Premises Liability Negligence Appeal (Falling Object)
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe litigant sought relief after being injured by a falling object while on the premises of the respondent, asserting that the fall resulted from the respondent's negligence in maintaining the property. The court, after reviewing the evidence regarding the condition of the structure from which the object fell and the respondent's knowledge or constructive notice of the defect, concluded that the evidence failed to establish a breach of duty on the part of the respondent, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the respondent.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Premises Liability Negligence Appeal (Falling Object): The court, after reviewing the evidence regarding the condition of the structure from which the object fell and the respondent's knowledge or constructive notice of the defect, concluded that the evidence failed to establish a breach of duty on the part of the respondent, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the respondent.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
$%%&'$'(() *$&+%$'(()
*
" * " ,*# ", #,
,- ! .
%. / ! '(()
!"#$#" % && $ ' & & & &
$
'' & & & &!$( $2# )*+,!"$-./+!0100 -
! "#
%13-% 0 *
05 !#04$607.8! 2#!(#"#(2(( "$$ 2"#2$ "9 ( :;; $ ( " <=# >% "9: ?($(08;#@144,5
15 (#(11@144,!: $A#B:$##$B#"( "$$ 2"#2$ ;#(# ( .+. ;5 " 2 (9 0 ;#@ 144,! C: 6( (:%2( 2 ( /78 ;5 "$$ 2"#2$$$#$#@);#!2$;C: "@$ *$ $A# D " C $ ) 22$ ( $$ "$ ( "#@A "; $ " (: $ $ C :$ #B$6$C"#@A5
.5 "#$# " : ! :$## ;2# ""$ . 2 144,5 (2$ @ E 22$ ( $$ $"#! @26 1441! 22 ( 001F/1. ;5 ,4 ( '($ $25 D"C C $$ 22 #$# $# "2$ ( :2"G$ "$ C " #= ( ($$5 $2@("$#$$$("6!(6$(:#@$"#(( "$C$6$B"$("#@A$ 5(2($C"$$$$(#$$2"$ (:$)A"$)#$C(6(5"($("9H$;$@ $$$$ ( "2$ " 2$$ ( 77F--, ;5 7+! ( A$ @ B 26(##(:2"G$!(($$"9((D6C!(#@$( $!@$)$#=C:2)B@5
,5 (# ( 1. 2 144+! : H$# :""$! 2$; C :$##:@$"#"$B(;("#@A( ("$ #= $! ( $ C: "@$ *$ 2 6##; ( "$$2"#2$$5
+5 :$2#((2($!:$##$H$#($(07 @144+5(922=C;$(""C2*2$$2$ C:B"C$("(#"$("#@A"((#" (@ $ ( " $ 2"$ ( ($$ )#5 "" C: @$ ""# ( $ 2"$ ( ( "$$ $ (: $ )A"$)#$C "($ B $ C: $ " "@ C: $ ;$""$($;B(6(5$B:$( (#$B@5
-5 #" ( 1. 2 144+! : "$# ( ! #;#$B(#""$5
/5 #$#$2$$=(#BH=5
300/13144+ %.3-%
# *
05 =@:=$H(>?#$#2(;#$$$#!(9 0I$144.! 6$(!2"#(+H=! ($"#($$@%"#($!+""#$$0-H=>$50$5 $+- ?5
&$B:$(:#$(0-H=!" 6;#(# 1/H@144,> '0.404-?!( =@("$#!0.;#@! ("$$$=$"2$$$ 6$( ( #= B $ H= $$! ! ( :$$$ ( :#$(@DH=5
