Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATAS/789/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/789/2007 Generato dall'IA

Enforceability of Liquidated Damages Clauses as Penalties

Numero d'incarto ATAS/789/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court addressed disputes concerning the validity of various contractual provisions and the appropriate remedy following a breach, specifically focusing on whether certain stipulated damages clauses were enforceable as liquidated damages or constituted an unenforceable penalty. The court reasoned that liquidated damages clauses are valid if the stipulated amount is a reasonable forecast of the harm caused by the breach and the actual damages would be difficult to ascertain, but such clauses are invalid if they are intended to coerce performance rather than compensate for loss. Applying this standard, the court analyzed the reasonableness of the specified amounts in light of the circumstances at the time of contract formation, ultimately determining which clauses were enforceable based on their compensatory nature and which were void as penalties, thereby affirming in part and reversing in part the lower court's award of damages.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Enforceability of Liquidated Damages Clauses as Penalties: The court reasoned that liquidated damages clauses are valid if the stipulated amount is a reasonable forecast of the harm caused by the breach and the actual damages would be difficult to ascertain, but such clauses are invalid if they are intended to coerce performance rather than compensate for loss. Applying this standard, the court analyzed the reasonableness of the specified amounts in light of the circumstances at the time of contract formation, ultimately determining which clauses were enforceable based on their compensatory nature and which were void as penalties, thereby affirming in part and reversing in part the lower court's award of damages.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
risarcimento contrattuale del danno validità della clausola arbitrale esigibilità ragionevole adempimento dei requisiti materiali decisione esecutiva appuramento dell'elenco oneri
Generato dall'IA

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

            ! "##$  $%&"##$

''

() '*+), , , ( )', *

-.  /  ! 0 "##$ 



  !"#   $%#&'#( & %)*+" % ,--. 

# %&/ !"#   $%,,,$0%12"  

#&%

!   $/%     ,    " % # %&&)3"(#&))11" 

4         "(#&" . '

                

  651  

, 1*

)7 %89&)) 6:";<=0% % 0(% <% & (%##$ #% > !"$?  @)%);1;& # %&/> !"$)%#A&);:2"BC$& &% $& 6) );;67

67 = //%)3 (# & /89&(%$ &$" % 0(% <% & #%#$(%&9(%# & $# %(%$#(%#/ #B (% =$(#D%&% 97

@7 89& #%"$/  & /6*8 6:$&$&% C#//  % 0$)@% 6+(#%D$& #(%&97

37  % 0  $  #  &$  (%&   #  %EF & && #EF  (%$#" (   &%($  & && # $/%   (% &    # B%  #&&  # %  B  (%  &$%$ %&  % 9"# &&%6) );;6&6*8 6:7

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

:7 & H  %"  & ((% BC & //  $ H    N!      N    

    5)1))56+ @51  

N ,   PE 'F( )%%);21"B# # % C$ &"  #&  % 9" H 4%7 @;C13@7:1 E B " #(& &  &$%O&#%"#%%(# &H4%7:1C:@)7:1#& #%F&"#&   #%"H 4%7)@;C1;17617#$B"C# %$%&% 9 C$<H4%7+@C;:@7:*E)@;C1;1761-:1C:@)7:1F7

+7 #&#&$&$&% D(%& &6*8 6+8%  & # %  B$BCH$/&C#0%& #%(%&"%%O&% &%%&& 07

27 C0C#08& #$ / D$"$&$9%$H89%7

, ('*

)7 C%&761# /$$%% 0%(9(%$#(%#/ #"   "% &&   &$)+$0%);;@E4F"&%$ 9% )%8 %6"%<9(%#$% #%7#%B#8# &#& (Q#%%(%&& ##%& H(%&9%E%&7)66&)6@ #  - F" 89  #%#($&&C%&7+@7)# /$$%% (%$# (%#/ #  61 8  );26 EF" # & H <  % 0 &#%# ( )%#A&6@"# &"(%<BC// %   $&$&% E%&7)36 F"D$&%C#// (%&9%0 $ %$(%& & #$&% $(%89 #%7

67 #C%&7664E#&% 9%( )%8 %6F"   #%"  (%&& #  #%&  B  %&  % 9 #& (%&9$ #/#%$& D%&7)66")6@")3)&)36 K%&7@H1 4C(( B& (%#9 #&&H&%/$%%E7)F7#%=B#8# &"(%&& # #%& H(%&9%#%%(#H //$%&%(%&& ##%& "9&$  # %   0% (9 D && $&&  #&   #%" &  (%&& ##%& "9&$# % 0%(9D &&$&& #&# #% 9E/7%&7634F7#%"#8#& H  (%&& #  #%&  & H C# %   0% (9 D &&  #&   # #  % 9  &$%O&   #&   #% E 4 )62  6@*K 4)6;333F7

 Q(<"  89  (% <% &  #%#$  (%&9 (% # & $  (%&& #  #%&  B  %&  % 9 (%  %7  & (%& &#&"Q(%&"% 9"6) );;6"Q&%(%&6*8  6:"&HB89& #%&D$&# %7

@7 #  #& (%# &"  (%&& # B  (&  % 9 (%  % C$< H 4%7 11C6:*7- &  B  B  (%  % && &  #  4%7 +@C;:@7:*"  &$%O& & $8H $&$ $ (% 

    5)1))56+ 351  

& && #(%$#$/%7  %# &H#D-$(# #&&4%76+C:@*7-#%BC # & 4%7@:C;2)72*"#%&B Q&  $/  &   % B  # & H # D-$(#D #&&  4%7;C@1)72*7

37 #/#%$& H  8% (%" (   8#% $&% & (#%  (%&9 8BC#&&%/%&(%&& ##%& #%"#8# &  #%$0$$/   %&&(%&& #%# &H &$%O&#(&# %% #&&- 7  &$%O&#&$&D  $9#C%&7)6 C#%#%(%$#(%#/ #  "% &&   &$  )2 %  );23 E 6F # #  &D %$9& %"    -  & ($% % E 4#(0 $@:5*6)28 &6@F7

17  $#&  % (%R"  (%#$% $&& 9%& & E%&7 +@ 7 6  & 2;'7)# %(%#$%  &%& )6(&0%);21F7



SSS



    5)1))56+ 151  

'  2 *1  '*+), , , ( )', *

)7  &    N!      N     N ,      P E 'F H &%/$%%"  #(&     > !" $ ?  "  #  4%7 ;C@1)72* H  4          N   .> '  /%  # % &/ > !"    B  &$%O& #(&# %# $%&"<6)8 6:8BC#& &%/%&7

67 Q#&&B0# 7

@7  &B(%#$%&9%& &7

37 /#%  (%&    BQ (& /#%% %#% #&%  (%$& %%O&   $   @* 8#% <  #& / & # (%<  % 0 /$$% E=T U%=#/B :":3  F"(%# %#%& <%%# & (0 "#/#%$&D%&726# /$$%% % 0/$$%)+ 8  61 E 4FK  $# %  %#% # &  B%  # #" #& / & #(%&(#%&% 9&%%#%&##& %K # & O&% %$  % 0 /$$% (% #  (#& # (% #  $&%# B D # & #  C%&7 36  47  (%$& %%O& &  ( <  (# #  %#%&" #B$##(%"# &O&%8# &HC# 7  9%// <%  %$ &I            44 M%   M 

#( #/#%(%$&%%O&&#& / $D(%&   BQHQ// /$$% %# (%9%//

    5)1))56+