Waiver of Arbitration Through Litigation
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute centered on whether a party had waived the right to arbitration by engaging in litigation, specifically by filing a motion for summary judgment and participating in discovery. The court held that the right to compel arbitration was not waived because the litigation activity, while substantial, did not cause undue prejudice to the opposing party, as the issues litigated were largely overlapping with the anticipated scope of arbitration, and the action was not overly protracted before the arbitration demand was made.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Waiver of Arbitration Through Litigation: The court held that the right to compel arbitration was not waived because the litigation activity, while substantial, did not cause undue prejudice to the opposing party, as the issues litigated were largely overlapping with the anticipated scope of arbitration, and the action was not overly protracted before the arbitration demand was made.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for the allocation of the court costs.
Testo completo
&'()*&)++, &-)+&)++,
! "! # ! #
'. /0 % '( / )++,
% 1111111111
2 !!!" #$ %& !! " '
!"# $%
- )(* -
3
%. /! /00000000001 !!!" 234 %+ 5! %&&&1 5! "" 66!!" 466! $7 8 $ 49 : 4- ! ! ; <1 7 % " = %&&>. 7 % ! %&&&1 ! "" 66!!" 466! ' ! ! 8 $ !! 9"" 4 ! ! 75.
). 3 4" 45! 66" $! 1 8 99"
$" $! %? 2! )+++. $@ A ++ )?)?&, B "" !6!" )> 2! )+++1 3 4" 6$$" 4$$!! .
?. "!! ? C )+++1 8 ! " " $! )D+*& 6. )+1 $" $! 4 =!9! ! ! 6"" 4- ! ; /< 25! ' 5! %&&&1 !! 3 )++ 6. 6! !!!6 6. 6! !.
,. 4" 6 " $$!! ), C )+++.
*. "!! $$!! %> C )++,1 8 6! " "!!.
E. 4!"" !2" %* $ = ! "!! $$!!1 "9 34' 4"$31 ! "! F: 91 34! 5! "" 66!!" 1 34! 45! 2 ! !9" 5 8 346! !" ! C ! @ G =! ' %++H I.
J. 5!" ' " !1 8 2 .
8 3!1 "" 9" ' 29.
>. "9" $! $! $! G ! I 3! ! 3 =!.
#
%. ! 95! 49!! 2!!! ;< "" !6!" !!"1 7 % C )++?1 != !1 $" * 291 $"! 5!-$"!1 * $$" %E 29 ;. % . *E <.
(%&)*()++,
- ?(* -
8! ' 4! 4"! %E 29 1 $ != 6"" )J 25! )++, ; K %?+ %+E<1 ! 95! $"1 %?
6"5!1 !$!! !! 9 $ != ! !"9 ' ! 29 !!1 1 4 4"! 5L 29 .
8 ! $=!1 != 6"" 1 M % 2! )++,1 6! " 3 !$!! !! !! ! $ ! "! 6 1 N1 ! 6"" ; K %?+ ))E<.
). 6 " ' D. *E . % . F. , 1 != ! N ! !3 ! $"5 ' 4! *E 3! !5 ' ! 6"" 4- ! %> %&&,. != $" ! !! 4" 4 $! "$: . 4" " !!!" ' 75 $ = )++,1 $" != " $ 29 4$7 !! "=!.
?. ! 6"" $! 9"" ! ! E = )+++ ; < " 5!9 % 25! )++? N !6!! = !$!! "9 ! !. $$!= 4$71 "!! !!9! %> C )++,.
,. 8 4. ? /1 $ !!!" 8! ! 4 $ ! ! M " $ $" "9 ! ! 3! !5 $! !! ! 8!. 4!"
"!9" $ 1 ' 5! 49 : 4- ! ! 4$71 66!! 466! $ 3! 4 $ "
! ' 4=!9! 4 $ !.
*. 4!"" !! "" 66!!" $7 8 % 25! ?+ 5! %&&&.
4 $ " "!! 4 . 8 7 ! !
" $! $! 4- ! ;. E% /<.
E. 6! 4M F: 9 $ $ ! 4M L $" $! $! 4- !. 5! 5F 3 "! $! $5 M " L " !! " !3 ;. E* / O . %+E . /<.
$$! ' 4!"" "$ 5! ' 4! =!. 1 4 66" " F 34! "! !!!" .
L 9 34! 75 $ 4$$ $! $! 3! ! " "1 ! !6 F 2.
(%&)*()++,
- ,(* -
J. 849! 6! $!1 ! 466! $$" $ "=! 31 4$71 $! =! ; K %> $ = )++%<.
>. "31 != " 6! 1 ' 1 !5" 4$$!! 6 " $@ $! A ++ )?)?&, B.
(%&)*()++,
- *(* -
#3 "! # ! #
%
4/5 6 7 89 ':) #$;
5
%. " 5=.
% 5
). 2.
?. !5" "6!!!5 4$$!! 6 " $@ $! A ++ )?)?&, B ' 1 ! )D+*& 6. )+ !! 3 6! ! $ 6.1 6! !!!6 $ )++ 6. 6! $!.
,. ! 3 $" 9!.
*. 6 $! 34 $5 6 $" M "! ?+ 2 7 !6!! $ $! " " != 6"" 1 8FP!QF63! E1 E++, 1 ! L $!. "! $ M $9". " ! ! R < !!3 L 3 "!! "! =! ! $ "!! 3"O =< L$ $ 3 !6 ! ! $5! "!!O < $ !9 $". 8! " ! ! $ ! "" " "" < =< < !-1 != 6"" $ $ !7 34! 5 " !5=. " ! ! @ $51 3! 2!1 !! 3 "!! 3" 45$$ 3 "" L$"!" ;. %?)1 %+E %+> <.
966!7R "! R
/!-! S ! #
$! 6 $" M !6!" L $! !! 34' 466! 6"" " $=!3 $ 966
(%&)*()++,