Validity of Assignments by Foreign Entity Lacking Internal Documentation Filing
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose regarding the validity of certain assignments, with one party alleging that the assignments were invalid because the assignor lacked the capacity to contract due to being a foreign entity whose internal documentation had not been properly filed, while the other party argued that the assignments were valid as the assignor was duly organized and the assignments were executed in compliance with governing statutes, including an earlier decision that had upheld the assignor's capacity in a related matter. The court held that the assignments were valid, reasoning that the assignor was properly incorporated and capable of contracting under the relevant statutes, and that the statutory requirement concerning the filing of internal documentation did not invalidate agreements executed prior to the filing or render pre-existing agreements unenforceable, especially given the prior judicial affirmation of the assignor's standing.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 93 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Validity of Assignments by Foreign Entity Lacking Internal Documentation Filing: The court held that the assignments were valid, reasoning that the assignor was properly incorporated and capable of contracting under the relevant statutes, and that the statutory requirement concerning the filing of internal documentation did not invalidate agreements executed prior to the filing or render pre-existing agreements unenforceable, especially given the prior judicial affirmation of the assignor's standing.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in order 1 as the basis for declaring the appeal inadmissible because it concerns a decision concerning only costs.
Cited in order 1 regarding the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
$%&'($%))* $+,-$%))-
##
. #. / .#/ /
/0 1 * %+ 2 1 %))-
!"#$#"%$ & $ '($$!) $**+#$*,
$
-- . '' !* $,# /01!"$234!5355 56
!"#
:3753:
3
5; ! # 0 <#= 504>! $=$ *" 36 , 50>1 "? * )$" @ ' $$ + ,A; '<<$ * * ,B$C*!)$##$"$#*$=*599D*" 65E=3993;
3; ) "$ * F ,* * ,"/ , < =,$ * *,$# E? 69 =,B 3993! <*$ *G ""$ *)G"$! ) ,$+ #$B " $ ; ! "#$ -&,#*$$C,$F!$)$"/C$+<<$#" $ ! G $, *+ "$# * $= #$$ * 599 D *?5 *#,B3993;)#$$#="B$**$G"$;
