Contributory Negligence Affirmation on Substantial Evidence Review
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court considered whether a finding of contributory negligence should be reversed where the evidence supported the lower court's conclusion that the injured party's failure to exercise reasonable care contributed to their injuries sustained in an incident involving a vehicle and an object on the roadway. The court reasoned that where the record contains substantial evidence to support the trier of fact's determination regarding fault, an appellate court should not substitute its judgment for that of the trial court, and therefore affirmed the judgment upholding the allocation of fault.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Contributory Negligence Affirmation on Substantial Evidence Review: The court reasoned that where the record contains substantial evidence to support the trier of fact's determination regarding fault, an appellate court should not substitute its judgment for that of the trial court, and therefore affirmed the judgment upholding the allocation of fault.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe provision was cited in the final order regarding the costs of the proceedings.
The provision was cited in the final order concerning the allocation of legal aid.
Testo completo
"##$%"#%%& "'(#"#%%)
! *! + !*+ +
+, & #( - #%%)
! "
"
## $ %% ! "01 &'()!*"+,-!.,.. ./
!
5,2(5
.
.6 !1,4708.(3,!"719"1&*" 8:"0"6.;*"08.((;!9<*"9"&=&8!""1 7 > " 8 1 & ? ?=6 *" & ?0"1"1*?@@"1"1*"91,->7.(((6
,6 <11"10A"&"7" "&< &<&"B5*C% D*=?"&<&"6
/6 ,3 *"08 ,444! <1 &1*1 &0& & *"" *C & <@@ " & <57&"1 B5*C < D 7" E 0"&7*@6
+6 < 0<1811@&<"?% &.)&108,44..) 0 ,44,! * &< "? % & .; 0 ,44, .3 > ,44,! E < &9 0 & @0" "* & "? 1"1 **16 <1 811@1 &< 0 & 0" 9"1 & " =F G % ! & . 0 ,44, /. "8 ,44/6 @ & 0! 1"" *17 ??0" =F <0*'! 7 & 8 0*"-+$444@6"34$444@6
-6 &< @ & G % 7 <"* H % ! <1!97"@""0"&"?019!1""1E&7 @@" & "? "&" 0*6 0 *@ 1"1 19 *?1 & I 0! & . 708 ,44/ /4 7 ,44+ =F G 2H 6
