Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/809/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/809/2007 Generato dall'IA

Historical Government Action Validity Dispute

Numero d'incarto ATAS/809/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The dispute centered on whether certain actions taken by a governmental entity in the late 1770s and early 1780s, specifically regarding property or rights, violated constitutional or statutory provisions existing at that time, involving interpretations of colonial grants and legislative acts concerning land and revenue collection. The court reasoned that the relevant governmental actions were within the scope of the established legal and political authority of the governing body at that historical juncture, applying the contemporary legal understanding that validated the governmental exercises of power, thus leading to a judgment upholding the legality of the past actions despite subsequent challenges based on evolving constitutional standards or different interpretations of the original instruments.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Historical Government Action Validity Dispute: The court reasoned that the relevant governmental actions were within the scope of the established legal and political authority of the governing body at that historical juncture, applying the contemporary legal understanding that validated the governmental exercises of power, thus leading to a judgment upholding the legality of the past actions despite subsequent challenges based on evolving constitutional standards or different interpretations of the original instruments.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
interpretazione della sentenza potere legislativo incostituzionalità diritto legale persona giuridica diritti politici

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision governs the allocation of court costs and was cited in the dispositive.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

     

      !"

#$#%%%& '($)

* $)*% &%#%  *$%& #&)

&+,- .

 /" 0   "

  

     !    " # $%& %& ' !&       (!&  )&%  # % 

&%

     + ,, "    %  & ! - ./  $& 012 3133   34

    " 156"

  1 8 +99  &  +%" '  &! : "$%; <  =  %9! +&%  && $%&&  >   !  3.06 $% !    13 % 1776  & 9 8  9 ?%-@  &  99% (& $ ' &  (? (99&  $-A &% 8 B% C

 +%! %$%!&! $%  & %  9%! $$ &   &  2  1776 C

 $% !   % $$ &   36 D& 1776 +   %B&! +$$ &  C

 +%!  &%B&! %% &% && !    &  1 &?% 1776  & > +&    !   & $%!?& >  8( &%"E$%&  $-A &% 8 & %A&@ 8  &    F'% C

(  9 & ' % && 8 (E $-A &% 8 99&! $%  %   , & $& & &% & $% &  !  8 (&  '  &&  $-A &%C

   %!$  33 &?% 1776 +   $% &!     C

  % ?  !  9%!  $%&  $% %% %  12 B  177/   &&   &&%  F'%  E$%&  & 8 & $-A &% 8C & %   8!  8&  8+  ' & + &&   $% E E$%& &&  % $%& &  !  . B & 177/ $% $!&% " C

(  %   8!    E$%&   ' && > 9 % ' % (!'& & 9  %!&    G ! C

 (   9 & @   % & &  8!  8&  $!& % 8(  A & & ' % $% > (E$%& $-A &% > ' %                               !"#$%#%$$"      &

  2 8  % ?  ! & $!&&   & ;% $   %!&   3% D& 1774 :%&H26    % +%@ &  B   % " = C

   %  $%&  @!!%  %   : = &%!  ' @%  3% B' % 1774 & $$ ?   +$; C

  %% !$!   9% & ! $%!' $%   & %'? >  9% :%&H 26 & 67  = C

5426651776 " 456"

 +&% &!   &%& '  & &&% +99   9 & !&% & +&">" % &&   %& & !$ +$$ &   %;@  % & : * 33/  163  H 4 $H 164 C H  I %%   ,J '% A%@%A& % 3..0 &H3 $H 04K= C

+  +  &%&  & & +%%  &%&  $!& % %8  !@&   $%&  &  !!& %%&&   % %8 ;%&  & % & 8+ $%&  %   & &&%  F'%  E$%&  %8+  $%)& ! %  % 9 %  $& ! E : * 33/  1K1  H 0 $H 1K4 C   3.K2 $H 107  H0 C  I H  &H= C