6; )$##*#"#*,**"$$"?*)=*$# *$*51,3996;
2; )<< $ H:"? I B$ * ) "$ * F "?**,#**)#$+$#*<<#$,#*; ""$ *)G"$ * 55 =,B 3993 J )$$$ * ) "$ * F! $ ; "# *F$ * ,BF "#<+! =$ + )G, F+ #$$ "$$# $ + )G, $#$ ,$$$ #=* ,$ * #" $ * C $? B *#=""#! *#,$$ "BB $$ #F? * F",; *F$)=$#""$#* $=!*"$*=C,$F+!)K$)#$$"E$<#$"$$ *=$K$,$=;
4; *$#"),*"$*F!$ <<$# G"$ "/C$+ * )# 5> , 3996; ""$ *)G"$ * 3> , 3996! "/C$ "# *F$ * #$ *#"= "F#; ')F$ * "$# * $=! "## + #$ *#"= "F# $ #$$ *#"< ,*##! * "" =*$; )C/"$C? * * $$! $#B $ F=,$ "$$,K,"*F$*=+$*$"=$" K$$$)#=$*$$"$#*$=*=$<+,$ B*)#$$,$+BE$=B+*,$$<$ $"<+$#$$"$E$<C($=*BL$,$;
8; ""$#$B*$*2=3996J)$$$*) !$'; !C<*+*=*C,$F*&!" *F$ * ,BF ,, C+ *" 65 E= 3993! * "#$C$ * CC FC C+ *" 69 E$ 3993 $ *)#$$ *#"< #$ *" <#= 3996; *+# +) =$ ),"
7361873992 :6753: *)= #$# "# *) ,BF $? # * ", $,"! "=$ "<$,$ # G $= *F 2:4! , + $=$ $C#"$+ $ $# <<$ $ + "F=,$ $# J C$ * * = $ F + CB$,$*#$*F*$$;##,$G$= )E$+$,"#$$;
1; *,* * '= ,#* #F ' ! $ "##+)#<<$*),BF,,C+; =BF+!$$#*#B**#$#$#$# 2:4 FC! <<,$ * "$ =$#B "# * 2 = $#C* $$ = 6:2; * G, + *#B$ * 3996*+$,"$$,$$*<G$*)G$!+* <G $# *$! $$ $ *) $$ $ * F * F$# * M "$<; "$ * = "/CF+! $# #$$ *#"< #$!$ *)"$*=!),? #=?,"$$ $$ ,$ # J )K$ * $=! , #F,$ J *= "B?, <,G; )"$# * $= $$ + C< *)#+" * $$ #$$ * 599 D = 3996; $=$# *"$# "$ K$ * 49D!"?,$"<;
>; ""$*0E=3992!$ !*' ! F + )G"$ * $ $B *#F##$< C* ,*## E$<$ " K$ * $= "F# $ + )G"$ "/C$ $$ *F$ * #$ *#"= "F# E$<$ " *)=*$#; =$ #+ * "=#F )= * *G G"$ J * ,#* $$$ + ""$ *),"$C $ = )# ,"KC$ *)K$ BE$<; )# "#$ "$# * $= GFB * 599D*$=$#CB$;
0; *#*36,3992!) <#)$*"$$J)#! ,$< + "$# * $= #$$ $? * $=$# CB$ * C< *)#+";
59; $- !*,* =' !<,#""$
5 = 3992! "#$ + "$$ B##<$ *) " CF "*"G&!+*)"CF"/C$+"?* $ ;""$+"$$$=*)*G?, G"$"?*,#*,*$#"):=*$#;
55; ) =$$$$$#*F,$,"#,$;
53; ""$ J ) * 58 , 3992! $ - "# *F$*,BFC+!=GB$FN*"65E= 3993;)"$#*$=$$+,A$*599D*"65E=
7361873992 :2753: 3993;"##+*,B$*,,B<#FC#$$ "$$*$$$=$#;,$C#"$+$#$##C! , #F? ,#$ $ $$< = *" *#B$ *) "/C$C#";
56; $ ! "#$ -& "/C$ $ "/C$C#"! *#""$J) 1=3992;*+#+"$$<<$ * * ,B C+ $ *) $B * )*"$$ = C, *#"=; *$BE$<$""$#*$=;')F$ **C+!"A$"!"$$#$$$$#G&;
52; ""$,#*$,#*#$B"$- *$*3 E$3992,$+)#$$*$#*)#$$$$+))/ "*CF,$**F$;"$#*$=*9D$CF# *""$,B3996$"$*)"$$?*#<=B#$$*# )#=$$+#F;
