Sale vs. Lease Determination
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court reviewed a matter concerning whether a specific transaction constituted a sale, which would trigger certain statutory obligations, or a lease, which would not. The appellant argued the arrangement was a lease because it contained terms typical of a lease, such as periodic payments and an option to purchase at fair market value, while the appellee contended it was a sale due to language suggesting transfer of ownership and the structure of the payments over the term. The court reasoned that the true nature of the transaction is determined by examining the substance over the form, specifically looking at whether the payments made over the lease term, even with an option to purchase, effectively cover the total value of the property such that the option price is nominal, thereby indicating an intent to transfer ownership, and ultimately concluded that the agreement possessed the economic indicia of a sale rather than a true lease.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; AI(ASSURANCE) ; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR L'ASSURANCE-INVALIDITÉ ; EXPERTISE ; EXPERTISE MÉDICALE ; COMPARAISON DES REVENUS ; REVENU D'INVALIDE ; SALAIRE RÉEL ; CONSTATATION DES FAITS | LAI4; LAI28
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order concerning the distribution of procedural costs.
Cited in the final order concerning the allocation of costs due to the appellant being granted legal aid.
Testo completo
"#$%%"#%%& '"()"#%%(
'
' *' * *
*+, # ! $% -. #%%(
!"#$% &'( ''( )!( *!(+(' ,'
('
-- * .. ' ( ! /01"#"" "2
! !
4#3""4
/ '
"5 6 4&'7 ''(8 ! "090 ( :' ( ;'( 5
#5 (( ( < = < 6(!!' &'> (:' ( 4 ' ;(( >( &' ' & ?( ('' ? >(&'&( ''!? '@!(!'?7& ('7 * 4;5 ( ' (' ! 3 #1 ! ( 8''(*((')!(( & (!(') 1 #$$" "AB(#$$"& C' %$D& (((5
25 ( A ;!)' ' #$$2 ''( !&! &'(( *' ) (!) (*(' *'(' ((;;( 5
95 *-- * .. 4 6 4&'7 8 (' ( ' (( (( '&&'( ! ''(5
. '&&'( ' @ ''? #" ' #$$2 *;;( ( &'!( & *( #$$$ *!(( (! ( (( ' '&!( '! '5* & (!(') ''( !( '* ?(("$$D7#2)' #$$"(%$D7"A B( #$$"5 *E '&&'( ! > > ( ) (! '( ! (( & ('& *!' (' ' ( & F C ' @ ( @'&':'5
.'&&'('! ?!!' ((! (' (( ''("9)' #$$2* & (!(') (%$D(' ( ) (! *( E ? F ''(5 ( E (( ;( ''(&(( 'F'?@F (!!(( (!C2$D &( & &'(' @'? & C E G ?@ ( )( ?@ ( '(' (5 ( )( &' '&' (') (F*F(! &'!) F; F5
A5 .' >( * ''( E& >! ) ' '&' ( ) (! * ?( C A$ D & : #$$2 ( > (E *( ) (! ( ((F'@) (!(!"$$D7"0H%& H$D&(F' #$$$'>*) (@ (!E''( ) (! 'C(!!) & C ) "$$ D 7 &(F' #$$#5 . ( ) (! :' ( C .&' !; ( )(; #$$25('(( (@ ' @'? ( ) (! * ?( ( &'! ( & &) ' ' ( '('' F& &'F7 ) (( (I@ !?7' &'; > '> 7'(E 5