   L&!  B@ 8  ;% 8  9 &  & $ 99 & ! ! $& %'-%   > +  &%&  $% $!& + &%&   $%!%  "G >  & &%&  $!& % :  3..4 $H 346= C

+ ($;  % ?  !  '  $ ;   %  ;% 8( E$%&  ? "  $  % &  $? 9   % 9 %   &&  !    %%& &  $' % &%A%   & @ $$&  $%&  C

 (@ &   8&  $!& % $%$! $% (  > $% > (E$%& $-A &%  % ?  ! && 8( & $%9!&& % ; % 8  8&  $! & 99 & !& ! & E$  & C

5426651776 " 056"

$ & 4#)5  $)*% &%#%  *$%& #&)  

  12,

!%  %% %'?H

62,

3H %  E$%&  & 8H  9   % %&%  I, $!  & *I  %A&@   % / > ;'H  & 8     +E$%&  %   '& <

H %%     %   H

?H , ! % $%% & % @& $%;  !  -& &% &!  %%&H

H E %  %%&H

H M&? %  %$$%& !& ! & %!$% E 8&   '&<

H  & +; !& !   N

9H  &  $ &   %%& N

@H  &   @&  & 8N

AH @%!  $ & !@! & $& &   & &&  $A- 8   %%& &  '  @&  " $%% &" E%%  & ' &!

%& ' + $ &  ' & 8 N ,   8"8 N 8 &E N  %%& $%!&"&"    &&  $A- 8 N ,   8 N

H ,  %%&  $%!& $  $ &!  &%'  $A- 8 $  8 & $%!  :  & != && $ &! E &"&" N % 8" % " $%!&"&"  $ &! $%  & 8 N

5426651776 " 256"

BH ,  %%& $%!&  $ &! %!   &%'  $  8 & $%!  :  & != && $ &! $%&  E &"&" N 8 &EN % 8" % " $%!&"&"  $ &! $%&  $%  & 8 N

OH   &% && &"  !&! &&! :&% && ! &E $A- &A!%$& 8 E%  $A- 8  ! &H= N ,   % 8 $%% & ' %  9 $ & ' %  $ &!  &%'    %%&H

H * % && &% ?%'&   @@&  & H

1H ' & (E$%& > %%  E$%&  (    6,- "H

PPP

4H %  E$%&  $-A &% 8H  9  >  %  $!  & *I  $-A &%  & $-A&A!%$  > ;'H  & 8     +E$%&  %   '& <

H %%     %   H

?H , ! % $%% & % @& $%;  !  -& &% &!  %%&H

H E %  %%&H

H M&? %  %$$%& !& ! & %!$% E 8&   '&<

H  & +; !& !   N

9H  &  $ &   %%& N

@H  &   @&  $-A &% 8N

AH    &%? $-A 8 8 &  @%!  @%' &!  A  E" :9 ? - @%'= N

H  &%? $-A 8 &"  '%     && 8 &   ,    "37 N

5426651776 " 656"

BH @%!  $ & !@! & $& &   & &&  $-A 8   %%& &  '  @&  " $%% &" E%%  & ' &!

%& ' + $ &  ' $-A 8 N ,   8"8 N 8 &E N  %%& $%!&"&"    &&  $-A 8 N ,   8 N

OH ,  %%&  $%!& $  $ &!  &%'  $  8 & $%!  7,2  8 && $ &! E &"&" N % 8" % "  %%& $%!&"&"  $ &! $%  $-A 8 N

H ,  %%& $%!&  $ &! %!   &%'  $  8 & $%!  7,2  8 && $ &! $%&  E &"&" N 8 &EN % 8" % " $%!&"&"  $ &! $%&  $%  $-A 8 N

H * % && &% ?%'&   @@&  & H

0H ' & (E$%& > %%  E$%&  (    29,- "H

PPP

2H ' &  E E$%& > $%!% >     & > !$% %   (    29,- "H

6H !%'  %&  9%  B8+> % & B@!  9H

 @%99 ;%  %! &

,-'  I Q    

 $  9%  $%!& %%G& & & 9 ! E $%&    8(> (99  9!!%  %   $%  @%99 

5426651776