54; =,#**33E$3992!' $,#+*G G"$ * #$$ "B$ $ + *)$ G"$ #$$ "<#$$;
58; *# * 50 $B 3992! ) E$# )""$ * )#! *#$ + *<<#$ ""$ $# )=$ ""$# ##,$ =;
51; "#$#";:$$=!)#$E$#*$*5> =,B 3992; $$# = "B$ * G"$ <<$# J *,* * ) ,* "$ * F $ $# "#B,$ " * )$$ * E+)J *$ EF# * + )""$J$$*?*=$ B*#H 7548373996I;
5>; ) )/#$$"""#!#$#"**$*59*#,B 3992E+)J*$*"#* 7548373996;
50; $E$#")$##$*#*),*"$* F #$# E$# " K$ * B * # * 4 E= 3994; 3> <#= 3994! ,*$ * $ <,# B +) $ *)" $ +)#$**, $*#$$#=+#;
39; **52,3994! B*#")$$* $,,+#J) )K$*4E=3994!$#<!)=$$J *#$,;
35; #" * 36 , 3994! ) $ E$ * ! = "B$*G"$/$#$#;
7361873992 :4753: 33; 3,3994!'($$ & <,# B*#+) =$#$#,,#*)<<""#$$$$#*#" *#";
36; #$*34,3994!$<$=+=*G"$ $ $$ $*$ = * ,#* $$$! $
- ; ' E"* * " *),"$ J )= * )G"$ +)J * ,#* $$$ * ),"$C + * "$ = " "$$! *=$ ! "=$ ,K, ,$! #$ *)G"$:#$#,*$#""+)$#,##" :; $$ + )G, + <<$# " $ $!+)"$#$,$*"$+""$$"J "$$+*F$$G$$,"$; )G"$)" ,# ,$!*$+B=$)$*,#*; $J)G"$ "/C$!,B=#$#<#"B=$* ! $$=$+))$"G+="/C$++=$**#B$ #=?)G$*)$B"/C$+*)$$#"#=?++ ,"$,$ $$ E*)C; $ J )$ *) $ $? *)=*$#*#$*$$$"C/+!B*,$J ,=*)G"$"*";
32; 51 E 3994! ) E$ * ! ""$ + = "B$ * G"$ *#EJ #$# EF# $ +) " )G$ $"$?",$$$**$*),"$$#*G"$;
34; *) $#$#,,+#$;'+! #$#F*#JEF;
#
5; F=)F$E*HI#$#,*<#$$$#!*? 5O$3996! B$*!,"#*4EF! *$"#*$$=:"#*$!4""#$$58EFH$;5$; $48 I;
'$J)$*)#$*58EF!" B<#*# 31E=3992H -569598I!* F=*"$#!56<#=! *"$$$F$",$$$ B$*
7361873992 :8753: * #F J $ EF $$! ! * )$$$ * )#$*=GEF;
3; <,#,$ J .$; 48 ; 5 $; C; 3 ! B $ * %$$+*$$$"#=J)$ 48 * <#*# "$ F## * *$ * * 8 $B3999H I+$$=J):=*$#*50E 5040H I;
',"#$"EF**)"?$#$B;
6; $$# =F 5 E= 3996! $%$ ,*<$ * ,B *"$ #F * *, * ; ' ",$#!"$*=+*$.""+*$K$$C#J,? *""+?F""B$=F,,$P <$ E*+,$ *#$,$ $ "*$ H - 531 281 *; 5! 538 568 *; 2B $ #<#I; =C! + "#*!$J*#<$*?F$$$!=*$.""+ #=*?E*$#=FH -55106*;8B!553 689*;2Q 500>R61";658*;6BI;
)!$$"$#*$=*"65E=3993; *$#=$J$"*$<<$+"$#,$5E= 3996Q#+!$$*"$,$#+?F*"#* * $""B;
$E$# * <, $ *# #FG! $ =B H$; 48 $ 89 I;
2; ')$;2;5 !"")$;> !)=*$#$*,$* "$# * F! "#,# ",$ * F *#! + #$ *) $$$J$#"C/+,$"=$*)<,$#F#$!*) ,* *) *$; )$$$ J $# )$ * " J *#$,$$"*#$+*,P$% "$#*$=/$*<<$"$#*F*)#H/:
! *F$( SB * =*=CF! TC 5001! "; >I; # ,E + )GA$ " *)$=$# $= =$ *)K$ $$$ * $#"C/+,$$*$$GF+)G$$ $=$# $ #"$# =* )$$$ J $# ,"KC *)," $=GCB$H$;4;5 I;
/*"#+E"*!$*)=*$#!* *$*!$$#,+$,#*Q$ #+ #,+ BE$= * )"$# <$ +) ,"$ *)#= H - 559 314 *; 2! 594 391 *; 3I; +)