36 C.0,44+!<11"1??1*<"*H % * & -,$444 @6 B@6 +$444 I ./D6 &1 & ./ 0 ,44+! < @01 <1 9<*C I1" & 0 & 0" *@ 9"1 & "! =71 7 C! ? 9< 1"! 0*1 E 8" 7" 7&"1! " @6 33$+.) @6! &" &?1 &<7&"1&,,J!@@"*7&"E"6
)6 <1@01"&"&,>,44+!1?"9<*7"* E*&"8*""&8>"@I6 @@"!"E @! 7 "* I?1 9" & ,); * E * * >6 ""&9"!1""&<8?"&"708&<= 8!91*"""16""&11"&"" 7&<*8"1&"@0"&=?&<"*6
;6 "&,(*"08,44+!7&1&*""*@ &< 719<17"&1>E&1&10!0"@*9<7"
2,,342,44+ 5/2(5 &K @@" & 08 = 10" * "" &<""& 9"I?1*<0*'6%&!&C&18"&*?"& "?! <1 7" 1"1 @01 & 0&@" 8 * "" *! E 7 & 9" 00I " E *C6 9" 1"" *&" &1E""&"@008>"@E""&"<*1"1&01 @"&&0"8"6%<0*'!<17"9@& @0"<"01*@@""7I&0&1""& "?0199&"?0"&"0*6<"*"! 7 * &<7"0" & <1! <0*' <7" * @71 @0" & "? "&" 9 <1 " * &0& " @@"0A0"0*90"6
(6 ; "8 ,44+! < >"1 <" & <1! 0"@ 9 0" <" "01 7 C * ??0"! 9< 7" 9 <"0 1 * @@" "7I &0&1 & "? 019 " 0 "&" 0* " 9< 1"" 0! *C .; 0 & @0"!&107&@6-,$44465L@@"!& "7"1&@8"""@0"&*&"!"7"10*"1*1""7! <1C7 E @6 -;$(+4 @6 ;4 * ,44/! " @6 -,$4+3 @6 3)4 7 8""0"&.4J6
.46 <"11">"1,708,44+!@"79<7"&1 &10! * 9< 7" &K @@" & 08 10" " "70&"&0=*""&9"I?1*<0*'! " 3444**0L""""7""M1&*8C0 &"1! @0&&&@@7&""06*&" "@"&" !""""&<*"1&"7&.44 J&C.)>,44+!7*E-4J&C,;>",44+"E.44J&C ->",44+6I*17"710*&""&"=F N % !E*"0*!&**"08,44+L"*'1E*"! 709&@0"!"7*?&<&&@6.43,@! -40"!9<"""@=&&*"08,44+6&0& @0" 0*10" * *7 "7 & "? "&"! O &18=1 " * ?&! " * & "? 0196
..6 1* & .( 708 ,44+! < >" & ! &1"9<11""@@00"1&*"16
.,6 "*"1&!&1"9<<7"*811@1 &<@0"&19"&"?6
./6 ,3 >" ,44-! 8 &0&1 " & *& @= & &&<"8,44+E>,44-!9*&&1&<
2,,342,44+ 5+2(5 =P0?6&=P0?*1*&&"E<&0"1 &/.>*@"?76<1"&018&<?1& -$..(@6!&1&"&?"01&6
.+6 &0" " 1"1 0091 E < ! 9 *"1 & 6
.-6 %9!1"1?&1E>?6
*
.6 ?7<?">&BD1"10&@1"""1!&C .K",44/! 8"&!0*1&->?! &"*1&""75*1&"!-1"".3>?B"6."6 "-3 D6
%"E<"&<1"&.3>?!* 8@1&1 ,)>7,44+B #./4.43D!& ?7&*"1!./@17! &*"""?"*0""" 8"& & 1? E " >? ""! ! & <""" & <1"&7I>?6
,6 @010" E <"6 -3 ! 8 " & M"! " 9! & """ "7 E @1&1 <57&"1&.(>.(-(Q 6
%0*1"*>?&&<*C"1"86
/6 @1&1*"?11&&"&&3"8 ,444B D ""1 7? . >7 ,44/! "M" 0&@" &08&*"1?&&0&6% *0"1!*"&79&"$9&"A""=1E0C &**9C?8"7?00"O @" >&90" &1"0" " *&" B # .,) +3) &6 .! .,3./3&6+8"1@1D6
7=! 9 *1&! " E &1@" & C? "" "! 7 &" $9 17 &C > & "1 7?B #..)(/&638!..,/34&6+L .((;R/)*6 /.3 &6 /8D6 $" *9 *1& *&" . >7 ,44/
