Judicial Review of Agency Property Boundary Determination
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party sought judicial review of an agency's decision regarding a property boundary dispute, specifically challenging the agency's interpretation and application of prior boundary determinations and associated agreements regarding adjacent lands. The court reasoned that the agency's decision was entitled to deference because the agency's interpretation of the agreements and the underlying survey data was reasonable and consistent with the established boundary lines and governing documents, thus concluding that the agency acted within its lawful authority and its findings were supported by substantial evidence.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Judicial Review of Agency Property Boundary Determination: The court reasoned that the agency's decision was entitled to deference because the agency's interpretation of the agreements and the underlying survey data was reasonable and consistent with the established boundary lines and governing documents, thus concluding that the agency acted within its lawful authority and its findings were supported by substantial evidence.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to order the appellant to pay the judicial costs.
Applied to rule on the request for legal aid and legal assistance.
Testo completo
&'()*&+, "&-*.&+,
" """
" #" # #
#/ % '. 0 +,
-$ !"##$ !%&'$(!$#))*+,),, ) !(.!$!
1
2" " #" # % '3 4% +, 5 "&6).&+,
1% &'()*&+, 00
//////////'-($$ !$0'.#'! -'# #1.!$2! $'$# 3 !"##$ !%&'$(!$#))*+,),, )
! "#! $% 7)4%7
% 7 8%($.' ((! )&-$)&&6#$ $'$ ! $# 8 0'9:-$8;'7$(<#$'$=$' >-.? //////////$0$! "# ! " (@ - !. '9:-$8 -$ < 3 '-(! )A (!-" )&&% ! ? $ .' -"- ! + -$ )&&B .!$! C!>.D
#1 !..$ !C!.'#)6$0#)&&6' !#$!.' ?1#' '#!3 '? !$E - !.'9:-$8(#)A(!-")&&%!' 3'?1# !<#($! -"#- !$ !,&1B,)>F*B@)A (!-" )&&% $ +, C$ 0 )&&B ! 3 ' ?1# # ! $''. ! 3 - !.'9:-$83($!,>.0)&&BD
($$G!,+C )&&6 !>.$E($!#+&C )&&6# " $#'.$ $ ' !$!. ? #1 !.. (0$! (.! 3 - !. '9:-$8 < # ,6 0-")&&%$!3#$?###$>$##!#$'.!.H////////// !( $0$! .!. ( '.D ?1# $ ' .. ? #1 !.. $0$! .!$"# $ 8. 0$-"#$ '?#0- !1 $#$- #%1&&&>FC?1 C )&&% ' ? -(#?$! 1$-!! #1E'' >>'!> 1 $'!0!. .( $ ! (# I-$ !#.#$7'$'!$! '$ ! 0-")&&)3C )&&%D ?1#$$ $-#'!$ #.#.' +-$)&&B!)&-$)&&6D
#$ '$ $ .(. # A $J! )&&6 -$ 1 !(.!$! '! $G! $##.8$ !#1E! '1 ' !$'! !#$' !$!$! !$E - !. '9:-$8 #1 !.. 3 '-(! ,6 0-" )&&% #- ! ! #1$ #$! .' + -$ )&&B ! )& -$ )&&6D ?1## #<0 ($ $## ? # #1 !.. #7-G- '#7' 1E@$! (# 1$'!0!. $(< #$ '.!. C##! )&&+ .C3D ?1## ' '#! ? $ ! # .#$7'$ '!$! # 1$ !$0$##. ?1 0 9!-$#I-?D?1# 1$$!($!$ !($!$E - !.'9:-$8<#,6 0-")&&% (#D
#$ '$ $ ($$##<#- ! .(. ' ! $- !$!> $(< " $#>..$#$$ '; K =#,B$J!)&&6D
#)*$J!)&&6# " $#'.$ $ >-.# K ?'1.!$!3!!?1#$0$! ?. $ $G!$ ## .' +-$)&&B !)&-$ )&&6!?1# ! $! C8- ! !(.!$! D
1 0!.3.!- #1 !..1!" .3.(.!?1#$0$!(.#0. $#$ C?1 C )&&%D
.'! $!. ,, (!-" )&&6 ! .!. !$ - 3 #$ '$ # ,) (!-")&&6D
4,%5&4)&&6 7+4%7 # 8% #$ # 8 0 #L8$ $! C'$ ;= $ .!. ->.!$ !!.<#,$J!)&&+ " $#'$ ! $#$$ ''$# '-(. B C8 ! (. ! ! 0'7(. ! B ((#.$ ! ! ,6 C8 $;$!F,#!F!B6 =D
!3#L$ #$! #L.#'! ,6C8$($# " $#>..$## )5C$ 0)&&%; K,+&,&6=#$ #8 0$$(!.#,+>.0 (! !$ !8 !(-!!$ !$ " $#'$ ! $#$$ ''$# .8 $ $ 3 ! C8 !!#$ ' $ #L$!! ! #L.#'! 0$EC8$D
1 0!#1$!FA%$#F,#$##$('.$- !$!0,)(!-" ,*AB; =$((#'$"#($ 0#1$!F6,#$#>..$##$($!8. .$# ! $$ ' '$# 6 '!" )&&& !. 08 # , C$ 0 )&&+ ; = #$ C'! ? $ !$!. !(<! $ .' #?1## ' ! ! ' !$'! !#(!>!#' .$ !D
1 #1'' '# " $#'.$ $$ $G!,+C )&&6$-? #1 !..(0$!(.! 3#1'!1 - !.3'-(!,6 0-")&&%D
1# 1 ! $! < # ($ $ # # .' + -$ )&&B ! )& -$ )&&6 (- ! ! -(#- ! (?1## (!$ ! # -"- ! (!$! )A (!-" )&&% $ +, C$ 0 )&&BD ?1# 1$8$! $ ' !$ 1$ #?($!##- !#!.' -"- !D
1#' 0 !<#'!>#(!> ' D
4,%5&4)&&6 7%4%7
# "9 " #" # #
% % :0 ;17 < 0 => ',+ $?
7
,F .'#$#$-$ 1 !(.!$! '0$"#F
17 0 + % 07 :@ % '3 4% +, 01 0 0 + 3 15%A
% 7
)F 1$-!!$ #($!##- !#.' +-$)&&B!)&-$)&&6 !$ !?1##(! !#$!!! 1 - !.3'-(!,6 0-")&&%F
+F ' >-(#(#F
%F >- # ($! ' ?L## (0 ! >- ' ' ! # (. ! $G! $ .#$ +& C < $ !>'$! ($ (# '--$ . $. $ " $# >..$# $$ ' '9MI9>?$ 6 6&&% ! E-(#$F .#$ (! G! (# 8.F -.- !N $= ? E$'!- !?##.' #'$ !."! #!(#$'#$.' $!!$?.D "= E( ( ?# -!> # !- (0 -$ '!! $! .' D '= (! $ 8 $! '## (. !$ !F # -.- ' ! ! ($ # ! .#.- ! . -.. #!! $= "= ! '= '7 # " $#>..$#$$ ' ($($ ! -$!<#'?L# 0$.'#$'0$"#F-.-'- ! $ '#-O (0 ? ! C ! $ ? #$ .' $!!$?. ! #L 0#(( $ #$?####$.!.E(..$'$ !;$!F,+),&6!,&A=F $8>>< $(. ! $7 P Q '(' >- (. ! $G!! !>.$E($!!$'.!$$!L !$!3 #L.' -($#8>>#
4,%5&4)&&6