$7
/47 8%# !%!%1$H$!!;$#7
2/32-445 6/02/06 +(*1 (*) (+ ) +*
456-- 7 0 83 "'% + 9
6-
/7 #!!%!!@97
6
-7 !;$$7
07 1$<"!%#!$:!$1$7
,7 8%! "!$1 <N "@$ 8%!! !%! %$! "!#$ !!H$ #1 04 ;%! ? %$181$1% "! "1 !%# !# !19 8##! ! (B[1J!B%8<1 5 544, $!%1 A"1!7 #1 "$ H$! "!%%:#7 #%1! %1$U D 11<! A$$<#11%!%!$#1!%9$1!1$"#11% $$<#O 9D A"%! "%! < %$18 1 $1 "%@%1! ! $$ $! #11%O D "%!$! 1:$! % % !"!#$$7 (1 #%1! %$1$ " $!%1 ##$ ##!# % $$! D 9D $ D 16 !198##!!"%!!"$!!$1?!!!%!<N1 @!#!!1!!@97#%1!!%!$1%!%!%) "!@ <1 !%$ ;%1$ 11 < #11% $$<# $ N@%"" <#$#A"#1#!%!$C!$7/0- /45$/43D7 :!881! "!#1$ \1 1
%"1%8%!"!#$!!H$$%$181#A"!$111<N=N8818##! !%1"!:!88
2/32-445