3#2$$3#$$% 423""4 %5 . J J 556 4&'7.8&'!!CE '(@&! > ''( "A &(F' #$$A5 K (( ' @ ''? '(@&! (-55L5'( ?( ) '!&' ' & (! (') !' 4 ' '& C ?@ 6'! ' ( 7'8 (( &'7 (!( '' ( ' (C?@(') 4F'@ ? '' (( )' (C'!&!( ( ' ('F!?!!'( ;5*E (''7)>* (')( @ ''? ;;(! #$$" * & ! '! /&((? ( > ''( (') (( ) ' C A$ D ' * ;( ? ( ( E ;'!>( '!) >*('+('('5*E (''7)>; F(E & (!(') '(&'('*(&( )!5. *E (' (') * ?( '&( &'; (( (( ;( 5 '( ' (' & F (! (@!'&( > ( *M(' !& ! & > (? > ' ( ( !5 E ( *(' &'( ? ' ? > *!)( ;)'F5 '!( 'F& (!(') &'((&(@? (&' @F ( ( ) (!5'!>(& (!(') *( ) (! @F ( ( ) (!&(!( "$$D!( '* ?( '&(( (( ;( > ( *!) (' )( '(( '!&!( ( ;)F'&!' '?@ >&'(@'?& >G 5
15 '! "")F'#$$A* ':(!&'(( ( ;>& (!(') (( 7'C&'( ' *(F'#$$"(> *(( (C(!*/(&'!! ( *(' '((&'& 5
H5 . (C*&& ( ''(* ; '!& ( &'! ' && ( #2 #$$%5 '!;7' ( ( C *E '(@&! > ( !5
05 ''#2: #$$%''((&'!F(C>* ('4E&'( ( ;;(!5 ' &( C > ! ( ? ( ! C >* '( * ) (! A$ D ( '! ( C >* (!&'('(' ('!')!) (!&5
&'! > * F!!; *'(* ) (!CA$D& : #$$2(&' (& ''&&'(! EC*&& '' (( ('2$:) '#$$%'!C* 5 '7) > *&&'! ( . ( F ) &'( ' > ' *&&'! ( & (!(') &'((@!' >(> *(&F!' ; ( *(4C4 ' ' ' @' > & ?( ?@ > (( &( (&'!(& (')( ?'!(F ( ' ? > !' 4 '5*E.'&(!((
3#2$$3#$$% 493""4 & (!(') '(!#$$"C#$$9&!' &(> * ) &'(5 ( (F ! ( & ?!' ! &'7 * (')( ( #$$#5& '''(*(&' ' )!@ ; ' '( !? ( &'!( !(( 'E @' > ( ) ( & ?( ?@5 . & (! ;( (''! (/&' ( ) (!* ?( :' 5'!( & (!(') &'(A$D5 &'! *) *E&'( !&(&! (@ ''? 5
(' ; ' &' &'( &' '( ; ( ! "0 : #$$%>(' (((( '>*& ;;' ':'*@ (( &( *( ) (! &'; &'( 7' ''( > ( ?!''#9!7)I?!"AC"0(''?7 '(* (!'E& !5
"$5 '!& "2 : ( #$$% * ( ':( '' ( C * '')F (!('('5
""5 ' F ! '! &'( &' &'( > *( (#0B(#$$%5K(( ''(!'!> (N
O B( #$$" ! * ; E! '&' (') C 9$D ;P C &'((''&'' >(I@*'(/'( )5 (( !&> : @ ( !?( ((' '&'' ( ) (! :' 5 &')( )( :*& &( C & (& > & > (>('5: #$$2'&' (') C@(' A$D!(!! !*&'(&'&'(('*&' 4&(*(' &'('((( )'&' :' *(!&' & F (!5 4&( ''& C ;'@(( "$ C "# @' * ?( ( >*& &(''&C;'@((#$C#9@'* ?(5
! ( :'*@ ! '( *( ((! & *&!'( #$$" &!:'( &5 (( '' !)( ('7 (5 &' 7' &!'( ) ( ( 7'( '!?' &'F7 > *&!(!5 E 7&!'( *(&'! ?'( ' ((! '( 5
.*? ( ;;!'*&&'! ( & (!(') '! (' ! * (('! :*E& >>'((( ( /(!( >( &'('F! ' ' *!& (5 ' ' (( :'! ( ('7 @ &! (( &' & (& &' E& : & )!@ ( ;P ?!!' : &E & ( ' ?@5 * * &' > ! * ! &&'! ( >( ' & ?( ?@ ( > (' &'( !'( &' ( (/& *( ) (! &'; !&/!5 .*? (
3#2$$3#$$% 4A3""4 ! ( ( ' E > : &E &'' & > : '(' '(*? (>(&'E@'Q5
K* * ' F'!*)'('>M( > &'( '! 5