7361873992 :1753: *)$=$#*)#!*##,+<$*#<$!/* <* *# *)* ,#*! * , P ",$$$ *)#= "$# * $= * )$## * * $=$# B,$ GFBH -554566*;3!59454>*;5I;
.=*$#$#"$#=*?+.$!"$$F=$#!""J =*$G"$$$$*#$H$;2;3 I;
')$;3>;5 !$=FE+)65*#,B3996!)# *$J$$?)$=*J88376D,!J*,:$) $ =* J 49 D ,! J +$ * $ ) $ =* J 29 D ,Q*"#B!)#"$!*)"?)$;3>;5B !"#$* *,:$)$=*J29D,;?5E=3992!)# *$J+$*$)$=*J29D,!J*,:$.$ =*J49D,!J$:+$*$.$=*J89D,$J $$?.$$=*J19D,;
')$;30;5 !*$J$"*"$U$J*$J "$*+)#"#$"$#*F*B*29"$ , H$; 1 I +) "#$#! ,/! "$# * $=*29"$,"*$#$"$$BH$;8 I;
4; )"?!$$"$#*$=$$*"65E=3993 *"B?,,B$C*!+*)#$$*#"<;
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
7361873992 :>753: EF,$ .#$$ * $# $ J *+ * + , $ " + $=$# .# $ "B * $=; $! *# ,#* $$$ ##,$ $ " *#$, + $=G "$ ! B,$!GF*.#H -554562*;3!552652*; 6!59454>*;5<I;
+="B$*)""$,#*!+$*#$,$ )$ + "$ $FG $ <$ )BE$ *) #$* $#! + ""$ <* * G, ,"$! +) " #F,$ *#$"$G",#""G,#!+)$#$##$B " * ),?! + *"$ * $G$ ,#* $ )""#$*$$,#*$$<+* )G"$ $ *O,$ ,$=#; *,$! )##,$ *#$,$ " = "B$ )$ )F * ,/ * "= *#F$ ,, ""$,,G"$!,B$B$H -534643*; 6!533589*;5$#<#I;
8; '",$+!$,#*/$G,#$$<,# +)<<*,BF"#<+*,BF,,C+! *#<$F+;
',#*$$$!$$,$$C#"$+$$#"$+,$ <<$*$)$#JC$**; ##,$G$,"#$$$"$$)= "<*$$",$;
$ !"#$-&,#*$$C,$F! =# * ""$ *)G"$ * 55 =,B 3993 + *F"C "$+# 65 E= 3993 $ , #=* ,"$$ $C B$#* W !$#$$"$$#;,B<<$# 31 O$ 3993 ,$ * $B *#F##$< ,*##! = "# *) $#C* $$ = 6:2 P $ <<,$ * "$ =$#B * 2 * "$ $# "=$ "* J # $,$+; )G"$ + ,BF B "=$ " G"+ F K$ * $= $ =# + )G, + ,$$$ #=**F$*)GF#$;"$*=C,$F+!)K$* $=)#$$"E$<#$"$$*=$K$,$=;
""$ ' * 69 "$,B 3996! $ ! * &! *+# + $ <<$ *) ,BF ,, C+; )G, + <<$# *#B$ 3996 *+$ ,"$$,$$*<G$*)G$!+*<G$# *$! $$ $ *) $$; $# * F * F$# * M "$<; "$ * = "/CF+! $# #$$ *#"<
7361873992 :0753: #$$*"$*=,"$$$$,$#J )K$*$=,#F,$J*="B?,<,G; $$,"$* $ "$! )"$# * $= $$ + C< *)#+" * $$ #$$ * 599 D * *? #=$ *)= 3996; $=$#*"$#!"$K$*49D"?,$"<;
' " "/C$+! $ $ * ""$ *)G"$*3>,3996!*F$*#$*#"="F# * :59!*)$$#,*##!*""=*$;G"+# +) "=$ " " *F$ * $B ,$<, *G! "$$!*)GF#$,<$**!$,,$* $=G *! + ,"KC * = ) G$$ =,$! " * * *)F ,$+! "$ * * "/CF?; )B *)##,$ "B$ $ * ! "=$ " $ *F$ = B *F# * =,B; F# +) )#$$ " G + = "/C$+ + =$ * *#B$ #=? )G$ *) $B "/C$+ *)$$#"#=?++,"$,$*)G"$#$$$; ! )#=$ * "$# * $= *=$ #F,$ "* ,"$$##,$;""$+"/C$$$$!)*=$$$ $"$CF"/C$+$<#$="$#*$=!F* ,J=;
' )$#<##GG"$**$J"$# *$=$$*)$=$#CB$;