2,,342,44+ 5-2(5 "&" *C "" &" &7" "8 " 0*1"" 0"C &$ " 1? * 7 C? & *1& " & " * &*" & *1& " & &@@1" *10&@1* 6
1*1&@0"&10*1*!*1""78 B@6"6-3"34 D6
+6 "? *" @" & 7 " " &" &<8" @0"0*10"!&C9<"071"1@@00"1&*"16
I"0&<"6;6. !17&01&<7&"1 00""&"I0&1&*""9"1"&"E 1"8 *"1 & ?! E <01! E 7?& E @7 <?6 &""&1"01@"&""&1&<"7"1*886
% <"6 .) 6 . ! <1 &" E 0" & 7 *@0""&1*<7&"1"*"1& ? *" ! "" 708! A" 7?&1 011 & 0C"86 "1*"17&&<"6.) *9<" * @@00" 1&*"1 * 9 <""" E "1 "! * " " ?7"1!"9<I""*"&<"7"1"7"1*" A"I?1B #../ ,3+&6.877S .(;;*6.+/D6 7 9*"&?&8!&E<7&"1!"&,4J7B # .,+..4&6,8L%,444*63/D6
0"! "& <08 & 0 & 1&*"" &<& *@9"1"&"E*E*1!9 7" &1>E I1 "7"1 "7 7" 7 & <7&"1! 7 *"1 & ? E * *C 197" E 9 1"" *7" B # .,, )( &6 /8288! .44 .(! (( /- &6 , 7 1@1LN R.(;;*6+3;&6,!.(;+*6(.L .(;;*6+(+&6,! .(;+*6(-D6
C??11!<1<&"9<I01"**E ""&8"&1&*""71!0*I09" 0&B #.,+..4&6,"1@1L%,44,*6 .4( &6 ,D6 ?@ 9< 0 & 1&*""! 1?& I " & @" " & &" & &<*C! &" A" **" 8" 71*1&*""6 @!C0*"1"K"&0C" &7" " & " 8 B # .4) ;; &6 ,L 5 T N0 =U"0U?V"*F* 0 %""= "?="L 6 !*6))!9;;D6
2,,342,44+ 532(5 -6 <!<"*""19"*7"*I "7"1"1&*"8:"0"61"10811@&<"?% & .) &108 ,44. .) 0 ,44,L " & " &<"1?" *@B D9*"1&<&*"""&<"?& "1"" 0*"87 0**"9&"109 0!E*"0*"7&0"0&&"7"1"70" 1?C 01?" 008 @1 ?=6 *7" 7 0 " @0" *"9 "*L & 8 *1"" " & "C ?18! " *""& *0""" & "7 "" 7 "C6 "" 7" 1"1 **1 "! @ & *0"" " &<I*10" &@@1" 01" & "? & ? &1"*!*?"&0&"01"1&1 @0&<"? % !&.;0,44,.3>,44,6
" % & ,, 0 ,44, @01 9 *"1 & "7 & <11"""C!9<7"*""&*0"""&7@0" *"9 "* " 9 ??0" 1"" @6 <"" 0I&*"11"""?!&0&9<"0"1"116 0&<1"1"0*7"1=1""1"10 811@&<0&@0"*"9"*&.;0!&.0 ,44,/."8,44/=FG % 6@&"?&7"8"E ??0" * <0*'! 0'" & 8 0* " -+$444@6"34$444@6
" & 3 > ,44/! "= 1&*"" 71 9 <0*'1""7&@7<"*H % 6 H 1"" &<& & ?& " & <"*! 0'"@0"*"90*10"6 @@"!"7@@"1* <1 1"" *9 I70" & "? 019! 9 & 7"*!"&7"7&0C0I"!E71?0" & "? "&" 0*6 " 19 811@1 &< *?" & @0" *"9 "* & I 0! & . 708,44//47,44+6
C.0,44+!"1"1??1*H % 7? &-,$444@6B+$444@6I./D6 0*1?9<"11,44+ 9"1 & *" =F 0*'! " 33$+.) @6! &?1 &<7&"1<17"*9<E,.!)J!@@"*7&"E"6
36 """71"1@@00"1&*"1!&0O<* "9"I?1*<"*"O&K&&10,;>" ,44+6I*9&*.*"08,44+!"71"7& "*&"?!O"*'1E*!09<&09 & @0"! 1 9< ? & <& & .<43, @6 * 06 <"