"#5 ("2(F'#$$% ' F'P'&&'(! (' ! : ( > ( C ) (! ;( A$ D5 '( (( ! > > '( ( !&(&'(@'?(( ) (!> ;('(CE &( )'''( ) '&'!@ C ?@ ;'(( ! ;( ? E ' (' ( (!'E!' )!& !5
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
3#2$$3#$$% 4%3""4 ) &>( ) (!' (&(')!&'(( (''> * * ( & F E *'' &( ( &'F &' ?(6('&'( )'&@(& (58 .'>( :* >>&'( ( E(F (!& ' &!:'( 5 ' - ? E &!'( @ ''? &)( ) ' ;;( ''5.M('&! (:* >>*C &' 7' *'(@'7 & ?( *( ; ( >* ' ' ''( & >* F ((( & ?( !')( '& ( &!'( & '!*&7Q5 K* * !(!)>* ((' (.&'74 )'FE * > '&&'( ! &' ) !(' ( 5! 2$)F'#$$% !(!; E!&'; '5
"95 ') ! #A(F'#$$%.(C>* & (' (' @ ''? '(@&! > ( ) * E&'( ( ;>* >' ( 'F ' ? >'!(5
"A5 ' !' (' #1 )F' #$$% ''( */ &&5 (( ' * ('( ( &'( ( ' ( &'((' ( & *&&'(' !!( &&!( ' '! 5 !'*& ?( !(!(F ! &' *&!'( &( / ) ' *! '( '( >* ) F ' ? > ( ( 5 .*? ( ! ( &' ( '&&'( &!( '('C:(5
"%5 &'7 (' (( !' (' C * 9 !F' #$$% !(! ?'!C:?'5
'
"5 ?) 'T'? ( : '68!(! ; !( ( (!7 "'B(#$$2 ' F(' &!A:? (&'! (() 4&'! (A&&!(("%:?'6'(5"(5 '(A% 85
. (CT( T!( "%:?'&' ' F;!!' #1:) '#$$96 -"2$"$%8' ?) &(!"2;!)' ' & ( (' ( ''?(&'((( ' F(' !?' ' C (' :? ( ( ' T((( T!( )E:?'5
3#2$$3#$$% 413""4 ;'!( C *'(5 A% 5 " (5 @5 # ' F ( ' +( ( >((( &'!)CT'( A% > ('( )C 'T'4 ) (!"0: "0A05
.&!(&':?'T&7( !(F 5
#5 ;!!''&'( ?!!'' (' %(F' #$$$6 8(('!) ?'"':) '#$$2('+( ; ( F' & ( !? ' 5.' &(!' & () '>' (*&& > (M('('@!C 7' &' &>'7?&& F() ?'(U ; (:' >(!(' ((&' (6 -"2$#2$ 5"5"V 22A 5"5#V -"#09 5"5#V -"#19%1 5""#%"2% 59F('!;!'85'7?&'!'>(C*&& >( '!')7:'('!) ?'6 -""102 5%F""#2%$ 59V "00H<21&52"% 52F85 T&& > T&7'*( ;;(&'( '* ('( ! &(!' '( "' :) ' #$$25 .*? ( &( ' ( C '( '7? ;!!''*' ) (!6 4&'7 8) ?':>* 2"!F'#$$#*&& >'(!@!(:>*C(((( ('"':) '#$$2&'&!' &(!' '5
25 (':(!;'(! &'!)&' &'!(''(')F 6;5'(5A%C%$ 85
95 >( ( ? () ' & (!(') (' (C '( (M(''C''( *(C:(( ('>* ';! (( &'(( 5 . &' &'!F( >( * !)( E&'( ''(5
A5 8 ('*'(5H5" ('!&(! ) (!* & (!? (( &'( > (&'!!&'(?'!5
'&) ''?'!* ) (!* ('( 6:?* / ''8F (>*! !)((*('&! ( )( ;' '5(I@! (C&'(':?('*!(( (!(C >'>'(&'>( ) (!*'!( &F (') '5 (' ! ! ( (( !!( ( &' !(' '>(')E(' F(E ? F&'(*'!6 - "#A#%" 59""A"29 5#""92"9 52"$A"AH 5 "85
F8 *&7 ' F & '&&'( ! E &! ( @ ''? (! (' ((''(&!(!*? (
3#2$$3#$$% 4H3""4 4C &' !'( *>M( > *E '(@&! >;;(!&'.5
8 > ' )' &'F( * '&&'( ! > ( !(' (*(>& ( ( ? E (; (*F:(*!( '( ! > '&&'( ; ' E &( >* &' !?( !'( & (E&' !&'&'E !>* (!(!!(F & *7 > ' &( (E( ! ( *&&'! ( (( ! ( '(; > *E&'( ( B( ( )!5 '( *!!( !(' ( &' )' &'F( *( *' ? / &') ! ?( '&&'(E&'( F(F (6 -"#A2A# 5 2"##"%$ 5"('!;!'85
.*? ( . ' ( '( ((' ' M & '&&'( *E&'( !( &' E& * (' *F')( ! *