* * )""$! )$,# + * F,$ ,"#,$ "? * ,#* $$$ * $; $ C !"#$-&"/C$$"/C$C#"!*+#+ "$$"#$$*"3993$B*)*"$$=C,*#"=! <, *)$B$# $ * $B * ,,; /,"$U, *#"< =$ #$# *#C# " *<<$# :"< $ * C+;',#*$$$!$B*)*"$$E$<" "$#*$=;
$ - ,$*""$*3E$3992+)#$$ * $# * $ $ $# $$! ,F# ,#$ "F? "?$=$"B *$F+J*G";"##+ "$ $ *#<=B +$ J #"#$ * "$# * $=! , E$<"$*="F*#*"CF$<<$# $$$=;
""$*33E$3992!' *##+G"$ * * =$ = "B$ $ + * G"$ ""#,$ #$$ "<#$$;
7361873992 :59753: 1; $$$="B$*G"$<<$#J*,** )"$*F$+$G"$"*"C,$F $$#"$C!+)=G"$"/C$+;
/*"""#B,$+E"** - !,#* $$$,*$*; $*"$"$?!* <#"++#F$$"$$7,#*;)"!*),B#!* * ,$$ *$ )"$# #F# " "$$! $$ * $$*)#=$*<<; ""!<$*<J"$$! +$C$B!$<$*"$E"=*)BE$=$##! F*#+)$"!B!*)K$"$"BJ"$$; ?F$*)+)#")G"$*"""$$H' 3995! 590 *; 6B7Q 50>>! "; 492 *; 3I; )G"$ $ * "$ *<<#$ "+) ) " ,*$ * ! , ,*$ *)G"$! #" J * +$ "# " * $; $$ ,"$ * <<,$*"$$;*$"<)#$*)""#$"BE$=* ,#*$$$H'3995";590*;6B7BBI;+""$ #,$*,#*$$$!EF"$$*$$,"$*<$=$* )G"# +! * " "$ * <*$ "=#F# + <? ,*$!,#*$$$$C**$<=*"$$H - 532514*;2$#<#$#QX*/8702";81I;
! )*,$$ EF! <*$ ""#$ * "= < " =$F$ G+ *=$ "#* *)<<! $ = + $ <$ "#$$ *F# * =,B"#"*#$$+*)$,"B$"$" ,*< $$ ""#$! $ "< *)*,$ *)$ "= H""#$ $"# * "=Q R! Y$F=<C * '(=CF! "; 353! Z 249Q R[(7&X! Y$F=<C * Y$FC$"<F**!3#*;!";60!Z555$";551!Z639Q/F! *=Y$FC$"<F! 3 #*;! "; 312Q <; - 533 280 *; 2! 533 336 *; 6! 539 B 330 *; 3B! 550 622 *; 6 $ #<#I;$,?*"#*="*$*)K$$* )$;30;3 $;H'3995Z59";3>*;2BI!E"** ),"*)$;2 $;#$$$E=BH -53202*;2B!533 583*;5*$)K$$#I;
B*#?=J$#F*+***$F/$""# $J"$*F!*#EJ"="B$G G"$ <<$# " $ $ ! + $ "#*# J ,? "# * ! J )G, + * )# $ " *)$#F$#**,#*!$,,$*F+; "$G",#"$$#$#","$$* G"$#$$"<$,$$B,$=#;
7361873992 :55753: $ G =G ""$ ,#*G! < $ * $$ +) $ ,$$+$)""#$**G"$; <<$!$ <,#+))/=$*$"/C$+JK$ * $= $ $ - ) " ""$# * =G ##,$! =$ " +) )/ =$ <*,$,$ " * *=F *F$+=G"$$+)""#$*)G"$"/C$#$$$? ""$;
=*+"#?*!,\=*)=G"$)=?$! B )/$ * )#$ * * G"$ <F$*!G$,*+"$#*$=GFB$$$ *)$=$#CB$;
<*#!E$#;
7361873992 :53753: # / 3 #. / .#/ /
45 6 7 2 89 ,(% :
6
5; #=B;
6
3; E$$;
6; $+"#*$F$$;
2; <, "$ * +) "=$ <, $ "#$ K$ * *# * 69 E *? $<$ " " ,,*# *# B <#*# * ! 'CY(C<+ 8! 8992 ! $ G,"; *# "$ K$ "F#; ,#, *$V I *+ G$,$+*#$*#B$$"**# $$+#Q BI G" " + ,$< $, "= *,* $$ $ *#Q I "$ F$ * "#$$; ' ,#, $$ " $ ##,$ #,## $$ I BI $ I :*! B<#*#*""$,$?+) *=*#=B;,#,*,$,/ * "=! + $ E$! + *# $$+# $ )="" * +#$#G"#*#$H$;563!598$59>I; F<< #*$ M*
"<,*"#$K$$$<#G"$+)J)<<<#*# *"F<<
7361873992