15 ;2#2$ B :$5 +- 5 1 $5 ! 6 $ ( J$!$C!($$$"#@B:$5,.( $"$$$2"#2$B:%@$ @@$$B:%@($#(1+$607-8> ?5
&2"#$"H=((:"9$#$65
.5 D$2(:$50 !"<=#!@@!")$ @($($B@222$(:(C$=$ " @2$ ( "$$ $ 2"#2$ B :% @!@@$$@($#5
@222$(#;B:$5. !2"#$#":$5.(9=2$ (:""$> ?5
,5 :6H$($=$B(#$2:$B6($C:$2#;# $ :$ ( "$$ 2"#2$ $ " 2$; C: $#"$("#@A";B(:$;C"#@A5
D$2(:$515, ;;$!"C$)!22$ ($$!"$("#@A";$"(:$ $C:$#B$6$C("#@A"@$6##; ("$$(#""$($5
+5 :"9!$(2$@E"$("#@A(:2$$ ( 001F1/.;5,4@261441!($$$"#$:@$# "26(@($$!C")$(=(@$$ :)$ (: 2) B @5 9= C: ("$# 2"$2$ "6!@$B#@$("$$("$("#@A $5 (2( #C B 6##; ( "$$
300/13144+ %,3-% 2"#2$$$$(2$$"($B $)A"$)#$CC:$"E""C$$;D6 (5
-5 :$ " $$# C $ : " $# "$ B 6$ ( "#@A5
22 $ ( &% ! 2"#$$ 2$9 ( $="$$"$$2"#2$;#(#$$!@$ : ( H= (: 6##; C @$ E! $ " ( $! "$ 5 : @$ # ($ D "$$ $ 2"#2$2$;C6$("#@A"#@":$515, :@$"#$###5H=$"($(##C:$$"$B @$(6@$D!:@$#B6$("#@A (:$515, >;5H=2$ 55(0.;#@1441?5
' $ "($ ( $$ :"9 C :$## : " # $$$# ( "$ B @$ ( 6 @$DK #$ ;;$ ( "9 "($ C: 26# (@ ($$ $$# "9 ( :& $ "$L!:$C$$#(:##(:2"G$!((#@$($! )$# 2) B @ $ )$# = ( @$! " $$ ( 77F--,;57+5
/5 $$:$("$$2"#2$$(9;#@ 144, $ "" ( $ 2"$! ( ! $ ( 2$$ ( $ ( "#@A)A"$)#$CC:$"E!$(6(5
&: !:""$(:$515, D$($B("$$ 2"#2$$5
("$ "#! ( ! ( 9=2$! C ; (:( ( "$$ $ 2"#2$ :$5 1 5 , (@ *$ 2$# ( $2"! C: ;($ "#( B $$ 2"$(2$$($C:$"E(6(5
#$($@D"#"$"6#(#2(( C $$ ("$ #$# "#@ M; ( "#@ 6 M >#2 ( ( 3"55-+8,?5(#=$(:#@$6! C "$ @ C C ) "$! ("( % "#" ( :@ " (2( 22#($2$ "$$ $2"#2$5""J$C:$$(#=$:" #$#("@#(($D"$$$2"#2$C :$$=$ " @ 222 $ (:( 22$ N "$ $! C C: $! #$# #"# : @$ @ B @$(6@$D5
300/13144+ %+3-% 6 ( # (9 C: $"#$$ $$@ ( :$5 1 5 . H$; $ C : $ #$( $ ( 6$ ( "#@A B (:$C@$(6@$D5 !($$($ "@$*$"2"$!2*2"$@$6$B(5 ("$#=C$";;$;$CH=$$ (:""C52*2!:$#;#$;D6( >;5 &(0."$26144+5 &3/++3144+?5
85 @$#C(:D2B"$(C(:#"$"#$( B ( "$$ $ 2"#2$ : @$ $# "$ B @$(6@$D5
& "9 ( (! ( :$## $ ( #" 2"$(:$2(@("$@2$0F,-+;5$0F+08 ;5! DC :H$$ "$$ 2"#2$ ;#(# ( .+. ;5 " 2! " 6( (: 2( " #"D ( /78 ;5 " 2 >;;$?! $ $$ ( ,F0., ;5 )= :#9@$ B 0F177 ; >A! )= 2"?!"/78;5("2(:%2(""!$1F47/;5 $B("$2$$(1F4.8;5"2>1,F,,,;5"#?" "5
!@22$(:(=$$(.,:+-4;5"# 1F884;5"2>.+F10-;5"1:7.,;5/4"2(90H@144+? ::=$(:"!($:(H$$$$:<=($$>$5.5 0 $5 6? ( 9=2$ (:""$ ( "$$ $ 2"#2$% ?5#$(;;#(8,1;5"2>1F884 O 1F4.8?! $ 04F04, ;5 " #! C "#$ ( C $ "2 $$B#"(:@$2"9$(6@$D (($$5
@26 1441 B ;#@ 144,! :$ 2$$ ( 01F-.4 ;5 > 8,1 ;5 D 0+ 2?C$$(I"#@"$"@$( 6@$D5
'$($$C:22$((2(!;#@144,!$ :$ " #"# "$ : :@$ $# B @$ ( 6 @$D C:B D ( #"5 ($ D "$$ 2"#2$$($*$!#C!#5
2C#B@$(6@$D($*$!#)#$! @$""$$(:$5
300/13144+ %-3-%
, #* 0 * " ,*# ", #,
123 4 / 56 %7' # 8
3
05 #@65
3
15 H$$5
.5 $C"#($=$$5
=;; #($ P( ";2("#$*$$$;#D"$"=;;
300/13144+