2,,342,44+ 5)2(5 "E<5=P0?!9*1*&&0"1 & /. > * @" ?7! &1" 9< 7" 9""1 "7 1*"1 78!<&<"0*6
% <9A" @@"1 * <"01 *C & <"* H % ! <"7119&*&1&G % !I?& &0" @" &1@"! 1"" & * 1"" &11 00 @86 C &18" & *?" & "?! <1 7" 1"1 @01 & 0&@"!E<"&""*!"00"&9""&E *C6 9" 1"" ""@ &1 E "" &"@ 00 8>"@ E ""&"<*1"1&01@"&&0"8"6% <0*'! " 7" 9 @ & @0" <"0 1 *@@""7I&0&1!""&"?0199& "? 0 "&" 0*6 " 7" &0&1 E <0*' & *7 7 @0" & "? "&"! * & &F 0 *C! 9< " * <@@" *C I 0 & "7 & "? 0196 "" &0& < * 1"1 &1! 0*" " & * &<7"0" & "! 9 7" &C &18" &91 <0*" 9< ""=" E 7 *71 " 9< " * *A" E @ & = 10"6
8&1""9"1"10811@&<0 &1&*""*@&"?019!*"E@ & <"* " E &0& & H % &< @0" 0*10" &< &1 & I 0 @ &<A" 0 & "7 1?0"&"?0"&"0*6@0"*@ "*&1&I6 ""0<"=717C!*9 <11"1??1*<"*&C.0,44+7?&+$444@6 *0!"F@*B"-,$444@6*1D6 "!*C1&*""! *"&?<1C7E,.!)J610!'&<&0""9<E< &@0"!""0&1I0"70"0A0 ? 9<*7" @0" 0*10"! &<"" * 9 **"7&?@"&*@&7"176
<" *"! < 1@C "8 . & < 9A" "" &B %%!&&"7"10*"1*1""7B7+D&" *71!""0&1?&+$--)@6*+4= &"7=8&0&,44,B109)2;,44-!*6((D6 00 8" "&&1 "" 0*" &< &1 =8&0& & "7 @1E0'&"*,44,B+.!)=L 109!32,44+!*6(4!(6,D0""&"A"*"1E+$)-4!" & -)$44; @6 1"1 ,44+ B& ,4(-L .(/( S .44L 109 )2; ,44-! *6 (( .456/D! <1C7 E -;$/++ @6 ;46
2,,342,44+ 5;2(5 0*1 ? 9< " 11 7&"1! " 33$+.) @6! &?1 &<7&"1<1C7E.,!.-J!I"""&"E"6
0"@ 791 * "! E 7 @" 9< &7" @ & = 10"**7*"9"!""*E09& @0"! &C 9< 7" 9 <"0 1 * @@" "7I &0&1 " 9 <7" * 1"1 &01 @" & &0"6 M" *"P" 9 " <1"" * "C @7" *C =?0" &<0*' " 9< * &1 & 0"" @ I " & "7&"&10>",44+6
7 & 9 *1C&! & " 7" E <8"" &< 0*10"&@0"">"16
)6 ""<&&< *"7"7B"6.;6. 6D "@!*191""&"70"@78 <*&"7&*0"6
!0@&1!&"A">"16
WWWW
2,,342,44+ 5(2(5 * + . *! + !*+ +
/0121 3 -11 1 45 ($# 6
21
.6 1786
21
,6 >""6
/6 "9*1&"?""6
+6 @0 *" & 9< *7" @0 " *1" A" & &1 & /4 > &C "@" * * 00&1 &1 8 @1&1 & ! %=XF=@9 3! 344+ ! " I0*6 &1 *" A" *?16 010 &"T D &9 I"0"9&1"&18""*&&1 ""91L 8D I* * 9 0"@ "0 *7 &0& "" " &1L D *" ?" & *1""6 % 010 "" * " 110" 1011 "" D 8D " D 5&! 8@1&1&**"0"C9< &7&1786010&0"0' & *7! 9 " >"! 9 &1 ""91 " <7 & 91"1I*1&1"B"6./,!.43".4;D6 ?@@ 1&" Y&
*@0&*1"A"""@1I*"9<E<@@@1&1 &*?@@
2,,342,44+