6 8('&&'(! !(F &'.(! ( !&' '( ('(E;; V((; ? ; &'>* )'?*& ('! .(! (' (( ( 7'?!!'! '((')')E&'( 5;;( -JJ . .. . 6 4&'7 - 8 )' &'F('&&'(! E((' (F &(W(*&&'! ' '?'' (7'( !6 525"V - &F !#9B(#$$% 02H3$A 525#85
8*'. 7' 4M>*E&'( (! ' E'(@&! >!(( &(5. ; ((E( ' F*( '& M 5 ;;( ! ?!!' ( ( &! ( ( &&'(! (( ! ! ! ' C ( ( ?5 ( E& >!;P) (> *;;( (;;'''(( !> (( & (! (') ( &' > ' (' (( (!( (!>(5': ?(&' '*!)( ! 4 5 (' '&&'(! E)'?(5. 'E&'!( . '('!C&' 7' &'!(' ( #A(F'#$$%5*/*!((&(' ( '&&'( '5 ) !)( ' ? > *( &' ' & (' C &!('( ( '5 ( ?( >*!(((& ?( ''( ( ( &' ' ((!5 . *&&'! ( & (!'! (') ''(( ( ? ( ' F(*) >*E&'( *(&! '&''!'((>( 5
'> '&'):?' ;! ; & ( (' ' '; (> ;(*M('!(F 7' ''!;(F&&' (&)' FF*(4C4 '> &'!((
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
'!>( '':?!*!((>* (! ' ?(' E&'( ')/'C* C((; 5
%5 8 ( @ ''? > ! (' (( ' ! 4 '( ( & (! (') '! *( ) (! @F (* ?(A$D& : #$$2( 7'(> (E *( ) (! ( &( ( ? '!5 !'( ( ! */ & *!'(' (( &&'! ( 5 . !!( '& (!(') !)! (N$D1 #$$" "AB(#$$"9$D7((((A$D7 : #$$25
F8.*'(5#H5" (') ?':>*2"!F'#$$2 *'!' (C'(( 7'* ( ) C%%#32D C 4 '(* ( ) CA$D C>'('(* ( ) C9$D V &! F *'! &( *&'7 *'(5 #H 5 "F &'!('C 4'(* ( ) C9$D 5& "':) ' #$$9%$D* ) (! (' (C(' 4>'('((1$D * ) (! C'(( 7'5
.*'(5#05" ' (C'(*'(5#H &' & (W( C ( C &'( ' > *'! &'!( & (! ? 'F9$D 6(58C&'( '> &'!(!/ & (! (') 9$ D &( ! (''&( (F6(5F85
3#2$$3#$$% 4"$3""4 @S '! ( ; ?'! * ) (! ( M(' !(' ! ' F * &' ')5 ' ') (') > * ) &'' ( F( ' E'P( *( ) (! >* &( ' F( ((' &'7 E!( !)( ' '!&(( ( &( ( * (( !> F'! '@! (') ( &'! ') >* ' ( & F( ' * *!( (& ) 6'(5#H5# 5
&(');;( ;('!&(!')* ) !(' ('>> &' '! E' ( ) (! > &( ((' > & (! (') '! ( & ( ( ! > ') '! ! ''& (') ;' ( > ( &( *((' C >* ( ') & M(' F( ' ;P 'F ( ( &'! ( (') &'( 7'( (F 6;5 ' ' *- . '( * ) (!(* &(4 @ ;;'2$%$( "012&5"0H( "0%"&5 1"85
8 ( *&75 ) ;'( ''( :' ( ? E&!' * ?( ( &( ( (( ;( > ( ;'((('C* (' ! > *( ) (! ( ( &(! E C @ & ( > & (!(') ' (&&!' '(' 5
15 *(C('(>* ';!((&'(( C''(5 !!(; ?'( '&'((('( ' & (!(') 'F )'(' (C '(* ) (!& #$$#5
H5 ''( > F( ( ? ' ( C !& > '( ; E! *&7C#*A$$;'5
[[[
3#2$$3#$$% 4""3""4 * 0' / ' *' * *
!
123,, 4 5 67 8&# 9
3,
"5 !'''')F5
! 3
#5 *((! "")F'#$$A(#2 #$$%5
25 (>''( (M(' F!!; * '(* ) (!& #$$#5
95 * )'( * (! ;)' ''( #*A$$;'5
A5 ;' &'( >T &)( ;'' '' (' &'!( ''M( ! 2$ :' 7 ( ; ( &'7 ' F ;!!' 6.@X S'@;> %%$$9 8&') ''( 7'' ( &F ;'!(E'(5H# ;!!'' ' F;!!'"1 : #$$A 6 -8V ! ' '' ( >' ( ; ( /&')(&'(' ?('''(( 'V ( M(' '! ' F ;!!' &' ) &( &' ) !(' > E ( *'(5 9# -5 &'!( ''M( ( & 7 & ''( )>!/&') )(M(': (C*) 5 ?';; 7' &'! ( ,\ ] F.
& ;'&'!(''M((( ; !E&'( >TCT;; ;!!' ' &'?';;
3#2$$3#$$%